Review
Sylvain Lehmann*, Constance Delaby, Jérôme Vialaret, Jacques Ducos and Christophe Hirtz
Current and future use of “dried blood spot”
analyses in clinical chemistry
Abstract: The analysis of blood spotted and dried on a matrix (i.e., “dried blood spot” or DBS) has been used since the 1960s in clinical chemistry; mostly for neona- tal screening. Since then, many clinical analytes, includ- ing nucleic acids, small molecules and lipids, have been successfully measured using DBS. Although this pre- analytical approach represents an interesting alternative to classical venous blood sampling, its routine use is lim- ited. Here, we review the application of DBS technology in clinical chemistry, and evaluate its future role supported by new analytical methods such as mass spectrometry.
Keywords: dry blood spot; enzyme-linked immunosorb- ent assay (ELISA); mass spectrometry; polymerase chain reaction (PCR); pre-analytics.
*Corresponding author: Sylvain Lehmann, CHU Montpellier, IRB, 80 Avenue Augustin Fliche, Montpellier 34295, France, E-mail: [email protected]
Sylvain Lehmann, Constance Delaby, Jérôme Vialaret and Christophe Hirtz: CHU Montpellier, Institut de Recherche en Biothérapie, Hôpital St Eloi, Laboratoire de Biochimie Protéomique Clinique et CCBHM, Montpellier, France; Université Montpellier 1, Montpellier, France; and INSERM U1040, Montpellier, France Constance Delaby: Université Paris 7-Denis Diderot, Paris, France Jacques Ducos: CHU Montpellier, Unité de Virologie Lapeyronie, Montpellier, France; and INSERM U1058, Montpellier, France
Introduction
Over a century since a new blood sampling method based on the use of a dry matrix was first described by Ivar Bang [1], the interest in dried blood spot technology has continuously evolved. This alternative approach, based on collecting blood spots on blotting paper and drying them, is called “dried blood spot” or DBS. In 1963, Robert Guthrie used this technique to develop systematic neona- tal screening for the metabolic disease, phenylketonuria [2]. Set up for the first time in Scotland, this use of DBS
spread to the UK in the 1970s, mainly to detect any innate errors in metabolism that were treatable. Of note, the use of DBS remains almost exclusively limited to this type of neonatal screening, even though many studies dem- onstrate its potential application in clinical biology, as well as in research. Indeed, classical clinical chemistry methods, small molecule and lipid analysis or molecular biology approaches, are all perfectly suited to the use of DBS. However, one limitation is represented by the small blood volumes associated with DBS sampling (5–10 µL) and therefore the need for very sensitive methods. Recent technological advances, in microfluidics, multiplex immunological/genomic detection systems, and mass spectrometry, could however settle most sensitivity prob- lems. In this overview we will summarize the pros and cons of this particular biological sampling method and evaluate its future role in clinical biology.
General DBS procedure
Collection and sampling
The collection area (finger, heel) has to be first disinfected.
The skin is then punctured with a sterile lancet (Figure 1).
The first blood drop is dabbed and subsequent drops are placed on blotting paper marked with circles to be filled.
Once all the required circles are filled, the blotting paper is left to dry for a few hours at room temperature on a non- absorbent surface. The drying time is very important as residual humidity favors bacterial development or molds and modifies the extraction stage [3].
Conservation
Once dry, the DBS cards are moved into a waterproof
plastic bag, possibly along with a desiccant and a humid-
ity indicator [4]. The purpose of the desiccant is to finalize
the drying process, which also minimizes any risk of infec- tion associated with sampling. Periods of storage at room temperature vary according to the biological factor, from 1 week for proteins [5], to 1 year or more for nucleic acids [6]. As far as serology is concerned, the blotting papers are usually kept at –20°C upon receipt [7]. For long-term preservation (up to several years) the blotting papers are stored either at −20°C or –80°C [8, 9].
Extraction
Extraction of the analytes from DBS specimens needs to be achieved using a standard procedure. One or more 2–8 mm diameter discs are then created with a specific punch. These small “spots” are placed in an elution buffer for variable time spans according to the procedure. The DBS extraction is then treated as a hemolyzed whole blood sample, and tested with methods often intended for plasma or serum. The elution buffer plays a major role in re-solubilizing the analytes to be tested. A wide variety of buffers are described in the literature. The most common are saline/phosphate buffers, often with added detergents (Tween, Triton…), carrier proteins and chelators [ethyl- ene diamine tetra acetic acid (EDTA)], as well as organic buffers with methanol, acetonitrile or ethanol. For nucleic acids, standard commercial kits exist which are compat- ible with molecular biology tests, from polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to genomic chips [10].
Patient Disinfection of
the sampling area
Prick with a lancet
Deposit on
filter paper Drying 1 to 3
hours at RT Transport/
Mailing
Punch (2-6 mm
diameter) Extraction with Analyses
appropriate buffer
Figure 1 DBS collection process.
Peripheral blood is collected by the patient at home. He disinfects the area (finger) and pierces the skin using a sterile lancet before blotting the blood onto high quality filter paper. The DBS is dried for 1–3 h at room temperature and mailed using the classical enve- lope. At the laboratory, the DBS is stored at room temperature. The sample is punched (2–6 mm) and the analytes are extracted using an appropriate buffer before analysis.
5x50µl 5
1500 rpm 5-10 ml
Dry Storage 4°C
y
Serum orPlasma
Storage Ambient T°
Whole blood with hemolysis Whole blood with
cell preservation VS.
Figure 2 Comparison of the use of classical blood sampling versus DBS sampling resulting in a 100-fold reduction in blood volume and an ease of storage.
Pros and cons of DBS
One of the main advantages of using DBS technology is that it allows access to samples in pre-analytical situations were standard blood collection is challenging (problem with sampling, storage). The typical DBS contains approx- imately 50 µL of whole blood on an average surface of 12 mm
2(Figure 2). It enables the testing of various analytes such as nucleic acids, proteins, lipids, or small organic and non-organic molecules (Table 1). Two types of DBS are mostly available: cotton paper filters of different qualities (Whatmann 903 Protein Saver Cards Whatmann, Spring- field Mill, UK; Perkin Elmer 226 Spot Saver Card, Perkin Elmer, Waltham, USA) and glass microfiber filter papers (Agilent Bond Elut DMS, Santa Clara, CA, USA; Sartorius Glass Microfiber Filters, Goettingen, Germany). The main difference between the two supports is that the glass fiber does not soak up reagents, which diminishes non-specific analyte adsorption on the membrane.
In comparison to conventional blood testing, DBS
offers practical, clinical and financial advantages. Firstly,
DBS collection is easy to perform and relatively painless
(Figure 1). It can be carried out by the patient at home,
without the need for specialized structures such as
medical laboratories. This sampling procedure is far less
invasive than venipuncture, therefore is better suited for
patients requiring numerous blood tests, such as those
with damaged/altered veins, the elderly or infants. The
use of DBS also minimizes the volume of blood taken
from patients. It has been shown that drying the blood
spot on blotting paper damages the capsid of viruses [HIV,
Cytomegalovirus (CMV), hepatitis C virus (HCV), human
Table 1 Overview of DBS card usage in clinical chemistry other than its use for neonatal screening.
Methods Parameter Clinical interest References
Exogeneous nucleic acid Real-time PCR
Q PCR Human herpesvirus type 6 Differentiation active human
herpesvirus type 6 infection from inherited HHV-6
[11, 12]
RT-PCR Human hepatitis C Monitoring hepatitis C virus
(HCV) infection among injecting drug users
[7, 13]
Real-time PCR Human hepatitis B Hepatitis B virus (HBV) DNA
quantification [14]
Real-time PCR, Q-PCR Cytomegalovirus Diagnosis of human
congenital cytomegalovirus infection
[15, 16]
Nested PCR, RNA assays, RT-PCR HIV virus Detection of human
immunodeficiency virus [8, 13, 17]
Peptides/proteines
ELISA HIV virus Human immunodeficiency
virus serotyping [18]
ELISA C-reactive protein Cardiovascular risk [19]
DELFIA Free-β human chorionic gonadotrophin
(free-β hCG) and PAPP-A Fetal aneuploidy risk [20]
Immuno-fluorometric assays Luteinizing hormone and follicle-
stimulating hormone Circulating gonadotropin
concentrations [21]
Chemiluminescent
immunoassay Prostate specific antigen (PSA) Prostate cancer screening [22]
RIA Somatedin-C (IGF-1) Screening test for growth
hormone deficiency [23]
ELISA Apoliproteins B Hypercholesterolemia [24]
Immune nephelometry α
1-Antitrypsin α
1-Antitrypsin deficiency [5]
ELISA α-Fetoprotein Open neural tube defect and
Down syndrome [25]
Enzyme assays Biotinidase Biotinidase deficiency [26]
EIA Calcitonin gene-related peptide Children with autism or
mental retardation [27]
LC-MS/MS Ceruloplasmin Wilson’s disease [28]
Spectrophotometry Hemoglobin Folate analysis [29]
Turbidimetric immunoassay Glycated hemoglobin A1c Diagnosis and treatment of
diabetes [30]
LC-MS/MS HbA
2Diagnosis of thalassemia [31]
Non-radiochemical HPLC Hypoxanthine-guanine
phosphoribosyltransferase adenine phosphoribosyltransferase adenosine deaminase
Purine metabolism disorders [32]
LC-MS/MS Iduronate 2-sulfatase Diagnosis of Hunter disease [33]
ELISA, RIA Insulin-like growth factor Evaluation of growth hormone
status [34]
ELISA Prolactin Diagnosis of epilepsy [35]
ELISA Transferrin receptor Iron deficiency [36]
DELFIA Thyroglobulin Thyroid status [37]
ELISA CD4 CD4+ lymphocyte counts in
HIV patients [38]
ELISA Measles and rubella IgM and IgG Detection of measles and
rubella IgM and IgG [39]
DELFIA Toxoplasma gondii-specific IgM and
IgA Screening of congenital
toxoplasmosis [40]
RIA Insulin Diagnosis of hyperglycemia/
hyper-insulinemia [41]
Enzyme assays Acid α-glucosidase Glycogen storage disease II [42]
Methods Parameter Clinical interest References
Enzyme assays 8 lysosomal enzymes Clinical differentiation among
mucopolysaccharidosis, oligosaccharidosis, and mucolipidosis II and III
[43]
Enzyme assays α-iduronidase activity Diagnosis of α-L-iduronidase
deficiency [44]
Biochemistry Phytanic acid and pristanic acid Diagnosis of peroxisomal
disorders [45]
Electro-immunodiffusion β-Lipoprotein Familial type II and combined
hyperlipidemia [46]
ELISA Fumarylacetoacetase Hereditary tyrosinemia type I [47]
Luminex TGF-β1, (MCP-1, (MIP-1α, MIP-1β,
NT-4, BDNF, RANTES, CRP, MMP-9… Inflammatory status [48]
Enzyme immunoassay IgE Allergic disease and repeated
macro-parasitic infections [49]
ELISA IgG and IgA Nasopharyngeal carcinoma
screening [50]
Enzyme assays Lysosomal b-d-galactosidase (bG; EC
3.2.1.23) Mucopolisaccharidosis type I [51]
Fluorometric immunoassay Thyroid-stimulating hormone Immunoreactive trypsin, creatine kinase MM isoenzyme
Congenital hypothyroidism, congenital adrenal hyperplasia, and muscular dystrophy
[52]
Column chromatography Thyroxine-binding globulin Neonatal hypothyroidism [53]
Immunoassay Trypsine immunoreactive (IRT) Cystic fibrosis [54]
ELISA Antibodies against hepatitis A Hepatitis A [55, 56]
ELISA Antibodies against hepatitis B Hepatitis B [57]
CORECELL Maternal antibody to hepatitis B Infection with HBV [58]
ELISA Anti-HCV antibodies Detection of antibodies to
hepatitis C virus [59, 60]
ELISA Anti-malarial antibodies Diagnosis of malaria [61]
ELISA
Pseudomonas aeruginosa antibodies Pseudomonas aeruginosa inpatients with cystic fibrosis [62]
ELISA Thyroid antibody Thyroid-antibody screening [63]
ELISA Antibodies against tetanus Screening of tetanus and
diphtheria toxins [64]
ELISA Antibodies against Brucella Diagnosis of human
brucellosis [65]
ELISA Antibodies against cysticercus Detection of anti-cysticercus
antibodies [66]
ELISA Antibody against HTLV-1 and HTLV-2 Detection of the Human
T-lymphotropic virus [67]
Immuno-fluorescence Antibodies against to Coxiella burnetii,
Bartonella quintana, and Rickettsia conoriiDiagnosis of Rickettsial
diseases [68]
ELISA Antibody against syphilis Diagnosis of syphilis [69]
Indirect hemagglutination test Antibody against Treponema Diagnosis of syphilis [70]
ELISA Antibody against Trypanosoma cruzi Diagnosis Trypanosoma cruzi
infections [71]
ELISA Antibody against Trichomonas
vaginalis
Seroepidemiology of
Trichomonas vaginalis
[72]
Fluorescent Galactose-1-phosphate
uridyltransferase (GALT) Galactosemia [73]
ELISA Epstein-Barr virus Epstein-Barr virus
immunoglobulin G (IgG) serology
[50]
EIA Rubella virus Detection of congenital
Rubella virus [74]
(Table 1 Continued)
Methods Parameter Clinical interest References
EIA Dengue virus Dengue virus diagnosis [75]
ELISA Antibodies against hepatitis A Hepatitis A [55, 56]
ELISA Antibodies against hepatitis B Hepatitis B [57]
CORECELL Maternal antibody to hepatitis B Infection with HBV [58]
ELISA Anti-HCV antibodies Detection of antibodies to
hepatitis C virus [59, 60]
Multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification on DNA (MLPA)
Detecting 22q11.2 deletions Manifestations associated
with DiGeorge syndrome [76]
PCR GSTM1 et GSTT1 gene variant Researching pediatric cancer
susceptibility genes [77]
ELISA multiplex Human papillomaviruses (HPV),
Helicobacter pylori, hepatitis C virus