Filtering Methods for Mixture Models

(1)

&('*),+-/.0'2143,5,.6'*7#'*3,7#89*),:;<'>=#.6+?;A@B:29*CEDF;A7,9*)

GIHKJ$L0MONOPQHSR2NUTVW>L0NOXHSPYL0NOZ\[K]^LR$_a`*NOL0NOZ\]bNOZc[K]

deLR$[KL]bNbHKMgfIRZihHKMj]jZiN%k

lmon#n#pqsr

tHu[ET"R]OZc_vHKMwxLykHS]OZ\LRzZcRvV?HKMjHSR[EH{V?TM|PYZi}*NO~vMjH_Zc]bNbMjZi$~NOZiT"R]TVx*RTy^RR*~PHKMTVx[ET"PQJ,T0

RvHSR2NO]|hBZ\LL]bHKN|TVx$iNbHKMFZ\RvMOHS[K~vMj]jZiT"R]KQtHYHE}BNbHSR_NOXvHuPQHKNOXvTB_TV_ZiMOHS[EN|]jZ\P~$\L0NOZiT"RVATM

_Z\]O[EMjHKNbH|PYZ}BNO~vMOH_Z\]bNbMFZi$~vNOZiT"R$]TV vHSL0MjRXHSL_#0""^Z\RTMj_vHKMUNbTLRLikB]bH|[ET"RNOZcR2~vT"~$]UPYZ}*

NO~vMOHuPYT*_vHSc]K$~vMONOXvHKMjPYTMOHxHZcRNbMOTB_~[EHQMjHS]OLPQJ$\ZcRv]bNbHKJ$]]jZ\PYZ\\L0MNbTaNOXvT"]bHZ\RJ$L0MONOZc[KiH

$iNbHKMj]gZiNOXZ\RNOXvH]ONbHKJ$]TVoNOXvH$iNbHKMjZcRv{MOHS[K~vMj]OZ\T"R]KB^XZ\[FXPYL0H[KL\[K~$\L0NOZiT"R]HKu[KZ\HSRN^LR$_

HSRL0$iH~]NbTLR$Lik*]OH\L0MjHKM_L0NOL]bHKNO]SUXHuJMOTJ,T"]bHS_ LiTMjZ\NOXP¡VATM¢MOHS]OLPQJ$\HS_#_Z\MOHS[EN

]OZ\P~\L0NOZiT"R$£Z\]L>HSRvHKMjL\Zc]OL0NOZiT"RzTVNOXHuJ$L0MONOZc[KiHY$iNbHKMTVUvHSL0MjRXHSL_¤00¥2^X$Z\[jX#L\iTyg]

V?TMPQHKMO"Z\RvZ\_vHSR2NOZ\[KL?¦6]jZ\PYZ\\L0MgJ$L0MONOZ\[K\HS]JMjZiTMNbTMOHS]OLPYJ$\Z\RvvtH[ET"PQJ$L0MOHQNOXvHQJ$MOTJ,T"]bHS_

LiTMjZiNOX$P§^ZiNOXuNOXZ\]J¨L0MONOZ\[KiHU¨iNbHKM(LR_u^ZiNOXQNOXH©Zi$$]]OLPQJ¨iHKM(~]jZ\Rv|]OZ\P~\L0NbHS_u_L0NOLLR$_

MOHSL_L0NOLu]bHKNO]K

ª>« r/¬¨qs®o¯°±A²b³j´Sµ^¶±?·{¸B¹iºµ<±<»¼v½Q¾x±¿y¿EÀQ¶¨º0·gÁ¨¹\³E²F½UÂF·gÁB»0²Eµº0¼¨´4³¶¨º·^Á¹Ã±A¼2Ä0½UÅUº0²Eµ<±´K¹\³Æ±A¹Çµ%³K²jÀF½

Å^³K²?ÈS³O´yµ¶±A·{¸B¹ºµ<±»0¼v½ÉU³<ÊS³O´yµ<±<»¼¶º0·gÁ¨¹Ã±A¼2Ä

Ë ÌÍIÎ,Ï/Ð|ÑYÒ{ÓoÎ,ÔjÐgÍ

W>Zi}*NO~vMjH^PQTB_vHS\]L0MjHg[ET"PYPQT"R$ikQ~]bHS_YVATMxTNOX_vHSR]OZ\N%k{HS]bNOZ\PYL0NOZ\T"RuLR_[K\L]O]OZi¨[KL0NOZiT"RYJMjTv

iHSPY]<]OHKHUZiNbNbHKMjZcRvNbT"R ³Kµº0¹iÕeÖS×Ø*Ù,W>[KdL[jXcLR>LR_wL0NO]bVATMj_/ÖS×ØØ*VATMUVA~MONOXvHKMU_vHKNOLZ\c]FF

wLSkHS]OZ\LRLRLikB]OZ\]TVgPYZ}BNO~vMOHPQTB_vHS\]XL]{MOHS[EHSZihHS_ÚP~[FX ZcRNbHKMOHS]ONTshHKMYNOXvH\L]bNQ_vHS[KL_H

L]LYMOHS]O~$iNUTVL_vh0LR[EHS]Z\R>[ET"PYJ$~vNOL0NOZiT"RLo]bNOL0NOZ\]ONOZ\[K]gLR$_HS]bJ,HS[KZ\L\\kWaL0MOTyh[jXLZcRW>T"RNbH

Û L0MjiT>W Û W Û PQHKNOXT*_]©Z\iB] ³Kµº0¹iÕeÖS××Ü*ÙÝ^Z\[FXL0Mj_]OT"RLR_a©IMOHKHSReÖS××"ÞF

ß RvHUJ$MOT$iHSPàgZiNOXYW Û W Û PQHKNOXvTB_]K,TNOXYZcRQHSRvHKMjL¨LR_YVATMNOXvHg]bJ,HS[KZi$[[KL]bHgTV,PuZ}*NO~MOH

PQTB_vHS\]K*Z\]NOXL0NxZiN([KLR,H^_Zi[K~iNNbT_$Z\L0"RvT"]bHI[ET"RhHKMOHSR$[EHITV/NOXHIW

Û

W

Û

LiTMjZ\NOXP2LR$_

XvHSR[EHx_Ziu[K~\N/NbTIá*~LR2NOZiV?k~R$[EHKMONOLZ\R2N%k|Z\R|LR2kL0JJ$MOTS}vZ\PYL0NOZiT"R|NbTgNOXvH(J,T"]bNbHKMjZiTMo_Z\]bNbMjZ\$~vNOZiT"R

$L]bHS_T"RâNOXvHaW

Û

W

Û

T"~vNbJ$~NKãvTMHE}BLPYJ$iHxNOXvH>LRLikB]OZ\]YTVINOXH>[ET"L%PYZ\R$Z\Rv_Z\]OL]ONbHKM

_L0NOLQ]OXvTs^RZ\R©IMOHKHSRzÖS××"xL]UZcR[ETMOMOHS[EN_~vHNbT{NOXvHW Û W Û LiTMjZiNOXPäRvTN[ET"R2hHKMO"Z\Rv

<[ET"PQJ$L0MOHNOXvHaMOHS]O~\NO]Z\R¤©IMOHKHSR/0"å"FÙLR_ãNOXvHW

Û

W

Û

(2)

0 5000

10000

15000

20000

2

4

6

8

10 Traces of maximum mu

Gibbs sample

0

10

20

30

40

50

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0 ACFs of maximum mu

Gibbs: autocorrelation time=6.34

0 5000

10000

15000

20000

2

4

6

8

10 Perfect sample

0

10

20

30

40

50

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0 True ACF: autocorrelation time=14.31

Zi"~vMOHÖ|MjL[EHYJ$\TNO]LR_L[EVJ$iTNO]VATM|NOXvHY\L0MOHKMTVxNOXvHYN(T^TMjPuLPQHSLR]KYUXHNbTJ

J$iTNO]x]O~PYPuL0MjZ\]bHUNOXHgT"~vNbJ¨~vNVAMOT"P NOXvH©Z\$]]jLPQJ$iHKM(^XZ\iH^NOXvH^,TNbNbT"P NbMjL[EHZ\]¨L]bHS_uT"R

Z\R_vHKJ,HSR_HSRN_vMjLy^]UVAMOT"P NOXvH|NbMj~vHJT"]ONbHKMjZiTMg_$Z\]bNbMjZi¨~vNOZiT"RLR_NOXvHTNbNbT"P L[EVJ$iTN^TVoNOXH

©Zi¨]T"~vNbJ$~vNUZ\]U$L]bHS_T"RNOXH|PQHSLRTVoNOXvH|NbMj~HJT"]ONbHKMjZiTMU_Z\]ONbMjZi$~vNOZ\T"R/

PQTB_vHS/Z\R ß

gHSZ\\,LR_ÝUT,HKMONO]ÖS×××"L\]bTQL0JJ,HSL0Mj]NbTuHZ\R$L[K[K~vMjL0NbHu<]bHKHHSL0MjRXvHSL_LR$_

WHScZiTNO]OZ\_vT"~00¥2FwxTNOXYNOXvHKTMOHKNOZc[KL$LR_{HSPQJ¨ZiMjZ\[KL*HKhBZ\_vHSR[EHTVJMOT$\HSPY] NOXL0NW Û W Û

LiTMjZiNOX$PY][KLR{XLyhHZ\RHE}BJ$iTMFZ\RvUNOXvHxNOLZ\\]TV¨LgJ,T"]bNbHKMjZiTM _Z\]ONbMjZi$~vNOZ\T"RL0MOH("Z\hHSRZcRÝ^THKMjNO]

0"å"F(t¤XZ\\H Û HSiHS~B} ³Sµ(º0¹iÕ 0L0MO"~vHNOX$L0NY¢bL\PQT"]bNUNOXHHSRNOZiMjHKN%kTV W Û W Û ]OLPQJ$\HKMj]

Z\PQJ$\HSPQHSRNbHS_VATM^PYZi}*NO~vMjH|PQT*_HS\]XL]V<LZ\iHS_NbTu[ET"R2hHKMOHS£B

eTY_HSPQT"R]bNbMjL0NbHNOXvHS]OH_$Ziu[K~iNOZ\HS]xH]OZ\P~\L0NbHS_0Q_L0NOLJT"ZcRNO]xVAMOT"PäLYs%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSRNRvTMO

PYLPYZi}*NO~vMjHIPQTB_vHSA^Z\NOX[ET"PYPQT"Rh0L0MjZ\LR[EHsFLR$_JHKMjV?TMjPYHS_LQwxLykHS]OZ\LRaLRLikB]OZ\]xTVNOXH

_L0NOL~]OZ\RL©Zi$]I]OLPQJ¨iHKMS|`B~PYPYL0MjkTVNOXvHT"~vNbJ$~vNITVNOXvHu©Zi$$]^]OLPYJ$iHKMZ\]^"Z\hHSRZ\R

Zi"~vMOHÖ^XvHKMjHxH]OXvTs LNbMjL[EHJ$\TN{LR$_ÚL~vNbT*[ETMjMOHS\L0NOZiT"RÚV<~R[ENOZ\T"R¤<L[EVF{J$iTN{V?TMQNOXH

\L0MOHKMTVNOXvHuN(TRvTMjPuLPQHSLR]KTM[ET"PQJ¨L0MjZ\]bT"R(HL\]bT>]jXvTyäLNbMjL[EHJ$iTN$L]bHS_zT"R

Z\R_vHKJ,HSR_HSRN|_vMFLS^]V?MjT"P NOXvHNbMj~vHJT"]ONbHKMjZiTM{_Z\]bNbMjZ\$~vNOZiT"RÚATNOLZ\RHS_*kzL>HSRHKMjL\Z\]OL0NOZ\T"R

TVNOXvH{PQHKNOXvTB_aTV(vHSL0MjR$XvHSL_/0"*]bHKHu`*HS[ENOZiT"Rå"gLR_LRL[EV(J$iTNITVNOXvHY©Zi¨]^T"~vNbJ¨~vN

$L]bHS_T"RNOXvH|PQHSLRTVoNOXvHNbMj~HJT"]ONbHKMjZiTMU_Z\]ONbMjZi$~vNOZ\T"RuTVoNOXvH|\L0MOHKMgRvTMjPYL/PQHSLRæNU[KLR

,H|]bHKHSRNOXL0NUNOXH©Zi¨]x]jLPQJ$iHKMUPYZc]O]bHS]NOXvH|~JJ,HKMxNOLZc/TVNOXH|J,T"]bNbHKMjZiTMU_Zc]bNbMjZi$~NOZiT"R/2LR$_

NOXZ\]UZc]XL0Mj_NbT_$Z\L0"RvT"]bHVAMOT"PNOXvH|L[EV J$\TNK

MOT¨iHSPY]|gZiNOX_ZcL0"RvT"]OZ\Rv[ET"R2hHKMOHSR[EHTV^W Û W Û L\TMjZiNOXPY]XLShHPQTNOZih0L0NbHS_#(TMO#Z\R

NOXvHL0MOHSLYTV Á³E²AÈK³j´SµÀF±A·¸B¹iºµ<±»0¼ PYHKNOXvT*_$]$L]bHS_T"RNOXvH>¢b[ET"~vJ$cZ\Rv{V?MjT"PNOXvHJ$L]bNO£uZ\_vHSL{TV

(3)

NOXvHS]bHZ\_vHSL]oNbT|PYZi}*NO~vMjH(PQTB_vHS\]gTHKMjN ³Sµeº0¹iÕvÖS×××*Ù Û L]bHS\\L ³Kµeº¹Õ0""$~vNoNOXvHMOHS]O~\NOZ\Rv

LiTMjZiNOX$PY]XLShHgHSZiNOXvHKMcZ\PYZiNbHS_{L0JJ$cZ\[KL0$Z\\Z\N%kTML0MOHgZ\PQJMjL[ENOZc[KL0$iHxV?TMHKhHSR]OZ\PQJ¨iHMOHSL%\ZiVAH

JMOT$\HSPY]K>W>TMOHMjHS[EHSRNOik#vHSL0MjRXvHSL_¤0""XL]_vHS]O[EMjZ\HS_L ±A²O³O´SµIÀ4±?·{¸B¹iºµ<±<»¼ PQHKNOXvTB_

NOXL0NUHSRL0¨iHS]UZ\R_HKJHSR$_vHSRN_vMjLy^]VAMOT"PNOXvHNbMF~vH|J,T"]bNbHKMjZiTMNbTuH|PuL_vH

t X$Z\\]bNoPQTMOHJMjL[ENOZ\[KL0¨iH(NOX$LRJ,HKMOVAHS[EN ]OZ\P~\L0NOZiT"R/6NOXvH_ZiMjHS[ENo]OZcP~cL0NOZiT"RPQHKNOXT*_{Z\RvHSL0MjRB

XvHSL_a0""([KLRuT"RikHgL0JJ$\ZiHS_NbT_Z\]O[EMOHKNbHg_L0NOLB2MjHS\L0NOZihHSik{]OPYL\$_L0NOL]bHKNO]IATV/NOXvHUTMj_HKM

TVgÖKNbTÖK_$L0NOLJT"ZcRNO]F^LR_]OPYLcoR*~P,HKMj]^TVx[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NO]YTMå"FæRaNOX$Z\]IJ$L0J,HKM

(HQ_vHS]j[EMjZi,H|HE}BNbHSR]OZiT"R]ITVNOXH_Z\MOHS[ENI]jZ\P~$\L0NOZiT"R>PYHKNOXvT*_aNOXL0NL\iTs^]IZiNgNbT,HL0J$J$\ZiHS_>NbT

[ET"RNOZcR2~vT"~$]PYZi}*NO~vMjHPQTB_vHS\]LR_#_$L0NOLa]bHKNO]TVU\L0MjHKM{]jZKH $~vNL0"LZcRVATMNOXHLRL\k*]OZc]|TV

PQTB_vHS\]^ZiNOXLu]OPYL\/R*~PHKMTV[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NO]<ZH~vJNbTåQ[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NO]FF

UXvHUT"~NO\Z\RvHTV,NOXvHgJ$L0J,HKMZ\]L](V?T"ciTy^]SæRYNOXvHgRvHE}*Nx]bHS[ENOZiT"Ru(HIZ\RNbMjT*_~$[EHNOXvHg[K\L]j]TV/PYZ}*

NO~vMOHPQT*_HS\]xHu^Z\c H[ET"R]OZ\_vHKMFZ\RvLR_MjZiH k_vHS]O[EMjZ\HQNOXH_ZiMjHS[EN]OZ\P~\L0NOZiT"RPQHKNOXvTB_

V?TMQ_Zc]O[EMOHKNbH_$L0NOLBæRÚ`*HS[ENOZiT"RÚåxHHE}*NbHSR_ _Z\MOHS[EN]OZcP~cL0NOZiT"RzNbT[ET"R2NOZ\R2~T"~]_$L0NOLB^XvH

$L]OZ\[QZc_vHSLZ\]NbT>_$Z\]O[EMOHKNOZ\]OHQNOXvHu_L0NOLBoL0JJ$ikNOXvHY_ZiMjHS[EN|]OZ\P~\L0NOZiT"RPQHKNOXT*_NbT>NOXvHu_Z\]j[EMOHE

NOZ\]bHS_T¨]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]KLR_NOXHSR[ETMOMOHS[ENUVATMUNOXZc]L0JJMOTy}BZ\PuL0NOZiT"R~]OZ\RMjHHS[ENOZiT"R>]OLPQJ$\ZcRvTM

Z\PQJ,TMONOLR[EH|]jLPQJ$\Z\RvæçR`*HS[ENOZiT"R¥(H_HS]O[EMjZi,HNOXvH|MOHScL0NOZiT"R]OXZ\JHKN(HKHSRa_ZiMOHS[ENU]jZ\P~$\L6

NOZiT"R>LR$_J$L0MONOZ\[K\H$iNbHKMj]KLR$_]OXvTs XvTy MOHS]OLPQJ¨\Z\RvQZ\_vHSL]^~]bHS_VATMUJ$L0MONOZc[KiH$iNbHKMj]^[KLR,H

L0JJ$\Z\HS_NbTQMjHS_~[EHNOXvH[ET"PQJ$~vNOL0NOZ\T"RL/[ET"]bNUTVo_ZiMOHS[EN]OZ\P~\L0NOZ\T"R/æR>`*HS[ENOZiT"RxHJ,HKMOVATMjP

[ET"PQJ$L0MjZc]bT"R]UTVT"~MgPQHKNOXvTB_gZiNOXNOXvHQ©Zi$]^]OLPQJ$iHKMg$L]bHS_>T"Ra]OZcP~cL0NbHS__L0NOLu]OHKNO]KLR$_

Z\R>`*HS[ENOZiT"RaÜ(H|[ET"PQJ¨L0MOH|T"~vMUPQHKNOXT*_gZiNOXNOXvH|J$L0MONOZc[KiH$iNbHKMTV vHSL0MjRXvHSL_#00¥2$L]OHS_

T"RMOHSLe_L0NOLBUXvHJ¨L0JHKMHSR$_]^ZiNOXLu_Z\]O[K~]j]OZiT"R/

äÔOÏÓoÎÔ ÒxÎ/ÔOÐIÍSÐ^ÏäÔÓÏ Î Ô |Î/Ò{Ï

tH[ET"R]jZ\_vHKMUPYZ}BNO~vMOHPQTB_vHS\]TV NOXvHV?TMjP

!

#"%$&o(' )

* +

,.-0/

+

!

#"($1

+

32 Öy

^XvHKMOH4&5'ä

/

-2 6 6 67-2

/

)

21

-2 6 6 67-21

)

^Z\]gNOXvH{]bHKNgTVJ$L0MjLPQHKNbHKMj]S8 Z\]^BRvTs^R/,LR_aXHKMOHLR$_

NOXvMOT"~v"XT"~vNexHx~$]bHNOXvH(HSRvHKMjZ\[xRvTNOL0NOZiT"RTV ! 9Ã/V?TM L^J$MOT$L0$Z\cZiN%kI_vHSR]OZiNkTMoPuL]O]eV<~R[ENOZ\T"R/

Û T"R]OZc_vHKMe_L0NOL;:<'à#"

-2 6 6 67-2="?>F0LR$_iHKN@A'àB

-2 6 6 6C-2B0>v,^XvHKMjHDB

+

_vHSRTNbHS]eNOXvHx[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N

TVÖyNOXL0NNOXHzT$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"RE"

+

Zc]_vMjLy^R¤V?MjT"PtHgZ\\L]O]O~PYHzGIZ\MjZ\[jX$iHKNJMjZiTMF]T"R

F

'

/

-2 6 6 67-2

/

)

QLR_ãZ\R_vHKJ,HSR_vHSR2NQ[ET"RGO~v"L0NbHaJ$MjZiTMj]QT"RH1I' 1

-2 6 6 6C-21

)

(4)

F

Z\] O~]bNGZiMjZ\[FXiHKN LR_{(HUX$LShH^Z\R$_vHKJ,HSR_vHSR2NeJ,T"]bNbHKMjZiTMF]VATM ! 1

+

$:(2@2oVATM ' Ö 2 6 6 6C28 ^XvH

GZiMjZ\[FXiHKN_Z\]bNbMFZi$~vNOZiT"R|T"R

F

_vHKJ,HSR_$]eT"R>#:(2@* ]bT"iHSikNOXvMOT"~v"X{NOXvHR*~PHKMF]TVT$]bHKMjh6L0NOZiT"R$]

L\iTB[KL0NbHS_¤NbT HSL[jX [ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NKàtHVA~MONOXvHKML]O]O~PQHNOXL0N ! 1

+

$:(2@2_HKJHSR$_]YT"R§#:(2@2

NOXvMOT"~v"X L¨RZiNbHu]bHKNTVU]O~PYPuL0MOk]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZ\[K]StH_HSRvTNbHu*k

¯

#:(2@2NOXvH]bHKNTVU]O~$PYPYL0MOk

]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZc[K]K¨gXZ\[jX^Z\\,,H|NOXvH~RZiT"RTVNOXvHR*~PHKM^TVL\iTB[KL0NOZiT"R]UTV T$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R]^NbTHSL[jX

[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N^LR_NOXvH|]j~PYPYL0MOk]bNOL0NOZ\]ONOZ\[K]VATMUNOXvH

!

1

+

$:(2@2ç]S$VATMU^XZ\[FX

! #& $:(2@2 ' ! #& $¯ #:(2@2b36

æçRNOXvH|VAT"\iTygZ\Rv(H|^MjZiNbH ¯ VATM ¯ #:(2@2U^XvHSRNOXHPQHSLRZ\R{Zc]U[KiHSL0MS

: p$n

F «

A¯S¯S

: mq

«

Û T"R]OZc_vHKMYNOXvH>[KL]OH>^XvHKMjH ! #"%$1

+

{_HSRvTNbHS]YNOXvHaJMOT$L0¨Z\\ZiNkPYL]O]uVA~R$[ENOZiT"RÚTVL oT"Z\]O]OT"R

MjLR_vT"P h0L0MjZ\L0$iH^ZiNOX>PYHSLR<1

+

;g]O]j~PQHLGZiMjZ\[FXiHKN^J$MjZiTMUT"R

F

^ZiNOX>J$L0MjLPQHKNbHKMF]ÚLR$_

Z\R_vHKJ,HSR_HSRNI"LPYPYL>JMjZiTMj]IT"R 1

-2 6 6 67-21

)

^ZiNOXJ$L0MjLPYHKNbHKMj]

p

LR_u^XvHSR[ET"R_ZiNOZ\T"RL

T"R #:(2@2xHXLyhHZ\R_vHKJ,HSR_HSRN|"LPuPYL_Z\]bNbMjZ\$~vNOZiT"R]|V?TM1

+

^XvT"]bHJ$L0MjLPQHKNbHKMF]Q_vHKJ,HSR_

T"R##:(2@2U]bT"iHSikNOXvMOT"~"XNOXvHR*~PHKMTV T$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R]UL\iTB[KL0NbHS_NbT[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSRN

+

$LR$_

NOXvHSZiM^]j~P

+

vTMFPYL\ik

! #& $:(2@2 ' ! #& $¯ #:(2@*b

' GZiMy

F

Ù )

+

,.-©LP1

+

Ù

+

!

+

2"

+

!

+

32

^XvHKMOHGZiMs#:Ù _vHSRTNbHS]NOXvHJMOT¨L0$Z\\ZiNkY_vHSR]OZ\N%kuTV LQGZiMjZ\[FXiHKN_Z\]bNbMFZi$~vNOZiT"Ru^ZiNOXJ$L0MjLPQ

HKNbHKMj]# HKh6Lc~L0NbHS_#L0N4:LR_Ú©LP>#"eÙ 2"K_vHSRvTNbHS]NOXvHuJMjT$L0$Z\\Z\N%k_vHSR]OZiNkTVUL"LPYPYL

_Z\]bNbMFZi$~vNOZiT"RgZiNOXJ$L0MFLPQHKNbHKMj]$?2"|HKh6Lc~L0NbHS_L0N;"<vTMV<~\_HKNOLZ\\]gTVNOXvHS]bH{[KL\[K~\L0NOZiT"R$]

]bHKHvHSL0MFRXvHSL_/¨0""F

wxTNOXzVATMNOXZ\]]bJ,HS[KZi$[HE}vLPQJ$iHLR_VATM|HSRvHKMFLPQT*_HS\]I^XZ\[FX]OL0NOZ\]bVAk>T"~vM|L]j]O~PQJNOZ\T"R]K

(H[KLRUMjZ\NbH

!

#& $: '

*

%

!

@ $:

!

#& $:(2@232 "

^XvHKMOH

! @ $:'&)( ! #:(2@ $&o! #&oç_?& '*( ! ¯ $&o ! #&oç_ &D6 å"

tH_vHK¨RvH ! ¯ (NbTY,HNOXvHMjZ\"XN%XLR$_]OZ\_vHTV NOXZ\]HSá*~L0NOZiT"R ^Ts "Zc]JMOTJ,TMONOZiT"RL,NbT

*

%

! ¯ ! #& $¯ #"2@*bD'

(5)

^XvHKMOH ¯ Ù=:IZ\]INOXvH ·{¸*¹µ<±Á¨¹Ã±´K±<µ TV(]O~v[KZiHSRN]bNOL0NOZ\]ONOZ\[K] ¯ /NOXvHQR2~$P,HKMITVL\iTB[KL0NOZiT"R]ITV

T$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]A:¤NbTz[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NO]{NOXL0NQJMjT*_~$[EHNOXZc]]OJHS[KZ\$[uh0L\~vHTV]O~vu[KZiHSR2N{]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZ\[K]S

UXZ\]MjHSL0MOMjLRvHSPQHSR2N^Z\]U$L]bHS_T"R_MjLS^ZcRv{NbTHKNOXvHKMIcZiHNbHKMjPY]UZcRz"F

UXvHY~]OHKVA~cRvHS]O]TVA¥2Z\]NOXL0NKoVATM_Z\]O[EMjHKNbHYPYZ}BNO~vMOHQPQTB_vHS\]KgXZ\iHNOXvHuR*~PHKMTVxNbHKMjPY]

Z\R "Z\R[EMOHSL]OHS]{HE}*J,T"RvHSR2NOZ\L\ikgZiNOX!NOXvHR2~$P,HKM{TV^NbHKMjPu]QZ\R NOXvHMjZi"X2N%XLR_ ]OZ\_vHTV

A¥2Z\R[EMOHSL]bHS]T"RikâL]L#JT"\k*RvT"PuZ\LUZ\R ~vMONOXHKMjPQTMOHUNOXHKMOHZc]uL#$iNbHKMjZ\RzMOHS[K~vMj]jZiT"R

NOXL0NHSRL0$iHS]NOXvHP~iNOZiJ¨\Z\[KZiNbHS]INbTH[KL\[K~\L0NbHS_HKu[KZiHSR2NOikUXvHZ\_vHSL,HSXZ\R$_NOXvH_Z\MOHS[EN

]OZ\P~\L0NOZiT"RãPQHKNOXvTB_TV|HSL0MjRXvHSL_à0""Z\]uNbT [KLc[K~\L0NbH>NOXHS]bHP~iNOZ\J$\Z\[KZiNOZ\HS]QLR_NOXHSR

]OZ\P~\L0NbH|_Z\MOHS[ENOikuVAMOT"P A¥2F

UXvHMOHS[K~vMj]OZ\T"RV?TMNOXvHP~\NOZiJ$\Z\[KZ\NOZiHS]gZc]L]V?T"\\Ty^]KGIHSRvTNbH*k :

- '¡#"

-2 6 6 67-2="

FæçNZc]

J,T"]O]OZi$\HINbT[KL\[K~\L0NbHNOXvH

-¯ Ù=:

-

ç]UVAMOT"P NOXvH

- ¯ Ù=:

-

-ç]KdHKN ¯

+

_vHSRvTNbHNOXH|h6Lc~vH|TV

NOXvHU]O~PuPYL0MOk|]bNOL0NOZ\]ONOZ\[K] V?TM_$L0NOL :

-

-^XZc[jX^Z\\JMOTB_~[EHLh6Lc~vH ¯ Z\VNOXvH NOXQT$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R

Z\]UL\\T*[KL0NbHS_>NbT[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N 8 (UXHSR

-¯ Ù=:

- D'

)

+

,.

-¯

+

Ù=:

-

-FxæçRJ$MjL[ENOZ\[EH]bT"PYH

TV^NOXvH

-¯

+

Ù=:

-

-PYLSk#,H KHKMOTv(LR_#[KLc[K~\L0NOZ\RvaNOXvHP~$iNOZiJ$\Zc[KZiNOZiHS]VATM{]j~PYPYL0MjZ\HS]|TV

_L0NOL4:

-

Z\]xPQT"]bNxHSL]OZ\ikYL[FXZiHKhHS_2k><ZA[KL\[K~$\L0NOZ\RvRvHKãh0L\~vHS]TVNOXvH]O~PYPuL0MOkQ]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZ\[K]

V?TML\ J$LZiMj]TVJ,T"]O]OZ\$iH{]O~PYPYL0MFZiHS]ITV :

-

-LR_zLciT*[KL0NOZ\T"R]TV "

NbT>[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NO]KÙoLR$_

<Z\Z?^PQHKMO"Z\RZ\_vHSR2NOZ\[KLh6Lc~vHS]ITVNOXvH{]O~PYPuL0MOk]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZc[K]gNOX$L0NL0MjHJ$MOT*_$~[EHS_/IæVNOXvHKMjH{L0MjH

RvHK h0L\~vHS]ITVNOXvH{]O~PYPuL0MOk]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZc[K]I[KLc[K~\L0NbHS_Z\R <Z?F,NOXvHSRNOXvHPYHKMO"Z\RvZ\R <Z\Z?[KLR

,HL[jXZ\HKhHS_>Z\Ru \TxNOZ\PQHxvTMgLR>HE}BLPQJ¨iH|]bHKH Zi"~MOHQLR_>V?TMUV<~\\HKMU_vHKNOLZ\\]U]OHKH

vHSL0MjRXHSL_#0""F

`BZ\P~\L0NOZiT"R VAMOT"P ! #& $:(2@*Z\]J,T"]O]OZi¨iH>*k <ZA[KL\[K~\L0NOZ\R NOXHRvTMjPYLcZ\]OZ\Rv [ET"R]bNOLR2NTV

NOXvHzMjZ\"XN%XLR$_ ]OZ\_vHTVA¥2FÙ<Z\Z?]OZcP~cL0NOZ\Rv

¯

VAMOT"P Lâ_Zc]O[EMOHKNbHz_Z\]ONbMjZi$~vNOZ\T"R^X$Z\[jX X$L]

JMOT$L0¨Z\\ZiNOZiHS]xJMjTJTMjNOZiT"RL,NbT

-¯ Ù=: ! ¯ FÙ/LR_ <Z\Z\Z?(]OZcP~cL0NOZ\RvQVAMOT"P ! #& $¯ FU`vZ\P~$\L0NOZiT"R

TV¨]OLPYJ$iHS]TV$L0MO$ZiNbMFL0MOk|]OZKHZ\]JT"]j]OZi$iHHK[KZiHSRNO\k<]bHKHvHSL0MjRXHSL_/"0""FUXvHRvTMjPYL\Zc]OZ\Rv

[ET"R]bNOLR2NQ[KL\[K~\L0NbHS_ Z\R <Z?|Zc]NOXvHHKhBZ\_vHSR[EHTVUNOXvHPQT*_HSoLR$_#[KLR ,H~$]bHS_zNbT[KL\[K~cL0NbH

wLSkHS]L[ENbTMj]gV?TMg[ET"PQJ$L0MjZ\RY_Z,HKMOHSRNUPYT*_vHSc]K

~vMONOXHKMjPQTMOHUZiNZ\]YJ,T"]O]OZ\$iHNbT ]jZ\P~$\L0NbHV?MjT"P

!

@ $:Q2kÚMjHKJ$\L[KZ\Rv<ZcZ\Z?L0,TyhH2k <ZcZ\Z

]OZ\P~\L0NbHVAMOT"P ! @ $¯ FäUXvH_Z\]bNbMjZ\$~vNOZiT"R ! @ $¯ Z\]~RZiVATMjP TyhHKML\gLciT*[KL0NOZ\T"R]^XZ\[FX

JMOTB_~[EHNOXvHMOHSá2~$ZiMOHS_h0L\~vHTV NOXvH]O~u[KZiHSR2NU]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZ\[LR_ZiNUZ\]UJT"]j]OZi$iHINbT]jZ\P~$\L0NbHV?MjT"P

NOXZ\]U_$Z\]bNbMjZi¨~vNOZiT"Ru~$]OZ\RvQLQ$L[j2L0Mj_a]OZ\P~\L0NOZiT"RPQHKNOXvTB_<]bHKH ^JJ,HSR_$Z} V?TMI_vHKNOLZ\\]FF

UXZ\]_ZiMjHS[EN{]jZ\P~$\L0NOZiT"R PQHKNOXvTB_ X$L]{JT"\k*RvT"PuZ\L]bNbTMFL0H>LR_ [ET"PQJ$~vNOL0NOZ\T"RL[ET"]bNK ^XvH

TMj_vHKMTVNOXvHJ,T"ikBRvT"PYZ\L_vHKJ,HSR_$]T"R NOXvHz_Z\PQHSR$]OZiT"RãTVNOXvH#]OPYL\iHS]ON]OHKNTV]O~$PYPYL0MOk

(6)

_L0NOL]bHKNÖ 2j 2SÖVATMQLs%[ET"PYJT"RHSRN oT"Z\]O]OT"R PYT*_vHS^XvH]j~PYPYL0MOk#]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZ\[K]S]OXvTs^R Z\R

MjL[jHKNO]KL0MOH#

-2

-FxNOXvHR*~PHKMYLR$_Ú]O~P TVINOXvHT$]bHKMjh6L0NOZiT"R$]QL\iTB[KL0NbHS_ÚNbTzNOXvHMF]bN

[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NeNOXZc]~RZcá2~vHS\k_vHKNbHKMjPYZcRvHS]NOXvHI]bHKNTV/]O~PuPYL0MOk{]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZ\[K]xL]NOXH^NbTNOLR2~P,HKM

LR_]j~P TVNOXvH>T$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]Z\]YBRvTygR/ UXvH>L0MOMjTy^]]OXvTy NOXvHJ,T"]O]jZi$iHh0L\~vHS]QTVNOXH

]O~PYPuL0MOka]bNOL0NOZc]bNOZ\[K]VATM|NOXZ\]_L0NOL>]bHKN|VATMHSL[jXzTVxNOXvHu]j~PYPYL0MOka]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZ\[K]|$L]bHS_T"Rz_$L0NOL

Ö0"FÙ/HSL[jXTV NOXvHcL0NbNbHKMI]O~$PYPYL0MOk]bNOL0NOZ\]ONOZ\[K]gX$L]gYL0MjMOTy^]gVATM^NOXvHJT"]j]OZi$iHL\\T*[KL0NOZiT"R$]UTV

NOXvHNOXZiMF_T$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"RNbTYHSZiNOXHKMNOXvHMj]bNTM^]OHS[ET"R_[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NKUXvHP~iNOZiJ¨\Z\[KZiNkQTVoLY]OHKN

TV]O~PuPYL0MOk]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZc[K]gVATMINOXvH[ET"PYJ$iHKNbH{_L0NOLZc]^TNOLZcRvHS_>*k]O~PuPYZ\RvYNOXHP~iNOZiJ$cZ\[KZiNOZiHS]

(7)

NbT[ET"PYJT"RHSRNO]Ö 2 6 6 6728 ÖuLR$_NOXvHSZ\M]O~P ANOXvHR*~P,HKMLR_ ]O~P¡TVNOXHuT$]bHKMjh6L0NOZiT"R$]

L\iTB[KL0NbHS_uNbT{[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N 8¡Zc]~RZcá2~vHS\k_vHK$RHS_Q2kQNOXHS]bHI]j~PYPYL0MOk{]bNOL0NOZ\]ONOZ\[K]VATMxNOXvH^TNOXvHKM

[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NO]FFx^XvH[ET"PQJ$~NOL0NOZiT"RL[ET"]bNgV?TMgNOXvH oT"Z\]O]OT"RHE}BLPYJ$iHZ\]UNOX2~]gLQJ,T"ikBRvT"PYZ\LTV

TMj_vHKMUv8ÖyFÙLR$__Z\MOHS[ENx]jZ\P~$\L0NOZiT"RuZc](J,T"]O]jZi$iHVATM_L0NOL{]bHKNO]TVe~vJNbTQL0MOT"~R_Ö0QVATM

8 ' QLR_zÖKYV?TM 8 ' å*

äÔOÏÓoÎÔ ÒxÎ/ÔOÐIÍSÐ^Ï¤ÐgÍIÎ/ÔjÍ|Ò{ÐIÒA Ô=|Î,Ò{Ï

UXvHMOHSL]bT"RNOXL0N_ZiMOHS[ENI]OZ\P~\L0NOZiT"RaZ\]gJT"]j]OZi$iHV?TM_Z\]O[EMjHKNbHPYZi}*NO~vMjHPQTB_vHS\]IZ\]^NOX$L0NgNOXvHKMjH

[KLR,HPYLRkL\iTB[KL0NOZiT"R]TVT$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]NbTu[ET"PYJT"RHSRNO]^X$Z\[jXJMOTB_~[EHNOXvH]OLPYHh6L\~HS]

TVgNOXH]j~PYPYL0MOk#]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZ\[K]S#vTMu[ET"R2NOZ\R*~vT"~]Q_L0NOLNOXZc]Zc]QRvTN{NOXvH[KL]bH HSL[jXâLciT*[KL0NOZ\T"R

TVT$]bHKMjh6L0NOZiT"R$]UNbT[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSRNO]g^Z\c,JMOTB_~[EHL_Z\]bNOZcR[ENh6Lc~vHTVNOXvH]O~PYPuL0MOk]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZ\[K]S

NOXvT"~v"XâPuLRk TVINOXvHS]bHh0L\~vHS]QgZ\\(HhHKMjk [K\T"]bHâeT#L_L0JNYNOXvH_$ZiMOHS[ENY]OZ\P~\L0NOZ\T"R L0J

JMOT"L[FX NbT[ET"R2NOZ\R*~vT"~]{_L0NOLxHJ$MOTJ,T"]bHPYHKMO"Z\RvNbHKMjPY]{Z\R¤A¥2NOXL0NQXLShH]OZcPYZ\\L0Mh6L\~HS]

TVNOXvH]j~PYPYL0MOk]bNOL0NOZc]bNOZ\[K]KUXvH]OZ\PQJ¨iHS]bNPQHKNOXvTB_TVL[FXZiHKhBZ\Rv>NOX$Z\]|Z\]NbT_Zc]O[EMOHKNOZ\]bHQNOXH

_L0NOL :NbT :LR_>L0JJ$ik_ZiMOHS[ENU]jZ\P~$\L0NOZiT"RNbTuNOXH|MOHS]O~\NOZ\RvQ_Z\]O[EMjHKNbH_L0NOLBUXZ\]J$MOT*_$~[EHS]

Z\R_vHKJ,HSR_HSRN]OLPQJ$\HS]V?MOT"P¡NOXvHYL0JJMOTy}BZcPYL0NbHYJ,T"]bNbHKMjZiTM ! #& $:SFeLR_NOXvHYL0J$JMOTS}vZ\PYL0NOZ\T"R

[KLR,HY[ETMOMjHS[ENbHS_ ~$]OZ\RvMOHbHS[ENOZiT"R#]OLPQJ$\ZcRvTMZ\PQJ,TMONOLR$[EHu]OLPQJ$cZ\Rvva<UXHuiHKhHSTV_Zc]

[EMOHKNOZ\]OL0NOZ\T"R~]bHS_NbTQJMOTB_~[EH : iHSL_]xNbTYL{NbMjL_vHET ,HKN%xHKHSRNOXvH|[ET"PQJ¨~vNOL0NOZiT"RL/[ET"]bNULR$_

NOXvH>L[K[K~vMFL[EkâTVNOXvH>L0JJMjTS}vZ\PYL0NOZiT"RÚTV ! #& $:{2k ! #& $: bF æNZ\]YL\]bTJ,T"]O]jZi$iHNbT#~$]bH

Z\PQJ,TMONOLR[EH|]jLPQJ$\Z\RNbTuL0J$JMOTS}vZ\PYL0NbHNOXvHHKh*Zc_vHSR[EH|VATM^L{"ZihHSRaPQT*_HS

eTZcPQJ$iHSPQHSR2N^HSZ\NOXvHKMMOHbHS[ENOZiT"RTM|Z\PQJ,TMONOLR[EH{]OLPQJ¨\Z\Rv(H{xTMO>^Z\NOXaNOXH{_$Z\]bNbMjZi¨~vNOZiT"R]

! @ $:SQLR$_ ! @ $:F ©ZihHSRãLz]OLPQJ¨iHVAMOT"P ! @ $:YZiNuZ\]u]bNbMjLZi"X2NbV?TMjxL0Mj_NbTJMjT*_~$[EHL

]OLPQJ$\HV?MOT"P

!

#& $:F$L]^Z\NUZ\]HSL]bkNbTu]OZ\P~\L0NbHVAMOT"P

!

#& $:(2@2F

GZiMOHS[EN^]OZcP~cL0NOZiT"RZ\]J,T"]O]OZi¨iHgVAMOT"P ! @ $: xLR_NOXvHZcPQJ,TMONOLR[EH]OLPQJ$cZ\Rv{(HSZ\"XNUZ\]

@2'&

!

@ $:

! @ $:

&

!

¯

! ¯

2

^XvHKMOH ¯ LR_ ¯ L0MjH|NOXvH|]O~PuPYL0MOk]ONOL0NOZ\]bNOZ\[K]^V?TM^LciT*[KL0NOZ\T"R @uLR_NOXH|MOHSLLR_>_Z\]O[EMOHKNOZc]bHS_

_L0NOL|MjHS]bJ,HS[ENOZihHSikU<UXvHUJ$MOT$L0$Z\cZiNOZiHS] ! ¯ L0MOHI_vHK$RvHS_Y2k{NOXvHUMFZi"XN%X$LR_Y]OZ\_HTVHSá*~L0NOZiT"R

å"FuæPQJ,TMONOLR[EHY]OLPYJ$\Z\RvJMOTB_~[EHS]L(HSZi"X2NbHS_]jLPQJ$iH{VAMOT"P

!

@ $:I*kMj]bN]OZcP~cL0NOZ\Rv

h6Lc~vHS]VAMOT"P ! @ $:SLR_zL]O]OZ\"RZ\RvHSL[jX ]OZ\P~\L0NbHS_zh6L\~HQTV @aLxHSZi"X2N|JMOTJ,TMONOZiT"R$L NbT

(8)

]O~[FXL,T"~R_a[KLRH[KL\[K~\L0NbHS_Ú<]bHKH{,HSiTs VATMLRHE}BLPQJ¨iHsNOXHSRaZ\R$_vHKJ,HSR_vHSR2N^]OLPQJ$\HS]

V?MjT"P

!

@ $:L0MjH|TNOLZ\RvHS_2kz<Z?x]OZcP~cL0NOZ\RvQL @/VAMOT"P

!

@ $: LR_<Z\Z?xL[K[EHKJ$NOZ\Rv @/gZiNOX

JMOT$L0¨Z\\ZiNk @? ^

: p$n

F

« ¨q6n#p

.: mq «

dHKN ! #"($1

+

_vHSRvTNbHQNOXHYJMOT$L0¨Z\\ZiNk_Z\]bNbMjZ\$~vNOZiT"RaTVxL>RvTMjPYL MjLR$_vT"P h6L0MFZ\L0$iH{^ZiNOXJ¨L6

MjLPQHKNbHKMj] 1 + 'à + 2 + F g]O]j~PQH|L{GZiMjZ\[FXiHKNJMjZiTMT"R F ^ZiNOXJ$L0MjLPYHKNbHKMj] $Z\R_vHKJ,HSR_HSRN Z\R2hHKMj]bH"LPuPYLYJMFZiTMj]T"R>NOXvH + ]g^ZiNOXJ$L0MFLPQHKNbHKMj] + LR_ " + ¨LR_aZ\R_vHKJ,HSR_HSRNRvTMjPuL JMjZiTMF]QT"RâNOXvH +

]TVNOXvHVATMjP

+

2

+

F ' Ö 2 6 6 6G28# UXHSRâ[ET"R_ZiNOZ\T"RLT"RâNOXH

T$]bHKMOhHS__L0NOL :âLR_NOXvHQ\L0NbHSRN|LciT*[KL0NOZ\T"Rh6L0MjZcL0$iHS] @NOXvH{J,T"]bNbHKMjZiTM_Z\]ONbMjZi$~vNOZ\T"RTVNOXH

PQTB_vHSJ$L0MjLPYHKNbHKMj]|_vHKJ,HSR_]T"Rã#:(2@2T"R$ik>NOXvMjT"~v"XzL]bHKNTVx]O~$PYPYL0MOk]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZc[K] ¯ #:(2@2

NOXvHQR2~$P,HKMTVT$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R]L\iTB[KL0NbHS_NbT[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSRN

+ /NOXvHSZiM]O~P + LR_NOXvHQ]O~$P TV NOXvH|]Oá*~L0MOHS_T$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R]K + ZH !

#& $:(2@2'

! #& $ ¯ #:(2@2b ' GIZ\My F

Ù )

+ + Ù + + + Ö'! + + 2 + + Ö'! + + ) + ,.-æO©!" + Ù + + 2" + Ö + # + + + + + + vÖ ! + + 2

^XvHKMOHIæO©Q#"eÙ 2"K_HSRvTNbHS]xNOXvHgJ$MOT$L0$Z\cZiN%k{_vHSR]OZ\N%kQTVeLRZ\R2hHKMj]bHI"LPYPYL{_Z\]bNbMFZi$~vNOZiT"R{gZiNOX

J$L0MjLPQHKNbHKMF] 2"HKh0L\~L0NbHS_¤L0N "e^LR$_ {#"eÙ(2su_vHSRvTNbHS]NOXvHaJMOT$L0¨Z\\ZiNk _vHSR$]OZiN%kÚTVL

RvTMjPYLe_Z\]bNbMjZ\$~vNOZiT"Ru^ZiNOXJ$L0MjLPYHKNbHKMj]$(2HKh0L\~L0NbHS_aL0N "e

UXvHJ,T"]bNbHKMjZ\TM_Z\]bNbMjZ\$~vNOZiT"R

!

#& $: [KLRQ,HUMjZiNbNbHSRuZ\RNOXvHV?TMFPàTV "F*^XZciHZiV$xHU[ET"R]OZ\_HKM

NOXvHQ_Z\]O[EMjHKNOZ\]bHS__L0NOL :y/NOXHSRaNOXH{L0J$JMOTS}vZ\PYL0NbHJ,T"]bNbHKMjZiTM ! #& $:Kg[KLR,HUMFZiNbNbHSRZ\R>NOXH

V?TMFPTVUA¥2FGIZ\MOHS[EN^]OZ\P~\L0NOZ\T"RZ\]J,T"]O]OZi¨iHV?MOT"P

!

@ $:Sx^X$Z\[jXZc]U~]bHS_L]gLR>Z\PYJTMjNOLR[EH

VA~$R[ENOZiT"RZ\RTMj_HKMUNbTu]OLPQJ¨iHV?MjT"P ! @ $:FUXH|Z\PQJ,TMONOLR[EH|]OLPYJ$\Z\RvxHSZi"XNgZ\]"ZihHSR*k

@2'& )

+

,.-%

" &

+ + + ! + Ö ! + + - + + +

" &

+ + + ! + Ö + + - + + + (')+*-, > *+. 6

(HSZ\"XNbHS_ã]OLPQJ$iH>V?MOT"P ! #& $:QZc]QTNOLZ\RvHS_2k MF]bNQTNOLZ\RZcRvzLzxHSZi"X2NbHS_ã]OLPYJ$iHTV

L\iTB[KL0NOZiT"R] @V?MjT"P ! @ $:F/^ZiNOXa(HSZi"X2NO]IJMOTJ,TMONOZiT"R$LNbT @2FLR_>NOXHSR]jZ\P~$\L0NOZ\RvYNOXH

[ETMOMOHS]bJ,T"R_$Z\Rv{J$L0MjLPQHKNbHKMgh6Lc~vHS]V?MjT"P ! #& $:(2@2F

UXvHUVATMjP TV ! #& $:(2@2LR$_YNOXvHUHE}BJMOHS]j]OZiT"RYVATMNOXH^Z\PQJ,TMONOLR[EHg]OLPQJ$\ZcRv(HSZi"X2NO]xZ\]]OZ\PuZ\\L0M

V?TMNOXH[KL]OHTVLÚRvTMjPuLIPuZ}*NO~MOHagZiNOXã_$ZHKMjHSRN[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N]bJ,HS[KZi$[PQHSLR]/

+

(9)

GL0NOL Ý`L[K[EHKJNOLR[EH x`` (f NOZ\PYH

<Z? Ö B0¥ 0"å6¥ B

<Z\Z? B"Ü6¥ Þ0ØBÖS× B

<Z\Z\ZA ÖK B\ÖE¥å ×å×å Ö0åÜ

<Zih 0 Bå"Þ0Ø0 ×"Þ0×Ø å*å

L0¨iH>Ö ghHKMjL0HL[K[EHKJNOLR[EHJMOT$L0¨Z\\ZiNOZiHS]ITVNOXvHYMjHHS[ENOZiT"R#]OLPQJ$cZ\RvveLyhHKMjL0HH HS[ENOZihH

]OLPQJ$\H^]OZKHS]TV ÖKB_vMjLy^]VAMOT"P NOXvH^Z\PQJ,TMONOLR$[EHU]OLPQJ$\ZcRvvLR_YLyhHKMjL0H Û f NOZ\PYHS]VATM

NOXvH[KL\[K~\L0NOZ\T"RTVeNOXvHL0JJMjTS}vZ\PYL0NbHJ,T"]bNbHKMjZiTM$L]bHS_T"RNOXvH_Zc]O[EMOHKNbHY<Z?TMjZi"Z\R$L¨_L0NOLBe<ZcZ?

_L0NOLYP~iNOZiJ¨\ZiHS_2k*<Z\ZcZ?_$L0NOLYP~$iNOZiJ$\Z\HS_u*kÖKLR_z<Zih_L0NOLYP~iNOZ\J$\ZiHS_2k0B

Ö 2 6 6 6728 $~vNY[ET"PuPQT"Rh0L0MjZ\LR$[EH <]bHKH Û L]bHS\\L ³Kµº¹Õ 0""uVATMuNOXvHN(T0%[ET"PYJT"RHSRN

PYZ}BNO~vMOHsF æRNOX$Z\][KL]bHNOXvHKMjHIL0MOHN(TQ]O~PuPYL0MOkY]bNOL0NOZ\]ONOZ\[K]K,

+

LR_

+

vTMNOXvH]bJ,HS[KZ\L$[KL]bH

NOXL0N 8 ' LT"~$R_ [KLR,H[KLc[K~\L0NbHS_z]O~$[jXNOXL0N @2 VATML\%@<]bHKH gJJ,HSR_Zi}

w VATMI_vHKNOLZc\]FLR_NOXvHKMOHKVATMOH,Z\R_vHKJ,HSR_vHSR2N]OLPQJ$\HS]^[KLRaH]OZ\P~\L0NbHS_VAMOT"P

!

@ $:U~]jZ\Rv

MOHbHS[ENOZiT"R>]OLPYJ$\Z\RvvBiHSL_ZcRvQNbTuLRHE}vL[ENg]OLPYJ$iHV?MjT"P ! #& $:F

tHXLShH]OZcP~cL0NbHS_ãÖK_L0NOL]bHKNO]{VAMOT"P Ls%[ET"PYJT"RHSRNQRvTMjPuL(PYZi}*NO~vMjHu^ZiNOX [ET"PYPQT"R

h6L0MFZ\LR[EHHSL[FX[ET"R$]OZ\]bNOZ\RTV/0T$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]StHIXLShHLRLikB]bHS_QNOXvHS]OH^_L0NOL]OHKNO]VAT"\iTygZ\Rv

NOXvHgL0J$JMOT"L[jX_vHKNOLZ\\HS_uL0,TyhHBVATM(_Z,HKMOHSR2NiHKhHS\](TV_Z\]j[EMOHKNOZ\]OL0NOZiT"RYTV/NOXvH^_L0NOLBv~]OZcRv,TNOX

Z\PQJ,TMONOLR[EH]OLPQJ$cZ\Rv>LR_#MOHbHS[ENOZiT"R ]OLPQJ$cZ\RvvUXvHMOHS]O~$iNO]L0MOH]OXvTs^R Z\R#oL0$iHÖ0atH

MOHKJ,TMONeNOXHxLyhHKMjL0H^L[K[EHKJNOLR[EHJMjT$L0$Z\\Z\N%kTVvNOXvHxMOHHS[ENOZ\T"R]jLPQJ$\Z\RvyNOXvHLShHKMjL0H^H HS[ENOZihH

]OLPQJ$\H]OZKHx`$`TVdZ\~ ÖS××Ü"g¨L]bHS_>T"R ÖKB_vMFLS^]gV?MjT"P NOXvH{Z\PQJ,TMONOLR$[EH]OLPQJ$cZ\Rv

]O[jXHSPQHLR_ÚNOXvHLyhHKMjL0H Û f NOZ\PQHVATMYNOXvH[KL\[K~$\L0NOZiT"RÚTVINOXvH>L0JJ$MOTS}vZ\PYL0NbHJ,T"]bNbHKMjZ\TM

$L]bHS_T"RNOXvHI_$Z\]O[EMOHKNbH{<Z? TMjZ\"Z\RL$_$L0NOLB/<ZcZ? _L0NOLP~$iNOZiJ$\Z\HS_{2k*/<Z\Z\ZA _L0NOLP~\NOZiJ$\ZiHS_{*k

ÖKuLR_z<Z\hv_$L0NOLYP~$iNOZiJ$\Z\HS_Y*k0B

æN[KLR,H]bHKHSRNOX$L0NuNOXvHZ\PQJ,TMONOLR[EH>]jLPQJ$\Z\RzL0JJMOT"L[FXxTMOB]uxHS\^ZcRÚNbHKMjPY]TV,TNOX

HKu[KZiHSR[EkYLR$_L[K[K~vMFL[Ek¨ÙBNOXvHgh6L0MjZcLR[EH^TV/NOXvHZ\PQJ,TMONOLR$[EHU(HSZ\"XNO]xZ\]]jPYL\HSRT"~v"XYNOXL0NxxH

[KLRX$LShH[ET"Rv$_vHSR[EHxZ\R|NOXHMOHS]O~$iNO]Ke~MONOXvHKMjPQTMjH6NOXH(]OLPQJ¨iHTNOLZ\RHS_|*kINOX$Z\]eZ\PYJTMjNOLR[EH

]OLPQJ$cZ\Rv{]O[jXvHSPYH|Z\]LRL[K[K~vMjL0NbHL0J$JMOTS}vZ\PYL0NOZ\T"RNbTQNOXvHNbMj~vHJ,T"]bNbHKMjZiTM<]OHKH|oZ\"~vMOHåVATMUL

[ET"PQJ$L0MjZc]bT"R^Z\NOXNOXvH|J,HKMOVAHS[ENg]OLPYJ$iHTNOLZ\RHS_hBZ\LQMOHbHS[ENOZiT"R>]jLPQJ$\Z\R2F(vTMINOXvHLR$Lik*]jZ\]

TVIL]OLPYJ$iHTVI0T$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R]{V?MjT"P LN(T0%[ET"PYJT"RHSRNuRTMjPYLPYZ}BNO~vMOH^ZiNOX _Z,HKMOHSR2N

h6L0MFZ\LR[EHS]NOXvHLShHKMFL0HxH ,HS[ENOZihH]OLPQJ$\H]OZKHTVÖKBI_vMjLy^]VAMOT"P NOXvH(Z\PYJTMjNOLR[EH]OLPQJ$cZ\Rv

]O[jXHSPQHZ\]å"Þ0ÜLR_NOXvHuLShHKMFL0H

Û

(f NOZcPQHuZ\]Ø*>]bHS[0ÝUHbHS[ENOZiT"R]OLPYJ$\Z\RvZ\]|HKu[KZiHSR2N

(10)

−10

−5

0

5

10 −10

−5

0

5

10 Importance Sampling

Rejection Sampling

Zi"~vMOHå âJ¨iTNVATM NOXvH[ET"PQJ$L0MjZ\]OT"RTV¨LgJ,HKMOVAHS[EN]OLPQJ$\HVAMOT"P NOXvHJT"]ONbHKMjZiTM _Z\]bNbMjZ\$~vNOZiT"R

TVNOXvHYPQHSLRTVLN%xT0%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NRvTMFPYLPYZ}BNO~vMOH{^ZiNOX[ET"PuPQT"Rh0L0MjZ\LR[EHQTNOLZcRvHS_hBZ\L

MOHbHS[ENOZiT"R>]OLPYJ$\Z\Rv^ZiNOXLu]OLPQJ$iHT$NOLZ\RvHS_hBZ\LQZ\PQJ,TMONOLR[EH|]jLPQJ$\Z\Rv

NbT[KL\[K~cL0NbHULT"~$R_V?TM 8ITMVATMPQTMOHU[ET"PYJ$\Z\[KL0NbHS_QPYZi}*NO~vMjHPYT*_vHSc]K\ZiHNOXvHURvTMjPuL

PYZ}BNO~vMOHQ^Z\NOX_Z,HKMOHSRNh0L0MjZ\LR$[EHS]KexHu_vTRvTNL_vhT*[KL0NbHNOXvHu~]OHQTVxMjHHS[ENOZiT"R]OLPQJ$\ZcRvZ\R

HSRvHKMjL

Ð D jÔjÍ

UXvHMOHS[K~vMj]OZ\T"R]^~]OHS_NbT[KL\[K~\L0NbHNOXvH{P~\NOZiJ$\Z\[KZ\NOZiHS]KvLR_XvHSR[EHNOXHJMjT$L0$Z\\Z\NOZiHS]TVHSL[jX

NbHKMjP ZcRA¥2L0MOHUMjHS\L0NbHS_QNbTJ¨L0MONOZ\[KiH$iNbHKMF] ]bHSá*~vHSR2NOZ\L$W>T"RNbH Û L0MjiTPQHKNOXvTB_]VATM(LR$Lik*]jZ\Rv

NOZ\PQH]bHKMjZiHS]I_L0NOL<]bHKHdZ\~>LR$_

Û

XHSR/eÖS××Ø*Ù/GIT"~[EHKN ³Kµº0¹iÕ

/0vÖ0/V?TMLRZ\RNbMjT*_~$[ENOZiT"R¨F

HKkZc_vHSL^gZiNOXZ\RJ$L0MONOZ\[KiHx$iNbHKMF]Z\]oNbT~]bHMOHS]jLPQJ$\Z\Rv6LR_xHRvTyâ_vHS]j[EMjZi,H(XvTs MOHS]OLPQJ$cZ\Rv

Z\_vHSL]|[KLRzHQ~]OHS_^ZiNOX_ZiMjHS[EN]jZ\P~$\L0NOZiT"RNbT>\Z\PuZiN^NOXvHY[ET"PYJ$~vNOL0NOZiT"RL[ET"]bNLR_PYL0HZiN

J,T"]O]OZi$\HUNbTQLRLikB]bHIcL0MOHI_$L0NOL]OHKNO]KvTMU]OZ\PYJ$\Z\[KZiNk{(H_vHS]O[EMjZ\HgNOXvHL0JJMOT"L[FXV?TM_Z\]j[EMOHKNbH

_L0NOL>AVATM^[ET"R2NOZ\R2~T"~]U_L0NOLBMjHS]OLPQJ$\ZcRv[KLR>]bNOZ\\,H~]bHS_JMOTsh*Zc_vHS_NOXvH|_L0NOLYZc]_Z\]O[EMOHKNOZc]bHS_

Mj]bNFF{tHu[KLc NOXvHQMOHS]O~\NOZ\RvL0JJMOT"L[FX ¢MOHS]OLPQJ¨iHS__ZiMOHS[EN]OZcP~cL0NOZiT"R£<Ý^G|`FLR_zRTNbH

NOXL0NUNOXZc]T"RikJMOTB_~[EHS]LRL0JJ$MOTS}vZ\PYL0NbH]jLPQJ$iHVAMOT"PNOXvH|J,T"]bNbHKMFZiTMU_Z\]bNbMFZi$~vNOZiT"R

tH|Z\R2NbMOT*_$~[EHgL0MONOZ\$[KZ\LNOZcPQHI]OTNOXL0NNOXvH_L0NOL{L0NNOZ\PQH Z\]D:

-

UXvHgJ,T"]bNbHKMjZiTML0NNOZ\PQH Zc]

!

#& $:

- &

*

+

-

¯

Ù=:

-

!

¯

!

#& $

¯

36 "

eT MOHScL0NbHNOX$Z\]uNbT J$L0MjNOZ\[KiH$iNbHKMj]KxH[KLR¤NOXZ\Rv TVNOXvHah0L\~vHS]TV ¯

L]J$L0MONOZc[KiHS]LR$_

¯

('

-¯

Ù=:

- ! ¯

L]NOXH|(HSZ\"XN^L]j]OZi"RvHS_NbTJ$L0MONOZ\[KiH ¯

L0MONOZ\[KiHS]LR_zNOXHSZiM|xHSZi"XNO]L0NNOZ\PQH [KLRz,Hu[KL\[K~$\L0NbHS_MjHS[K~vMj]OZihHS\kaVAMOT"P¡NOXHuxHSZi"XNbHS_

J$L0MONOZ\[K\HS]L0NNOZ\PQH Ö0`BJHS[KZ\$[KL\ikZiV ¯

-+

(11)

¯ (' )

*+

¯

-+

! ¯

-+

6

^TNbHNOXL0N^ZcRJMjL[ENOZ\[EH]bT"PQH|TV NOXvH ¯

-+

^Z\\,XLyhH KHKMOT(HSZi"X2NK¨LR$_XvHSR[EH|xT"~\_>RvTNU,H

Z\R[K\~$_vHS_Z\RNOXZ\]|]j~PQæRJMjL[ENOZ\[EHo(Hu(T"~c_[KL\[K~\L0NbHYNOXHu]bHKN|TVx(HSZ\"XNbHS_J$L0MONOZ\[KiHS]L0N

NOZ\PQH *k$Mj]bN JMOTJ$L0"L0NOZcRvL\BJ$L0MONOZ\[K\HS]L0NNOZ\PQH ÖLR_{NOXvHSRQPQHKMj"Z\RvZ\_vHSR2NOZ\[KL*J$L0MONOZ\[K\HS]

L0NUNOZ\PQH O

ÝUHS]OLPYJ$\Z\Rv[KLR H~]bHS_#^ZiNOX$Z\R]O~$[jX L>J¨L0MONOZ\[KiH$iNbHKMNbT\Z\PYZiNNOXvH[ET"PYJ$~vNOL0NOZiT"RL[ET"]bN

<]bHKH Û XHSRLR_deZ\~/0BÙovHSL0MjRXHSL_zLR_ Û cZTMF_/0"å"F g]O]j~PQH{(HQgZ\]OXNbT>]bNbTMOHL0N

PQT"]bN J$L0MjNOZ\[KiHS]xL0NLR2kuNOZcPQH æVxH[K~vMOMOHSR2NOikYXLyhHPQTMOHNOXLR J$L0MONOZc[KiHS]KxHMOHS]OLPQJ¨iH

J$L0MONOZc[KiHS]K ~vJ/_L0NbHuNOXvHSZ\MxHSZi"X2NO]KLR_#NOXvHSR#L0J$JMOTS}vZ\PYL0NbH ! #& $:

-

¨L]bHS_T"R#NOXvHS]bH

RvHK (HSZi"X2NbHS_J$L0MONOZ\[KiHS]SL0MFZiT"~]MjHS]OLPQJ$\ZcRv|LiTMjZiNOX$PY]XLyhHg,HKHSR]O~vHS]bNbHS_V?TMxJ$L0MONOZc[KiH

$iNbHKMj]|Z\NOL0"LSLBeÖS××Ü*Ù Û L0MOJ,HSR2NbHKM ³Kµº0¹iÕ,ÖS×××*Ù¨deZ\~ ³Kµº¹ÕÖS××Ø"F$~vNxxH~$]bHNOXvH]O[jXvHSPYH

TVHSL0MjRXvHSL_YLR$_ Û \Z,TMj_0"å"^XZ\[FX{Z\]oTJNOZ\PYL"ZcRNbHKMFPY] TVPuZ\RZ\PYZc]OZ\RvUL]Oá*~L0MOHHKMOMjTM

[ET"R_ZiNOZ\T"RT"RNOXvH|RvHK (HSZi"X2NO]KTshHKMILc/~R¨Z\L]bHS_MOHS]OLPYJ$\Z\Rv{]O[FXvHSPQHS]K

UXZ\]MjHS]OLPQJ$\ZcRv]j[jXvHSPQHJMOTB[EHKHS_]UL]UVAT"\iTs^]

<Z? I]O]O~$PQH{NOXL0N|T"~vM|L0JJ$MOTS}vZ\PYL0NOZiT"RNbT ! #& $:

-

IZc]$L]bHS_T"R J$L0MONOZ\[K\HS] ¯

-2 6 6 6C-2 ¯

gZiNOX(HSZ\"XNO]

-2 6 6 67-2

<Z\Z?

Û

L\[K~\L0NbHINOXvH]OT"\~vNOZiT"RTV '

,.-PYZcR,

2SÖyF

<Z\Z\ZAuTMD'äÖ 2 6 6 672^ZiV

ÖNOXHSRHKHKJJ$L0MONOZ\[KiHgZiNOXNOXvHQ]OLPQH{(HSZ\"XNK I]O]O~$PQH

]O~[FXJ$L0MONOZ\[K\HS]UL0MOH|HKJNK

<Z\hvfI]bH(NOXvH(]bNbMFL0NOZiHS_]jLPQJ$\Z\RULiTMjZiNOXP TV Û L0MOJ,HSR2NbHKM ³Kµº¹Õ ÖS×××"eNbT]OZ\P~\L0NbH

J¨L0MONOZ\[KiHS]^V?MOT"P NOXvHMOHSPYLZ\R$Z\Rv J¨L0MONOZ\[KiHS]K g]j]OZi"RaHSL[jXMOHS]OLPYJ$iHS_J¨L0MONOZ\[KiHL

xHSZi"X2NÖ 6

UXvHMjL0NOZ\T"RLiHVATMUNOXZ\]UL\TMjZiNOXPZ\]"Z\hHSR>Z\RvHSL0MFRXvHSL_>LR$_ Û \Z,TMj_0"å"F

`BZ\P~\L0NOZiT"RYV?MOT"P NOXvHI$RLL0JJ$MOTS}vZ\PYL0NOZiT"RuTV ! #& $:Z\]]bNbMFLZi"XNbVATMOL0Mj_/T]OZcP~cL0NbHUV?MjT"P

NOXvHL0JJ$MOTS}vZ\PYL0NOZiT"RTV

!

@ $:Z\]J,T"]O]OZi$\HIL]g_vHS]O[EMjZi,HS_Z\R gJJ,HSR_Z}

Û

: p$n

F

« ?¯y¯S : mq « q « A¯ y« ®

tHL0JJ$\ZiHS_zNOXZ\]|MjHS]OLPQJ$\ZcRvLiTMjZiNOX$P¡NbTLås%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N T"Zc]O]bT"R PYZ}BNO~vMOHuPQTB_vHStH

LRLikB]bHS_Q_L0NOLVAMOT"PàdHKMjT"~B}LR_ (~vNbHKMjPYLRÖS××"TV$NOXvHUR*~P,HKMoTV,PQTshHSPQHSRNO]2kLV?HKNOL

(12)

MOHSá2~HSR[Ek ÖSØ ¥Ö ÖS Ö

oL0$iH I~PHKM^TVoPQTshHSPQHSR2NO]^*kL{V?HKNOL\LP>TyhHKMI6¥"[ET"R]bHS[K~vNOZ\hHQ]bHS[ET"R_>J,HKMjZiTB_]K

0

2

4

6

8

0

2

4

6

8 Exact Posterior

Resampling: 2000 particles

0

2

4

6

8

0

2

4

6

8 Exact Posterior

Resampling: 5000 particles

0

2

4

6

8

0

2

4

6

8 Exact Posterior

Resampling: 10000 particles

0

2

4

6

8

0

2

4

6

8 Exact Posterior

Resampling: 20000 particles

Zi"~vMOH|¥ ~LR2NOZ\iHE%á*~LRNOZciHJ$iTNO]UVATMUNOXvH[ET"PQJ$L0MjZ\]OT"RTVLQJ,HKMOV?HS[ENg]OLPQJ$iHVAMOT"PNOXH|J,T"]

NbHKMjZiTMUgZiNOX]OLPQJ$\HS]TNOLZ\RvHS_>~]OZ\Rv{Ý^G|`V?TM^_$ZHKMjHSRNUR*~PHKMF](TV J$L0MjNOZ\[KiHS]]bNbTMOHS_

tHI[ET"PYJ$L0MOHS_YNOXHgL0JJMjTS}vZ\PYL0NbH^]OLPYJ$iHxH^TNOLZ\RHS_u~]OZcRvÝ^G|`QNbTLJ,HKMOVAHS[EN]OLPQJ$\HUV?MjT"P

_ZiMOHS[ENQ]OZcP~cL0NOZiT"R/ [ET"PYJ$L0MjZ\]bT"R TVINOXvH]OLPQJ$\HS]VATMY_Z,HKMOHSR2N{h6L\~HS]TV Z\]"ZihHSRZ\R

Zi"~vMOH¥v¤æçNu[KLRâ,H>]OHKHSRâNOXL0NNOXvH>L0JJMjTS}vZ\PYL0NbHa]jLPQJ$iHS]QT$NOLZ\RvHS_Ú*kÚÝ^G|`ÚL0MOHá2~$ZiNbH

L[K[K~vMjL0NbHHKhHSRVATM^PQTB_vHKMjL0NbH|h0L\~vHS]TV #

¤Ð; AÏÔ¨ÐIÍ ÔbÎ H

æçRuNOXZ\]]OHS[ENOZiT"RYxHg[ET"PQJ¨L0MOHUNOXvHIÝ^G|`{L0JJMjT"L[jX^ZiNOXQNOXvH©Zi$]]jLPQJ$iHKMS UXvHg[ET"PQJ$L0MjZ\]OT"R

TV NOXvHS]bH|N(TLiTMjZiNOXPu]UZ\]$L]OHS_T"RLRLikB]bHS]^TV ]jZ\P~$\L0NbHS__L0NOLYLR_>ZiN^Z\]PYL_HZ\RNbHKMjPY]

TV NOXvH|[ET"PQJ$~vNOL0NOZ\T"RL/HKu[KZiHSR$[EkTVoNOXvHL\TMjZiNOXPY]S

tH[ET"R]OZ\_vHKMx_Z,HKMOHSR2N(]OZ\P~\L0NbHS__L0NOL]bHKNO]xV?MOT"Päs%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NRvTMjPYL¨PYZ}BNO~vMOHS]LR$_]O~$P{

PYL0MjZ\]OHNOXvHJ,HKMOV?TMFPYLR[EHTVHSL[jXPQHKNOXvTB_aT"RaL"ZihHSR_L0NOL]bHKN~]OZ\RvuNOXvHH ,HS[ENOZihHQ]OLPQJ¨iH

]OZKHa``gTV Û L0MOJ,HSR2NbHKM ³KµIº0¹Õ ÖS×××"FUXZc]IZc]|_vT"RvHQ*kMj~RRZcRvu,TNOXzLiTMFZiNOXPY]Z\R$_vHE

J,HSR_vHSR2NOik#ÖKNOZcPQHS]T"RHSL[FX#_L0NOL>]bHKNKYvTML>]bJ,HS[KZi$[VA~$R[ENOZiT"RTVxNOXvHYT"~vNbJ$~NKNOXvH x`$`

(13)

TMjZiNOXPUXZ\]PQHSL]O~vMOHTVHKu[KZiHSR[Ekz[KLR#,Hu~]bHS_#VATM,TNOXzJ¨L0MONOZ\[KiHY¨iNbHKMj]LR$_#W Û W Û

LiTMjZiNOX$PY]KæçVLRLiTMFZiNOXPXL]ULR ``TVYNOXvHSRZcRvV?HKMjHSR[EH$L]bHS_T"RNOX$Z\]LiTMjZiNOXPZc]

MOT"~v"X\kL]gL[K[K~vMjL0NbHL]gZ\RvVAHKMOHSR[EH$L]OHS_T"R Z\R_vHKJ,HSR_vHSR2N_vMjLy^]VAMOT"PNOXvH|V<~\J,T"]bNbHKMjZ\TM

_Z\]bNbMFZi$~vNOZiT"R{gTNbHYNOXL0NNOXZ\] ``aZ\]g_$ZHKMjHSRNNbTNOXL0NTV(dZ\~/ÖS××Ü*e~]OHS_ZcR`BHS[ENOZiT"Rzåu

NOXvT"~v"XNOXHZ\R2NbHKMOJMOHKNOL0NOZiT"RTVNOXvHh6L\~H|Z\]NOXvH]OLPYHsF

[ET"PQJ$L0MjZ\]OT"R$L]bHS_>T"RNOXvH ``Z\]UHSá2~Z\h6LiHSR2NNbTLu[ET"PQJ$L0MjZ\]OT"R$L]bHS_>T"RNOXvHh0L0MjZ\L0¨Z\\ZiNk

TVeHS]bNOZcPYL0NbHS]xTVL"ZihHSRVA~R$[ENOZiT"RuJ$MOT*_$~[EHS_Y*kYNOXvH_Z,HKMOHSR2N(LiTMFZiNOXPY]x[ET"R]OZ\_HKMOHS_/BLR_Zc]

]bHSR]OZ\$iHgXHKMOHIL],TNOXLiTMjZ\NOXPY](JMOTB_~[EHg]jZ\PYZ\\L0M(HS]OZ\PYL0NbHS]TVNOXvHJ,T"]bNbHKMjZiTMPQHSLR]xTVeNOXH

VA~$R[ENOZiT"R]xH[ET"R]OZc_vHKMS

UXvHIMOHS]O~\NO](xHJMOHS]bHSR2NL0MOH$L]bHS_T"R~]OZ\RNOXvH]OLPQHR*~PHKMxTVeJ¨L0MONOZ\[KiHS]xVATMÝgG|`uL]NOXH

R2~$P,HKMoTV$ZiNbHKMjL0NOZiT"R$]eTVNOXH©Z\$]e]jLPQJ$iHKM<L0V?NbHKM¨~vMjRB%Z\RFUXvHxJ$L0MONOZ\[KiHS]Z\RÝ^G|`J$MOT*_$~[EH

L_$Z\]O[EMOHKNbH_$Z\]bNbMjZi¨~vNOZiT"RT"R>NOXHL\iTB[KL0NOZiT"RaTVT$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]^NbT[ET"PYJT"RHSRNO]KtHJMOTB_~[EHL

]OLPQJ$\H|V?MjT"P NOXvHJ,T"]bNbHKMjZiTMI_Z\]bNbMjZ\$~vNOZiT"RTVNOXvHJ$L0MjLPQHKNbHKMj]I*kMOHS]OLPQJ$cZ\RvYZ\R_HKJHSR$_vHSRNO\k

V?MjT"P NOXH_Zc]bNbMjZi$~NOZiT"RTV^L\iTB[KL0NOZiT"R]S LR$_#NOXHSR#]OLPYJ$iHL>h0L\~vHTVUNOXvHJ$L0MjLPQHKNbHKMj]Q[ET"Rv

_ZiNOZiT"R$LT"RNOXH{LciT*[KL0NOZ\T"R]KI[ENO~L\\k/(HQJMjT*_~$[EHLxHSZi"X2NbHS_]OLPQJ$iHQ_~HNbTNOXvHYRHKHS_

V?TMZ\PQJ,TMONOLR[EH]OLPQJ¨\Z\Rv(HSZ\"XNO]QVATMYHSL[FX]OZ\P~\L0NbHS_ÚLciT*[KL0NOZ\T"R¨F g]Y]jZ\P~$\L0NOZ\RvV?MjT"P

NOXvHY_Z\]ONbMjZi$~vNOZ\T"RTV(LciT*[KL0NOZ\T"R]Z\]P~[jXá*~Z\[jHKMNOXLRJMOTB_~[KZcRvuNOXvHQ]bHKNTVxJ$L0MONOZc[KiHS]K/xH

MOHS]OLPQJ¨iH|LY\L0MOHKMgR2~P,HKMTVJ¨L0MjLPQHKNbHKM^h0L\~vHS]UNOXLRNOXvHR*~P,HKMTVJ$L0MjNOZ\[KiHS]K

âV<LZiM [ET"PQJ$L0MjZ\]OT"RTV$NOXvHN%xT|LiTMjZiNOXPu]exT"~\_NOL0HUZ\R2NbTIL[K[ET"~R2NNOXvH_Z,HKMOHSR2N

Û

(fâ[ET"]bNO]

TVUNOXvHLiTMjZiNOXPu]KGZiMOHS[EN[ET"PYJ$L0MjZ\]bT"R$]|TVUNOXvH Û f[ET"]ONO]Zc]_Zi[K~iN|_~vHuNbTah0L0MjZ\L0NOZiT"R$]

Z\RNOXH|HKu[KZiHSR[EkTV NOXvH[ET"PQJ$~vNbHKM[ETB_vH~]bHS_$LR_NOXH]bJ,HKHS_TV NOXvH[ET"PQJ$~vNOZcRvu\LRv"~$L0H

^Ts(HKhHKMyMOT"~v"X{[ET"PQJ¨L0MjZ\]bT"R]o[KLR{,H(PYL_H(^X$Z\[jX^Z\\2LZ\_NOXvHxZcRNbHKMOJ$MOHKNOL0NOZiT"RTVNOXvHMOHS]O~$iNO]

(HJMOHS]bHSR2NK(TMgT"~vM^HE}*J,HKMjZ\PYHSRNO]K$NOXvH

Û

(f [ET"]ON^TV Mj~RR$Z\RvNOXvHÝ^G|`LiTMjZiNOXP^ZiNOX

LRHE}BNbMjL[ET"]bN_$~vHYNbTMOHS]OLPQJ$cZ\RvJ$L0MjLPYHKNbHKMh0L\~vHS]V?MOT"P NOXvHu¨RL]bHKNTVJ$L0MONOZ\[K\HS]KoLR$_

LuV<~vMONOXHKMg[ET"PQJ$~NOL0NOZiT"RL [ET"]bN_~vHNbTNOXvH{PQHKMO"Z\RuTVJ$L0MONOZc[KiHS]^J$MjZiTM^NbTMOHS]OLPYJ$\Z\RvvU^XvH

tHXLShH[ET"R]OZ\_HKMOHS__L0NOL]bHKNO]TVU]OZKH ' 0BUÖKaVAMOT"P å>_ZHKMOHSR2Ns%[ET"PYJT"RHSRN{PYZ}*

NO~vMOHS]K æRYHSL[FX[KL]bHgNOXvH^PYZi}*NO~vMjHU[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSRNO](xHKMOH^\L0,HS\iHS_QL[K[ETMF_Z\Rv|NbTLRuZ\_HSRNOZi¨L0$Z\\ZiNk

[ET"R]bNbMjLZcRNT"RNOXH[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N{PQHSLR]KÙNOXH]OPYLciHS]bNPYHSLR#L]L]O]bTB[KZ\L0NbHS_ ^ZiNOXzNOXHMF]bN

[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NKUXvHPYZ}vZ\Rv|J$MOTJ,TMONOZiT"RTVNOXvHMj]bNx[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NxL]BÜ*LR_NOXvH[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N

(14)

LR_â<Z\Z?

-'Ö0

' *

-' Ö0

' *Ag\ _L0NOL]OHKNO](HKMjHYLRLikB]bHS_~R_vHKMINOXvHQJMFZiTM

]bJ,HS[KZi$[KL0NOZiT"RzTVU`BHS[ENOZiT"R#å*o^ZiNOX ' Ö 2SÖyF

-'

' Ö0 "

-' "

' Ö0

-'

'äTM

-'

' åQLR_

-'

' Ö0

tHLRL\k*]bHS_NOXvHS]bH_$L0NOLY]bHKNO]^~$]OZ\Rv<LU0J$L0MONOZc[KiHS]VATMUNOXvHÝgG`^ZiNOX0MOHS]OLPQJ¨iHS_

Mj]bNÖK|_vMFLS^]o,HSZ\RvI_Z\]O[KL0Mj_HS_/vTMNOXvHÝ^G|`(H_Z\]j[EMOHKNOZ\]bHS_NOXvH]OZ\P~\L0NbHS_T$]bHKMjh6L0NOZiT"R$]

NbTYNOXvH|RvHSL0MjHS]bNUZ\R2NbHKHKMSUXvH ``h6Lc~vHS]V?TMg]bT"PQHTVoNOXvH|PQTB_vHS,J$L0MjLPQHKNbHKMF]UL]xHS\,L]UVATM

]bT"PQHYNOLZc JT"]ONbHKMjZiTMJMOT¨L0$Z\\ZiNkV?TMNOXvHY]OPYL\\HS]bNTV(NOXvHQN(TaPQHSLR]|L0MOHY]jXvTy^RZcRL0$\HS]

ås*

UXvHHKu[KZiHSR$[EkTV^,TNOXÚLiTMFZiNOXPY]{_vHS[EMOHSL]OHS]Q^ZiNOX NOXvHR*~P,HKM{TV^T¨]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]QLR_/(Z\R

HSRvHKMjLgZiNZc]YMOHSL0NbHKML0NHS]bNOZ\PuL0NOZ\RvNOXH[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2Nh6L0MjZcLR[EHS]uNOX$LRãL0NHS]bNOZ\PuL0NOZ\RvNOXH

]OLPQJ$\HKMS gTyxHKhHKMSINOL0*Z\R Z\R2NbT#L[K[ET"~$RNNOXvHaVAL[ENNOXL0NNOXvH Û f [ET"]bNVATMNOXvHÝ^G|`âZc]

NOXvHHKhBZ\_vHSR[EH>TVINOXH>PQTB_vHS

ß

~vM]OZ\P~\L0NOZiT"RÚ]bNO~$_ZiHS]QXLyhHa]OXvTs^RÚNOXL0NNOXvHHKhBZ\_vHSR[EHZc]

L[ENO~L\ik HS]bNOZ\PuL0NbHS_ hHKMOk¤L[K[K~vMjL0NbHSik æçR LcT"~vMHE}vLPQJ$iHS]KINOXvH]ONOLR_L0Mj_¤HKMOMjTMTVNOXH

HS]bNOZ\PYL0NbHTVoNOXHiT"L0MjZiNOX$PäTVoNOXHHKh*Z\_HSR[EHTyhHKM{ÖKYMOHKJ¨\Z\[KL0NOZiT"R]xL]^iHS]j]NOXLRB"*

¤Ð; AÏÔ¨ÐIÍ ÔbÎÏÎ,ÔjÓ zÔÎÏ

g]x_Z\]j[K~]O]bHS_QZ\R`*HS[ENOZiT"RY¥v*NOXvH^ÝgG|`QLiTMjZ\NOXP§Z\](L[ENO~L\ikQLJ$L0MjNOZ\[KiHU$\NbHKMS L0MONOZc[KiHU$iNbHKMF]

V?TM{LRLikB]OZ\R>PYZ}BNO~vMOHYPQTB_vHS\]_vT>HE}vZ\]bNAæç]OX2L0MjLR ³Sµº0¹Õ0vÖ0Ù HSL0MjRXvHSL_/ 00¥2F^XvH

HSRvHKMjLL0JJ$MOT"L[jXÚZ\]NOXL0NKxL0V?NbHKMYXLyh*ZcRvaJ$MOT*[EHS]j]bHS_ ]bHSá2~HSRNOZ\LcikNOXvHMj]bN T$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]S

HSL[jXTVeNOXvH [K~vMOMOHSR2N(J¨L0MONOZ\[KiHS]x[ET"R]OZ\]ONO](TVL]bJ,HS[KZi¨[^L]O]OZ\"RPQHSR2N(TVNOXH T$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R]xNbT

[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NO]KUXvH J$L0MONOZ\[KiHS]IL0MOHJMOTJ$L0"L0NbHS_L]IHSL[FXRvHK T¨]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"RZ\]^J$MOT*[EHS]j]bHS_>*k

[ET"R]OZ\_HKMjZ\RvV?TMHSL[FXJ$L0MONOZc[KiHL\NOXvHJ,T"]O]OZi$\HgL]O]OZ\"RPQHSR2NO]TVeNOXvHuãÖyç]bNUT$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"RNbT

LY[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NK(UXHSR/ RvHK J$L0MONOZc[KiHS]UL0MOH|J$MOT*_$~[EHS_V?TMgNOXvHMj]ON¤ÖyT$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]*k

(15)

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

_vMjLSg] _vMjLSg] J$L0MONOZ\[KiHS] J¨L0MONOZ\[KiHS] _vMFLS^] _vMFLS^] J$L0MjNOZ\[KiHS] J$L0MONOZc[KiHS]

-å"Þ0 åå åBÖSÜ ¥"Þ0 BÖS å0"Ü ÖE¥""× ÖSØ×BÖ

-ÖS×å BÖE¥Ö BÖÖS ÖK"BÖ ÖS×6¥Ø BÖyÞ0Ü ¥ÖSØÜ Ø0

/

-å0"å BÖSØ åBÖyÞ å"Þ0Ø BÖE¥ åÜÜ ÖE¥¥Ö ÖSÜ"Þ6

Ms

-â ¥"vÖ Ü6¥× Ø× "ÞÞ0Ü × å"Þ*Ö ÖSÜ"Þ0Ü åå6¥Ø

LR_ÚÖKT$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R]V?MjT"P NOXvHQRvTMjPYLs%[ET"PYJT"RHSRNPuZ}*NO~MOHgZiNOXJ$L0MjLPQHKNbHKMj]

-' Ö0

' *"

-' Ö 6*

' QLR_

/

-' 6Ü*

0YT$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R] ÖKuT$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

-¥Ø ×Ø ÖS× ¥¥"" Ø0 Ü6¥å Ü6¥ ÖS×

-0"å å× åÜÜ Þs¥å× ÖSÜØÜ ¥åÜÜ ÜÜå ÖSå6¥6¥

/

-ÖÖyÞ ååå å0Þ Ø6¥¥× ×å 0Þ BÖE¥ ÖÖE¥×

Ms

-â ØØBÖ ÜØØ åBÖSØ× Ü6¥Ø å Þ6Þ ÖK"åÜ 0"×Ø

L0¨iHQ¥

Û

-' Ö0

' å*"

-' Ö0

' {LR_

/

(16)

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

-× ÖE¥å"Þ 0" åØBÖSÜ Þ0Ø ÖSÜ åÜ Ü

-å×6¥ ÖÖSØ"Þ å0Þ*Ö Üå6¥Ü ÞÞ 0"å ØBÖ ÖSØ

/

-ÖSÜ ×× å××Ü ÖÖS×Ø ØØ ÖyÞ6 Ü"Þ ÖSØBÖS

Ms

-â ÖSå å×Ø BÖyÞ6 ÖSÜBÖSÜ ××Ü Ü00¥ ÖSÜ"Þ0å 0"

-' Ö0

' *"

-' Ö0

' {LR_

/

-'¤ 6Ü*

UXvHYJ¨L0MONOZ\[KiHY¨iNbHKMj]|TVæ]OX2xL0MFLR ³Kµº0¹iÕ 0vÖyLR_HSL0MjRXvHSL_¤00¥2(HKMOH_vHS]OZi"RHS_zVATM

LRLikB]OZ\RvLPuZ}*NO~MOHgPQTB_vHS¨^XvHKMOHgNOXvHR2~P,HKM(TV[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSRNO]Z\]x~RvBRvTs^R/ÙBXvTyxHKhHKMNOXvHKk

[KLR,HHSL]OZcik>L0JJ$cZiHS_NbTNOXvHQ[KL]bH{TV(LBRvTygRR*~P,HKMgTVx[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSRNO]S|vTM|]O~[FXL[KL]bH

NOXvHJ$L0MONOZ\[K\H$\NbHKM (|TVIvHSL0MjRXHSL_ 00¥2{Z\]{[KiT"]bHSikMOHS\L0NbHS_ NbTT"~vMQÝ^G|`#LiTMjZiNOX$P

vTM_Z\]O[EMjHKNbH^_L0NOLBBNOXvH^_ZHKMOHSR$[EH^,HKN%xHKHSRuNOXH LR_uÝgG`YZ\]NOX$L0N(Z\RYÝgG|`QJ$L0MjNOZ\[KiHS]gZiNOX

Z\_vHSR2NOZ\[KLh0L\~vHS]eTVvNOXvH]O~v[KZiHSRN]bNOL0NOZ\]bNOZ\[K]L0MOH(PYHKMOHS_|JMFZiTMNbT^MjHS]OLPQJ$\ZcRvvevTM [ET"RNOZcR2~vT"~$]

_L0NOLBNOXvH (ã[KLRzHhBZiHK(HS_L]L]OJHS[KZcLo[KL]OHQTVxÝgG`,,L]VATM|]O~[FX_L0NOLNOXvHQLPQT"~R2NTV

PQHKMO"Z\RTVJ$L0MONOZ\[K\HS]_vHKJ,HSR_]T"R#NOXvHiHKhHSTVU_Zc]O[EMOHKNOZ\]OL0NOZ\T"Rz~]bHS_/ I]xH_Zc]O[EMOHKNOZ\]bHQNOXH

_L0NOL{iHS]O]KBNOXvHSRNOXvHKMjHg^Zc\,HiHS]O]PQHKMO"Z\RTVeJ¨L0MONOZ\[KiHS]KBLR_NOXvH Z\](NOXvHhHKMj]OZiT"RTVeÝgG`

(HTNOLZ\R^Z\NOXRvTY_Z\]O[EMjHKNOZ\]OL0NOZiT"R/vLR_>XvHSR[EHRvTYPYHKMO"Z\RvQTVoJ$L0MONOZ\[K\HS]K

æçRâNOXZ\]Y]bHS[ENOZ\T"RâxH>[ET"PQJ$L0MOHaNOXvHÝ^G|`âLiTMjZiNOXP ^ZiNOX NOXvH ( TVvHSL0MjRXvHSL_ 00¥2Z\R

NbHKMjPY]ITVNOXH[ET"PQJ¨~vNOL0NOZiT"RLoHKu[KZiHSR$[EkTVNOXvH{N%xTLiTMjZiNOX$PY]K ß ~vM[ET"PQJ$L0MjZ\]OT"RaZ\]I$L]OHS_

T"RLRLikB]OZ\RvN%xTYMOHSL/_$L0NOL]OHKNO]U~]OZ\R{s%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NULR_ås%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N oT"Z\]O]bT"RPYZi}*NO~vMjHS]K

UXvHMF]bNU_L0NOLu]OHKN^[ET"R[EHKMjR]UNOXvHR*~P,HKMTV_vHSL0NOXaRvTNOZ\[EHS]UTVoxT"PQHSR/Ø0YkHSL0Mj]UTVL0HLR$_

T"\_vHKMS^XZ\[FXYL0JJ,HSL0MOHS_QZ\RQNOXHUdT"R_vT"RuUZ\PQHS] HSL[FX_Lyk{V?TML|kHSL0M(J,HKMjZiTB_`B[jX$Z\\\Z\Rv*ÖS×6¥2ÞF

UXZ\]_L0NOLZ\]"ZihHSRuZcRYL0¨iHgÜ*UXvHg]bHS[ET"R__L0NOL]bHKNx[ET"R]OZ\]ONO]TV,NOXvH^VAHKNOL\LPPQTyhHSPQHSR2NO]

_L0NOL><deHKMOT"~B}LR_ (~vNbHKMjPYLR/ÖS××"TVL0$\H*

tH~$]bHS_NOXvH ``PQHSL]j~vMOH|TVHKu[KZ\HSR[Ekz

Û

L0MOJ,HSRNbHKM ³Kµº0¹iÕoÖS×××"NbT[ET"PQJ$L0MOHNOXvH|J,HKMOVATMb

PYLR[EHTVxNOXHYN%xTL\TMjZiNOXPY]Se[ET"PQJ$~vNbHS_#L0V?NbHKMMj~R$RZ\Rv,TNOXzLiTMjZiNOX$PY]|Z\R_HKJHSR$_vHSRNO\k

ÖKNOZcPQHS]T"RuHSL[jX_L0NOL]OHKNKUXvHUMOHS]j~iNO]xH^JMjHS]bHSRN(L0MOH^$L]OHS_YT"Ru~$]OZ\RvNOXvHI]OLPQHIR2~P,HKM

(17)

GIHSL0NOX T"~$RN Ö å ¥ Ü Þ Ø ×

vMOHSá*~vHSR[Ek ÖSÜ Ü"Þ "Þ*Ö ÖSØ ÖÖÖ ÜBÖ "Þ Ø å Ö

L0¨iHÜ g~$P,HKMUTV_vHSL0NOXRvTNOZ\[EHS]^TV(T"PYHSR/Ø0kHSL0Mj]ILR_T"\_HKMS$Z\RNOXHdT"R$_vT"RUZ\PYHS]

HSL[jX_LSkVATM^LQkHSL0MgJHKMFZiT*_

s%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSRNgPYZ}BNO~vMOH ås%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N^PYZi}*NO~vMjH

Ý^G|` ( Ý^G|`

0 0 0 0 0

J$L0MjNOZ\[KiHS] J$L0MONOZ\[K\HS] J$L0MONOZ\[KiHS] J¨L0MONOZ\[KiHS] J$L0MONOZ\[K\HS]

1

-Ü"Þ0 ÖS×åBÖ ØÜBÖS ÖyÞÞ60¥ ØåBÖ ÖyÞ0Ø"Þ

/

-Ü0"å ÖSØØ å×"Þ ÖSØØ"Þ*Ö Ø× ÖÖSåÜ

L0¨iHuÞ

Û

T"PQJ¨L0MjZ\]bT"RaTVNOXvH{HKu[KZ\HSR[EkTV(ÝgG|`>LR$_aNOXH (ãL0NLRL\k*]OZcRvuNOXvH{VAHKNOL\LP

PQTyhHSPYHSRNO]_L0NOLY~$R_vHKM oT"Z\]O]bT"RPuZ}*NO~MOHS]K

h6Lc~vHS]NOXLRNOXvHR*~P,HKMeTVvJ$L0MONOZc[KiHS]]OZ\R$[EH]OZ\P~\L0NOZ\RV?MOT"P NOXvHJ,T"]bNbHKMFZiTMTVvNOXvH(J$L0MjLPQHKNbHKMj]

Z\]hHKMjkQVAL]bNK g"LZ\RNOXvHgPuZ}*NO~MOHU[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NO]xHKMOHgcL0HSciHS_YL[K[ETMj_ZcRv|NbT{LRZ\_HSRNOZi¨L0$Z\\ZiNk

[ET"R]bNbMjLZcRNT"RNOXHY[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSRN|PYHSLR]K{UXvH{JMjZiTM]bJ,HS[KZi¨[KL0NOZiT"RxL]L]|Z\Rz`*HS[ENOZiT"RgZiNOX

+

' Ö0

+

' Ö|LR_ "

+

' Ö0 ' Ö 2jYTM ' Ö 2j 2jå*

tHzLRLikB]bHS_ãNOXvHaVAHKNOL\LP PYTyhHSPQHSR2NO]_L0NOL ~R_HKMLÚs%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N oT"Z\]j]bT"RãPuZ}*NO~MOH

~]OZ\Ra<L^0J$L0MjNOZ\[KiHS]^LR$_0MOHS]OLPYJ$iHS_>_MjLS^]SLR_ AU0J$L0MjNOZ\[KiHS]ILR_a0

MOHS]OLPQJ¨iHS_ _vMjLSg]KtHL\]bTLRLikB]bHS_ NOXZ\]{_L0NOL~$R_vHKM{Lås%[ET"PYJT"RHSRN oT"Z\]O]OT"R PuZ}*NO~MOH

~]OZ\R0J$L0MONOZc[KiHS]gLR$_0MjHS]OLPQJ$iHS_a_vMjLy^]KUXvH x``h6Lc~vHS]^VATMNOXvHJ$L0MjLPQHKNbHKMj]

L]O]bTB[KZ\L0NbHS_Ú^Z\NOX NOXvHMj]bNQ[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NYL0MOH]OXvTs^RÚZ\R oL0$iH>Þ2ÚvTMu[ET"PQJ$L0MFZ\]bT"R NOXvH x`$`

h6Lc~vHS]T$NOLZ\RvHS_Y*kQLRLikB]OZ\RvNOXvH^VAHKNOL¨cLPPQTyhHSPQHSR2NO]_L0NOL~R_vHKMs%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSRNxLR_ås

R2~$P,HKMoTV$J$L0MONOZc[KiHS]ZcRNOXvHJ$L0MjNOZ\[KiH¨iNbHKMj]K0xHKMOHHKN(HKHSR{T"RHLR$_N(TTMj_HKMj]oTV$PYL0"RZiNO~$_vH

]OPYL\\HKMUNOXLRNOXT"]bHTV NOXvHÝ^G|`LiTMFZiNOXPxoZcRL\ikvxHLRL\k*]bHS_>NOXvH_LZcik_HSL0NOX>RvTNOZ\[EHS]

_L0NOL~R$_vHKMILs%[ET"PYJT"RHSRN oT"Z\]j]bT"RPYZ}BNO~vMOH{~]OZ\R0>J$L0MONOZ\[KiHS]LR_z0>MOHS]OLPQJ¨iHS_

_vMjLy^]K UXvH x``h6L\~HS]VATM(1

-LR_

/

-VATM NOXvHxÝgG|`L\TMjZiNOXP (HKMjHå6¥LR_QØ*MOHS]bJ,HS[ENOZihHS\k

^XZ\\HIVATMUNOXvH ( NOXvHKk(HKMOH¥¥LR_Ü*¨MOHS]bJ,HS[ENOZihHSik

æN[KLRz,Hu]bHKHSRNOXL0NKgXZ\iHNOXvHuÝgG`zLiTMjZiNOX$P J,HKMOV?TMFPY]P~$[jXz,HKNbNbHKML0NLRLikB]OZ\RNOXH

V?HKNOL \LPPQTyhHSPQHSR2NO]_L0NOL]bHKN~R_vHKMILs%[ET"PYJT"RHSRNPYZ}BNO~vMOH¨NOXvH (âJ,HKMOVATMjPY]^HKNbNbHKM

(18)

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900 1000

1100

−14

−12

−10

−8

−6

−4

−2

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900 1000

1100

20

60

150

400 1100

2000

8100

22000

PF

RDS

PF

RDS

(a)

(b)

Zi"~vMOH (<LdT"L0MjZ\NOXP TVBNOXvHMOHS]OLPYJ$\Z\RvHKMOMjTMeL0"LZ\R]bNZiNbHKMjL0NOZiT"R|LR$_YA x`$`IL0"LZ\R]bNNOXH

R2~$P,HKMTV,T$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R]VATMNOXHg_LZ\\k_vHSL0NOXRvTNOZ\[EHS](_L0NOLLRLikB]bHS_Y*k{NOXvHgÝgG`YLiTMjZiNOX$P

LR_NOXvHJ$L0MONOZ\[KiH$\NbHKM^~R_vHKMLus%[ET"PYJT"RHSRN T"Zc]O]bT"RPYZi}*NO~vMjH~$]OZ\RvY0YJ¨L0MONOZ\[KiHS]K

NOXvHu\L0MjHY_LZ\ik>_HSL0NOXzRvTNOZ\[EHS]_L0NOL~R_vHKM|Ls%[ET"PYJT"RHSRNPuZ}*NO~MOHQUXvH{MOHSL]bT"RV?TMNOXZc]

]bNbMjZiBZ\Rv{_Z,HKMOHSR[EHZ\RNOXHMOHS\L0NOZihHL[K[K~vMjL[EkTVoNOXvHN%xTuL0JJ$MOT"L[jXvHS]UV?TMU_ZHKMOHSR2NU_L0NOLQ]bHKNO]

[KLRH~R_vHKMF]bNbT2TB_*kiT*T*ZcRvuL0NNOXvHMjHS]OLPQJ$\ZcRvYHKMOMOTMZ\R2NbMOTB_~[EHS_*kNOXvH{Ý^G|`>LR_(

LiTMjZiNOX$PY]K

æçRQ Zi"~MOH^Z\]]OXvTs^RQLJ$iTNTVNOXvHMOHS]jLPQJ$\Z\R^HKMOMOTM(L0"LZ\R]bNNOXvHUZ\NbHKMjL0NOZiT"R{TVNOXvHULiTMjZiNOX$P

V?TMINOXvH{_LZ\ik_vHSL0NOXRvTNOZ\[EHS]I_L0NOLLRLikB]bHS_*kNOXvH{Ý^G|`>LiTMjZiNOXP LR_aNOXvHJ$L0MjNOZ\[KiH|$\NbHKM

~R_vHKMxLs%[ET"PYJT"RHSRN oT"Z\]O]bT"RPYZ}BNO~vMOH^~$]OZ\Rv0J$L0MjNOZ\[KiHS]LR$_0{MOHS]jLPQJ$iHS__vMjLSg]K

vTMNOXZ\](_L0NOL]OHKN(NOXvH x``Qh6Lc~vHS]T$NOLZ\RvHS_Y*kYLRLikB]OZ\R]O~v$]OHKNO]TV/NOXvHI_L0NOLTVeZ\R[EMOHSL]jZ\Rv

]OZKH(HKMjH[KLc[K~\L0NbHS_¤LR_ãNOXvHKkL0MOHL\]bT ]OXvTs^R Z\Rã Zi"~MOH* æçN[KLR ,Ha]OHKHSRãNOX$L0NNOXH

MOHS]OLPQJ¨\Z\RvHKMOMOTM|TVxNOXvHYÝgG`Z\]]O~v$]ONOLRNOZ\Lcik]OPYL\\HKMNOXLRNOXL0NTVxNOXvH VATM|NOXvHQMF]bN

ÖS0IT$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]K0LR_NOXvHKMOHSL0VANbHKM HSL[jX{LiTMjZiNOX$P XL]oL^]OZcPYZ\\L0MLPQT"~$RNoTVvHKMOMOTM Z\R2NbMOT*_$~[EHS_

h*ZcLMOHS]OLPYJ$\Z\RvaL0NHSL[FXÚZiNbHKMjL0NOZiT"R/aUXvHuJ¨iTNTVUNOXH ``]OXTy^]NOXL0N{Ý^G|`z]j~v$]bNOLR2NOZ\L\ik

T"~vNbJ,HKMOVATMjPY](NOXvH zgXvHSRLR$Lik*]jZ\RvNOXHI$Mj]bNgÖS0T$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R]ATMV?HKxHKM4FBNOXvHMOHK"ZiT"RVATM

^XZ\[FX NOXvHMOHS]OLPQJ¨\Z\RvaHKMOMOTMYZ\]{]O~v¨]bNOLRNOZcL\ikz]OPYLciHKM{V?TMYÝgG`,Ùo¨~vNNOXHN%xTzLiTMjZiNOXPu]

J,HKMOV?TMFP§]OZ\PYZc\L0Mjik|gXvHSRYLRLikB]OZ\R0T$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R]TMxPQTMOH*^XvHSRQNOXvHgMOHS]OLPQJ¨\Z\RvHKMOMOTMF]

TV NOXvHN%xTLiTMFZiNOXPY]L0MOH]OZ\PYZ\cL0MS

æçR{ Zi"~vMjHxÜIL0MOH]OXvTygRJ¨iTNO]eTV$NOXvHMOHS]OLPQJ$cZ\RvUHKMOMjTMoL0"LZ\R$]bN NOXvHxZ\NbHKMjL0NOZiT"RTVNOXvHLiTMjZiNOX$P

V?TM^NOXvHV?HKNOLcLPPQTshHSPQHSR2NO]^_L0NOLQLRL\k*]bHS_*kNOXvHÝ^G|`LiTMjZ\NOXPäLR_NOXvHJ$L0MONOZc[KiHg¨

NbHKM~R_vHKM<LL{s%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N oT"Z\]j]bT"RPuZ}*NO~MOH^~]OZcRv0J$L0MONOZ\[K\HS]LR_0{MOHS]OLPQJ¨iHS_

(19)

0

50

100

150

200 −15

−10

−5

0

50

100

150

200 −15

−10

−5

0 PF

RDS

PF

RDS

(a)

(b)

Zi"~vMOHÜ dT"L0MFZiNOXPTVNOXH|MOHS]OLPQJ¨\Z\RvQHKMOMjTMgL0"LZ\R]ON^ZiNbHKMjL0NOZiT"R>V?TMINOXvH|VAHKNOLo\LPPQTyhHE

PQHSR2NO]_L0NOL¤LRLikB]bHS_ *k NOXH ÝgG` LiTMFZiNOXP LR_ NOXvH#J¨L0MONOZ\[KiH $iNbHKM~R_vHKMÚ<LaL s

[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N oT"Z\]O]OT"RPYZi}*NO~vMjH~]OZ\Rg0IJ$L0MONOZ\[KiHS]oLR_A/Lås%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N oT"Z\]j]bT"RPuZ}*NO~MOH

~]OZ\RQ0J$L0MONOZc[KiHS]K

J$iHS__vMjLy^]K|æRNOXvHQ[KL]bHQTVxNOXvHYs%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2N|PYZ}BNO~vMOHNOXvH{MOHS]OLPQJ$cZ\RvuHKMjMOTMTVNOXvHQÝgG`

Z\]]O~v¨]bNOLRNOZcL\iku]OPuL\iHKMNOXLRNOX$L0NTVoNOXH xÙLR_XvHSR$[EHNOXvH|]O~v$]ONOLRNOZ\LcikY,HKNbNbHKMUJ,HKMOVATMb

PYLR[EHZ\RNOXZ\]o[KL]bHvTMNOXHås%[ET"PYJT"RHSRN[KL]bHNOXvHMOHS]OLPQJ$cZ\Rv^HKMjMOTMZ\] ]OZ\PYZ\cL0MeVATMoNOXHxN(T

LiTMjZiNOX$PY]VATMxNOXvHg\L]ONIÖS0T$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]xLRLikB]bHS_/BLR_XvHSR[EHgNOXvHI]jZ\PYZ\\L0MJ,HKMOVATMjPYLR$[EH^TV

NOXvH|N(TLiTMjZiNOXPu]K

UX*~]xHu]bHKHuNOX$L0N|NOXvHKMOHuZc]|LNOXvMOHS]jXvT"\_/Z\RzNbHKMjPY]|TVxNOXvHuR*~P,HKM|TVT$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]K^XZ\[FX

TyhHKMjR$]NOXvH>MOHScL0NOZihH>J,HKMOVATMjPYLR[EH>TVÝ^G|`ÚLR$_NOXvH xxæVVAHK(HKMNOXLRNOXZ\]uR*~P,HKMuTV

T$]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R](Z\]LRL\k*]bHS_YNOXvHSRuÝgG`Q^Z\\B]O~$]OLR2NOZ\L\ikT"~vNbJ,HKMOV?TMFPàNOXvH (( ß NOXvHKMO^Zc]bHNOXvHKk

^Z\\("ZihH]OZcPYZ\\L0MMOHS]O~\NO]KUXZc]NOXMOHS]OXvT"\_ Z\R[EMjHSL]bHS]Q^ZiNOX NOXvHR*~PHKM{TVIJ$L0MONOZ\[K\HS]K#vTM

HE}BLPYJ$iHNOXvH|R*~PHKMTVoT$]bHKMjh6L0NOZiT"R$]TVNOXHV?HKNOLcLP>_$L0NOL{NOXL0N^[KLR,HLRLikB]bHS_~R$_vHKM

LYs%[ET"PQJ,T"RvHSR2NUPYZ}BNO~vMOHIHKVATMOHL{MOHS]OLPQJ¨\Z\RvHKMOMOTMTVMjHSL0NbHKMUNOXLRBvÖ|L0MOH|×0B¨0"{LR$_

6¥"aANOXvH^XvT"iH|_L0NOLu]bHKNFxVATMÖKB0LR_zÖKJ$L0MONOZ\[KiHS]MjHS]bJ,HS[ENOZihHSik

L0¨iHÞ]O~vHS]bNO]NOXL0NNOXvH ( [KLR#HKhHSR#T"~NbJHKMjV?TMjP Ý^G|`ZiV]O~vu[KZiHSR2N|T$]OHKMOh6L0NOZ\T"R]L0MjH

LRLikB]bHS_/2JMOHS]O~PuL0$ik,HS[KL~]OHUTV,NOXvHg_ZHKMOHSR2NLSkB]NOXvHgMOHS]OLPQJ¨\Z\RvHKMOMOTMxL[K[K~P~\L0NbHS]xZ\R

NOXvHN%xTYLiTMjZiNOX$PY]K t XHSR[ET"PQJ$~vNOL0NOZiT"R$L¨NOZcPQHZ\]xNOL0HSRZ\RNbTQL[K[ET"~R2NANOXvH (Z\]á*~Z\[OHKM

NbTaZ\PYJ$iHSPQHSR2NNOXLRzÝ^G|`L]ZiN|_vT*HS]RTN|Z\RhT"\hHuLPQHKMO"ZcRv]bNbHKJF Ý^G|`]OXT"~\_T"Rik,H

JMOHKVAHKMOMOHS_NbTNOXvH ÚZiVV?HKxHKM^T¨]bHKMOh0L0NOZiT"R]NOXLRNOXZ\]NOXvMOHS]jXvT"\_L0MOH,HSZ\RvQLRL\k*]bHS_