Performance of
MMSE Multiuser
Detecti'on
in
Cellular
DS-CDMA Systems Using Distributed Antennas
Lie-Liang Yang
School ofECS,University ofSouthampton,S017IBJ,UK
Tel: +44-23-8059 3364;Fax:+44-23-80594508 E-mail: lllyecs.soton.ac.uk; http://www-mobile.ecs.soton.ac.uk
Abstract- In this contribution we propose and investigate a high-capacity cellular direct-sequence code-division multiple-access
(DS-CDMA)wireless communications system,where numerous antennas are distributed in the area covered by the system. The bit error rate(BER) performance of the distributed antenna cellular DS-CDMA system is inves-tigated, when minimum mean-square error (MMSE) multiuser detection is employed, and when transmission pass-loss, lognormal shadowing slow fading and Nakagami-rn fast fading are considered. Our study suggests that thedistributed antenna cellularDS-CDMA system constitutes a high power-efficiency wireless system. For utilizing the same set of system parameters,it is capable ofproviding an extremely higher capacity, than the cellularDS-CDMA systemdesignedbased on theconventional cellular concepts.Furthermore, the proposed distributed antenna cellular system canbeoperated withouthavingto usepower-control.
1. INTRODUCTION
Amongradio technologies, multiple-input-multiple-output (MIMO)
systemsusing multipletransmit and/or receive antennas have attracted wide research interests in recentyears[1], [2].Inthiscontribution we
proposeand investigate a cellular DS-CDMA system using distributed antennas, where
many
antennas are distributed in the area covered by the system. Here weconsider the DS-CDMAtechnique, since it has beena typical multiple-access scheme inboth the second- and the third-generation wireless communications systems [3]. Without anydoubt, DS-CDMA technique will constitute animportant candi-date in the future generations of wireless communications systems.In ourproposed distributed antenna cellular DS-CDMA system, the distributedantennas areconnected withanumnberof
signal processing
centers, which are referred to as base-stations (BSs), using optical fibers. Thereasonforemphasisonoptical fiber instead of wireless for implementing communications between distributedantennasand BSs ismainly for the sake of saving the highly limited wirelessresources. Notethat, we stillusethe concept ofBS, however, inthe proposed distributed antennacellular DS-CDMA system the BS isnowrather
a signal processing centerthan aconventional BS. The antennas at
the BSs of theproposed distributedantennasystemareassumed have
no priority in comparison with the other distributedantennas. ABS
or a signal processing center is mainly responsible for the signal processing of the users within the area covered by the distributed
antennasconnected with this BS.
Inthis contributionwefirst describe the distributedantennacellular DS-CDMA system. Then, the MMSE multiuser detection for the distributed antenna cellular DS-CDMA system is investigated. The
BERperformance of the cellular DS-CDMA system using distributed
antennas is evaluated, when communicating overcomposite
lognor-mal shadowing slow fading and Nakagami-nm fast fading channels associated with transmission pass-loss. Our study shows that, in the distributed antenna cellular DS-CDMA system the detection is location-aware. The distributed antennacellular DS-CDMA system constitutes ahigh
power-efficiency
wireless system. Whenusingthesaice
setof systemparamnetersandthesacie nuniber
ofantennas,ourproposed distributedantennacellular DS-CDMA system iscapable of
supportinganextremely higher number ofusers,than aconventional concept-based cellular DS-CDMA system, which employs centralized
BSantennas.
II. CELLULAR DS-CDMA SYSTEMWITHDISTRIBUTED ANTENNAS
A. SystemDescription
The structure of the proposed cellular DS-CDMA system using distributed antennas canbe well-described with the aid ofFig. 1. It
is well-known that,inconventional cellular systems [4], [5] each cell is centered around a BS, which may employ a set of antennas. By contrast,in the proposed distributed antennaaided cellularconcept,
as shown inFig. l, each cell has numerous setsofantennas, which
are distributed within the area coveredby a cell and are connected
to the BS using optical fiber, as we mentioned previously. In the distributed antennacellular systems ofFig. 1, theantennas near the borders may be connected withtwo orthree BSs,sothatsoft-handoff
canbeachieved.Forexample,asshowninFig. 1, each of theantennas
within the dash-dotted boxorthe dashed circle may be connected with BS1 of Cell1, BS2of Cell2orBS3of Cell 3.
Inthe considered distributed antenna system, for the convenience ofanalysis, we assume that the cells are shaped as hexagons with the common radius of R. We assume that any a pair of
adjacent
antennas are separated by a distance of r.Hence,
each antenna is surroundedbynumerous distributed antennas locatedat the corners of thelayered hexagons. Specifically, for the antenna miarkedasA3
in Fig. 1, the first layer has six antennas, the second layer has 12 antennasincluding theantennalocatedatBS1, andsoon. Notethat, the
structureofFig. Iis sufficiently general for approximately modeling the distributed antenna systems having anarbitrary antenna density. Thiscanbe doneby
appropriately
changing the radius value of RinFig. 1.
Indistributed antennasystemsasshown inFig. 1,we assumethat the distributed antennas only implement the functions of conveying
a signal from radio frequency (RF) to baseband orfrom baseband
to RF, in order to make the computation burden at a distributed
antenna aslowaspossible. The above assumption might be duetothe size constraint of the distributed antennas and the constraint arising fromsomesupported signal processing.Forexample,when advanced multiuser detection (MUD) isemployed,information associated with each mobile terminal (MT)and eachantennashould be sharedbyany individual processor. Inthis case, using distributed processing in the
contextof eachdistributedantennawouldrequireanextremely power-ful network forconveying the informationtimelyandefficiently,which might notbe practical in thenear future. Hence, in our distributed
antenna systemall signals received from the MTsby the distributed
antennas are conveyed to the BSs, where the processing is carried
out.
Simultaneously,
all the distributed antennas are also used for transmittingsignalsfromn the BSstothe MTs, in ordertoimuprovethe down-link transmissionquality.of aMTareused to communicate between thisMTand its BS. Hence, the propagation channel between aMTand any of the antennas within its virtual cell can be well modeled by a composite shadowing-fading model [8],where (slow) shadowing can be described by a lognormal distribution [8],while (fast) fading by a Rician or Nakagami-m dis-tribution [9]. Specifically,inthis contribution frequency non-selective
Nakagami
fading [9] is used to model the fastfading.
LetMTobe the referencetermninal and assume that the signal trans-mitted by the reference terminalMTois being detected. The reference terminal MTo randomly moves within the triangle area with three antennasatits corners.Forexample,MTCinFig. 1 randomlymoves
within the triangle area
S,
We assume that there are U antennas within the virtual cell ofMTo.Signals collected from these U antennasareprocessed,inordertodetect the information transmittedbyMTo.
Consequently,
whenassuming that K user signals in additiontothat fromMToarereceivedby the uthantenna,the receivedcomplex low-passequivalent signalcanthen beexpressedasK
ru,(t')
=-\2h,,
bo(t)Co (t)
+E
.. ...hk k=1(2)
Fig. 3. A conceptual cellular DS-CDMAsystem structure with distributed
antennas,where the distributed antennas are connected withone,two orthree base-stations(BSs) located at the centers of the cells usingopticalfiber.
In this contribution, specifically, we consider and investigate the distributedantennasystemsusing DS-CDMA signaling. Hence, when considering conventional binary phase shift keying (BPSK) baseband modulation, the transmitted DS spread spectrumsignal,sayby thekth MT,canbe expressed as
Sk
(t)
= v2Pbk(t)Ck(t)
cos(27rft
+Ok)
(1) where P is the user's transmitted power,f,
is the carrier fre-quency, whileOk
denotes the initial phase angle associated with the carrier modulation. The data stream's waveformbk
(t)EZ
=bk[]
PT(t
-nTP)
consists of a sequence ofmutually
independent rectangular pulses of duration I and of amplitude of
+1 or -1, where Tb is the bit duration. Finally, in (1)
Ck(t)
uiCki
yVT
(t
-jl'c)
denotes thesignature sequence waveform of the kth user, whereCkj
assumes values of +1 or -1 with equal probability,while FbTC(t)
is thechipwaveform,which is definedoverthe interval
[0,
TP)
and has theproperty
ofj0T TC.(t)dt =TPNotethat, in this contribution we assume that each MTemploys onlya single antenna, which is sufficient for fulfillour
objectives
by focusing on the issues of the distributed antenna systems. However,ourinvestigation canbe extendedtothe distributed antennasystems that usemultipleMT antennasaidedbysomeadvanced transmit and receive schemes [6], [7].Furthermore,we assumethat the distributed
antennacellular DS-CDMA uses nopower-control. This is because,
asshown inFig. 1,no matterwhere a MTis,it communicates witha
number ofantennaslocated within itsline-of-sight (LoS)area.The sig-nalssampled from theantennaswithin the LoSareaof the considered
MT usually fall within the cluster of strongest signal. Consequently, the consideredMTconflictsno orlightnear-farproblem.
B. PropagationChannelModeling
Indistributedantennacellular systems, for anyagiven MT, thereare anumber ofantennaswithin the LoSareaof theMT.The LoSareaofa MTis referredto asitsvirtualcell. Theantennaswithin the virtual cell
where
nU,(t)
is the complex-valued additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN)received by the uth receive antenna, which has zero-mean and a single-sided spectrum density of No per dimension, rk rep-resentsthe channeldelay
associated withasynchronous
transmission andpropagation,which is assumedtobeuniformly distributed within[0, Tb).
Furthermore, in (2)hk
representsthe channelgain connecting MTk and the uth antenna. The channel gainhk,
takes into account bothshadowing and fading, whichcanbeexpressed ashku
=3utk5
jOk". (3)where,withoutloss of anygenerality,the initialphaseseenin(1) and thephase duetochannel have been absorbed into
Oku,
and Okuisas-sumedtobeuniformly distributed in
[u,
27r).
In(3)
3urepresentsthe lognornmal shadowing factor, accounting for large scale geographical variation, while akurepresents the fastfading envelope.Weassumethat the transmission pass-loss is absorbed in the shadowing factor
k,sothat the mean-square valueofakuisunit, i.e.,Q =E [t 2
1.
Furthermnore,
we assumethat kuandCtku
aremutually independent and both of themarealsoindependent ofOkuP
Since the fastfading
atu
is modeledby Nakagami-rndistribution, hence,Ct2
is Gamma distributed with theprobability density function (PDF)expressedas[9]pa2k
u~rY
(y)
= r(m)
y exp(-
rTy)
7 y>0(4)
where F(.) is the Gamma function, and, again, m is a parameter accounting for the fading severity.In(3) k,representstheshadowing,
whichcanbe modeledaslognormal distribution [9].It canbe shown that/32, alsoobeys lognormal distribution having thePDFgiven by [9]
Pk 2(r) v exp [- (10 ) 1 r>00 (5)
where I
O/
1n104.3429,
andcku
(dB)
and a(dB)
arethemeanand standard deviation of 10
loglo
r,respectively. Finally, sinceweassumed that both the fastNakagami-a fadingand theshadowing slow fading are independent random processes, hence the PDF of
Ih
12issimply the product of (4) and (5).Antennasinthe
virtual cell Chip-waveform
, ' ~ ~\ \ matched-filter
Sampling
V2(t)
ru(t)
'' D
-77 LIP
by
Detection
algorithms
1 iT
Co = 0X [Coo,COi,* * ,
CO(N-1)0
'N-FCk(N-1,,,,-1) Ck(N-11,_
Data output
CkU
1Fig. 2. Receiver block diagram for thereference MT in the distributed antenna cellular DS-CDMA system.
.1)
Ck(N-1
Ck(N-lp
1.,
+l1
Ck(N-2) Ck(N2-1)
0
0 0
0 0
0 0
-Rg,
(Vkul)
C.
-Rep-.sentation
of
TheReeie Sina fhi=0L
The receiver structure for detection of the reference signal from
MTo is shownin Fig.2.Asshown inFig.2 the received signals from the Uantennas inthe virtual cell ofMTo are first passed through a
bank of filtersmatchedtothe chip-waveformn pulse of F/TC (t).Then,
theoutputsof thematched-filtersaresampledatarateof
lIT,C
Hence,in correspondence with each databit, a total of N samples can be
obtained fromeachantenna,whereNrepresentsthe number of chips
perbitorthespreadingfactor. Letusconsider the detection of the first
databittransmittedbyMTo.Then,the Ath sample of the uthantenna
canbeexpressedas
Yu = V2PN) I r,(t)i/-(t -A )dt (6)
where A = O,lL...IN- 1; u =
1,
2,...,U,V/2PNlT
is anormalization factor,and*representsthe complexconjugate.
Let
YU =
LYou,
YlU, ,Y(N-)ut
nut = [noun.ul n(N- )u
where
RV
(Vk
) andR&,
(vk
) arethe chip auto-correlationfunctions,which are defined as R,(s) = T (t)i-(ts)dt and
Rp
(s) =RgI(T
-s)for0 < s<T,,
respectively.Furthermore,let
y = yT yT yT T
(10) which collects all the samples from the U antennas relatedto the
detection ofthe firstbitofMTo.Then,y canbe expressedas
K
y=
(IU
Xco) hobo[0]
+E
CkRfkHkbk (IL1)where
n= n1 n2I ?nu (12)
isanUN-length Gaussian noisevector,whichhaszero meananda
co-variancematrix of
2uT2IuN,
XrepresentstheKroneckerproduct [10] operation,and the otherargumentsin(I 1)aregivenasfollows:Ck
(7)
fRk
(8)
be the N-length observation vector and noise vector corresponding tothe uth antenna. Accordingto
(6),
we canknow thatthe elermentnAtt inn is a complex Gaussian random variable with zero-mean
and avariance of(T2 = No/2Ebperdimension, where Eb = Pl'b representstheenergy perbit. Letus assumethat Ttu =ILk,,C+Vku
where Ik, > 0 and 0 < Vku < ' . Then, upon substituting the
received signal inthe form of(2) into (6) and expressing invector and matrixforms,itcanbe shown that
yul
canbeexpressedasK
Yu ho0cobo
[0]
+E
hkuCkuRf
(Vku)bk+
nl(9)
k=1
wherebk
[bk
[-1]
bk[0]]T
contains thetwodata bitstransmittedby
the kthMTwithin[0 '1),
while the otherargumentsin(9)aregiven[hoi, hO2, ..,hou]T
diag {Ckl,tCk2,. ..,Cku}
diag
Rp
(Vkl),
Rf(k2
),..**,Rf(VkU)
[HT Hk HLUT
(13) (14)
(15)
(16)
whereHku =
hkJ2.
Letus nowdiscuss the MMSEdetectioninthedistributedantennacellularDS-CDMAsystems.
III. LoCATION-AWARE MMSE MULTIUSER DETECTION
In this section we investigate the location-aware detection in the
distributedantennacellularDS-CDMAsystems,wherea user
signal,
sayMTo isdetectedbythe MMSEprinciplesbasedontheobservation
datasampledfrom the antennaswithin the considered user's virtual cell. The detectionis onthe basisofsymbol-by-symbol.
ForalinearMMSEassistedMUD,the receivedobservationvectory
givenin(I1),which is obtained fromthe LoSareaofMTO,is linearly
processedtoform the decisionvariable, ZO, i.e.,wehave
zo = X{wHy (17)
where }representsthe realpartofx,whilewis theweightvector,
theoptimum weightvectorofwhich in MMSEsense canbeexpressed as
w10 Ry (18)
o
o
o
o
0
0 CkO
0
CkO Ckl
Ck(lk
.-2)
Cki(1
k. -1)Ck(ku-1) Ckt _
0 0 R,I (VkU) Rf,
(Vk
loo
to-,
10-2
10-3
10-4
l0-5 -50
m 1.5, U= 12,
EbINo
= 20dB_30 040 80
I[m] 10 [ml
500
Fig. 3. Antennas whose signalsmaybecollected for detection ofMTO,when
MTois within the filledarea.
where fR is the autocorrelation matrix of the receivedvectory,while
7ybo
is the cross-correlation vectorbetween the receivedvectoryandthe desiredsymbolbo
[01.
Theycanbe, respectively, expressedasRf =E YY rybo =E
[ybo [°]]
(19)Fig. 4. Single-user bound:BERversuscoordinates
(XI
y) performance of the distributedantennacellularDS-CDMA systemsupporting singleuserusing the specificparametersofrr = 1.5, U = 12, EbNo = 20dB, when theusersignal experiences pass-loss,lognormal shadowingslowfading and Nakagami-7m fastfading.
Assume that all the data bitstransmittedbydifferent MTsare
indepen-dent.Then,wehave
Ry
= (IUXco)hohot
(iU XC)K
Ir B
[C,RQ,HkH7RTI,C;{0
21JIU
k=(20)
cll P
(21) ;4 .n
ryb = (Iu X co)ho
where Eo represents the covariance matrix of theinterfering signals plus background noise. Finally,upon substituting (20) and (21) into
(18),weobtain
wo= (Iu o co)hoho (iu 4) +o '(Iu co)ho (22)
With the aid of the mnatrix inverselemIna [10], (22)canbesimplified as
t-1
(iu
h(co)ho
mO=
Furthermore,the resultant MMSE is
given by
MMSE L 7yboU}
1L + ho(u co)
(Iu
c)ho(23)
(24)
Let us now show a range of BER performance results, in order to characterize the distributedantennacellular DS-CDMAsystems.
IV. EXAMPLESOFPERFORMANCE RESULTS
In this section we provide a range of results for illustrating the
achievableperformanceof theexemplifieddistributedantennacellular DS-CDMA system using a set of specific parameters. Due to the
symmetric structureof the distributedantennasystemshowninFig.1,
it is sufficient forustoevaluate the BERperformanceofMTO,when itmoveswithin thetriangulararea shown in
Fig.31,
which shows the'Wenotethat,forthe sake of convenience fordrawingthefigures,inFigs.4 and 5 the BERwithinthedash-dottedsquarewasevaluated. However, onlythe BERcorrespondingtothetriangularareaismeaningful.
100
lo-l
10-2
10-3 1o-4 lo-5
-50_
m7Tn: 1.5I U= 12:
EbINo
= 20dBx[m [ml
Fig.5. MMSE:BERversuscoordinates (.r y)performanceof thedistributed
anrtennacellularDS-CDMA systemsupporting K=10000usersusingthe spe-cificparametersofm = 1.5, U = 12,
EbINo
= 20dB,whenusersignalsexperiencepass-loss,lognormalshadowingslowfadigaandNakagami-Tnfast
fading.
antennas within the virtual cell ofMTO. Note that the SNR perbit ofEb1NO used in the figures of this section represents the average
SNR per bit at the MT transmitter location. Conventionally, when transmission pass-loss is not considered or ideal power-control is
assumed,the averageSNRatthe receiverisusuallyused. Duetothe transmissionpath-loss,itcanbereadilyshow that the SNRmeasured
atthe transmitter side issignificantly higherthan that measuredatthe receiver side foragivenvalue of transmittedpower.
In
Figs.
4 and 5weevaluatedthe BERperformanceofMTO, when it moved within thetriangular areaasmarked in Fig.3.Specifically,inthecontextofFig.4using U = 12 receive antennas,we assumed
that the distributedantennacellular DS-CDMAsystemsupported only
y
A6
*10
.-1
LOmo
5 10 15 20 25
Eb/No (dB) at the MT position
Fig. 6. Single-user bound: BER versus SNR perbit,
EbVNo,
performnanceofthe distributed antenna cellular DS-CDMA systemsupporting single user,
when the usersignalexperiencespass-loss,lognormal shadowing slowfading
and Nakagami-m fast fading.
a)
cc
bJ
m
U=12,a=b=2, N=31
0R=500m,r=
1OOm,do=1Om,g= 1OOm--- MMSE
1 -| Single-user bound
)10-3 1 nnnn
10o-1 0
10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Eb/No (dB) at the MT position
Fig. 7. MMSE: BER versus SNRperbit,
EbINo,
performancefor the dis-tributedantennacellular DS-CDMA systemusingMMSEdetectors,when usersignals experiencepass-loss,lognormalshadowing slow fading and
Nakagami-mfast fading(rn=2).
one user. Hence,the corresponding BERperformance represents the single-user BER bound. By contrast, Fig.5 corresponds to the dis-tributed antennacellular DS-CDMA systemsupporting K = l0000
userspercell.Fromthe results ofFigs.4and5,we canobserve that the BERperformance doesnotvary significantly,whena MT moves
within the system, provided that it is not too close to an antenna.
However,whena MTis closeto anantenna,the received powerby this
antennawill dominate the achievableBERperformance of theMTand the resultantBER is lower than thatachieved, when theMTis away from all theantennas atcertaindistances. By comparing the results of Fig.4andFig.5,itcanbe shown that the multiuser interference also
slightly
degrades the achievableBERperformance.The results in Figs. 6 and 7 were evaluated, whenMTo is atthe
centerof the shadowedtriangleseeninFig.3.InFig.6 the single-user
BERboundversusSNR perbit of
EVNo
performancewasevaluated inthecontextof the distributedantennacellular DS-CDMA system for rM = 1,1.5, 2, 3 and oc, and for U = 3and U = 12.Explicitly, theBERperformanceimproves,when the fastfading becomes less severe,
i.e.,when the value of the
fading
parametermincreases. Thedetectionusing thesignals collected from U = 12 antennas outperforms that
from U = 3 antennas, and the gain forin = I is about5dB, while
form oc is about
3dB,
atthe BER of10-3
By contrast,inFig.7the achievable BERperformance of MMSE detector isdepicted. The benchmark single-userBERbound is also shown in Fig.7.Asshown
inFig. 7,whenthenumber ofuserssupportedby acell isK = l000,
weobservenoerror-floor fortheMMSEdetector. However,when the numberof users per cell is K = 5000 or K = 10000, explicit
error-floors are observed. This might bebecause, although the interfering
signalsareweak,butthenumberof interfering signals receivedbyeach antennaishigh,whichmaybe far beyond the interferencesuppression
capability of theMMSEdetector.
Furthermore, as shown in Fig. 7,for the targetBERof
10-2,
the MMSEassisted distributedantennacellular DS-CDMAsystemusingaspreading factor of N =31 is capable of supportinguptoK= l0000
users percell with the SNR perbit of 19dB atthe transmitter site.
Supporting K =10000users per cell is far beyond the capability ofa
conventional cellularDS-CDMA concept,when itusesthe spreading
factor of N = 31 and employs 91 antennas located at the BS.
This isbecause, in thiscase,the total number of degrees-of-freedom available at a BS in the conventional cellular DS-CDMA system is about 31 x 91 = 2821. Any linear detector using this number of
degrees-of-freedom
is impossible todistinguish
K = l0000signals,
which have a similar power-level due to using power control. Inconclusions,inthiscontributionwehave proposed and investi-gated a distributed antenna cellular DS-CDMA wirelesssystem,where a big number of antennas are distributed in the area of a cell and are connected with the signal processing center referred to as BS. From our analysis and results, we may argue that the distributed
antennacellular DS-CDMA system consists of one of the high power-efficiency wireless systems. When using the same set of system param-eters,the distributed antenna cellular DS-CDMA system is capable of supporting anextremely higher number of users, than the conventional cellular DS-CDMA systems using centralized BS antennas.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The author would like to acknowledge with thanks the financial assistance from EPSRC of UK.
REFERENCES
[1] I.E. Telatar, "Capacity ofmultiantenna Gaussian
channels,d
European Trans. onTeleconii.,vol.1O,
pp.585-595,Nov./Dec.1999.[2] A. J.
Paulrajn
D. A.Gore,R. U.Nabar,andH.Bolcskei,"Anoverview of MIMOcommunlications-A key toGigabitwireless,"Proc. off/ieIEEE,vol.92, pp. 198-21L8, Feb. 2004.
[3] L.Hanzo,L.-L. Yang, E.-L. Kuan, and K. Yen,Single- and Multi-ccrrier DS-CDMA. John Wiley andIEEEPress, 2003.
[4] A. J. Viterbi, CDMA: Principles ofSpreaidSpectrum Coiimuniciations. NewYork: Addison-Wesley PublishingCompany,1995.
5] W. C. Y.Lee, MobileCommunicationsEngineering.NewYork:
McGraw-Hill,2nded.,1998.
[6] D.Gesbert,M.Shafi,and et.al, EFromtheory topractice: An overview of MIMOspace-time coded wirelesssystems,"IEEEJ. onSelect. Areas in
Commun.,vol.21,pp.281-302,April2003.
[7] B.Hochwald,T. L.Marzetta,andC. B.Papadias, "Atransmitterdiversity scheme for wideband CDMA systemsbased on space-timespreading," IEEEJ. onSelect. Areas inCommun.,vol.19,pp.48-60,Jan. 2001.
[8] T.S.Rappaport,WirelessCommunicationsPrinciplesandPractice.New York: PrenticeHall,Inc,2ed.,2002.
[9] M[. K. Simon and M.-S.Alouini,DigitalComnmunication overFiding Chainnels. NewYork: JohnWiley & Sons, 2000.
[10] H. L.V1Trees,Optimuni Arrcy Processing. WileyInterscience,2002.