Stable transfectants of human MCF-7 breast
cancer cells with increased levels of the human
folate receptor exhibit an increased sensitivity
to antifolates.
K N Chung, … , K H Cowan, P C Elwood
J Clin Invest.
1993;
91(4)
:1289-1294.
https://doi.org/10.1172/JCI116327
.
A major problem in cancer therapy is tumor drug resistance such as is found with antifolates
(e.g., methotrexate [MTX]). We are specifically interested in the role of the human folate
receptor (hFR) in MTX resistance. To investigate whether transfection of hFR results in
increased MTX uptake and increased drug sensitivity, human mammary carcinoma (MCF-7)
cells and Chinese hamster ovary cells (CHO) (cells which do not express detectable levels
of hFR) were transfected with hFR cDNA. Stable human mammary carcinoma and Chinese
hamster ovary transfectants expressing high levels of hFR were selected for further
analysis. Transfected cells which express increased levels of hFR grow more rapidly than
mock transfected or wild type cells in media containing physiologic concentrations of
folates. The hFR expressed by these cells is sorted to the plasma membrane and is
functional as determined by cell surface binding of a radiolabeled folic acid derivative and
by internalization of [3H]methotrexate. The stable transfectants that express increased
levels of hFR are also more sensitive to MTX in physiologic concentrations of folates. We
conclude that increased expression of hFR by human mammary carcinoma and Chinese
hamster ovary cells cultured under these conditions results in an enhanced growth rate,
increased folic acid binding, and increased MTX uptake and cytotoxicity.
Research Article
Find the latest version:
Stable Transfectants of Human MCF-7 Breast
Cancer Cells with Increased Levels of the Human Folate Receptor
Exhibit
an
Increased Sensitivity
to
Antifolates
Koong-Nah Chung, Yutaka Saikawa, Tae-Hyun Paik, Katharine H. Dixon, TimothyMulligan,
Kenneth H.Cowan, and PatrickC.Elwood
Medicine Branch, National Cancer Institute, National Institutes ofHealth, Bethesda, Maryland 20892
Abstract
A
major
problemin cancer therapy is
tumor drugresistance
such as
is found with antifolates (e.g., methotrexate
fMTXI).
We are
specifically
interested
in the roleof
the humanfolate
receptor (hFR)
in MTXresistance.
Toinvestigate
whethertransfection of
hFRresults
in increased MTXuptake
and in-creaseddrug sensitivity,
human mammary carcinoma(MCF-7) cells
and Chinese hamster ovary cells(CHO)
(cellswhich
do notexpress
detectable
levelsof hFR)
weretransfectedwith
hFR
cDNA. Stable
humanmammary carcinoma
andChinese
hamster
ovarytransfectants expressing high
levels of hFR wereselected for further analysis.
Transfected cells which express increased levelsof hFR
grow morerapidly
than mocktrans-fected
orwild
typecells
inmedia containing physiologic
con-centrations of folates.
The hFRexpressed by
these cellsis
sorted to the
plasma
membrane andis functional
asdetermined
by
cellsurface
binding of
aradiolabeled folic
acidderivative
and
by internalization of I3Hlmethotrexate.
Thestabletrans-fectants
that expressincreased levels of
hFR are also moresensitive
to MTX inphysiologic concentrations of
folates. Weconclude
that increasedexpression of
hFRby
humanmammarycarcinoma and Chinese
hamster ovarycells cultured
underthese conditions results
in anenhanced
growth
rate,increased
folic
acid binding,
andincreased
MTXuptakeand cytotoxicity.
(J.
Clin.
Invest.1993.91:1289-1294.)
Key words: cellgrowth
.drug resistance
*folate
binding
proteins
*folic acid
* metho-trexateIntroduction
Studies in normal and neoplastic human,
andmurinecells sug-gestthat
cellular resistanceto methotrexate(MTX)'
cytotoxic-ity is commonly
due to a defect in MTX transport ( 1-8).Al-though transport defects
have beenimplicated
indevelopment
Address correspondence to Koong-Nah Chung, Medicine Branch, Building10, Room 12N226, National Institutes of Health, 9000 Rock-ville Pike, Bethesda, MD 20892.
Receivedfor publication29July1992andinrevisedform30 Oc-tober1992.
1. Abbreviations used in this paper:CHO, Chinese hamster ovary; CMV,cytomegalovirus;DMEM, minimal essential media without fo-licacid; hFR,humanfolatereceptor;KB,humannasopharyngeal epi-dermoid carcinoma cells; MCF-7, humanmammarycarcinoma;
MCS,
multiple cloning site; MTX, methotrexate;PSF, penicillin/streptomy-cin/fungizone.
TheJournal of ClinicalInvestigation,Inc.
Volume 91, April 1993, 1289-1294
of
resistance
to MTX,specific mutations
or changes inexpres-sion
of transport molecules
have not beendescribed.
Atleast tworeceptorsystems
seem to beinvolved
in MTXtransport.
The reduced folate/ methotrexate transporter contained
inmu-rine
L-1210leukemia
cells (7, 9, 10) and humanCCRF-CEM
lymphoblastic
cells ( 1 1, 12) has an apparentmolecular
weightranging from
36 to 78 kD onSDS-PAGE
analysis (13-16)
andshows
preference for
reduced folates and equalaffinity
for MTX. The secondfolate/MTX transport
systemconsists
of amembrane-bound folate
receptor with highaffinities
for folatesincluding folic acid.
Itis
found in humannasopharyngeal
epi-dermoid carcinoma (KB)
cells, MA104
monkeykidney
cells, T47Dhuman
mammarycarcinoma
cells, L- 1210 andCCRF-CEM cells, and its expression increases when
cells areadapted
to
low folate concentrations ( 17-24). This folate receptor is
a40-kD
glycoprotein
and in
somecell lines
appears to berespon-sible
for internalization of folates
andmethotrexate.
Thefolate
receptor cDNA has been cloned and
described (25-30).
In
preliminary
studies of
KB cellsublines
selected for MTXresistant phenotypes
(31, 32),expression of
human folate re-ceptor(hFR)
mRNAandprotein
werefrequently
reduced inparallel with decreased
MTXuptake.
These resultssuggest
that hFRis
animportant determinant in
MTXresistance
orsensi-tivity in these cells.
Apotential problem in
theinterpretation of
such studies is that when drug resistant cell lines
areproduced,
gene
products other than the
oneof interest
may be induced orinhibited
andthese secondary changes
maycontribute
totheobserved
phenotype.
Tocircumvent this potential problem
and to
study the
roleof
asingle
gene product (the human folatereceptor) in
MTXsensitivity,
weintroduced recombinant
KBcell
cDNAencoding the
hFRinto human
mammarycarci-noma
(MCF-7) and Chinese
hamster ovary(CHO) cells
(cellswhich normally
do notexpress detectable
levelsof
hFR), andasked whether increased
hFRexpression leads
toincreased
MTX
sensitivity.
Wepresent
datawhich demonstrate that
stably transfected MCF-7 and CHO cells
expressing
increased
levels
of
hFR growbetter in
physiologic
folate
concentrations,
have an
increased surface binding of folic acid, internalize
more
MTX, and show increased sensitivity
to MTX.Methods
Materials.
'251I-labeled
pteroylglutamicacid(folic acid,['25 ]histamine derivative,[l-carboxy-3-(N)2-(4-[ 1251]iodoimidazolyl]
ethyl[car-bonoylJ-l-pteroyl-amino
propane)(histamine
derivative of folic acid),[35S]
methionine and[35S ]cysteine
werepurchased
fromNewEngland Nuclear, Boston, MA. Methotrexate was
purchased
from SigmaChemical Co. (St. Louis, MO).[3',5',7-3H]
MTX(sp
act, 20Ci/mmol) waspurchasedfrom Moravek Biochemicals
(Brea,
CA).
Scintillation fluidwas3a70Dfrom Research Products International (Mt. Prospect, IL). Acrylamide and low molecular
weight
markerswas obtained from Bethesda Research Laboratories (Gaithersburg, MD). Allrestriction enzymes and enzymes and reagents for radiolabel-ing cDNA probes were purchased from Promega Corp. (Madison, WI).5(alpha-32P]dCTP and dGTP(each withaspactof>800
Ci/
mmol) wereobtained from Amersham Corp.(Arlington Heights,IL). Nytranmembraneswereobtained from Schleicher & Schuell(Keene, NH). All other chemicalswereof reagentgradeorhigher, and were purchased from Sigma Chemical Co., Fisher Scientific (Pittsburgh, PA), or J. T. Baker Inc.(Phillipsburg, NJ).
Plasmid construction. The pRc/cytomegalovirus (CMV) vector (Invitrogen Corp., San Diego, CA) contains a cytomegalovirus
promo-torandaneomycinresistance gene. The cDNA encoding hFR (FR-PI0) was isolated from a placental cDNA GTl 1 library (Elwood, P. C., K.Price, Y. Saikawa, S. T. Page, P. Pacheco, and K.-N. Chung, manu-script inpreparation) and subcloned at the EcoRI multiple cloning site (MCS) of pGEM4Z (Promega Corp.). The insert-purified FR-PlO cDNAcontaining EcoRI ends was blunt-ended using Klenow large fragment (33). The HindIll linearized pRc/CMV expression vector was treatedwith Klenow large fragment and alkaline phosphatase, and vector wasligatedwith blunt-ended insert using T4 DNA ligase. Com-petentEscherichia coli (JM109)were transformed with theligation mixture and recombinant plasmids were isolated by maxiprep kit (Qia-gen,Inc.,Chatsworth, CA). The sense orientation ofthe folate receptor cDNA inpRc/CMV vector(pRc/P1O) was verified by restriction en-zymedigests. We designated the plasmid construct containing pRc/ CMVvectorandthe human nasopharyngeal epidermoid carcinoma (KB) cellfolate receptor cDNA (FR-PI0) as pRc/ P10.
Transfection.For stabletransfectionof MCF-7 and CHO cells with pRc/PlO,weused thecalciumphosphate method(34).MCF-7 and CHO cells were alsotransfectedwith pRc/ CMVvectoronly.Wefound that the wild type andneocontrol cellsareidentical in theirphenotype. These wild type andtransfectedclones servedascontrols inour experi-ments.Stable transfectants ofMCF-7 cells and CHO cellswereclonally selected in 1 mg/ml geneticinsulfate(antibiotic G418;Gibco Labora-tories,GrandIsland, NY)and 500 ug/ml G418, respectively, using cloning cylinders. 1,000 cells were plated per 10-cm tissue culture plates, and - 10 cloneswerepickedfrom eachplate.Stable
transfec-tantsofboth cell typesarebeingmaintained incytotoxic
concentra-tions of G418(200
,g/
ml).The cloneswereinitiallyselected in mini-malessential media (RMEM, 2.2MMfolicacid;GibcoLaboratories) and thentransferredtomediacontaininglowconcentrations of folates (DMEM, 1-10nMfolatesderivedfrom the added fetal calfserum). Wild type andtransfected cell lines have been maintained in DMEM for>12mo.For allexperiments reported herein,cellswerecultured inDMEMfor>6 passages(> 30doublings).
Immunoprecipitation ofhFR. MCF-7 stable transfectants (desig-natedasclones neo, A6, and A4)wereplated in 3 ml ofDMEM, containing 10%FCS, 100U/ml penicillin, 100Mg/ml streptomycin, 0.25
,g/ml
fungizone (PSF),and200Mg/ml
G418,in 35-mm wells (FalconPlastics, Cockeysville,MD)at37°C, 5%CO2.Plating densities wereadjusted so that cells were 75% confluent whenwecarriedoutthe immunoprecipitation experiments.Cellswerewashedoncewith 2 ml media containing no methionineorcysteine(Gibco Laboratories), andincubated in 2 ml of thesamemedia for 1 hat37°C, 5%CO2. Newlysynthesized proteins were radiolabeled by pulsing the cells in 1mlofthesamemedia containing 100
MCi
[35S]
methionine and100MACi
[35S]cysteinefor 1 h at37°C, 5%CO2.The cells were washedonce (2 ml) in media containing added cold methionine (15 mg/liter; Gibco Laboratories) and cysteine (24 mg/liter; Gibco Laboratories), and proteins were chased in this complete media (2 ml) for 5 h at 37°C, 5% CO2.Atthe endof the chase period, cells were washed three times with (2mleach)ice-cold PBS, pH 7.4 (10 mM Na-phosphate, 150 mM NaCl; BiofluidsInc.,Rockville, MD). Cells were scraped into (5 ml) ice cold PBS, 20mMEDTA, pH 7.4, and 0.3% PMSF, and centrifuged
at3,000 g for 15 min at4°C.Cell pellets were resuspended in ice-cold (I ml) 10mMpotassium phosphate, pH 7.4, and freeze-thawed twice. Cell membraneswerespunfor 15 min at 13,000 g at4°C.Membrane
proteins
were solubilized in 1 ml PBScontaining 1%Triton X-100(vol/vol)for 18hat40Con ashakingplatform. (All subsequent steps werecarried out in buffers containing PMSF). Debriswasremovedby centrifugation for 15 minat13,000 gat40C.Supernatant sampleswere
used forimmunoprecipitationasfollows: ProteinA-Sepharose (Sigma ChemicalCo.)wasprewashed in immunoprecipitation buffer (10 mM Tris, 150 mMNaCl, 2 mM EDTA, pH 7.4, and 1% Triton X-100) and resuspended 1:1 (vol/vol) in immunoprecipitation buffer. Protein
sam-pleswerepreabsorbed with 100 Ml of prewashed Protein-A Sepharose for 2 hat40Candcentrifugedfor 1min,14,000g,at40C. Preabsorbed protein samples were assayed for protein by the Biuret method (Pierce ChemicalCo., Rockford, IL) and volumeswereadjustedtogive identi-calprotein concentrations. BSAwasusedasthe standard. Protein
sam-ples (lOgI each)wereimmunoprecipitated with 50 Ml rabbit anti-hFR antiserum in 750
,l
immunoprecipitationbuffercontaining0.1% SDS for 3 hat250C.Immunoprecipitateswereincubated with 100 Ml Pro-teinA-Sepharose for 30 minat roomtemp and washed four times(1 ml) withimmunoprecipitationbuffer. SDS-PAGEsamplebuffer (50 Milconsistingof 0.125 MTris, pH 6.8,
2%SDS,
20%glycerol,
0.08% bromophenol blue, and 100 mMDL-dithiothreitol)wasaddedtothe finalProtein-A Sepharose pellets.Sampleswereboiled for 5 min and Protein-A Sepharose pelleted in themicrocentrifuge. Supernatants (50,Ml)
andprestained
lowmolecularweight
markers(Bio-Rad
Laborato-ries) were electrophoresedon a 12.5% SDS-PAGE and the gelwastreated three times(15 mineach)with 50% methanol and 10% acetic acid,rinsedoncewith H2O, and incubated for 1 h in Enlightening (NewEngland Nuclear). After drying, the gelwasautoradiographedat
-70°C incassetteswithtwointensifyingscreens.
RNAslot blot.Total RNA(IOg)isolated fromstablytransfected clonesofMCF-7 cellswastransferredtoNytran membranesbymeans
ofaslot blot apparatus(Schleicher&Schuell, Inc.).Theblotwas pre-hybridized,hybridized with radiolabeledFR-PlO,and washed as previ-ously described (25). Under these conditions, a single species of mRNA
('-
1,100 bp)hybridizeswith radiolabeled hFR-PlO cDNAonNorthernanalysis ofcellsexpressingthe hFR.Signalintensities of each bandwerequantitated usingaspectrophotometer (DU65;Beckman Instruments,Inc., Fullerton, CA)equippedwithadensitometer. Hy-bridizationwith radiolabeled actinwasusedto correctfor RNA loaded. Growthstudies. Stable transfectants of wild type MCF-7cells,were
seededat50,000 cells/3mlin DMEMcontaining10%FCS, PSF,and 200
,g/ml
G418 in 35 mmwells,at37°C,5%CO2. Cellswere har-vested 5 d later. Cellswererinsed twice with (3 ml) cold PBS and solubilizedasdescribed above (seeimmunoprecipitation studies). Pro-teinconcentration in each solubilizedsamplewasdeterminedas de-scribed above. Growth experimentswerecarriedoutthree separate times. Values from separateexperimentsvariedby<10%.Cellsurface folic acid bindingassay. MCF-7 stable transfectants wereplatedasdescribed above (see immunoprecipitation studies). KB cellsweremaintained in thesamemediawithoutG418.Plating densi-tieswereadjustedsothat cellswere75% confluentfor the folic acid bindingassays. The form of radiolabeledfolicacid used isaniodinated, histamine derivative of folic acid obtained from New England Nuclear. Cellswerewashedtwotimes with(3ml) ice-cold pH 4.5 saline (10mM
Na-acetate, 150mMNaCI)todissociate surface-bound folates from cellsurfacefolate receptor. Cell monolayersweresubsequently washed
twotimes with(3ml) ice-cold PBS, pH 7.4,to returnthepH to neutral. For cellsurface-bindingof radiolabeled folic acid, cells were incubated in 2mlof ice-coldDMEM(without FCS), containing iodinated, hista-mine derivative of folic acid (20,000 cpm total added to 50 nM cold folicacid) and 50
Mg/ml
BSA for 15 min in an ice-H20 bath. To determinespecificcellsurface binding (cpm/mg protein), parallel ex-perimentswereperformedin which 1,000-fold excess of cold folic acidwasadded. The monolayer was washed two times with (with 3 ml each) ice-cold PBS, pH 7.4. Cells were solubilized as described above (see immunoprecipitationstudies). Supernatant samples were counted in a gamma counter(55B; Beckman Instruments, Inc.) at - 70% effi-ciency.Protein concentration in each solubilized sample was deter-minedasdescribed above. The datareflect specific cell surface-binding ofradioligand,since in the presence of1,000-foldexcess of
tivefolic acid, theamountoffolic acid binding was<5%ofthat seen in controls.Cell surface folic acid binding experimentswerecarried out three separate times. Values from separate experiments varied by
<10%.
Folic acidbinding assay. Folic acid binding assays on detergent-so-lubilizedprotein extracts were carried out as previously described ( 19). Methotrexate transport studies. MCF-7 stable transfectants and KB cellswereplatedasdescribed above (see folic acid binding assays). Cell monolayerswere washed twotimes with (3 ml) ice-cold pH 4.5 saline andtwotimes with(3 ml) ice-cold PBS, pH 7.4. For internalization of 3H-MTX, cells wereincubated in 2 ml of prewarmed(370C)DMEM (without FCSor other additives), containing 50
Ag/ml
BSA,and 2AM
[3H]MTX, for 30 min at 370C, 5% Co2. To determine specificMTXinternalization (pmol/mg protein), parallel experiments were per-formed in the presence of500-foldexcesscold MTX. Todifferentiate transportmediated byhFRfrom the reduced folate transporter, paral-lelexperimentswere runin the presenceof molar(100-fold) excess of coldfolic acid which inhibits transport via hFR. The monolayer was washed oncewith 2mlice-cold PBS (pH 7.5), once with2mlpH 4.5 saline to remove surface-bound 3H-MTX, andfinallywith 2 mlof ice-cold PBS (pH 7.5). Cells were solubilized as described above (see immunoprecipitation studies). Samples (500
Al)
were added to 10 ml ofliquid scintillation cocktail and countedon a liquidscintillationcounter(Tri-carb;PackardInstrumentCo., Inc.,DownersGrove, IL) at - 50% efficiency. The data reflect specificinternalization of
3H-MTX,since in the presence of excess nonradiolabeled MTX, MTX
internalizationwas <10% of totaluptake for all datapoints. Protein concentration in eachsolubilized samplewasdeterminedasdescribed above. The 3H-MTX transport studieswerecarriedoutthree separate times. Values from separateexperimentsvariedby< 10%.
Methotrexate sensitivity. MCF-7 stable transfectants (clones neo, A4, andA6) and CHO stable transfectants(CHO,clones 1 and2)were
plated asdescribed above (see growth studies). After 24 h (to allow the cellstoattachtotheplates),medium containing increasing concentra-tions ofMTX(0-1,000 nM)wasadded. Cellswere harvested 5 d later. Cellswererinsed twice with 3mlcoldPBS, andsolubilized as described above (seeimmunoprecipitation studies). The protein concentration of each samplewasdeterminedasdescribed above. The MTX sensitiv-ity studies werecarriedoutthree separatetimes and the values from separateexperiments varied by< 5%.
Results and Discussion
Previous studies (32)
have demonstratedacorrelation
between decreasedinternalization of methotrexate(MTX)
and reducedT7
SP6
IBGHpolyAsignal
Neo
Figure1.
pRc/PlO
construct. ThepRc/PlO
construct (6,372 bp) consistsof the pRc/CMVvector(5,452 bp) and cDNA insert (920 bp).MCF-7
CLONES
neo
A6
A4
Figure 2. Immunopreci-pitation ofhFRprotein. MCF-7 cells (clones neo, A6, and A4) were
MW
std incubatedplates inDMEMin35-mmcon-taining 10% FCS, PSF, and200Ag/mlG418. Newly synthesized
pro-106 kd
teins
wereradiolabeled
with [35S] methionine
80
and[35S]cysteine,
and immunoprecipitatedus-49.5 ing rabbit anti-hFR an-tiserumasdescribedin Methods. The immuno-precipitates were elec-trophoresed on 12.5% 32.5 SDS-PAGEand the
au-toradiogramis shown.
(Lane 1) 10,ug
of mem-27.5 braneproteins of neoclone. (Lane 2) 10 ug of membraneproteins of A6 clone. (Lane3) 10
,ug
of membranepro-teins of A4 clone. The
18.5
molecularweight
mark-ers areindicated.
expressionofthe folate receptorinKBclones selected for resis-tance to MTX. To
determine
ifincreased expression of
the folate receptor contributes to MTXcytotoxicity,
we trans-fected hFR cDNAinto mammalian
cells.Fig.
1showsthe plas-mid constructcontaining
pRc/CMV vector and the human KBcellfolate receptor cDNA(FR-PI0),
which
wedesignate
as pRc/P10.Compared
to thepreviously
reported KB cell c32 cDNA(25),
the FRP1O cDNAcontains
anidentical
openreading frame,
but shorter 5' and 3'untranslated
regions.
We chose thisconstructbecause thelength
ofthe 5'UTR may af-fect theefficiency
of translation orstability
of thetranscript
and because the
5LJTR
of c32 containsseveral
termination codons upstreamtothetranslational initiation site.Since
human mammarycarcinoma
(MCF-7)
cells donot expressdetectable levels of
hFR mRNA orprotein (25),
we transfected MCF-7 cells withpRc/P1O
and obtained clones thatstably
express hFR. Weselected
aclonetransfected
with vectoralone (neo), andtwoclonestransfected with pRc/
PI0(clones
A6 andA4)
for furtheranalysis.
As determinedby
immunoprecipitation of radiolabeled newly
synthesized
pro-teins,
stabletransfectants (clones
A6 andA4)
expresshigh
lev-elsof the
hFRprotein
whencompared
tocontrol
cells(neo
clone) which
donotcontain
detectable levelsof hFR,
asshown inFig. 2.
The A6 cloneexpressed
thehighest
level and A4clone
expressed
thenexthighest
levelof
hFR.Toassessthe hFR levels more quantitatively, the level of hFR
transcripts
expressed by stable MCF-7 transfectants weredetermined by
slot blotanalysis of total
cellular RNA.Fig.
3 A showsthat
clones A6 and A4 expressincreased
levelsof hFRtranscripts.
Aspreviously
reported, MCF-7 cellstransfected
with pRc/CMV
vectoralone(neo clone) did not express de-tectable levelsof
hFRtranscript,
represented inFig.
3 A asA Figure 3. (A) Slot blot
100- analysis of mRNA. The
slot blotcontaining to-talRNA from each
(0_
|transfectant
of MCF-7E 'e' 50 _ _ cellswas
prepared
andcc
<
hybridized
asdescribedin Methods. The
u.d. mRNAlevelswere
de-0 tected
by
using
aradio-neo A6 A4 labeled hFR cDNA probe and theintensity of thesignal for each clonewasquantitated usingadensitometer. Since clone A6
ex-B pressed the highest level,
400 allvalues were
normal-ized to the-transcript abundance observed in
°2 1 _clone A6. The neo clone
'j0
4had
undetectable(ud.)
eJ °
2001
_ - hFR mRNA levels.(B)
0-0 |_ _Determination of
growth. MCF-7 cells -00
neoA6 A4 (clones neo, A6, and
A4) wereincubatedfor 5 d inDMEMcontaining10%FCS, PSF, and 200
Ag/ml
G418. Cells were solubilizedwith PBS containing 1% TritonX-100 overnight at 4°C.Supernatantwasassayed forprotein,and resultsareexpressedas apercentage ofproteinin control cells(neoclone, 100
jig).
Next weexamined whether clones A6 andA4expressing
increased levels
of hFRreplicate
faster than the neo clone in lowconcentrations
of folates. We foundapositive
relationship between hFRexpression
levels andgrowth
inlowconcentra-tions of folates
asshown inFig.
3 B. Stabletransfectantsex-pressing increased
levelsof
hFR(A6
andA4)
grew3.2-
and2.8-fold faster
thancells transfected
withvectoralone
(neo)
orparental
MCF-7 cells(data
notshown).
Similarfindings
wererecently
reported(35).
The hFR expressed byclones A6 andA4
is
sorted to theplasma membrane and
binds
ligand. Fig.
4Ashows that
clones A6 and A4bind
high levels of radiolabeled folic acid
(iodin-ated, histamine derivative of folic
acid)
atthe cellsurface,
at levels(50-70%)
approaching
thatseenin
KBcells
(normally, ahigh
hFRexpressing
cell
line). Fig.
4 Aalso
showsthat the
neo clonedid
notcontain
detectable levelsof
cellsurface folic acid
binding ("u.d.").
Wehave also
carried
out ourstudies
onthe cellsurface-binding
of this radioligand for
30 min at0°C
and foundnodifference
betweensurface-binding
at 15 and 30min(data
not shown). We have performed preliminaryligand-binding studies using
thephysiological circulating form of fo-late (5-methyltetrahydrofofo-late) and observed identical results(data
notshown).
When compared to control cells (neoclone),
thesolubilized
totalcellular extracts of clones A6 and A4alsoshowed proportionate increases in their total folic acidbinding capacity
atlevels
(40-50%)
approaching that seen in KBcells
(data
notshown).
To
show
that thefolate
receptor is functional at the cellsurface
in thesetransfectants,
we measuredspecificinternaliza-tion of [3H]methotrexate.
Asshownin
Fig.
4B, stable transfec-tants expressing elevated levels of hFR show increased3H-MTX uptake when cultured in DMEM: clones A6 and A4 internalize 3.2- and 2.4-fold more3H-MTX than cells mock transfectedwithvectoralone(neo). Fig. 4 B also shows that MTX transport found in clones A6 and A4areapproaching levels found in KB cells which internalize 3.6-fold more
'H-MTX than theneoclone.Interestingly, theneoclone demon-strated folicacid insensitive MTX uptake consistent with the absence of cell surface folic acid binding. In contrast,MTX
uptake by the A6 and A4 transfectants is inhibited by both cold MTX (>90%) and folic acid (> 60%). The absence of cell surface folicacid binding and the lack of inhibition of
MTX
influx in thepresence ofexcessfolic acidsuggestthat MCF-7 cells haveahFR-independent method of accumulatingMTX suchasthereduced folatetransporter( 1-8 ).However, trans-fection of MCF-7 cells with hFRappears to further increase (2.4- and3.2-fold) their abilitytointernalize additionalMTX. To determine whether the differences inMTX uptakeare reflectedinMTX cytotoxicity, growthinhibitioninincreasing concentrations ofMTXwasmeasuredfor each transfectant. As shown inFig. 5 A, clones A4 and A6are8- and 10-fold respec-tivelymoresensitive toMTX than cells mock transfected with vector alone (neo) and wild type MCF-7 cells (data not shown). These results also demonstrate that the growth of mock transfectantswasnotcompletely inhibited,even atMTX concentrations 100-fold greater than that which inhibited >99% of thegrowthof clonesA4 and A6. Theexperimentson thesensitivitytoMTXwerecarried out for5d. We havefound
A Figure 4.(A)
Determi-100- nation of cell surface
folic acid
binding.
MCF-7 cells(clones neo,A6, and A4) were@X50- | i X incubated in 35-mm
plates
inDMEMcon-taining
10%FCS, PSF, and200,g/ml
G418.0-
KKBI i zE
cellsweregrown inneo A6 A4 KB DMEM containing 10%
FCS and PSF.After dis-sociatingsurface-bound folates from cell surface folate receptors with acid salineasdescribed
B in Methods, cellswere
400- incubated with
radiola-beledfolicacid for 15 minat
0°C
withor withoutexcesscoldli-XC 11 gand.
Aliquots
ofsolu-°200- | %bilizedcells were
counted and the results
are
expressed
ascell neo KB surface binding relativetothat observedin KB
cells.(B) Determinationof[3H]methotrexate transport. MCF-7 cells from eachclonewere incubated inDMEM containing 10% FCS, PSF, and 200
gg/ml
G418. KB cells were grown in DMEM contain-ing 10% FCS and PSF. After dissociatcontain-ing surface-bound folates from cellsurface folate receptor as described in Methods, cells were allowedA MCF-7cells
100 4O--eo
--00- 1A4
U~A6
80
-60
VE
] e<
0 0
Ao
40-20
1
T0- 7
0 1 10 100 1000
MTX(nM)
B CHO cells
100 0- CHO
0 clone 1
U-clone2
80-
60-0 60-0
a-0a
O
40-
20-0 1 10 100 1000
MTX(nM)
Figure
5. Determination ofMIX sensitivity
intransfectedcells. MCF-7cells(A)
andCHOcells(B)
fromeach clonewereincubated for 5 d in DMEMcontaining
10%FCS,
PSF,
and200,tg/
ml G418 withincreasing MIX
concentrations. After solubilization ofcells,
the supernatantwasassayed
forprotein.
Resultsareexpressed
as a per-centage ofprotein
ateachMIX
concentration relativetototalprotein
in the absenceof
MIX
foreachseparateclone.identical
results when theexperiments
werecarriedoutfor 10 d(data
notshown).
Identical
resultswereobserved whengrowth
inhibition
wasdetermined
by
cellcounts.Wehaveconfirmedour
findings
inMCF-7 cells
by
estab-lishing
and characterizing Chinese hamster ovary(CHO)
transfectants which
stably
express functional hFR.Fig.
5 B shows that whencompared
to control cells, these stable trans-fectants(clones
1and2)
areapproximately
5-foldmore sensi-tive toMtiX.
Furthermore,
compared to control CHOcells,
clones 1 and 2 also bindmoreradiolabeled folic acidatthe cell
surface,
internalize 2 to 3-foldmore 3H-McX
andgrow
4-fold
better in
physiologic
concentrations
of folates(data
notshown).
Inthese
studies,
wehave
observed thatsensitivity
toMIX
depends
ontheconcentration
of folates contained in theme-dium. When folate concentrationsarelow, stable
transfectants
that express
elevated
levelsof hFR
are moresensitivetoMTX
than wild
typecells
(Fig.
5, Aand
B). However,in standard
medium,
wedid
notobserve
adifference in
MTXsensitivity
between neo and
A4/A6 clones (data
notshown). Since
stan-dardmedium (e.g.,
RMEM)contains
2.2AuM
folic acid andsince intracellular folate concentrations
are adirect function of
folate concentration
in culturemedium (36), it
is likely that thereduced
MTXcytotoxicity
that weobserved
intransfec-tants
cultured in
RMEMresults from competitive inhibition of
MTX
transport
by folic acid[which
has a higheraffinity
than MTXfor
the hFR].This
effect of folic acid concentration
on MTXcytotoxicity
has also beenobserved
in KB cells(36).
In
conclusion,
we haveestablished
stabletransfectants
which express
high levels of hFR, to levelsapproaching
thatfound
in KBcells. These clones show that inphysiologic
con-centrations
of folic acid, increased levels of
hFRexpression
arerelated
to cellgrowth, folic
acidbinding
andtransport, MTX
transport,
and
MTXsensitivity.
We have alsoobserved
small butreproducible differences in
theexpression of
hFR
between
clones
A6 and A4which
areconsistent with different
biochemi-cal
assaysfor
hFR
function. Although it is possible
that otherfactors
maybe different between
these two clones andtheir
controls,
thereappears
to be acorrelation between
levelsof
hFRand
function
ofthehFR.
References
1.Assaraf, Y. G., andR. T.Schimke. 1987. Identification of methotrexate
transportdeficiency in mammalian cells usingfluoresceinatedmethotrexate and
flowcytometry. Proc.Nati. Acad.Sci. USA.84:7154-7158.
2.Flintoff,W.F., and C. R. Nagainis. 1983. Transport of methotrexate in Chinesehamster ovarycells:a mutantdefectivein methotrexate uptake and cell binding. Arch.Biochem. Biophys.223:433-440.
3.Frei, E.,III,A.Rosowsky, J.E.Wright, C.A.Cucchi,J. A.Lippke,T. J.
Ervin, J. Jolivet, and W.A.Haseltine. 1984. Development of methotrexate
resis-tanceinahumansquamouscellcarcinomaofthe head and neck in culture. Proc.
Nati.Acad.Sci. USA.81:2873-2877.
4.Galivan, J. 1981.5-methyltetrahydrofolatetransport by hepatoma cells and
methotrexate-resistantsubline in culture. Cancer Res. 41:1757-1762. 5. Schuetz, J. D., L. H.Matherly,E. H.Westin, andI.D.Goldman. 1988. Evidence forafunctional defect in thetranslocationof the methotrexate trans-port carrier inamethotrexate-resistantmurineLl210leukemiacell line.JBiol.
Chem.263:9840-9847.
6.Sherwood, S. W.,Y.G.Assaraf,A.Molina, and R. T. Schimke. 1990.Flow
cytometric characterization ofantifolate resistance in cultured mammalian cells
using fluoresceinated methotrexate anddaunorubicin. Cancer Res. 50:4946-4950.
7.Sirotnak,F. M. 1985.Obligate genetic expressionintumorcellsofafetal membrane property mediating "folate" transport. Biological significance and
implicationsforimproved therapy ofhuman cancer.CancerRes.45:3992-4000.
8.Underhill,T.M., andW. F.Flintoff. 1989.Complementation ofa
metho-trexate uptakedefect in Chinese hamster ovarycellsbyDNA-mediatedgene
transfer. Mol. Cell.Biod.9:1754-1758.
9.Goldman,I.D., andL. H.Matherly. 1986. Membrane Transport of
Anti-neoplasticAgents InternationalEncyclopediaof Pharmacology and Therapeu-tics.Section 118. Pergamon Press, Oxford. 283-302.
10. Henderson, G. B., and E.M.Zevely. 1984.Affinity labelingofthe
5-meth-yltetrahydrofolate/methotrexate transportproteinof L1210 cellsbytreatment
with an N-hydroxysuccinimide ester of [3H]methotrexate. J. Biol. Chem. 259:4558-4562.
11. Henderson, G. B. 1990. Folate-binding proteins. Annu. Rev. Nutr.
10:319-335.
12. Jansen, G., G.R.Westerhof,M.J.A.Jarmuszewski,I.Kathmann,G. Rijksen, andJ. H.Schornagel.1990. Methotrexatetransportin varianthuman
CCFR-CEM leukemiacellswithelevatedlevelsof the reduced folate carrier. J. Biol. Chem.265:18272-18277.
13. Fan, J.,K.S.Vitol,andF. M. Huennekens. 1991. Biotin derivatives of
methotrexate andfolatesynthesisand utilization foraffinitypurificationoftwo
membrane-associated folate transporters from L1210 cells. J Biol. Chem.
266:14862-14865.
erythro-leukemiacellsup-regulatedfortetrahydrofolatecofactor and methotrexate
trans-port. Cancer Res. 51:3420-3426.
15. Price,E.M., M. Ratnam, K. Rodeman, andJ. H.Freischeim. 1988.
Characterizationof the methotrexate transport pathway in murine L1210 leuke-mia cells:involvement ofamembrane receptor andacytosolic protein. Biochem-istry. 27:7853-7858.
16. Yang, C. H., F.M.Sirotnak, and L. S. Mines. 1988. Further studieson a
novel classof geneticvariantsof the L12 10 cell with increased folate analogue transport inward. J. Bio.Chem.263:9703-9709.
17.Antony,A.C., M. A.Kane, R. M.Portillo, P. C. Elwood,and J. F.
Kothouse. 1985. Studies of the role ofaparticulate folate-binding proteinin the uptake of5-methyltetrahydrofolate bycultured human KB cells. J. BioL.Chem.
260:14911-14917.
18. Deutsch, J.C., P.C.Elwood, R. M.Portillo,M.G. Macey, and J. F.
Kolhouse.1989. Role of the membrane-associated folatebinding protein(folate
receptor) in methotrexate transport by human KB cells.Arch. Biochem.Biophys.
274:327-337.
19. Elwood,P.C., M.A.Kane, R. M.Portillo,and J. F. Kolhouse.1986. The isolation,characterization,andcomparisonofthe membrane-associatedand solu-blefolate-bindingproteins fromKBcells.J.Biol. Chem.261:15416-15423.
20.Henderson, G. B.,J.M.Tsuji,and H. P. Kumar. 1988. Mediateduptake offolate byahigh-affinity binding proteininsublinesofLI210 cellsadaptedto
nanomolarconcentrations of folate.J.Membr.BioL. 101:247-258.
21. Jansen, G., I. Kathmann, B. C. Rademaker, B. J.M.Braakhuis,G. R. Westerhof, G. Rijksen, and J.H.Schornagel. 1989.Expressionofafolatebinding
protein in L1210 cells grown in low folate medium. Cancer Res. 49:1959-1963. 22. Kane, M. A.,R. M.Portillo, P.C. Elwood,A.C. Antony, and J. F. Kolhouse. 1986. Theinfluence ofextracellularfolate concentrationon
metho-trexateuptakebyhuman KBcells. J.Biol. Chem. 261:44-49.
23. Kane, M. A., P.C. Elwood, R. M. Portillo,A.C. Antony, and J. F. Kolhouse. 1986. The interrelationship of the soluble membrane-associated folate
binding proteinsin human KB cells. J.Biol.Chem.261:15625-15631. 24.Kane, M. A., and S. Waxman. 1989.Biology of disease:roleof folate bindingproteinsinfolate metabolism. Lab.Invest. 60:737-746.
25. Elwood,P.C. Molecularcloningandcharacterizationof the human
fo-late-bindingproteincDNA fromplacentaandmalignanttissue culture (KB) cells. 1989. J. Biol. Chem. 264:14893-14901.
26. Lacey, S. W., J. M. Sanders, K. G. Rothberg, R. G. W. Anderson, and B. A. Kamen. 1989. Complementary DNA for the folate binding protein correctlypredictsanchoring to the membrane by glycosyl-phosphatidylinositol. J.Clin.Invest.84:715-720.
27. Sadasivan, E., and S. P. Rothenberg. 1989. The complete amino acid sequence of a human folate binding protein from KB cells determined from the cDNA. J.Biol. Chem. 264:5806-581 1.
28.Brigle, K. E., E. H. Westin, M. T. Houghton, and I. D. Goldman. 1991.
Characterizationof two cDNAs encoding folate-binding proteins from L1210 murine leukemia cells. Increased expression associated with a genomic rearrange-ment. J.Biol. Chem. 266:17243-17249.
29. Campbell,I.G., T. A. Jones, W. D. Foulkes, and J. Trowsdale. 1991. Folate-binding protein is a marker for ovarian cancer. Cancer Res. 51:5329-5338.
30.Coney, L. R.,A.Tomassetti,L.Carayannopoulos, V. Frasca, B. A. Ka-men, M.I.Colnaghi, and V. R. Zurawski, Jr. 1991. Cloningofa tumor-associated
antigen:MOv18 & MOv19antibodies recognize a folate-binding protein. Cancer Res.51:6125-6132.
31.Knight, C. B.,P.C.Elwood, and B.A.Chabner. 1988. The human folate receptor inKBcellsis alteredintransportmediated, acquiredmethotrexate
resis-tance.Blood.72:274A.
32. Saikawa, Y., andP.C. Elwood. 1990. Decreased humanfolatereceptor (hFR)expression is associated withacquiredmethotrexateresistance.Blood.
76:164A.
33.Sambrook, J.,E. F.Fritsch,and T.Maniatis. 1989. MolecularCloning:A
Laboratory Handbook. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, ColdSpringHarbor, NY.
34.Cullen, B. R. 1987. Use of eukaryotic expression technology in the func-tionalanalysis of cloned genes. Methods Enzymol. 152:684-704.
35. Matsue, H., K. G. Rothberg, A. Takashima, B. A. Kamen, and R. G. Anderson. 1992. Folate receptor allows cells to grow in low concentrations of 5-methyltetrahydrofolate. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA. 89:6006-6009.