Three-dimensional shakedown solutions for anisotropic cohesive-frictional materials under moving surface loads

http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/124073/

Version: Accepted Version

Article:

Wang, J and Yu, H-S (2014) Three-dimensional shakedown solutions for anisotropic

cohesive-frictional materials under moving surface loads. International Journal for

Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics, 38 (4). pp. 331-348. ISSN 0363-9061

https://doi.org/10.1002/nag.2207

Copyright (c) 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. This is the peer reviewed version of the

following article: Three-dimensional shakedown solutions for anisotropic cohesive-frictional

materials under moving surface loads, which has been published in final form at

https://doi.org/10.1002/nag.2207. This article may be used for non-commercial purposes in

accordance with Wiley Terms and Conditions for Self-Archiving.

eprints@whiterose.ac.uk https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/ Reuse

Unless indicated otherwise, fulltext items are protected by copyright with all rights reserved. The copyright exception in section 29 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 allows the making of a single copy solely for the purpose of non-commercial research or private study within the limits of fair dealing. The publisher or other rights-holder may allow further reproduction and re-use of this version - refer to the White Rose Research Online record for this item. Where records identify the publisher as the copyright holder, users can verify any specific terms of use on the publisher’s website.

Takedown

If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by

For Peer Review Only

!" # ! $

% " & ' () * + , ' ( ") - ' . ( ( ) * + , ' ( ") - ' . ( (

/ 0 # 1 # 0 ) % "! ) )

For Peer Review Only

! "

# $ ! %&!' #% %!(

) $ **+ ,-. -/,0

1 $ 2 # #

! &

) 3 4 & 2 #

2 # 35

2 0 -3

For Peer Review Only

*

4 ! ( # ( & 4 #

! # 4 ! 6 & # % 1 !

& 6 4 # # % )

# 4 # ( !

4 # % 7 6 !

( # ! 4 ( ! % 8 !

! #6 &

! 4 ( ! % 8 ! ( !

# # 6& 9 ! 7 # ! ! !6 !

! 6& # ! ! ! ! % & # &

6& # ( # !

# : #!# 4 ! % ) ( # 4

( 4 ! # & ! # &%

! "

( & ; ! #6 ; &; &; # 4

#$ %

( ( # ! ! !

! & & & 6 4 & # 6 (

# " 6! ! # # % 1 4 &

6 4 ( # ! ! & ! ! ! #

# # ! <*=%

8 6 ! : #

!# ( ( & 4 6 #

4 # ! # 4 <- >=% 1 ( & ( & ( &

4 # # & ( # 4 4 #

! ! % ) ! # # 6 ! ! $ ( # ! 6 !

( # <0= 6 ! ( # <,=% ? !

6 ! ( # 6 ! 4 # ( &

6 # # ! <@ **= ! 6 !

For Peer Review Only

-( # # & # # </ + *- *>=% )

6 ! ! 6 ! & : # ! &

( <*0 *,=% ) # 6 ! ( ! 6& 9!

? <*,= 6 !# 4 % 8

& 4 6 & 4 # # : 6 #

& 6 ! 4 & 6

A <*@ -*=% 1 6 ! & # & !

4 # ! # 6 & ! ! <*@ -- -/=%

1.1. Elastic Anisotropy

# & ! # 6 # !# 4 4 :

&## & # & A 6!

4 <-+=% ) ( & ( & 4

&% 8 6 4 ! # 6 6

$

*B B B

B *B B

B B *B

*B *B

*B

-xx h h h vh v xx

yy h h h vh v yy

zz hv h hv h v zz

xy h xy

xz vh xz

vh

yz yz

E E E

E E E

E E E

G G

G

δε υ υ δσ

δε υ υ δσ

δε υ υ δσ

δε δσ

δε δσ

δε δσ

   − −  

  _{ } 

− −

    

  − −  

=

  _{ } 

    

    

  _{ } 

     

   

*"

# δσij # δεij : % %i

j x : y : z : " z : 6 4 ;Eh 9 ! 7 # ! !

A C" ;Ev 9 ! 7 # ! ! 4 " ;Gh # ! !

A ; Gvh # ! ! C ; υh 7

A # # & A ";υvh 7 4

A "; υhv 7 A 4

"%) 6 # D%- E D%."

# 6 ! & 6& 4 # %

- * "

h h

h

E G

υ

=

+ -"

vh v hv h

E E

υ

υ = % ."

For Peer Review Only

.

4 6 & : % : # & 4 !

EvBEh & # & # %-+ *%** <-+ -0=% : # ! <-, -@=

4 <. = # & EvBEh # *% > -%

# C ! 6& <-*= & ! & 6

6 6& # $E* υF α6& 4 $Ev GEF

EhGα-EF υhGυF υvhGυFBα GvhGαEFB -H-υF" GhGα-EFB -H-υF"%

1.2. Plastic Anisotropy

I 6 & # # ! 4

# % <- .* ..="% 8 6

4 ! & #!

# & % <- .. ./="% !

! 4 6 ! 6 6 4 ! %

<.+ .>="% C 4 # ! ! & 6 ! %

) # ! 4 6 ! ( !

! # # 4 ! % 9! <*0= 9!

? <*,= 7 ( # 6 ! 4 6 !

( ! % 7 ( # &

! ! ( #6 !

D! 6 ! 4 & % 8

! #6 & 6 ! !

% ) & 6 6& !

%

&$

) # ! 4

4 : &## & ! *% 1 #

& 6 6& ! A &

% 1 # ! ! # ! p

! q # 4 x % p q !# 6 6!

D! ! a x-Hy- ≤ a-"$

(

_{- - -}

)

*B -.

.

-P

p a x y

a

π

= − − /"

For Peer Review Only

/

(

_{- - -}

)

*B

-.

.

-Q

q a x y

a

π

= − − +"

P # z Q x

% ) 6! ( # C A

6! % 8 # : #!# ! p G .PB-πa- x Gy GzG

"% ) # !# 6 6& " G

QBP%

'$ (

C <.0= 4 # :

z J ! # C A 6! D%/ E D%+% 4

** *. .. // >>

A A A A A ! # 6 4 6 $

** ** >> *.

** >> ** *.

*. *. .. >> // // -xx xx yy yy zz zz xy xy xz xz yz yz

A A A A

A A A A

A A A

A A A δσ δε δσ δε δσ δε δσ δε δσ δε δσ δε    −      ₋     _{ }    _{ }  =             _{ }    _{ }             % >"

) 4 9 ! 7 # ! ! # ! ! 7

$ _** * vh hv h v A

E E

υ υ

−

= _*. hv _- h hv

h A

E

υ +υ υ

= -.. -* _h h A E υ −

= A_// =-Gvh >>

-* h h h E A G υ = = +

(

)(

)

-* _h * _h - _{hv vh}

h v E E

υ

υ

υ υ

+ − −

= %

3 #6 σ_*=σ_xx+σ_yy σ_- =σ_xx−σ_yy+-iσ_xy τ_z =σ_xz +iσ_yz

: 4 6& C <.0=%

) ! # P 4 6 $

(

)

(

)

( )

( )

- -. * - ->> * . * * * > *

k k k

k k

k k k

m l a

HPA

z a l a

a m γ γ σ γ ρ =  − +       =  ₋   − −          

∑

0"

(

)

(

( )

)

( )

- -. - - - ->> - . - * * * -- -* i k k k k k HPA e

a l a a a l a

For Peer Review Only

+

(

)

( )

( )

( )

-* * - -* . * * -. * -k k

z k k k

k

l a

P

z a l a

a

σ γ

π γ γ ρ

+

=

    

 

= _− _{  }− − _

−

∑

_{    } @"

(

)

( )

( )

( )

( )

- -* * -. -* * - -. * /

k k k

i z

k k

a l a a

l a

P

e

a l a

ϕ

τ

ρ

π

γ γ

ρ

+

=

  _{  −} 

 _{ }

= _− − _{ }+ _

−

∑

_ _{  } _% * "

) ! Q 4 6 $

(

)

- -

(

₍

)

₎

.- *

( )

*

( )

- -

( )

>> *

-* . - - *

* * .

- *

k k k k

i i

k

k k k

m l a l a

HQA

e e l a

a m

ϕ ϕ γ γ

γ γ

σ ρ ρ

γ ρ ρ

− =  − +       = + _{ }− _{ }+ − _ − _{   }     

∑

**"

(

)

( )

( )

( )

( )

( )

(

)

( )

( )

( )

( )

-* * -

>> *

-- . * * . * . - - - - . - -* * * . . *. *. . . . * * * - -/ - -. . * - -k k i k k k k i k

k k k

i

l a l a

HQA

e l a

a m

l a

z

e l a a a l a a l a

l a l a

Q e a ϕ ϕ ϕ γ γ

σ ρ ρ

ρ ρ

ρ

ρ ρ

ρ

π γ ρ

=          =  ₋    − −                 _{ }   −  _ + _ − − + −       _   − _{ }−  

∑

( )

( )

( )

(

)

( )

( )

- -*. . *. . . - - - - . - -*. *. *. . . -/ - -. i l a l a z

e ϕ l a a a l a a l a

ρ ρ ρ ρ ρ  _ _ −               _{ }   +  _ + _ − − + −       _ *-"

(

)

(

)

( )

( )

( )

( )

-* _{* * -} * -* . -* * -. * ,

k _{k k}

i i

z k

k

l a l a

Q

e e l a

a

ϕ ϕ

γ γ

σ ρ ρ

π γ γ ρ ρ

+ − =        = ₋ +  − −  + −          

∑

*."

(

)

( )

( )

_{( )}

(

( )

)

( )

( )

_{( )}

(

( )

)

( )

* . - - - -* * * - - * -* . -* * -. - - - -*. *. *. - - -. *. . -- -* . / . - -. / . k k k k i

z k k

k k

i

a l a a a l a

l a Q

z a l a e

a

a l a a a l a

l a Q

z a l a e

a

ϕ

ϕ γ γ

τ

π γ γ γ ρ ρ

π ρ ρ

+ =  ₋  _{  − + −}   _{ } = _ − _{ }+ − − _ − _  _{ } _      _{  − + −}    − − _{ }+ − +  _{ }   

∑

*/"

- _{* -"}

k nk k

γ = =

For Peer Review Only

> k

n # : K! " D! D! $

(

)

-** // *. *. - // ** .. .. //

A A n +_A A + A −A A _n+A A =

(

)

(

* - **-

)

** .. *.

-A H

A A A

γ γ

π

+ =

−

k k z z

γ

=

-

-x y

ρ = +

(

)

(

)

L B

B

y x

y x

y x

ϕ

ρ

ρ

π

= =

 

=_ ≥

 _{+ <}



( )

(

(

)

- -

(

)

- -

)

*

*

-k k k

l a = ρ+a +z − ρ−a +z

( )

(

(

)

- _-

(

)

- _-

)

-*

-k k k

l a = ρ+a +z + ρ−a +z

%

) 4 ! & 6 6 ! σ_xx=_σ_*+

( )

σ_- _B

-" "

xz z zz z

σ = τ σ = σ # & σ_z ! 6 4 & # "%

)$ "

I <.-= !# ! 4

6 6 6& # # : $

-"

h v h

c_θ =c + c −c θ *+"

ch cv 4 ! A 4 4 &

cθ # ! θ A

% 3

For Peer Review Only

0

# 4 ! #6 !

4 % 1 9! <-/= # 4 4

4 6 ! -" 6 ! $

-"

n h v h n

s=cθ −σ φ=c + c −c θ σ− φ *>"

# # 6$

-

-n xx zz xz

σ =σ θ σ+ θ σ− θ *0"

-xx zz xz

τ

= −

σ

θ

θ σ

+

θ

θ σ

+

θ

% *,"

φ

# %

) #! 6 # % %

τ

− ≤s " $

[

]

(

)

-

(

- -

)

--

%

xx zz xz

h v h xx zz xz

c c c

σ θ θ σ θ θ σ θ

θ φ σ θ σ θ σ θ

− + +

 

−_ + − − + − _≤ *@"

3 D!

(

)

-zz xx xz

v h xz xx zz

s

c c

τ σ σ σ φ

θ

θ σ σ φ σ φ

∂ − − −

= ⇒ =

∂ − + − + - "

! 4 6 $

(

) (

-

) (

-

)

--

-zz xx xz v h xz xx zz v h xx zz

f = σ −σ − σ φ + c − +c σ −σ φ σ+ φ − c + −c σ φ σ− φ ≤ % -*"

*$ +

7 ( # ( &

# : #!# # 6 D! 6 ! 6 !

4 & % ! !

& # ! # % 8

# # & 6 : # !

# % C 4 &## & # # %

6 # # # !

4 : &## & ! # #

! 6 4 x" % 8 6

For Peer Review Only

,

# 6& 9! <*0= 9! ? <*,= ! # 4 #

C A 6! # xz

6& y G % M & 6 ! A !

r xx

σ

6 ! D! 6 !# 6 ! & # 6 &

!

σ

_xzr ! 4

σ

_zzr% )

# 4 C A 6! # y G & 4 # #

6 !# ! $

e r

xx xx xx

σ =λσ +σ --"

e zz zz

σ =λσ -."

e xz xz

σ =λσ -/"

λ

# #

σ

_ije ! !

!

p

%

8 y A !

σ

r_yy # & : ! #

y G

σ

_yy

=

λσ

_yye

+

σ

_yyr %

σ

r_yy 6 & ! z 6

yy

σ

& # % 8 # K

# & yG %

8 ! #6 & D% -* ! 6

# &

σ

_yy # D% -- E D% -/

!6 ! & D% -* & D! # 7 (

# 4 $

(

) (

)

(

)

-

--

-e e r e e e r e

zz xx xx xz v h xz xx xx zz

e r e

v h xx xx zz

f c c

c c

λσ

λσ

σ

λσ

φ

λσ

λσ

φ σ

φ λσ

φ

λσ

φ σ

φ λσ

φ

= − − − + − + − − +

− + − − − ≤

-+"

) 6 4 ( 6 $

(

_r

)

-xx

f =

σ

+ Μ + Ν + Ρ ≤ ->"

For Peer Review Only

@ r

xx

σ

D! 6

(

)

-e e e

xx zz ch zz

λσ λσ λσ φ φ

Μ = − + −

(

_-

) (

) (

-

)

-/ φ *  λσe_xz c_h λσ_zze φ 

Ν = + _ − − _

 

(

)

(

)

/ c_v c_h λσe_xz c_h λσ_zze φ 

Ρ = − _ − − _%

8 ! 6 c_v D! c_h A D% -> 6 # D! 4

( 9! ? <*,= # %

8 & D% -> #! 6 # $

Ν + Ρ ≤ -0"

) 6 4 D% -0 6 $

Α×Β ≤ -,"

(

)

e e

xz ch zz

λσ λσ φ

Α = − −

(

-

)

(

)

* _xze c_{h zz}e c_v c_h

φ λσ λσ φ 

Β = + _ + − _+ − %

) 6 * !##

λ

& D% -,

e e

zz xz

a=

σ

φ σ

+ -@"

(

)

-

-* B

e e

zz xz

v h b

c c

φ

σ φ σ

φ

+

= −

+ % . "

1 & x y z" a b 6 4 4 !6K

% #6 a b

# λ & D% -,%

4 λ 4 ( #! 6

$ 2

For Peer Review Only

*

* - .

# # h # h # # h h

case case case

c c c c

a b a b

λ≤ _ _ _ _ _ _{ } ___

      

 % .*"

) 6 4 6 $

( )

( )

(

)

* - .

# : # : # : # :

h

case case case c

a b a b

λ≤

 

 

.-"

& ! 4 & # : #!# 4 !

( )

( )

(

)

* - .

# : # : # :

case a case b case a b

 

  4 & ( # λsd

6&$

( )

( )

(

)

* - .

# : # : # : # :

h sd

case case case c

a b a b

λ =

 

 

% .."

D% .. # D! 6 !# ! 4

# : #!# 6 ! & ! 6 ! ( # % 8 D! !

6 6 ! ( # ! ( ! % C 4 D% ->

D! 6 !# # # ! $

*" D% -> D! & i !

σ

_xxr #! 6

6 f₌ $

r xx

i i i σ i i i

−Μ − −Ν −Ρ ≤ ≤ −Μ + −Ν −Ρ ./"

i i

−Ν − Ρ #! 6 4 & ( D%

.-%

-" ) D! 6 !# D! !

σ

_xxr &

z = j#! 6 ! D! % ) 6 ! z = j#!

6 $

# : i i i" xxr # "

z j

j i

z= −Μ − −Ν − Ρ ≤σ ≤ = −Μ + −Ν − Ρi i .+"

For Peer Review Only

**

# "

z j r

xx i i i

σ

=

= −Μ + −Ν −Ρ N# #!# 7"

# : "

z j r

xx i i i

σ

=

= −Μ − −Ν −Ρ N# : #!# # 7"

! %

4 # λ D! ( # !

# #!# # : #!# # " !6 ! D% ->

# : "

z j= f = % C 4 λ ( # # :z j= f" 6

A % ) 6 ! λ 6 4 ( # # 6

## ! # ( f ≤ # % )

( 6 # 6 # # #! $

( )

(

)

( )

( )

# : #

# "

!6K

# : "%

r e e

xx

r e r e

xx i i i xx i i i

z j z j

f

λ

σ λσ

λσ

σ λσ

σ λσ

= −Μ + −Ν −Ρ = −Μ −

 _≤

−Ν −

= = Ρ

  

.>"

D% .> 6 ! : & 4 6

λ

# # # $

( )

# : #

!6K f %

λ

λ

≤ .0"

& ! ! D% 0 E D% */ # : #!# # # (

f λ"≤ ! 6 ! ( #

λ

_sdO

6 #%

,$

-8 ! ! # : #!# # D% .>%

) ! 4 6 ## M ) 12% )

4 6 4 6& # # ! ! 1 1P3 % !

! & &

&% 2

For Peer Review Only

*-6.1 Shakedown solution procedure

1 # ! 4 D% .> 6 6 ! ( #

λ

_sdO

! ! .% ! & ( #

λ

_sd 6 !

i i i

−Μ + −Ν − Ρ −Μ − −Ν − Ρi i i ! i % 8

!# % *a 4 : x0

y0 z0 " & #% ) !

6 6& ! # #!# # : #!# #

% ) ! ! ! z%

( ! # 6 ( 6& !6 !

λ

_sd

! D% .*% 8 # : #!# 4 ! f #

! 6 4 & * . " 6 ! ( ! O

sd λ

& (

λ

_sd% M # :

( )

f

* . # # D! % 8 6 # 6 #

# # : #!# # 6 # O

sd

λ !#

! ! ! #6 &

4 & % 2 # 4

6

λ

_sd # 6 ! #!# ( #

&% 8 ! !# 4 & #

#

λ

_. * ." ! 6 ! ( # !

# : f" # * 0 * . D! & * / _≤ # : f"_≤ * .

6 4 ! ( # % 1 ( #

4 # : #!# 4 ! f 6 %

& : ( # !

! ! ! ! & & & % %

(

)

(

r O e

)

xx sd

f σ λ σ ≤ " 6 ! & ! % ) 6 !

( ! ! ! 6

& ! f4 ! 6! # : f"% )

6 ( 6& !6 ! ! & D% .*%

For Peer Review Only

*.

6.2 Results and discussion

8 ! 6 ! ( # 6 ! #

# # : #!# ! p # #$ O O

# : sd B h

k =λ p c % )

# 6 6& & ( D% ..

! #$ k_{# :} =λ_sdp Bc_h%

6.2.1 Special case 0 isotropic half0space

4 & 4 & ( !

!# 6 !# ! 6 # % )

!# ! ( # ! # 4 !

! / 4 #

φ

% )

( ! !# 6 ! 6 6& ! <.,= !

# ## D! % 8 (

# & %

6.2.2 Effect of elastic cross0anisotropic parameters

1 & & &% 1 #

6 # 4

# # ! $ Eh Ev/Eh Gvh/Gh υh υvh% ) 6

- # ( # 6 !#

6 ! # % ) # !

# # C ! 6& <-*= ? &% 8 #

! 4 !# 4 # ( # 6& #!

- Q% 1 ! & ( & # & !

4 # %

! 4 6 # # !

( # ! 6& 9 ! 7 # ! ! ! % %Eh Ev"

6! 6& 9 ! 7 # ! ! Ev/Eh% ) ( !

# ! 4 & 9 ! 7 # ! ! % 8

7 & & 4 ( #

! +%

! > ! 0 4 ( #

" 4 ! 9 ! 7 # ! ! Ev/Eh # ! !

For Peer Review Only

*/

Gvh/Gh% 8 ! 6 4 ! % % Ev/Eh ≠ *

Gvh/Gh ≠ *" ! ( #

"% 1 # 6& # 4

# 6 ! N !6 ! ! 7"

! N ! ! 7"% ) ! !6 ! !

! ! ! 4 ! " # 4 !

Ev/Eh 4 ! Gvh/Gh% ) # !6 ! ! # ( &

! Ev R Eh GvhJ Gh% ? !6 ! ! ( #

6 6& Ev/Eh Gvh/Gh ! ( 4 ! % ?

! ! ( # 6 6& Gvh/Gh &

4 # ! 06"%

8 ! 4 4 4 Ev/Eh Gvh/Gh ( #

! ,% ) ! # % ?

" A ! & 6 ! % % !6 ! ! "

( # # D! ( & Ev/Eh Gvh/Gh! ( 4 !

% 8 ! ( 4 ! ! + φG S ! -- φG . S%

? "G %+ # & ! % %

! ! " ( # # 6& 4 Gvh/Gh

Ev/Eh : ( #

6& !6 ! % 1 # : #!# 4 ! O

# :

-k = 6 4 φG S%

) ! # & ( ! (

! 4 # ! # C A 6

6&Ev/Eh !6 ! ! 6! 6&Gvh/Gh ! ! %

6.2.3 Effect of plastic anisotropy

! @ ( # " 4 !

cvBch φ ( S *+S . S /+S 4 &%

( ! cvBch ! * % #

! 6 $

*" ? cvBch # * ( ! !

% ) ! % %cvBchG *"% ? cvBch

* : ( 4 ! ( ! 4 #!#

For Peer Review Only

*+

" > "% ) # !

4 ! & # : #!# "= % % # &"%

-" ) cvBch & ( #

O O

# : sd B h

k =

λ

p c % 1 ! * ( #

& cvBch 6 ! ( # k# :O D!

& ( k_{# :} 4 ! 6& *Bb D%

. "% C 4 & ! ! * *

# :

k # k_{# :}O % 8 cvBch ! ( # &

# : #!# 4 ! 6& *Ba D% -@"%

." ! ! @ 4 ! ! !6 ! ! 6&

% ) !6 ! ! 4 !

6& *Ba% M

6 ! 6 ! ( # 6& *Bb% M

( # 6& ! %

/" ! ! # ( & ! cvBch ! -% ? cvBch 4 &

% % cvBch G * " 4 & # % % cvBch G %*" ! 6

! %

+" 1 6 # # 4

% ) # ! ! ! 4 !

# %

6.2.4 Effect of combined elastic and plastic anisotropies

4 ! & : # ! &%

C 4 # # <. =%

: # # # A ! 4 EvJ Eh cv J

ch% ) 6 . # ( !

! $

" EvBEhG %+ GvhBGhG %0 υhG %*+ υvhG %-- cvBchG %,; " EvBEhG *%+ GvhBGhG *%- υhG %*+ υvhG %*- cvBchG *%-%

8 ! ( ! " 6&

#! .,Q & # ( ! " 6& #!

For Peer Review Only

*>

/-Q% ) 6 ! 6 ( !

! ( # ! # 4 ! %

.$ /

7 ( # 4 6 ! (

! 4 ! # !

% 1 #

! ! #6 & %

4 D! 6 ! ( 6 # !

! # 6 4 6& !# ! % )

( ! 6 ! 6 ( ! 9! ? - *-"

# %

1 ! 4 # 6 4 ! !

6 ! ( ! 6 # # & 6&

9 ! 7 # ! ! Ev/Eh # ! ! Gvh/Gh% 4 !6 !

! ( # # 6& 9 ! 7 # ! ! ;

! ! ( # # 6& # ! ! %

? cvBch ( # !

D! # cvBch"; 4 !

# : #!# 4 ! % 8 ( #

& ( !6 ! ! % % # ";

( # 6& ! % %

"% 8 !6 ! ! ! cvBch 4 &

4 & # % & cvBch J * ( : ( #

4 & 5 # *"% ) # !

& 5G % % # &"%

) ( # ##

2 # # 2 " ( &

4 # & ! % ) 1! ( 357

& ! " 3 4 &

2 # ! %

For Peer Review Only

*0 0

*% 9! C %Plasticity and geotechnics% - >%

-% 9! C T! ? T% : # 6 ! (

& & 4 # & # %Géotechnique- *-;,&$ @-. @.-%

.% ? T 9! C % ( ! 4 !

# 4 ! % Geomechanics and Geoengineering: An International Journal

- *.;1 * */%

/% ? ( T % ( 4 # ! # 4 ! %Journal of

Transportation Engineering, ASCE*@,/;##2$ * */%

+% 9! C C U% I 6 ! ( & & 4 # !

! ! % Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering

*@@,;#,.$ - @ ---%

>% 4 # T % ( & 4 # % 8 $ The 12th

International Conference of International Association for Computer Methods and

Advances in Geomechanics - ,; 8 % //.- //.,%

0% 5 ?)% # % 8 $ Progress in solid mechanics

82 C "% 1# #$ 2 C *@> ; *>+ --*%

,% % ! A! C (& 7 5 !!# 6

4 V ! % Sitzungberichte der Ak. Wissenschaften Wien (Ser. 2A) *@.,;

#).$ 0.%

@% 1 C 1 T 5I% 1 ( # (

# % Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of

Solids*@,+;''$ ..@ .>-%

* % 8 % ( # ! # 4 ! %

International Journal for Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics*@,0;##$ / @ /- %

**% ! 6 6 1 % : # #

6 # % Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering - +; #3)$ />..

/>+ %

*-% ! 6 6 8 ? I% ( &

4 # & !6 % Canadian Geotechnical Journal - ;

'.$ ,,- ,,@% 2

For Peer Review Only

*,

*.% I ? 2 K# ?% 6 & #! & & # ! %

Transportation Research Record*@,,;#&2.$ *,* *,>%

*/% ! C 9! C % I # ( & &

4 # %Transportation Research Record- ;#.'2$ **0 *-/%

*+% 2 !& 1 C # 1 ? % 1 #

( & 4 # % International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering- ,;.*$ /*/ /.@%

*>% 5 66 W 5 I& # 1 ?% ( 4

!6K % International Journal of Solids and Structures

- 0;))$ .@@, / ,%

*0% 9! C % ) # & ! ( 4

# ! # 4 ! %Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical,

Physical and Engineering Science- +;),#$ *@+* *@>/%

*,% 9! C ? T% ) # ( ! 4

# ! # 4 ! % International Journal of Solids and Structures

- *-;)3$ .0@0 ., 0%

*@% M 5 ( 8 C ! )% : # ! &

6& %Soils and Foundations*@0,;#1$ -+ .,%

- % 1 ! T A 5% 8 & % Géotechnique *@0-; &&$ **+

*-,%

-*% # T C ! 6& )% 1 & ! &% Géotechnique*@,.;''$

*>+ *, %

--% M 5 ( 8% & 6 &

%Soils and Foundations*@0@;#3$ *+ -,%

-.% 1A # 1 ! A A ( ! % & !

4 & ! # % International Journal for Numerical and

Analytical Methods in Geomechanics- * ;')$ 00* 0@.%

-/% 9! C ?% I # & ! #

## %Mechanics Research Communications*@@/;&#$ +/+ ++/%

-+% I I 2 )% 1 #

# ! # ! &%Géotechnique- ;*2$ * @ *-+%

->% 9! ( ! % # ! %

Journal of Geotechnical Engineering *@@.;##3$ *+>, *+,>% 3

For Peer Review Only

*@

-0% 9 # 5% # ! & %

Géotechnique- **;,#$ , @ ,*/%

-,% C D! ) ! ( )% ! !

: # %Geotechnical Testing Journal*@@>;#3$ /** /- %

-@% 5! T T% M 6 & & !

# 4 & # %Géotechnique- -;*&$ 0-0 0/@%

. % T I ) ! ( 1 5 ( T% 8 ! &

4 & # & 4 %Géotechnique*@@0;).$ + @ +-*%

.*% ! % % Journal of

Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering- ,;#')$ *.** *.*,%

.-% I 59% 6 & 1 % Journal of Soil Mechanics and

Foundations Division, ASCE*@>+;3#$ ,+ * >%

..% ? 5 1 ! T % 8 ! & % Géotechnique *@,+;

'*$ /0* /,*%

./% 5! !(! ! & I M 5 A # C% 1 & !

4 6& : %Soils and Foundations*@@@;'3$

-* . %

.+% I % ! # % International

Journal of Solids and Structures- 0;))$ +*/> +*>-%

.>% U U T 9 9% 1 A ! # %

International Journal of Solids and Structures- * ;).$ .*>> .*,+%

.0% C )% ) C A !

4 &%Journal of Tribology*@@-;##)$ > > >**%

.,% ! C Numerical methods for shakedown analysis of pavements under moving

surface loads% % % ) 3 4 & 2 1! %

For Peer Review Only

-) 6 *% 2 & (

a b 6

# D% -,

!## & 6 * + − c_h c_h

a b

λ≤ λ≥ ch

a

λ

≤ ≤

h c

a

λ

≤ ≤

h h

c c

a b

λ≥ λ≤ 2 1

- − + c_h c_h

a b

λ≥ λ≤ ch

b

λ

≤ ≤

h c

b

λ

≤ ≤

h h

c c

a b

λ≤ λ≥ 2 1

. + + c_h c_h

a b

λ≤ λ≤ _# ch ch

a b

λ

≤ _ _

  _# ch ch

a b

λ

≤ _ _

 

h h

c c

a b

λ≥ λ≥ # : ch ch

a b

λ

≥ _ _

 

/ − − c_h c_h

a b

λ≥ λ≥

λ

≥

λ

≥

h h

c c

a b

λ≤ λ≤ 21

2 $

λ

≥ D! ; 21 # 4 6 "

For Peer Review Only

-*

) 6 -% & ( # ? &

Eh " EvBEh GvhBGh υh υvh ( #

* @%.+ %+. %0. %*0 %-. 4.00 *+Q

- >%@> %/* %>/ % , %*- 3.74 - Q . 0%>0 %+- %0- %*0 %-. 3.97 *+Q / +%0> %0> %,0 %-. %-0 4.37 0Q

& /%>,

For Peer Review Only

--) 6 .% # ( !

" φ (_°) EvBEh GvhBGh υh υvh cv/ch ( #

* * * %*+ %*+ *

- %+ %0 %*+ %-- %, 3.14 033%

. - *%/ %*+ %** *%- 5.31 13%

/ . * * %*+ %*+ *

+ . %+ %0 %*+ %-- %, 8.37 038%

> . - *%/ %*+ %** *%- 19.15 42%

0 %+ * * %*+ %*+ *

, %+ %+ %0 %*+ %-- %, 1.60 020%

@ %+ - *%/ %*+ %** *%- 2.37 18%

* %+ . * * %*+ %*+ *

** %+ . %+ %0 %*+ %-- %, 2.42 017%

*- %+ . - *%/ %*+ %** *%- 3.74 28%

For Peer Review Only

!" 2

For Peer Review Only

3

For Peer Review Only

2

For Peer Review Only

!! !! "#$% 3

For Peer Review Only

!! !! " #$

For Peer Review Only

!"#$ $$ " $$ %&' 3

For Peer Review Only

!"# ## ! ## $%&

For Peer Review Only

!"#

For Peer Review Only

Ev/Eh Gvh/Gh νh=νvh=0.2

! "## "## $%&

For Peer Review Only

Ev/Eh Gvh/Gh νh=νvh=0.2

!"# 3