A hole in the cloud: Is cloud secure?
N. Vijaykumar
Infosys Technologies Limited, Bangalore
Security in cloud is a key challenge !
… Some highlights include SMBs' concerns regarding security and privacy with cloud environments, topping the list, at 51%, as a reason for not being
interested in pay-per-use hosting of virtual servers, also known as cloud
computing…
Source: Forrester Research, The State Of Emerging SMB Hardware: 2009 To 2010 Business Data Services North America And Europe 0%
10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
Data integrity tampering Interruption of availability Hacker / Data breach Loss of data due to system failure Business Continuity / DR Source: CSO Forum, 2010
All these only goes to suggest that Cloud security is being viewed as a critical parameter for cloud adoption !
Security is a common thread, whatever
flavor of cloud be…
Private Cloud
Public Cloud (SaaS model)
Public Cloud (for usage
burst)
For accessing SaaS enabled applications over public internet
For supporting capacity burst from Private to public clouds For private
cloud access
IaaS
How different is security in “cloud”, from an
“on-premise” datacenter?
1 3rd party service provider
2 Multi-tenancy
3 Geographical Distribution
Breaking down security concerns in cloud
Manageability
• Provisioning ofusers
• Identity & access
management
• Policy based
management
Data Security
• Data privacy• Data protection &
leakage prevention
• Data availability
Compliance
• Compliance tostandards (HIPPA, GLBA…)
• Monitor & enforce
compliance
• GRC requirements
Contractual
• SLA management • Business servicesmanagement
• Audit & reporting • Above all, TRUST
In cloud, these become very critical
Host Security
Network Security
Data Security & Protection
Host Security: server hardware is still at
risk…
Virtualization is the key building block of any cloud environment
Virtual instances are vulnerable… There have been such instances in most of the Hypervisors
Underlying hardware is susceptible to attacks using Hypervisor
Virtualization software is not a kind of security layer, hence secure it..
Check how cloud service provider has implemented host security before signing up (IaaS)
Network Security: The attack area gets only
bigger in cloud
Cloud being implemented and accessed over
internet, provides a much bigger network security risk as compared to “on-premise”
Enterprise and cloud are disconnected
A conventional perimeter security model would not suffice for cloud
Identity and access management is a concern area in cloud. Enterprises might not have control of end users logging on to cloud
Concern-in-chief: Data security
How secure is the data? How secure is the application?
Data life cycle management: in rest, transition etc. Data (of multiple customers’) are co-located !!!
How does a public cloud provider, provides
segmentation and ensure data security, integrity? Levels of encryption and data protection offered by public clouds
Compliance and audits: Only Trust can help
Adherence to security standards (SAS, HIPPA) by the provider
Where is my data? requirement for data to be within the country’s geographical boundaries
Is the cloud auditable?
Ensure that contract includes everything qualitative…
Cloud Information Assurance Framework by
ENISA
Aims at increasing transparency by
defining a a minimum baseline for:
Comparing cloud
offers
Assessing the risk
to go Cloud
Reducing audit
burden and security risks
Applicable to both
public and private clouds 0 0.51 1.52 2.53 3.54 4.55 Personnel security
Supply chain security Operational Security Identity and Access
Management Data and Service
Portability Business Continuity Management Physical and Environmental Controls Asset Management
Legal and compliance requirements
Example Provider Comparison Chart
Score Provider 1 Score Provider 2
Key questions that you should ask your
cloud provider
Do I have a control over where my information will be stored? Where is my data stored ?
Is your cloud operations open for physical and 3rd party inspections
Will you share the audit results of the ISMS audits in your infrastructure?
What are your policies concerning my sensitive information? What are the anti-theft and anti-hacking mechanisms that you have implemented?
The last word
Cloud means different things to different people
"Cloud Computing Security“ is no different than "Regular
Security“, in some ways
Security is perhaps one of the weakest link in the cloud lifecycle. Identify the weakest security mechanism and increase the lines of defenses
Such issues can be tackled with a combination of technology and management
So the only weapon we have is mutual TRUST, backed by complex set of contractual & legal
THANK YOU