W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R 1
Jeff Benjamin
Senior Vice
President
Nuclear Power Plants
(NPP)
AP1000™ Technology: Passive & Proven
The Right Fit for Brazil
AP1000 is a tr ademar k or r egis ter ed tr ademar k of W e s tinghou se Elec tr ic C o mpany LLC , its and /o r its subsid ia ries in the United State s of America and may be registe re d in othe r cou n th ro ugh out th e w o rl d . All ri g h ts r e s e rv ed. U n a u thor iz e d use is strictly proh ib ite d . Othe r names may trade ma rks of their respe c tive owne rs.
2 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
W
estinghouse Electric Company
•
Incorporated in
1886
by
George
W
e
stinghouse
•
Responsible
for some
of the
world’
s
most
important achievements:
–
AC technology
–
1
st
commercial radio broadcast
–
USS Nautilus
–
1
st
camera on the moon
–
Commercial nuclear power
USS Nautilus
Geor
ge
W
estinghouse
W
o
rld’
s first pr
essurized
water
re
actor
V
ision: to be the customers’
choice in
supplying leading-edge nuclear
technology to satisfy
the world’
s
growing demand
3 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
Solely Focused on Commercial Nuclear Technology
•
Our
newest design –
the AP1000
®
pressurized water reactor
(PWR)
–
features
innovative passive safety systems and
proven
technologies based on Westinghouse’s
50+ years of experience
Nearly
50 percent
of the nuclear
power plants in operation
worldwide are
based on
W
e
4 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
Nuclear Power
Plants
Specializing in
the development
and delivery
of new nuclear
power
plant projects
Automation and Field
Services
A
global
field
services
and
instrumentation and control solutions
provider
, focused on
delivering
industry-leadi
ng operations solutions
and better outage services worldwide
Nuclear Fuel
A
single-source fuel
provider for
PWR,
BWR, VVER and
AGR reactors
worldwide
Westinghouse Electric Company
Business Structure
Engineering, Equipment
and Major Projects
Focused on ensuring new
and
operating
plant success by providing
technically superior engineering,
hardware and
services that
enhance
plant safety
, ensure
plant reliabili
ty
,
5 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
W
estinghouse Locations
60+ Sites Worldwide!
6 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
World Energy Demand
Is Growing
•
W
o
rld population will
increase 14 percent in the
next 12 years
•
Rising
energy demand from
economic output
and
improved standards of living
will strain
energy
supplies
•
W
o
rld energy consumption
is
projected to grow 56%
between 2010 and 2040
Source: U.S.
Energy Info
rm
ation Adm
inistration,
July 2013
7 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
Critical Decisions Must Be Made
•
We
need
to address growing
energy
needs with environmentally
responsible
energy solutions that
benefit our communities
•
Multiple ways
to achieve these
goals:
–
Conservation
–
Balanced portfolio
of
“clean”
energy
technologies
–
Deployment of
vehicles powered
from clean
energy
sources
8 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
Nuclear Energy Has an Environmental Impact
Comparable to
Renewables
0
500
1000
1500
gr
am equiv CO2/kWh
Low
High
Coal
-M
odern
Plant
Solar Photovoltaic
Natural Gas
(Combined
Cycle)
Wind
Biomass/forestry/waste
combustion
Nuclear
Hydropower
2
-48
2
-59
15
-101
7
-124
389
-511
13
-731
790
-1182
So u rce: “ H y d ropow er -I nter nalis ed C o s ts a n d Ex te rnalis ed Be nefits ,” Frans H. Koc h . Internation a l En e rgy Ag enc yLif
e Cy
cle Emissions
for V
arious
Electricit
y
Sour
ces
9 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
For a Number of Reasons…
•
Increasing energy demand
•
Climate change
•
Security of supply
•
High-paying jobs
•
Economic value for
communities
Nuclear energy MUST
be
part
of the future energy
10 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
Brazil’s Unique
11 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
Brazil’s Unique
Position in the World Today
T
op
10 in >100GW Capacity
Top 10
in
Population
T
op
10 in GDP
T
op
10 in Uranium
Reserves
12 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
0
2
000
4
000
6
000
8
000
1
0000
12000
14000
16000
18000
Canada
United
States
Australia
Korea,
Rep.
Saudi
Arabia
Belg
ium
Switzerland
Japan
France
Germany
Cz
ech
Republic
Spain
Italy
Chile
China
Argentina
Urug
uay
Brazil
Mexi
co
Pa
nama
Pa
ra
guay
India
Electric
Energy Consumption (kWh per Capita)
Source: World Bank 201
1
Currently 84
th
: expect
significant
increase with
growing economy
Since 2006:
Brazil:
+ 17%
India:
+ 40%
China: + 157%
13 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
Brazil’s Rich and Diversified Energy Reserves
Source: BEN 2007 (Note: does not account
for
recent O&G
discoveries offshore)
Estimated
National
Energy
Reserves
(equivalent in
millions of barrels
of oil)
55.633
16.453
3.249
63.560
Uranium
N
atural Gas
Oil
Coal
100 yrs: 19.102
100 yrs: 122.040
Biomass
Wi
n
d
100 yrs: 76.948
Hydro
14 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
Estimate:
>800 million
tons
So u rce: BEN 2007Uranium Resources in
Brazil
T
oday’
s capability: > 300
million
tons de U3O8
6
th
Reserve in
the
W
orld
• with only 30%
of the national territory
explored
• allows for availability of material
and
stability
of fuel prices
• existing capability of fuel technology
15 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
Fuel Cycle Technology Established and Growing
Source: Industrias
N
ucleares
16 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
Mature Nuclear Energy Generation Experience
Gener
ation
thr
ough
2012:
198.490.932
MWh
Generation
rec
ord
2012:
16
TWh
2
nd
Best
Availability Factor in
the W
orld
in 201
1
Angra 1&2 : 95.7%
17 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
Sustainability of Brazilian Nuclear
Industry
•
Brazil has Competitive Edge for Supporting
New Build
–
Capable, recognized nuclear operator
–
Fuel Cycle
Capability
–
Mature Regulatory
Body
–
Nuclear Construction Experience
–
Strong Engineering & Sciences
Programs
–
Experienced Supply Chain
•
Demographics Challenging Industry
•
New Projects Attracting Limited Amount of New Talent
•
Maintaining
the Key Skills Needs to be part of Debate
Scale of Industry is KEY to Sustaining
18 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
Westinghouse Presence in Brazil
Angra 1
INB
Eletronucl
e
ar (ETN)
•
Angra
1 NSSS supplied
in 70’
s
•
Operati
o
ns support
•
Outage support
•
Codes &
Methods
Indústrias
N
ucleares
do Brasil
(INB)
•
Provided technol
ogy for
manufact
u
ri
ng of
Angra 1
reload fuel
•
Joint Developm
ent
of 16x16
Next
Generati
o
n Fuel
Program
•
Codes &
Methods
A
long partner
with the
nuclear
industry in Brazil
19 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
•
Passive safety
replaces
mechanical and electrical systems
–
harnesses natural forces like
gravity
, convection
and
condensation to
achieve safe
shutdown
•
Strong licensing pedigree
on reviews in multiple countries;
first
and only Generation III+
reactor to receive design
certification from the U.S. NRC
•
Simplified design and
modular
construction
provides a plant that
is easier and less expensive to
build, operate and maintain
AP1000
Plant:
S
afe, Simple
and
Standardized
AP1000
Plant Site at Sanmen,
China
©Sanmen Nuclear
Pow
er Company
20 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
All Critical Station Blackout
Response Features
FAIL SAFE
●
Passive Safety-Related Systems
–
Use “passive” processes only
, no
active pumps,
diesels, ….
–
O
ne-time alignment
of valves
–
N
o support systems required after
actuation
–
Greatly reduced dependency
on operator
actions
●
Active
Defense in
Depth-Related Systems
–
Reliably support
normal
operation
–
R
edundant equipment
powered by onsite
diesels
–
Minimize
challenges to
passive safety
systems
–
Not necessary
to mitigate design
basis
accidents
●
Severe accident scenario ef
fects
are
mitigated
by
in-vessel
retention of the melted fuel
Major Safety Advancements of the
AP1000
21 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
•
EUR confirms the
AP1000
plant can be
successfully deployed
in Europe (May
2007)
•
AP1000
plant amended design
unanimously
approved
by NRC (December
201
1)
•
UK regulators grant
Interim Design
Approval
(December 201
1)
•
China licensing activities on-track, with
Final
Safety Analysis
Report
(FSAR) submitted to
customer (2012).
•
Combined construction and operating
licenses (COL) approved for
V
ogtle 3&4
site
(February 2012) and
V
.C. Summer
2&3
site
(March 2012)
Regulatory Certainty
Westinghou se Proprietary Class 3 © 2013 Westingho us e Electric Compa ny LLC. All Rights Reserved .
Summary of Key Conclusions
AP1000 Plant Response to Extreme Events
•
W
estinghouse assessment concluded that
AP1000
Plant maintains all safety
limits
•
The
AP1000
Plant passive design assures
–
Containment integrity
–
No fuel damage (both spent fuel and reactor)
–
No radiological release
as a result of the event
AP1000
achie
ves
and
main
ta
ins
Saf
e
Shut
do
wn,
prot
ects
public
health
and
saf
ety
, and
pre
ven
ts
loss
of
utility
in
ves
tmen
t.
[…],
as
has
b
een
poin
te
d
out
to
me
by
Japanese
co
lleagues
as
the
y
reflect
upon
Fu
ku
shima,
had
the
plan
t
b
een
o
pe
ra
ting
AP1000
reac
tors,
it
is
lik
ely
that
the
o
ut
come
would
h
ave
b
een
ver
y
dif
feren
t.
The
A
P1000’
s
p
assive
saf
ety
sy
st
ems
p
rovide
the
ability
to
main
tain
core
cooling
for
at
leas
t
7
2
hours
with
lit
tle
human
in
te
rv
en
tion.
7
2
h
ours
to
mak
e
repairs,
transport
emergency
equipmen
t,
and
tak
e
o
ther
actions
in
response
to
the
earthquak
e
and
ts
u
nami
that
assault
ed
the
Fu
ku
shima
sit
e
w
ould
have
made
a
ver
y
signific
a
n
t
diff
erenc
e.
US
NR
C
Commissioner
Willi
am
D
Magw
ood
23 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
AP1000
Westinghou se Proprietary Class 3 © 2013 Westingho us e Electric Compa ny LLC. All Rights Reserved .
Modular Construction
Allows More T
o Be Done in Parallel
Westinghou se Proprietary Class 3 © 2013 Westingho us e Electric Compa ny LLC. All Rights
AP1000 Plant Modular Construction
An Innovative
Approach Unique in our Industry
●
Improved Quality
Control and
Efficiency
●
Reduced
Construction Schedule and Optimized
Westinghou se Proprietary Class 3 © 2013 Westingho us e Electric Compa ny LLC. All Rights Reserved .
Long
lead
or
der
s
placed
48
mon
ths,
then
36
mon
ths
la
te
r
units
T
y
pical AP1000
Construction
Schedule
Westinghou se Proprietary Class 3 © 2013 Westingho us e Electric Compa ny LLC. All Rights
Local Content &
T
echnology
T
28 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved. V.C. SUMMER VOGTLE HAIYANG SANMEN
AP1000
Plant Global Project Delivery
•
Eight
AP1000
units under construction
worldwide
-F
our units in China
-F
our units in the
United
29 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
China
AP1000
Plant Progress: Sanmen
Unit 1 First Concre te – M arch 200 9 Unit 2 SG/Refu e ling Cana l Modu le – D ece m b e r 201 0 Unit 1 React o r Vesse l – A ug u s t 201 1 Photos © Sanmen N u cl ear Pow e r C o mpany , Ltd. Al l ri g h ts r e ser Unit 1 CVTH Set – J anu a ry 201 3
30 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
Sanmen
1 Reactor Vessel Internals (RVI)
Manufacturing Progress (cont.)
Upper Cylinder
Assembly
Upper Support
Cylinder
31 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
China
AP1000
Plant Progress: Haiyang
U n it 1 R e a c tor Ve s s e l – J a nuar y 2 0 1 2 Unit 2 Auxiliary Building – D ecember 2010 Unit 1 First Concre te – S epte m b e r 200 9 Photos © Shandong N u cl ear Pow e r C o mpany , Ltd. Al l ri g h ts re ser Unit 1 CVTH Set – M arch 201 3
32 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
Progress of China Projects: Summary
•
Major
equipment delivered and installed at
Sanmen Unit 1 and Haiyang
Unit 1 includes:
–
Reactor V
e
ssel
–
Steam Generators
–
Reactor V
e
ssel Internals
–
Polar Crane
–
Integrated Head
Package
●
Containment V
e
ssel
T
op Head
(CVTH)
set at
Sanmen Unit 1 in January 2013 and Haiyang
Unit 1 in March
2013
●
Digital I&C turnover
to
Startup
staf
f
in progress
●
Potential Sanmen operators
have completed
simulator training; Haiyang
operators started
simulator training in July
●
T
e
chnology transfer
well advanced
Sanme n Site – O ctob e r 201 3 Photo © Sanmen N u cl ear Pow e r C o mpany , Ltd. Al l ri g h ts r e ser v ed. Haiyan g Site – O ctob e r 201 3 Photo © Shandong N u cl ear Pow e r C o mpany , Ltd. Al l ri g h ts re ser v ed.33 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
2009 to 2013
Sanmen Site
Progress:
T
ime Lapse V
iew
34 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
U.S.
AP1000
Plant Projects
V
.C. Summer 2&3
Jenkinsville, South
Carolina
V
ogtle 3&4
W
a
ynesboro, Georgia
35 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
U.S.
AP1000
Plant Progress: V
ogtle Site
Photos © 2013 Geor g ia Pow e r C ompany . Al l r ig Unit 3 Turbine Building – S eptember 2013 Unit 3 Accumu la to r Tank Delivery – Octob e r 201 3 Unit 3 CA20 Modu le Assemb ly – Octob e r 201 3 Unit 3 CVBH Set – J un e 201 336 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
U.S.
AP1000
Plant Progress: V
.C. Summer
Site
Unit 2 React o r Vesse l Delivery – J une 201 3 Photos © 2013 South C a ro lina El ectr ic & Gas. Al l ri g h ts re ser v ed. CH80 Modu le Lift – S ep te mb e r 201 3 Unit 3 First Concre te Pour – N ovembe r 20 1 3 Unit 2 CVBH Set – May 201 337 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R
Progress of U.S. Projects: Summary
•
Nuclear island basemat
concrete
pours completed for
V
.C. Summer
Units 2&3; V
ogtle Unit 3
•
Containment V
essel Bottom
Head
(CVBH)
set
in nuclear island for
initial
units at each site
•
CV ring fabrication
underway
•
Component and
module fabrication
proceeding
•
Reactor vessels delivered
for initial
units at each site;
additional
equipment and component
deliveries continue
to
proceed
Vo g tle U n it 3 N u c lear Is la nd – O c tober 2 0 1 3 V.C. Summer Site – A ugust 2013 Photo © 2013 Geor g ia Pow er C ompany . Al Photo © 2013 South C a ro lina El ectr ic & Gas. Al38 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
Benefits of
AP1000
Technology and Westinghouse
Approach to New-Build Business
•
AP1000
plant combines proven technologies
and innovative passive safety
systems
–
5,000 man-years of
design work
•
Eight units under construction
worldwide;
more are planned
–
First
nuclear concrete
placed for
first
eight
•
Regulatory certainty
–
Almost 300 man-years of
licensing review in
US and UK alone
•
We Buy Where We Build™
approach
provides rich opportunities for
local
suppliers
•
Committed
to developing
the next generation
of engineers
and
other technical
39 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
Lessons Learned: Requirements
for a Successful
New-Build Program
•
Strong reference
plant
•
Leverage “Country of
Origin” Licensing
•
Utilize Modern
Construction Methods
•
Defined Approach to
Sustainable Localization
•
Avoid First-of-a-Kind
Deployment Issues
•
Take Advantage
of
40 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
AP1000
Plant Value Proposition
Proven T
echnology
with Passive
Safety
Systems
Simplified Design
with Modular
Construction
Reviewed in Multiple
Countries by
Independent, T
echnically
Rigorous and T
ransparent
Regulators –
U
sing a W
e
ll
41 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h
Westinghouse Technology and Brazil:
The Right Fit
•
Westinghouse Looks Forward to
Continuing our Long
Nuclear Partnership with
Brazil
•
Our Approach
Helps
Achieve
…a balanced energy
supply
…safe, clean electricity
generation
…sustainable economic
42 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h ts R e s e rved.
43 W e s tin gho use N o n -Pr op ri e tar y C la s s 3 © 2 0 1 3 W e s tin ghou se Ele c tr ic C o mp any L L C . All R ig h