arXiv:astro-ph/9512032 6 Dec 1995
BROADABSORPTIONLINEQSOS
OBSERVEDBYTHEROSATPSPC
PaulJ.Green 1;2
andSmitaMathur
Harvard-SmithsonianCenterforAstrophysics,60GardenSt.,Cambridge,MA02138
ABSTRACT
RecentresultsfromtheROSATAll-SkySurvey(RASS)haveshownthatbroad
absorptionline(BAL)QSOsareeitherhighlyabsorbedorunderluminousinthesoft
X-raybandpass.Here,weextendthisworkbyanalyzingallknownbona deBALQSOs
observedwithintheinner20 0
oftheROSATPSPC.Thissampleincludesbothtargeted
andserendipitousexposuresrangingfrom8to75ksec.Despitethesedeepexposures,
mostoftheBALQSOsareundetected,andhaveunusuallyweakX-rayemission,as
evidencedbylargeoptical-to-X-rayslopes
ox.Largevaluesof
ox( >
1.8)mayproveto
beade ningcharacteristicofBALQSOs.WepredictthatsamplesofQSOcandidates
withlarge
oxwillyieldahigherpercentageofBALQSOs,particularlyatlowredshift.
Asacorollary,X-ray-selectedQSOsamplesshouldyieldfewerBALQSOs.
Theoptical/UVemissionlinespectraofBALandnon-BALQSOsarequitesimilar,
suggestingthattheirintrinsicspectralenergydistributionsaresimilaraswell.Absorp-
tionthusseemsthelikelyreasonfortheX-rayquietnatureofBALQSOs.Toconstrain
thetotalabsorbingcolumnoftheBALclouds,wecompareourmeasuredsoftX-ray
uxesorupperlimitstothoseexpectedfromnormalradioquietQSOsofcompara-
bleopticalcontinuummagnitudeandredshift.FromsensitiveX-rayobservations,we
derivecolumndensitiesof >
210 22
cm 2
forintrinsiccoldabsorbersofsolarmetallic-
ity.Thesenewresultssuggestcolumnsatleastanorderofmagnitudelargerthanthe
columnspreviouslyestimatedfromoptical/UVspectraalone.
Subjectheadings:galaxies:active|quasars:general|X-rays:galaxies
1
HubbleFellow
2
1
brought to you by View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk
provided by CERN Document Server
Ab out 10 - 15% of optically-selected QSOs have
optical/UV sp ectra showing deep, wide absorption
troughs, displacedto theblue oftheircorresp onding
emission lines. Occasionally these broad absorption
lines (BALs), seen inthe high ionization transitions
of CIV, SiIV, NV, and OIV,are alsovisible inlow
ionization sp ecies, like MgI I and AlI I I. The BALs
are found only among the radio-quiet QSO p opula-
tion(Sto cke et al. 1992),andaresusp ected toresult
from a line of sight passing through highlyionized,
high columndensity (logN
H
20 cm 2
) absorb ers,
owingoutwardfromthenuclearregionatsp eedsup
to 0.1-0.2c.
For years, BALQSOs weredebated tob e eithera
di erent class of QSO, or normal radio-quiet (RQ)
QSOs viewed at an orientation traversing a BAL
cloud (thus implying that the BAL \covering fac-
tor" is 10 - 15%). More recently, the low BAL
cloudcoveringfactorsandabsenceofemissionlinesat
the high velo cities observed in BALQSOs (Hamann,
Korista, & Morris 1993), along with the similarity
of emission-line and continuum prop erties of BAL
and non-BALQSOs (Weymannet al. 1991,hereafter
WMFH)suggest that orientationisindeedthecause
of the BAL phenomenon, i.e. that all radio-quiet
QSOs have BAL clouds. Thus, BALQSOs provide
auniqueprob eofconditionsnearthenucleusofmost
QSOs. Still,thegeometry,covering factor,temp era-
ture,density, metallicityandionizationparameterof
theabsorbingcloudsarep o orlyundersto o dfromop-
tical/UV(OUV) absorptionlinestudies(Lanzettaet
al. 1991). This is b ecause onlyafew lines aremea-
sured (e.g., OVI1035, CIV1549,NV1240), yield-
ing column densities of a few ions, but little infor-
mation on theionization state. Since theX-ray ab-
sorptionisrelativelyinsensitiveto ionizationandde-
pletion (Morrison &McCammon1983), X-raysp ec-
tra give atotal columndensity. Techniques have re-
centlyb eendevelop edbyMathur(1994)andMathur
et al. (1994) thatsimultaneouslyexploitUVand X-
raysp ectratoconstraintheallowedrangesoftheBAL
cloud conditions. An applicationofthese techniques
to BALQSOs may eventually provide stronger con-
straintsonBALclouds,butuntilrecently,theX-ray
prop ertiesofBALQSOsasaclasswereunknownsince
few rep orts of X-ray detections of BALQSOs exist.
Furthermore, no homogeneous sample of BALQSOs
withavailableX-raydataexisted. However,Greenet
SOsuniformlyselectedfrom908QSOsobserveddur-
ing the ROSATAll-Sky Survey inthe Large Bright
Quasar Survey (LBQS; see Hewett, Foltz & Cha ee
1995 and references therein). Using a Monte Carlo
technique, they found that the average numb er of
PSPCcountsforBALQSOs(forane ectivetotalex-
p osuretimeofab out21ksec)waslowerthanthecor-
resp onding numb er for carefully chosen comparison
samples at least 99.5% of the time. This indicates
that BALQSOs are (1) either highly absorb ed, (2)
intrinsicallyunderluminous inX-rays, or b oth. The
great similarity of OUV emission lines in BAL and
non-BALQSO samplesleads usto susp ect that their
ionizing continua are similar. This, together with
knownOUVabsorption,makestrongabsorptionseem
thelikelyexplanationforthepaucityofBALQSOde-
tections inthesoftX-raybandpass.
Inthis pap er, to b etter constrain the absorption,
we studydeep,p ointedobservationsofBALQSOsby
the ROSAT PSPC that are available in the public
data archive. We cho ose a sample of high-quality,
deep soft X-ray imagesthat provides several detec-
tions,as wellas muchmoresensitive ux upp er lim-
its for ab out a dozen BALQSOs. In every case, we
estimatetheintrinsiccoldcolumndensity,N intr
H ,nec-
essarytoabsorbtheX-rayemissionexp ectedfroman
average radio-quiet (RQ) QSO. We also brie y con-
siderthee ectsofmetallicityandionizationonthese
estimates.
2. Sample
We rst generated alist ofoptical BAL p ositions
fromHewitt&Burbidge1993,Junkarrinen,Hewitt&
Burbidge(1991),andfromanup datedlistkindlypro-
videdbyTomBarlow(privatecommunication).From
thislist,weremovedobjectsthatarenotlistedde ni-
tivelyasBALQSOsbasedonanalysisofOUVsp ectra
by all these authors. We then cross-correlated our
list with the list of ROSAT PSPC archived p oint-
ings (version May 18, 1995). A matching tolerance
of 20 0
fromeach optical BALp osition includes b oth
serendipitous and targeted observations, but avoids
theribsofthePSPC.ThisinnerareaofthePSPCalso
b oasts thenarrowestp ointsource resp onse function,
thereby optimizing signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and
decreasingsourceconfusion. Lastly,weremovedfrom
thesample one QSO (0042-267) lying closeto arib,
and twoQSOs (0104+318 and 0413-116)lying < 1 0
Ab ell483, resp ectively). The resulting sample of 12
BALQSOsislistedinTable1. Fiveofthese(witho -
axisdistances>1 0
inTable1)wereobservedserendip-
itouslyoraspartofageneral eld,whiletherestwere
targetedobservationsoftheQSO.Theresultingsam-
ple isneithercomplete noruniformly-selected, butit
do es minimizecontamination from normal QSOs or
from QSOs with narrow-line/intervening absorption
systems.
3. Dataand Analysis
Table1showsBmagnitudes,redshiftandGalactic
columndensityN Gal
H
aswellastherawX-raydatafor
eachBALQSO inoursample. WederivednetPSPC
source countsusingcircularap ertures withradiiR
ap
(in arcseconds) listed in Table1. Small radii were
sometimesrequired to avoidnearby unrelated X-ray
sources. To comp ensate for the exclusion of source
ux fromsmallap ertures, we applyanap erture cor-
rectionfactortosource counts(takenfromFig.11of
Brinkmannet al. 1994),forb oth detections andup-
p er limits.Backgroundcountsareshown normalized
to the source ap erture area, although we use much
larger areas for background estimation,and exclude
any overlapping sources. Upp er limits to thesource
countsareset at3 .
For comparison of the observed count rate or its
upp er limit to that exp ected from a typical RQ
QSO, we rst derived an optical luminosityderived
from the observed magnitude. Optical luminosities
are calculated using the magnitudes listed in Ta-
ble1, with H
0
= 50 km s 1
Mp c 1
and q
0
= 0:5,
and sp eci c optical zerop oint from Marshall etal.
(1984). WeincludeareddeningcorrectionofE
B V
=
max[0;( 0:055+1:98710 22
N Gal
H
]andA
V
=3E
B V .
Wethenpredict anintrinsicsoftX-ray ux usingthe
slop e
ox
ofahyp otheticalp owerlawconnectingrest-
frame2500
A and2keV,where
ox
=0:384log(
lopt
lx ).
Objects with large
ox
thus have stronger optical
emissionrelativetoX-ray. Weassume
ox
=1:6,the
meanforRQQSOsintheROSATPSPC(Greenetal.
1995). Using ourpredicted softX-ray ux, we then
usedPIMMS(thePortableInteractiveMulti-Mission
Simulator;Mukai1993)toderive theexp ectedPSPC
count rate corresp onding to this ux, assuming a
p ower-law mo del with
E
= 1:5 (the mean PSPC
E
for radio-quiet quasars; Laor et al. 1994) and
the Galactic columndensity. If the exp ected PSPC
(as is the case for all BALQSOs in oursample), we
increased the columndensity of the absorb er in the
sp ectralmo deluntiltheobservedcountrateorupp er
limitwasreached. Thisresultsinalowerlimittothe
`observed' column, on the assumption that the ab-
sorb er iscoldgaswithsolarmetallicity. Afterderiv-
ingthe(z=0)additionalcolumnrequired tomatch
thePSPCcountrateorupp erlimitfortheBALQSOs
inoursample,wethenused XSPEC(anX-raysp ec-
tral tting package; Arnaud 1995) to calculate the
columndensityoftheabsorb eratthesourceredshift
z
em
. Using the January 1993 PSPC resp onse ma-
trix, we rst simulatedaPSPC sp ectrum of aQSO
with
E
=1:5. This slop eis used togetherwith the
corresp onding total (z = 0) absorption and mo del
normalizationfound via PIMMS. We then re t the
simulatedsp ectrum with a 5 parameter mo del: (1)
Galactic column density ( xed at N Gal
H
), (2) intrin-
siccolumndensity(free),(3)sourceredshift( xedat
z
em
), (4)sp ectral slop e( xed at
E
=1:5),and (5)
mo delnormalization( xedatthePIMMSnormaliza-
tion).
Table2showstheap erture-correcte d PSPC count
rateforeachQSO,thederivedX-rayluminosity,and
ox
. We thenlist thetotal columndensity at z=0
required toobtainthat countrateassumingthetyp-
icalRQ QSO valueof
ox
= 1:6. The next column
shows the intrinsic column density, N intr
H
, required
if the absorb er is at the source redshift, with for-
mal1 errors fromXSPEC. We nd
ox
> 1:8and
N intr
H
> 210 22
cm 2
forall the bona de BALQ-
SOswith sensitive X-rayobservations(but seenotes
onPG1416 129and0312-555insection5.).
We also tested our technique on a sample of 10
RQ QSOs studied by Laor et al. (1994). We nd
asample mean of
ox
=1:450:08. To obtainthe
observed ROSAT PSPC countrates, none ofthe10
QSOs required additional(z=0)columnmorethan
110 20
cm 2
over the Galactic value. Indeed, 8 of
theQSOshadhigherPSPCcountrates thanwepre-
dicted, showing that our choice of
ox
=1:6 results
inconservative estimatesoftheabsorption.
Allour calculationsassume
E
=1:5,and acold
absorb eratsolarmetallicity.Inthefollowingsection,
we discussthee ectsoftheseassumptions.
umnN intr
H
Since X-ray sp ectra cannot b e adequately mo d-
eled for the weak or undetected QSOs in our sam-
ple, we must make several assumptions in order to
derive an estimate of the intrinsic column. Essen-
tially,wemo deltheexp ectedX-ray uxf
x
asafunc-
tion f(B;N Gal
H
;
ox
;
E
;Z ;U;N intr
H
), where Z is the
metallicity expressed in solar units, and U is the
ionization parameter. In most cases here (the non-
detections), we know only B and N Gal
H
, and we as-
sume values for thenext 4parameters (
ox ,
E , Z,
and U)to derive N intr
H
. In the discussion following,
we brie y examinethe e ects of these 4 parameters
onourresults.
4.1. Optical-to-X-raySlop e
ox
Our assumed value of
ox
is 1.6, which we take
torepresent theintrinsicsp ectralenergydistribution
(SED) of the QSO, i.e., b efore absorption by BAL
material. Since there mayalready b e some absorp-
tioninnormalRQQSOs a ectingthis value,we are
in e ect deriving the additional absorption ab ove a
typicalRQQSO,ratherthanrelativetothebarecon-
tinuum. However,thedi erence isprobablynotim-
p ortant,sincethemajorityofoptically-selectedQSOs
observedinsoftX-raystodateshowlittleevidencefor
any substantialN intr
H
(e.g., Fioreet al. 1994,Bech-
toldet al. 1994,Walter&Fink1993).
Smallerassumedvalues of
ox
wouldincreaseour
estimated values ofN intr
H
. For RQQSOs, arangeof
values from ab out 1 to 2 is observed (Green et al.
1995). The di erence b etween ourassumed valueof
1.6 and the extremes of this range represents afac-
tor of up to 30 in our predicted broadband uxes.
Thelower-than-exp ected softX-ray uxesofBALQ-
SOs could b e entirely accounted for without excess
absorption ifthe intrinsic SEDs of BAL QSOs have
ox
>
1.8. However, given such di erent SEDs, we
wouldexp ectmuchlargerdi erencesb etweenthecon-
tinuaandemissionlines ofBALandnon-BAL QSOs
than areseen (WMFH).Ontheother hand,there is
asyetnodetailedstudyofwhetherlargedi erencesin
UVsp ectral prop ertiesareindeedseeninQSOswith
widely divergent
ox
. Suchastudyisnowunderway
using IUE and LBQS sp ectra (Green et al. 1996).
The b ottom line is that our assumed value of
ox
probably results inconservative estimates of the in-
trinsicabsorption,asdeterminedab ovefromtestson
fromLaor etal. (1994).
4.2. X-ray Sp ectralSlop e
E
IftheintrinsicX-raysp ectra were notassteep as
we assume (i.e.,if
E
< 1:5),then our estimates of
N intr
H
would b e systematically lower. Fits to high
signal-to-noise X-ray sp ectra of low redshift QSOs
yieldvaluesof
E
from1.0to2.2ab outthemeanof
E
1:5that weusehere(Laoretal. 1994,Fioreet
al. 1994). Suchareasonablevariationoftheassumed
sp ectral slop eintheX-raybandpass makesnomore
thana20%di erence inthederivedbroadband ux,
andcorresp ondinglynomorethana30%di erence
inthederivedN intr
H .
An intrinsicstrong soft excess, or sp ectral curva-
ture, typicallyb elowrest-frame energy 0.5keV,may
exist in a large fraction of RQ QSOs (Schartel et
al. 1995). Our analysis is not a ected for all but
the 3lowest redshift QSOs in our sample,since the
PSPC bandpass excludes this sp ectral region. For
these 3QSOs, ourassumptionof asimplep ower-law
of
E
=1:5resultsinamoreconservativelowerlimit
toN intr
H .
4.3. IonizationParameterU
Wehaveassumedacold,neutral gasastheintrin-
sic absorb er. The soft X-ray opacity of the absorb-
inggasdecreases withincreasing ionizationstate,so
thatourassumptionresultsinconservativeestimates
of the actual gas column. If instead of neutral gas,
we assumeU 0:1,basedonphotoionizationmo dels
oftheOUV data(Hamman,Korista,&Morris1993;
HKMhereafter),thenourtypicalresultofafewtimes
10 22
cm 2
would rise by ab out an order of magni-
tude. Evenhigherionizationparameters arelikelyto
b e required to repro duce observed sp ectra; U 0:1
wasderivedassuminglowercolumndensitiesthanwe
ndhere. Newertheoreticalcalculationswithcolumn
densities N
H
>
10
22
cm 2
require 1
<
U
<
60(Murray
etal. 1995,Hamannet al. 1995).
4.4. MetallicityZ
We have assumedsolar metallicity. Emissionline
ratiosinhighredshift QSOs suggesthigherZ values
in non-BALQSOs (e.g., Hamman & Ferland 1993).
Studies of thechemicalenrichmentofgas inBALQ-
SOs (e.g., HKM) supp ort values b etween 2 and 10
solar. OurestimatedvaluesofN
H
areinverselypro-
p ortionalto the assumedmetallicity. Unlessthe nu-
clearenvironmenttypicallyhasabundances100times
solar(Turnshek1988),we still requirecolumndensi-
tiesatleastanorderofmagnitudehigherthantypical
forRQQSOs(Fioreetal. 1994),allelseb eingequal.
5. Noteson IndividualObjects
5.1. 0312-555 = MZZ9592
AtB =21:8,this istheopticallyfaintestQSOin
our sample. Even with atotalPSPC exp osure time
of 56ksec, the X-ray observation is not suÆciently
sensitivetoputinterestinglimitson
ox orN
intr
H for
this object. An exp osure timeof at least 250ksec
wouldb erequired.
5.2. 0759+651 = IRAS07598+6508
This object is a memb erof the rare class of low-
ionization BALQSOs. These show a strong blend
of broad absorption and emission lines in b oth low
and high states of ionization. It is also an extreme
(optical) FeI I emitter,and an`ultraluminous'IRAS
source. Hines and Wills(1995) nd thesp ectral en-
ergydistributiontob ereddenedbyE(B V)0:12
relativetonon-BALQSOs. Sprayb erry&Foltz(1992)
nd thatsuch reddeningis typicalforlow-ionization
BALQSOs, and accounts for thesp ectral di erences
fromthegenerallybluerhigh-ionizationBALQSOs.
Assumingagas-to-dust ratiogivenbyBurstein&
Heiles(1978),andthesamereddeningequationused
in our calculation of L
opt
, the observed OUV red-
deningimpliesanequivalentGalacticcolumnofonly
10 21
cm 2
. From our X-ray analysis, we nd a
(z = 0) column>2:010 22
cm 2
. This illustrates
thattheabsorb erisprobablywarm{suÆcientlyion-
ized that its e ects are not seen in the OUV, and
with alowdust-to-gasratio. A lowdust-to-gasratio
mightseemstrange inanIRASQSO where muchof
the far-IR luminosity is exp ected to b e from warm
dust(p ossiblymergerrelated). However,muchofthe
IR-emittingregionmayb eextranuclear.
5.3. 1246-057
BasedonthePSPCimage,thereapp eartob etwo
sources near to the optical QSO p osition. Source A
is at 12 h
49 m
13:1 05 Æ
59 0
13:0 00
, only 14 00
from the
optical QSO p osition. Source B, at 12 h
49 m
14:7
06 Æ
00 0
34:6 00
,is77 00
fromtheopticalQSOp ositionand
hasnoobviousopticalcounterpart onthePOSS.We
assumethat source Ais theBALQSO.Netcountsin
thehard(0.41-2.45keV)bandare7412. Thesoft
(0.12-0.40keV)bandshowsonlya3upp erlimitof
32.4counts.
Although this is one of only 2 detections (see
PG1416 129 b elow) in our sample, it still shows a
value of
ox
that is at the extremeX-ray weak end
oftheobservedrangeforQSOs. Theintrinsiccolumn
we derive,1:210 23
cm 2
,isthehighest inthesam-
ple. This indicates that ourlower limitstoN intr
H , in
thecaseofnon-detections,areprobablyconservative.
5.4. 1416 129= PG
PG1416 129is a strong detection that has b een
analyzedbydeKo ol &Meurs1994. Theirresults for
the ROSAT bandpass were quite typical for a RQ
QSO (
E
= 1:2), while earlier GINGA results were
very at(
E
0:1,Williamsetal. 1992). The4year
separationof thoseobservations,however,couldren-
derthedatadiÆculttointerpret,since at-sp ectrum
QSOs inparticular can vary enormously. The BAL
classi cation was originallyawarded by Turnshek &
Grillmair (1986), based on a single IUE sp ectrum
in each of the SWP and LWR instruments. How-
ever,wehaveexaminedthehigherquality,optimally-
extracted and co-addedsp ectrum ofPG1416 129of
Lanzetta, Turnshek, & Sandoval(1993), and we b e-
lieve that theobject is not aBALQSO. Atthe very
least, it unquestionably shows the weakest UV ab-
sorption of anyQSO in oursample. An HST sp ec-
trumwouldresolve theissueonceandforall.
Using the standard technique we have describ ed
(which assumes
E
= 1:5 and only N Gal
H
), we de-
rive anexp ected count rateconsistentwith that ob-
served. That is, noN intr
H
is required. Furthermore,
ox
forthisQSO isonthelow(X-raybright)end of
therangeforRQQSOs. TheseX-rayresults,consis-
tent with deKo ol & Meurs (1994) thus also suggest
thatPG1416 129isnotabona deBALQSO.
6. Conclusions
Usingdeepp ointedobservations fromtheROSAT
PSPC, we demonstrate that BALQSOs are weak in
thesoft X-raybandpass incomparisonto RQQSOs
with normal OUV sp ectra. The only object in our
samplewithasensitive X-rayobservationthatisnot
anomalously weak in the ROSAT PSPC bandpass
is PG1416 129, which has a low value of
ox and
theQSOsinoursample,PG1416 129hastheweak-
estBALs. Considerationofoptimally-extractedIUE
dataandourROSATanalysisleadustoprop osethat
it isnotabona de BALQSO.
True BALQSOs have proved notoriously diÆcult
to detect in X-rays, but evidence until recently has
b een mostly anecdotal. As an example, Bregman
(1984)obtainedEinstein IPCobservationsof3BALQ-
SOs, and rep orted detection of only one, UM232,
which showed no evidence of an absorption cuto .
It turns out that the X-ray source is not UM232,
but a low-redshift, non-BAL QSO projected nearby
(Junkkarinen,Barlow,&Cohen1993). Ourworkex-
tends and complementsthat of Green et al. (1995).
Their sample of 36 BALQSOs was chosen from a
large uniformly-selected QSO sample (the LBQS),
and formsthemost`complete'sampleever observed
in X-rays. The short ( 600sec) exp osure times of
the ROSAT All Sky Survey meant that the upp er
limits (for35 of the 36 QSOs) were not very sensi-
tive. By stacking the X-ray data, they achieved a
total exp osure timeof ab out 21ksec. By using the
meanN Gal
H
andredshift forthat sample,we nd here
that nointrinsiccolumnis required withinthelarge
errors. However, Green et al. (1995) were able to
show that the BALQSO sample was X-ray quiet at
the99.5%levelcomparedtocarefullychosencompar-
isonRQQSOsamples. Althoughthesamplewestudy
hereisbynaturemuchmoreheterogeneous,themean
exp osuretimeof25ksecforeachobjectmeansthat
we are able to provide muchmore interesting limits
(
ox
>1:8)ontheoptical-to-X-rayslop eofbona de
BALQSOs withsensitive X-rayobservations.
We sp eculate that largevalues of
ox
may prove
to b e a de ning characteristic of BALQSOs. Atthe
very least, we predict that samples of QSO candi-
dateswithlarge
ox
willyieldahigherp ercentage of
BALQSOs, particularlyat lowredshift,where BALs
areless easilydetected intheoptical,andX-raysur-
veysaremoresensitivetolowluminosityobjects. As
acorollary,X-ray-selectedQSO samplesshouldyield
fewer BALQSOs.
Several arguments in the literature suggest that
BALQSOs are not a separate p opulation 10% as
large as normal RQ QSOs, but rather RQ QSOs
viewedalongalineofsightthroughanabsorb ertypi-
edbya10%coveringfraction. First,theemission
line parameters indicate similarionizing continuain
b oth BALand non-BALQSOs (WMFH).Also, con-
suggest that all RQ QSOs have BAL regions. In
any case, the intrinsic sp ectral energy distributions
of BALQSOs are likelyto b e similar to their unab-
sorb edanalogs,butBALQSOsprovideasp ecialview
intothegasdynamicsaroundnormalRQQSOs. Al-
thoughwith these data, we cannot de nitivelyiden-
tifytheOUVandX-rayabsorb ersasthesamemate-
rial,basedontheargumentsjustpresented,weexp ect
thelargeobservedvaluesof
ox
inBALQSOsmayb e
causedbyabsorptionbyhighcolumndensity,ionized,
out owingmaterialalong theline ofsight. If this is
indeed the main di erence b etween BALQSOs and
normalRQQSOs, theintrinsicabsorbingcolumnsin
BALQSOs are morethan 100timeshigher. Usinga
sampleof12QSOsobservedinthesoftX-rayregime
bythe ROSATPSPC,we place highlower limitson
thisabsorptionofN intr
H
>210 22
cm 2
for10QSOs.
Ofthetwothatdonotrequireexcess absorption,one
isatb est amarginalBALQSO (1416-129),whilethe
other(0312-555)hasanX-rayobservationto oshallow
toprovidesensitivelimitstoN intr
H
. Theonedetected,
de nitiveBALQSO,1246 057,yieldsthehighestcol-
umnestimateofall,N intr
H
=1:210 23
cm 2
.
Wenotethatsomevariabilityhasb eenseeninthe
BALsp ectraof3QSOsinoursample.Smith&Pen-
ston (1988)foundchanges intheBALsof 1246 057
and p ossibly 1309 056at the 20%level, indicat-
ing lower limits to column changes of only ab out
10 14
cm 2
. A demonstration of correlated variabil-
ityb etween BALsandsoftX-ray uxwouldprovide
moreevidence thattheUV andsoftX-rayabsorb ers
arephysicallyasso ciated,butisadauntingtaskgiven
theweakX-ray uxes. Thecasefor1413+117ismore
complicated,sinceitisgravitationallylensed(Hutse-
mekers1993).
Most mo dels for BALQSOs (e.g., Arav, Li, &
Begelman1994)have b een tailoredto repro duce the
columnsinferredfromOUVdataalone. Atleastone
recent mo del(Murrayet al. 1995)predicts acolumn
densityof 10 23
10 24
cm 2
, consistent with theto-
talabsorbing columnswe derive here. Murray et al.
(1995)explainBALsp ectrainQSOsastheresultofa
(nearlyedge-on)lineofsightalonganaccretiondisk,
wheretheinneredgeofaradiativelyacceleratedwind
entrainsdensegaso thedisk. Thelargecolumnand
warm ionization state of this gas blo cks the softX-
raysfromthenucleus,buttransmitsUV photons. In
thisway,cloudmaterialfurtheroutcancontinuetob e
radiativelyacceleratedto 0:1c,since itsCNO ions
sion. This mo delisconsistent withour ndings here
ofveryhigh intrinsiccolumndensitiesinBALQSOs.
The much lower absorbing columns (e.g., N
H
10 19
to 10 20
) inferred for the BAL clouds from the
OUV data (HKM, Turnshek 1988) are such that a
priori we would have exp ected very littlesoft X-ray
absorption ( << 1). Soft X-ray observations thus
proveusefulinconstrainingthetotalline-of-sightcol-
umn. Ifthe BALQSO phenomenon is indeed onlya
viewing angle e ect, then in the hard X-ray range
(>3keV),BALQSOsshouldhavesp ectralslop essim-
ilartonormalradioquietQSOs. Someearlyevidence
for this is that an ASCA sp ectrum of theprototyp e
BALQSO, PHL5200, is b est t using a typical RQ
QSOp ower-lawwithlargeintrinsicabsorption,N intr
H a
few times 10 23
(Mathur, Elvis, & Singh1995). We
have b eenawardedXTEtimeto furtherpursuehard
X-raystudiesofBALQSOs.
Many thanks to Tom Barlow for providing us a
list of BALQSOs with his valuable comments. Be-
linda Wilkes' comments substantially improved our
rstdraft. Supp ortforPJGwasprovidedbytheNSF
through grant INT9201412, and by NASA through
Grant HF-1032.01-92A awarded by the Space Tele-
scop e Science Institute, which is op erated by the
Asso ciation of Universities for Research in Astron-
omy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS5-26555. SM
wassupp ortedbyNASAgrantNAGW-4490(LTSA).
Thisresearch hasmadeuseofdataobtainedthrough
the High Energy Astrophysics Science Archive Re-
searchCenterOnlineService,providedbytheNASA-
Go ddard Space Flight Center, and of the Simbad
database,op eratedatCDS,Strasb ourg,France.
Arav, N., Li, Z.-Y., & Begelman, M. C. 1994, ApJ,
432,62
Arnaud, K.A., 1995. Astronomical Data Analysis
Software and Systems V., eds. G. Jacoby and J.
Barnes,inpress.
Bechtold, J.,etal. 1994,AJ,108,374
Bregman,J.M.1984,ApJ,276,423
Brinkmann,W.et al. 1994,A&A,288,433
Boyle, B.J., Fong, R., Shanks, T., Peterson, B. A.
1990,MNRAS,243,1
Burstein, D.,&Heiles,C.1978,ApJ, 225,40
deKo ol,M. &Meurs,E. J.A.1994,A&A,281,L65
Elvis,M.,Lo ckman,F.J.,&Wilkes,B.J.1989,AJ,
97, 777
Fiore,F.,Elvis,M.,McDowell,J.C.,Siemiginowska,
A.,&Wilkes,B.J.1994,ApJ,431,515
Green, P. J., Schartel, N., Anderson, S.F., Hewett,
P. C., Foltz, C. B., Fink, H., Brinkmann, W.,
Tr ump er,J.,&Margon,B.1995,ApJ,inpress
Green, P.J.,etal. 1996,inpreparation
Hamann,W.R.,Korista,K.T.,&Morris,S.L.1993,
ApJ, 415,541
Hamman,W.R.,&Ferland,G.J.1993,ApJ,418,11
Hamman,W.R.,Korista,K.T.,&Morris,S.L.1993,
ApJ, 415,541(HKM)
Hamman, W. R.,Zuo, L., & Tytler, D. 1995, ApJ,
444,L69
Hewett, P. C., Foltz, C. B., & Cha ee, F. H. 1995,
AJ,109,1498
Hewitt A.,&Burbidge G.1993,ApJS,87,451
Hines, D. C., & Wills, B. J. 1995, ApJ Letters, in
press
Hutsemekers,D.1993,A&A,280,435
JunkkarinenV. T., Hewitt A., &Burbidge G. 1991,
ApJS,77,203
Junkkarinen, V. T., Barlow, T. A., &Cohen, R. D.
1993,BAAS, 25,1445
Korista, K. T., Voit, G. M., Morris, S. L., & Wey-
mann,R.J.1993,ApJS,88,357
Lanzetta, K. M., McMahon, R. G., Wolfe, A. M.,
Turnshek,D.A.,Hazard,C.,&Lu,L.1991ApJS,
77, 1
1993,ApJS,84,109
Laor, A., Fiore, F., Elvis, M., Wilkes, B. J. & Mc-
Dowell,J.C.1994,ApJ,435,611
Low,F.J.,Cutri,R.M.,Kleinmann,S.C.,&Huchra,
J.P.1989,ApJ,340,L1
Marano,B., Zamorani,G.andZitelli,V. 1988,MN-
RAS,232,111
Marshall,H.L.,Avni,Y.,Braccesi,A.,Huchra,J.P.,
Tananbaum,H.,Zamorani,G.,&Zitelli,V.1984,
ApJ,283,50
Mathur,S.1994,ApJ, 431,L75
Mathur, S., Wilkes,B., Elvis, M.,& Fiore, F.1994,
ApJ,434,493
Mathur, S., Elvis, M., & Singh, K. P. 1995, ApJL,
455,L9
Morrison,R.,&McCammon,D.1983,ApJ,270,119
Mukai,K.1993,HEASARCNewsletter, 3,21
Murray,N.,Grossman,S.A.,Chiang,J.,&Voit,M.
1995,ApJ,submitted
Schartel, N.,Walter,R.,Fink,H.H.,&Tr ump er,J.
1995,A&A,submitted
Schmidt,M.&Green,R. F.1986,ApJS,61,305
Smith, L.J. & Penston, M. V. 1988,MNRAS, 235,
551
Sprayb erry,D.,Foltz,C.B.1992,ApJ, 390,39
Stark, A. A.,Gammie,C. F., Wilson, R. W,Ballie,
J., Linke, R. A., Heiles, C., & Hurwitz, M.1992,
ApJS,79,77
Sto cke,J.T., etal. 1992,ApJ, 396,487
Turnshek,D.A.,&Grillmair,C.J.1986,ApJL,310,
1
Turnshek, D. A. 1988, in QSO Absorption Lines:
ProbingtheUniverse,ed. S.C.Blades,D.A.Turn-
shek, andC. A.Norman (Cambridge: Cambridge
UniversityPress),17
Walter,R.&Fink,H.1993,A&A,274,105
Weymann,R.J.et al. 1991,ApJ,373,23(WMFH)
Williams,O.R.etal.,1992,ApJ,389,157
This 2-columnpreprint was preparedwith the AAS L A
T
E X
macrosv3.0.
RAWDATAFORBALQSOSWITHROSATPSPC POINTINGS
N Gal
H c
PSPC O -Axis Exp osure
d
Counts R
ap
Bmag
Name B
a
z b
(10 20
cm 2
) Sequence Dist( 0
) (s) Source Bkg (
00
) Refs
0043+008 17.2 2.141 2.03 rp700377 0.3 10858 <34:0 ... 79.8 2.8 90 1
0059 275 18.0 1.594 1.99 rp700121AO2 0.1 15154 <36:6 ... 104.4 3.2 90 1
rp700121 0.1
0226 104 17.0 2.256 2.59 rp700114 0.4 9517 <36:0 ... 76.0 3.4 90 1
0312 555 21.8 2.710 1.68 wp701036N00 11.5 56213 <54:0 ... 299.5 3.8 75 2
wp701036AO1 11.5
0340 450 18.7 2.004 1.61 rp900495N00 3.7 74784 <60:0 ... 367.40 4.4 75 3
rp150029 3.7
0759+651 14.5 0.148 4.33 wp700258 0.1 8354 <32:4 ... 74.0 1.6 90 4
0932+501 17.1 1.914 1.35 rp400243 10.7 10184 <24:0 ... 53.6 1.7 90 1
rp400244 9.8
rp400245 9.8
1246 057 17.1 2.222 2.10 rp60026 14.7 57591 84.4 15.7 690.1 8.8 45 1
rp60026AO1 14.7
rp60026AO2 14.7
1309 056 17.2 2.212 2.56 rp700376 11.8 12197 <34:9 ... 89.2 2.4 75 1
1413+117 17.0 2.542 1.78 rp700122 0.1 28066 <80:1 ... 576.7 8.0 120 5
1416 129 15.7 0.129 7.20 wp700527 0.3 9109 3440. 61. 177.7 8.0 120 5
1700+518 15.1 0.288 2.67 rp700123 0.2 8196 <26:1 ... 65.1 2.2 90 5
a
B magnitudeincludesBALk -correctionfromSto cke etal. (1992).
b
RedshiftsfromKorista etal. (1993)whenavailable,otherwisefromHewitt &Burbidge (1993).
c
N Gal
H
fromStarket al. (1992)except for0043+008and1416 129fromElvis,Lo ckman,&Wilkes(1989).
d
Summedexp osuretimeofalllistedPSPCsequences.
REFERENCES.|(1)Sto cke et al. 1992(2)Marano,Zamorani,&Zitelli1988;(3)Boyleetal. 1980;(4)Lowetal.
1989;(5)Schmidt&Green 1986
DERIVEDPROPERTIESOFBALQSOSWITHROSATPSPCPOINTINGS
CountRate N
b
H
Name (corrected) l
a
2keV
ox
(z=0) (z=z
em
) error
0043+008 <0.0034 <27.00 >1.89 35 560 230
0059 275 <0.0027 <26.55 >1.83 20 180 100
0226 104 <0.0041 <27.24 >1.83 30 500 220
0312 555 c
<0.0019 <26.70 >1.36 ... ... ...
0340 450 <0.0009 <26.27 >1.90 30 420 140
0759+651 <0.0042 <24.66 >2.13 200 280 50
0932+501 <0.0025 <26.62 >2.00 55 790 380
1246 057 0.0019 26.62 1.98 65 1240 130
1309 056 <0.0032 <27.09 >1.84 30 480 200
1416 129 c
0.3863 26.56 1.40 ... ... ...
1413+117 <0.0029 <27.08 >1.93 40 920 160
1700+518 <0.0034 <25.02 >2.30 250 460 80
a
Mono chromaticluminosityat2keVinergs 1
Hz 1
.
b
Inferred intrinsiccolumndensityinunits10 20
cm 2
.
c
See discussioninx5.
