University of Warwick institutional repository: http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap
A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of Warwick
http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap/4502
This thesis is made available online and is protected by original copyright.
Please scroll down to view the document itself.
#'(*))*+),
-/.
0 + 2143654+78 9
:<;'=?>A@B>
CEDE-EF!GIHHJLK%HM!HONPJRQSPGIT/JAU#VGIH#.WMYX[Z]\^U#_*GI`a
XbMcU+HONPJKEJLdPU#JLJ&MeX
fhg9iPj/gklg?mono;9@bpBgq>rgqs';qt
u
#v9#Pwxzy ,78{|W}~'!,,*h*w{9
!"$#&%(')*
+-,/.01*23$*4𐂬 9
:/0;0(4&*4=<>%(?,/*8606 9
+-8'),/ 9
:/08')64@%6,/860 9 ?
ACB1<6*'EDGFIHC<68J5K?L*8$&0M10646,NBGL8?,OG<&8J5P*860 D
RQ SUTVB`LMcF XWJLHJASPJLVVYQQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q
RQ CPGF!DXW\eHJLK]\&SESPJA\/WIGSPdYQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q
RQ_^ `HONPJAU NPJADEU#GIVHGI`LVaQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q b
RQdc CPHMP`LNE\eVHGI`Z`& PHGF!GIVO\eHGMPSeQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q f
ACB1<6*'hg6FIi16,RB18,7100GXj01# D;D
*Q CPHMP`LNE\eVHGI`\/SESPJA\/WIGSPdhVk9GSEa\/SPK]l,\/WmWMQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q /
*Q S\noIT/J\& E EU#Mc\e`LN]Q[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q 8^
*Q_^ CPGF!DXW\eHGSPd6\ HONPJAUFo\/WV.PVHJAF QQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q c
*Qdc pJLVODXWIHV QQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q 8q
*Q_b r*NPJ&_ GKEHNMeX9HONPJ&JAUU#MPU'KEGIVHU#G-EDPHGIMcSsQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q /
^*Q S/HOU McK DP`LHGIMcS7QQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q Rt
^*Q k?McUF ` X r*NPJZ`& PHGFo\/WrMcDEU CP`A\/WIGSPd3\&U#dcDEF JAS/HVQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ^/
^*Q_^ u,MPFo EDPHO\eHGIMcSE\ WGpJLVODXWIHV"k?McU"r*NPJZT r*C*T Q[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ^/
^*Qdc r*NPJ GF GHGSPd]u \eVJ Q[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ^R^
^*Q_b S M/HJLV*MPSh\ WId/McU GHNEFBFo XWIJAF!JAS^HO\eHGMPS QQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ^Rb
^*Q_t u,MPSP`WDPVGMPS QQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ^Rt
^*Q_q \& E EJASPKEG QZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ^Rq
ACB1<6*' FIHC? !"$*4 HC<&8j5K?L*8$&0
cQ S/HOU McK DP`LHGIMcS7QQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ^Rf
cQ QSP`LJAU#HO\eGS^H#.QQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q cc
cQ_^ r*NPJ&M^GW JWKhF!MPKEJW QQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q c ^
cQdc pJLVODXWIHV"QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q c t
cQ_b u,MPSP`WDPVGMPSPV QQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q bE
ACB1<6*'6F- %6860=j5K$*4*#;#G') #;*8$&0
b*Q S/HOU McK DP`LHGIMcS7QQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q bR^
b*Q ` 1V W\eHHGI`LJ!SPM/GIVJRU#JLK DP`LJLK%KEGqDPVGMPS-WIGF!GIHJLKh\ed/dcU#JLdP\eHGIMcS QQZQQQZQQ[Q tR^
b*Q_^ pJW\eHGIMcS<HMoHNPJF!JLHONPMPK QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q tRq
b*Qdc u,MPUU#JL`LHGIMcS<HM!V`A\ WGSPdJE EMcSPJAS^HV QZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q qE
b*Q_b pJLVODXWIHV QQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q qRb
b*Q_t u,MPSP`WDPVGMPS QQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q qRf
ACB1<6*'6F 01G'N57?*8601064!- + j0" #
t*Q S/HOU McK DP`LHGIMcS HMoU#JASPMcUF \/WIGV\eHGIMcS QZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q f/
t*Q $2JA\eVODEU JAF!JAS/HV MYX[HONPJ%"PJLK M/GS/H&SPM/GIVJ!U#JLK DP`LHGIMcS-QQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q f/c
t*Q_^ &' JL`LHGT^JSPM/GIVJRU#JLK DP`LHGMPS QQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q fRq
t*Qdc (1\ `WDPVHJAU#VdcU#Me_S GS]^)( Q[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q *E
t*Q_b u,MPUU#JL`LHGIMcS<HM!V`A\ WGSPdJE EMcSPJAS^HV*GSO^)( QQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q */
t*Q_t k9GPJLK EM^GS^HSPM/GIVJ!U#JLK DP`LHGIMcS GSO^)(YQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q */c
t*Q_q SDEF!-EJAU,MeX'\/UF V*GS]^)( QQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q *Rf
q*Q CPHMP`LNE\eVHGI`\/SESPJA\/WIGSPd QZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q AR^
q*Q T+U#Mc-E\/-PGmWIGIVHGI`!HOU\ T/JWmWIGSPd<VO\/WIJLVOF \/S EU#Mc-XWIJAF QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q A/c
q*Q_^ `GmW JWIK2Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGMPS QZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q A/c
q*Qdc S M/GIVJU#JLK DP`LHGIMcS%GS ((\ QQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ARb
q*Q_b u,MPUU#JL`LHGIMcS<HM!V`A\ WGSPdJE EMcSPJAS^HV QZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ARb
q*Q_t pJASPMcUFo\ WGIVO\YHGIMcS<MeX (1\ QQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ARt
*Q r*NPJ Mc PHGFo\/WE`LNPM/GI`LJMYXHONPJ\Y`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJ& EU#Mc-E\/-PGmWIGIH . X McU JAUU#McU9VGFaV
XWIJKEGIVHU#G-EDPHGIMcSPV8QQQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q 8f
*Q `& PHGFo\ W \e`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJ!UDXWIJLV*XbMcU,-PGF!MPK \/W KEGIVHU#G-EDPHGIMcSPV8Q6Q[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q E
RQ r*NPJUW\/DE-EJAU\/SPK $2JLHOU#Mc MRWIGIV \e`L`LJA PH\/SP`LJ&XBDESP`LHGIMcSPV8Q Q[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q c
RQ JLHHGSPdoVHODP`La GS%\IWIMc`A\ W F!GSPGFRDEFEQ QZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q q
*Q r*NPJ EU GSP`LG XWIJW-JANPGSPK2VHMc`LNE\eVHGI`!\/SESPJA\/WIGSPdQQQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q 8^
*Q \ VOaeJLH`LN<MeX9HONPJF!MPKEG JLK&\/DPVVG\/S<KEGIVHU#G-EDPHGIMcS1Q]QQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q /
*Q_^ \VaeJLH`LNhMeXHONPJWHNPJAUFo\/W,\e`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJlUDXWIJ<XbMcU HONPJF!McKEG JLK \/DPVVG\^S
KEGIVHOU G-EDPHGMPS1Q QQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q /
^*Q r+.E PG`A\ W SPJA\/U,Mc PHGF \/W \o EU#GIMcU G \/SPKl EUDESPJLK7Tr*C*T HMcDEU#V8QQQZQQQZQQ[Q Rf
^*Q r*NPJ9JE EJL`LHJLKR EUDESPJLK!HMcDEU;WIJASPd/HONKEGITcGIKEJLKo-/.HONPJ+J JL`LHJLKRU#J VBMP PHGF!GIVJLK
HMPDEUWIJASPd/HN QQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q *
^*Q_^ r*NPJ,Fo\eVHJAU `ADEU T/J9XbMcUHONPJ, EUDESPJLKHMcDEU1WIJASPd/HON KEGITcGIKEJLKo-^. EUDESPJLK
6QZ^/
^*Qdc r*NPJ,Fo\eVHJAU `ADEU T/J9XbMcUHONPJ,\* EU#GIMcU#GPHMcDEU(WJASPd^HON&KEGITPGKEJLK<-/.
\o EU#GIMcU G Q^R^
^*Q_b CENPGXbH&XB\e`LHMcU#V XbMcU&\ EU#GIMcU#G9HMPDEU#V`LMPFo E\/U#JLKhHMWHONPJ J DPGITr\ WJAS^HoF!JA\eVODEU J V
F!JAS^H*MeXco`LGIH .HMcDEU#V8Q QZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ^/c
^*Q_t $2JLHONPMPK!XbMcU9Mc-PH\eGSPGSPd!JLVHGF \eHJLV'MYX HNPJ*`NE\^SPd/J*GSoHNPJJE EJL`LHJLK EUDESPJLK
HMPDEUWIJASPd/HN QQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ^Rb
^*Q_q r*NPJ!JE EJL`LHJLK EUDESPJLKhHMcDEU WIJASPd/HON%XbMcU\/SESPJA\/WIGSPd/V_NPJASo\/SPK
\/U J
GSP`AU#JA\eVJLK F!McSPM^HMcSPGI`A\/WmWI.RQ3QQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q ^Rt
cQ r*NPJ&H#.E PGI`A\/WVJLHODE 6XMPU \ j^)( +VJLGIVOF!GI`!VODEU#T/JL.RQOQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q cc
cQ r*NPJ EU G`LJ MeX9`AUDPKEJM/GmW GS/-E\/UU#JW+X U McF *Rq/c!HMW^//*QOQQZQQQZQQ[Q cc
cQ_^ k@WIMe_ KEG\YdcU\/FVNPMr_ GSPd<HONPJ EU#MP`LJLVV*MYX[Mc PHGF GV\eHGIMcS Q[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q c ^
cQdc \ H#. PGI`A\/W EU McK DP`LHGIMcS%U\eHJXbMcU,\oU#JLVJAU#T/M/GUQ6Q[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q cRc
SPJA\/WIGSPdQ QQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q c q
cQ_q r*NPJ&`LMPS dcDEU\eHGIMcS MeX HONPJ!-E\eVJ&`A\eVJRQ]QZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q c f
cQ_f r*NPJ`LMcS dcDEU\eHGIMcS MeX HONPJ& EMRWIGI`L.`LNPM/VJAS<-/.<Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGMPSo_NPJAS<HNPJVG! LJ
MeX JA\e`N%U#JLVJAU#T^M/GU,GIV\eVVODEF JLKlHMo-EJ!acSPMe_S1Q QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q c *
cQ* r*NPJ&`LMPS dcDEU\eHGIMcS MeX9HONPJ EMRWIGI`L.l`LNPM/VJAS%-/.<VHMP`LNE\eVHGI`R\^SESPJA\/WIGSPd_NPJAS
\o JASE\/WIH#.WGIVd/GIT/JASGX \!U#JLVJAU#T^M/GU,HMW-JKEJLT/JWIMc JLK GIV*JAF PH.RQQQQZQQ[Q b/
b*Q & \/F XWJLV MeX[KEG DPVGIMcSOWIGF!GIHJLK2dcU#Me_*HON!GS%U#JA\/WV.PVHJAF V8Q QQQZQQQZQQ[Q b/c
b*Q r*NPJ&`LMPFo EDPHO\eHGIMcSE\ W F!JLHONPMPK<XMPU (1\ McSNV W\eHHGI`LJRQKQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q bRt
b*Q_^ \ VOFo\/WmW ((\`WDPVHJAU dcU#Me_S McSNVW\eHHG`LJRQ QQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q bRq
b*Qdc CPGIJAU PGSPVOa^GV&dc\eVOaYJLH8Q-QQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q bRf
b*Q_b \ SPM/GIVJRU JLK DP`LJLK (1\ `WDPVHJAUdcU#Me_S<McSNV W\eHHG`LJRQ QQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q tE
b*Q_t \SPM/GIVJ V U#JLK DP`LJLK (1\ `WDPVHJAU[b)VbXbMRWIKz\^SPGVM/HOU#Mc ^. `LMcS^HO\eGSPJLKh_*GIHONPGS2GIHV
JAS^T/MRWIMc JRQ QZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q t/
b*Q_q r*NPJSPM^GVJ V U#JLK DP`LJLK (1\ \/WId/McU#GIHONEFEQ]QZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q t/c
b*Q_f & \/F XWJSPM^GVJRU#JLK DP`LJLK2M)1V W\eHHGI`LJ (1\ `WDPVHJAU#VsQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q tRb
b*Q* r*NPJF JA\eVODEU#JLK XU\Y`LHO\/W KEGF!JASPVGMPSlMYX'(1\ GSl)( QQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q tRt
b*QA=r*NPJU JW\YHGIT/JR JASPJLHOU\eHGIMcS KEJA PHON \YV\ XBDESP`LHGIMcSMeX8Q QQZQQ[Q tRq
b*Q/ r*NPJ EU GF GHGT^J F \/ XMPU'HNPJ %hF!JLHONPMPK6Q QQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q tRf
b*QA=r*NPJ EJASPJLHOU\YHGIMcSoKEJA PHN XMcU %%`WDPVHJAU#V*\/SPKSPM/GIVJ&U#JLK DP`LJLK (1\ `WDPVHJAU#V8QIt *
b*Q8^ \ ENE\eVJ&VO E\Y`LJR XWIM/H*MeX9HONPJ&KEG EMNWJo Mr_,JAU \edc\YGSPVH*HONPJU#JW\eHGIT/J! EJASNV
JLHOU\eHGIMcS<KEJA PHON
QOQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q q/c
b*Qc(&GJAU#JAS^HG \/W XWIM/H,XbMcU,HONPJU JW\YHGIT/JR JASPJLHOU\eHGIMcS<KEJA PHN
Q QQQZQQ[Q qRt
b*Q8b (&GJAU#JAS^HG\/W* XWM^HV!XbMcU!HONPJU#VH!XbMcDEU bSPMcSNVBHU#GITcG\/W<FRDXWIHG MRWIJzF McF!JAS^HV
QCQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q qRq
b*Q8t=r*NPJ `LMcUU#JL`LHGIMcSzHMV`A\/WIGSPd2J McSPJAS/HV&XbMcUHONPJWF!DXWIHG EMRWIJ EMe_,JAU#V
*\/SPKHONPJ!U#JW\eHGIT/JR JASPJLHOU\eHGMPS<KEJA PHON1Q Q[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q qRf
b*Q8q=r*NPJ2\eV.EFo PHM/HG`%Tr\/WDPJLV XMcU HONPJhFRDXWIHG MRWIJ]F!McF!JAS^HV "!
#
o_NPJAS SPMcU V
Fo\ WGIVJLK2-/.
#
Q6QQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q q *
t*Q \ VGFo XWIJoU#JASPMcUFo\ WGIVO\YHGIMcS<V`LNPJAF!JRQ"QQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q fE
U\YKEGDPV)QZQQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q fRq
t*Qdc '
\edc\eGSPVH QXQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q fRf
t*Q_b u,MPFo E\e`LH,dcU#Me_*HON MeX9H#_ MoSPJLGIdcNP-EMcDEU GSPdl\^UF!V8Q QQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q f *
t*Q_t r*NPJo M/GS/H `LMcUU#JW\eHGIMcS XDESP`LHGIMcS FRDXWIHG XWIGIJLK -/.2\/S%J JL`LHGIT/JWSPM/GIVJWU J V
K DP`LHGIMcS QKQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q */
t*Q_q Me_4HNPJZWIJASPd/HON<MeX'-EU\/SP`LNPJLV&\/U#J&`A\/WI`ADXW\eHJLK6QQQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q *E
t*Q_f r*NPJ-EU\/SP`N KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS1QQQ[QQQZQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q */
t*Q* \ ^)( (1\ `WDPVHJAU _*GIHON A\/SPK RQ*QZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q *R^
t*QA=r*NPJF JA\eVODEU#JLK XU\Y`LHO\/W KEGF!JASPVGMPSlMYX[`WDPVHJAU VdcU Mr_SoGS]^ (CQ@QZQQQZQQ[Q */c
t*Q/(&GJAU#JAS^HG \/W XWIM/H*MeX
XbMcU,`WDPVHJAU#VdcU#Me_S GS]^)(CQ7QQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q *Rb
t*QA (&GJAU#JAS^HG\/W* XWM^HV!XbMcU!HONPJU#VH!XbMcDEU bSPMcSNVBHU#GITcG\/W<FRDXWIHG MRWIJzF McF!JAS^HV
+X MPU'`WDPVHJAU#VdPU#Me_SoGSO^)(CQCQZQQQ[QQQZQQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q *Rt
t*Q8^ (&GJAU#JAS^HG\/W XWIM/H*MeX
XMcU`WDPVHJAU#VdcU#Me_S GSO^)(CQ6QQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q *Rq
t*QcMr*NPJ&`LMPUU#JL`LHGIMcS HM!V`A\/WIGSPdWJE EMcSPJAS^HV&F!JA\eVODEU JLK<X McU ^)( (1\ `WDPVHJAU#V8QQ *Rf
t*Q8b=r*NPJ EM/GS^H`LMcUU#JW\eHGIMcS XBDESP`LHGIMcS<XbMcU,`WDPVHJAU VdcU Mr_SoGS]^ KEGF JASPVGIMcSPV8Q1Q * *
t*Q8t=r*NPJ-EU\/SP`N KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS6X McU`WDPVHJAU#VdcU#Me_S GSO^!KEGF!JASPVGIMcSPV8Q QQZQQ[Q A/
t*Q8q=r*NPJU JW\YHGIT/JTe\/U#G\/-PGmWIGH#.%MeX'
GSl)( \/SPK%GSO^)(CQYQQ[QQQZQQQZQQ[Q AE
9_,McDXWIKhWIGaYJHM!HONE\/SEa pMc-PGShl,\/WmWXMPU NPGIV E\YHGIJASP`LJ&GS<KEGU#JL`LHGSPdF!JHONEU#McDPdPNoHONPGIV*VFo\/WmW
\/U#JA\ MeX[ EN^.cVGI`LV8Q
'\e`LaPSPMr_ WJLKEd^JJASCE\/SPKEJAU\/SPK &@WmW\/a<CPMcF XB\eG?XMcU+`LMRWmW\/-McU\eHGIMcS GSHONPJ&_,McUa MeX
`LNE\/ PHJAU"b*Q r*NPJLGU,GSE EDPH&GS HONPGIV\/U#JA\ _\YVF M/VH,XBUDPGIH#XBDXW Q
*_,McDXWIKKWIGaeJ<HMHONE\/SEa2CPHJLT^J McMPKE_*GS @T JLHJAU GSPdh\/SPK l+Mc-hCEF!GIHON XMcUHNPJLGU
NPJW _*GIHON HONPJ&_,McUa MeX `LNE\/ PHJAU c;Q
E_*GIVONHM*JE EU#JLVV HONE\/SEa^VHM,JLT/JAU#.^McSPJ'_NPMNE\eV NPJW EJLKoF!J+GS F .VHDPKEGJLV)Q JLMcU#d/J
pMr_ W\^SPKEV_NPM/VJ,\eVVGIVH\/SP`LJ'GS!\/WmWcHNPGSPd^V[Fo\YHONPJAFo\eHGI`A\/WPNE\eV[-JLJAS TcGIHO\/W / E\/U HGI`ADXW\^U WI.XbMcU
GSE EDPH&GSl`LNE\/ PHJAU*Q pMPKEKE.'\/SES2\/SPK/GF \edPDPJ&XbMcU*\eKETPGI`LJRMPS`LMcFo EDPHGSPdFo\eHHJAU#V8Q
$h\/UaCl,\/UU#Me_ XbMcU*NPGIV&\eVVGIVH\/SP`LJ&GS dcDEU#J! EU#JA E\/U\YHGIMcS\/SPKlFo\/S^.<M/HONPJAU*\/UJA\eV8Q
r*NE\/SEa ./McD HMl T \/SPKHONPJ &T+CXp u XbMcUSE\/SP`LG\/W VODE E EMPU#H2K DEU#GSPd4F . VHODNV
KEJAS^HVONPG 1Q
k9GSE\/WmW. _*\/S^H HM&HONE\/SEa F.WIMeTPGSPd _*GXJ PCED1Q *JAUWIMeT/J*\/SPKo E\eHGIJASP`LJ&NE\AT^J -EJLJAS
\eH,HGF!JLV HONPJ&McSXWI.HONPGSPdoHONE\eH*NE\eVaeJA PHF!J&d/M^GSPd;Q l+JANPGSPKlJLT/JAU#.<VODP`L`LJLVV XDXW F \/S<GIV\
r*NPJXbMRWmWIMr_ GSPd<VJL`LHGIMcSPVMeX9HONPGIV*HONPJLVGIV&\/U#J&GS^HJASPKEJLK%XMcU, EDE-XWIGI`A\eHGIMcS1Q
u*NE\/ PHJAU CPHMc`LNE\eVHG`!\/SESPJA\/WIGSPd 1pMc-PGS]uQ1l,\/WmW' S*JLGmWmW &"Q1l+Me_"WIJAU GrqMW-J
VODE-EF!GIHHJLKlHMCT'N^.PVGI`A\/W pJLTPGJL_ JLHHJAU#V ``LHMc-JAU*//ENQ
u*NE\/ PHJAU[^ u*NE\/U\Y`LHJAU#G! A\eHGIMcS2MYXHNPJ6 EU#MP-E\/-PGmWGIVHG`%HOU\ T/JWIGSPdlVO\ WJLVFo\/S EU#Mc-NV
WIJAF S JLGmWmW&"Ql'Me_"WIJAU r*NPMcFo\eV $ Q6k9GSEa pMc-PGS uQl,\/WmW ,CEDE-EF!GIHHJLK HM T'N^.PVGI`A\/W
pJLTcGIJL_ & //ENQ
u*NE\/ PHJAU[c `GmW JWIK Mc PHGF!G! A\eHGMPS DESPKEJAU<DESP`LJAU#HO\eGS^H . S*JLGmWmW &"Ql+Me_"WIJAU
pMc-PGS-uQl,\/WmW Sl EU#JA E\/U\eHGIMcS /^ERQ
u*NE\/ PHJAUUb ` 1V W\eHHGI`LJoSPM/GIVJWU JLK DP`LHGIMcSh\/SPK2HONPJoDXWIHGFo\eHJ!V`A\ WGSPd%MeX (1\ GS
H#_,M*KEGF!JASPVGIMcSPV /pMc-PGSIuQ8l,\/WmW RS*JLGmWmW & Q8l+Me_"WIJAU JLMcSE\/U#K $ QACE\/SPKEJAU &>WW\/a CPMcF XB\eG
CEDE-EF!GIHHJLK%HM3T+N/.PVGI`A\/W6pJLTcGIJL_ JLHHJAU#V ?//ERQ
u*NE\/ PHJAUt S M/GIVJoU#JLK DP`LHGIMcSh\^SPKhHONPJ "cJLK EM/GS^H&MeX (1\ GSK^<KEGF!JASPVGIMcSPV
r*NPGIV'HONPJLVGV XMP`ADPVJLV9McS HONPJ*U#MRWIJ XW\ ./JLKW-^."$DP`LHODE\eHGMPSPV'GSo-EM^HON!HONPJAUF \/WcMP PHGF!G_V
VO\eHGMPS<HJL`NESPG!EDPJLV \^SPKKEG DPVGIMcSEWIGF GHJLKz\Yd/dcU#JLdc\YHGIMcS1Q@r*NPJaeJL.<GKEJA\ GIV*HONE\eH*-^.WHDESPGSPd
HONPJ"WIJLT/JWMeXGSE EDPH*SPM/GIVJ&\eV.EFo PHM/HGI`U JLVODXWIHV Fo\ .o-EJ&\eHH\eGSPJLKWF!McU#JU\/ PGIK*WI.RQ CPHMP`LNE\eVHGI`
Mc PHGF!GIVO\YHGIMcSo EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V'\^U#J,`LMcSPVGIKEJAU#JLK /_NPJAU#J*HONPJ+XBDESP`LHGIMcS!-EJLGSPd!Mc PHGF!GIVJLKo`A\/SESPM^H[-J
aPSPMr_S!J \Y`LH WI. \^SPKWFo\ .!McSXWI. -JJLVHGFo\eHJLK6Q@r*NPJ&SPM/GIVJ*GS HONPJ*JLVHGFo\YHJLV'GIV*DPVJLKW\eV+HONPJ
\/SE\/WIM/dPDPJ MYXHONPJAUF \/W $DP`LHDE\eHGIMcSPV9GS!VGF!DXW\eHJLKW\/SESPJA\ WGSPdQ r*NPGIV \/SE\/WIM/d^.GIV'Fo\eKEJ,JE\e`LH
-^.RDPVJ*MYX \/S!\e`L`LJA PHO\^SP`LJ,XDESP`LHGMPS c\/SPKoVHMc`LNE\eVHG`*\/SESPJA\ WGSPd!GIV'VJLJAS HM -J*HONPJ*d^JASPJAU\/WIG_V
VO\eHGMPSMYXVGF!DXW\eHJLKo\/SESPJA\/WIGSPd!HMVHMc`LNE\eVHG`,Mc PHGF GV\eHGIMcSo EU#MP-XWJAF V8Q@r*NPJ EU#Mc-E\^-PGWIGIVHGI`
HOU\ T/JWmWIGSPdVO\/WIJLVOFo\^Sl EU#Mc-XWIJAFjT r*C*T GV&DPVJLKh\eV&\!HJLVH V -EJLK%XMPU,VHMP`NE\YVHGI`R\/SESPJA\ WGSPd
\/SPK!VGIdcSPG `A\/S^H'SPJL_ U#JLVODXWIHV'\/U J9XbMcDESPK6Q\ d/MPMcK `NE\^U\e`LHJAU#GIVO\YHGIMcS GV XbMcDESPK XbMcUHONPJ"Tr C*T
\/SPK!V`A\/WIGSPdo\/U#dcDEF JAS/HV9\/U#J,VONPMe_S HM&-EJ\e`L`ADEU\eHJ+XbMcU KEJLHJAUF GSPGSPd!HONPJ,JE EJL`LHJLKCWIJASPd/HN
MeX*HONPJW EUDESPJLK \/SPK]\2 EU#GIMcU#G+HMcDEU#V qVO EJL`LG `A\/WmWI. EUDESPJLK
EUDESPJLK
6Q-\&S
M/GmW JWIK EU#MJL`LH P\eV*\ `LMcFo XWIJW`LMPFoF!JAU#`LG\/W EU#Mc-XWIJAF GV `LMcSPVGIKEJAU#JLKl\/SPKVHMc`LNE\eVHGI`&\/SNV
SPJA\/WIGSPdGIV*VJLJASHMWFo\/aeJ&\IW\/U#d^J&GF EU#MeT/JAF!JAS^H*GSHONPJ J JL`LHJLK U#JLHDEUS<MeX9HONPJ EU#M#JL`LH8Q
S*M^GVJU JLK DP`LHGIMcS!GS KEG DPVGIMcS WGF!GIHJLK\ed/dPU#JLdc\eHGIMcS (1\ qGIV aPSPMe_S&HM&-EJ `AUDP`LG\/W
HM<McDEU&DESPKEJAU#VH\/SPKEGSPdQ\ d^JASPJAU\/WIGIVO\eHGIMcS2MYX SPM/GIVJoU#JLK DP`LHGIMcS2M)1V W\eHHG`LJ!GIV&GS/HU#McK DP`LJLK
\/SPK SPM/GIVJU#JLK DP`LHGIMcSGIV!VONPMe_S2HM2-EJl\`LJAS^HOU\ W E\/U\^F!JLHJAU&`LMPS/HOU MRWmWGSPd2HONPJ<dcU#Me_*HON%MeX
(1\IQ BS ,KEGF!JASPVGIMcSPV /\ WW DE\/S^HGIHGIJLV9\/ E EJA\/UqHM*-EJ+GS $DPJASP`LJLKW-/.HONPJ9V WIMe_,JLVH`LMcUU#JL`LHGIMcS
HM<V`A\/WIGSPd _*GIHON%JE EMcSPJAS^H ^*Q%BS7^ KEGF JASPVGIMcSPV VMcF!J DE\^S/HGIHGIJLV\/UJRSPM/H&\ JL`LHJLK
-^.RHNPJ*V WIMe_ JLVH'`LMcUU JL`LHGIMcS!HM V`A\/WIGSPd PJ McSPJAS/H *Q r NPJ U#JASPMPUFo\/WIGIVO\eHGIMcS MeX (1\ GV
`LMcSPVGIKEJAU#JLK ?\/SPKWHNPJSPM/GIVJU#JLK DP`LHGIMcS<\eH+HONPJ"PJLK EM/GS^H GIV*F!JA\eVDEU#JLK6Q@r*NPJ SPM^GVJ cd^GT^JAS
\eV*HNPJU#JW\eHGIT/JTe\/U#G\/-PGmWIGIH .%GSlJPHOU#JAF \/W`WDPVHJAUU\eKEGDPVGIV XMcDESPKHMW-EJ
/R^!\/SPK
S M/GIVJGIV\/S<GFo McU#HO\/S^H\eV EJL`LHMeX EN/.PVGI`LV ?`AU#JA\eHGSPd<GFo EU#JL`LGIVGIMcS2GSlF JA\eVODEU#JAF!JAS^HV&\/SPK
Mc-PV`ADEU GSPd2DESPKEJAU WI.cGSPd2HOU#JASPKEV)QCr*NPGIVHONPJLVGIV J \/F GSPJLV HONPJoU#MRWIJoMeX*SPM/GIVJoGS2H#_,M6\^U#JA\eVUV
Mc PHGF!GIVO\YHGIMcS2\/SPK2KEG DPVGIMcSOWIGF!GIHJLK \ed/dcU#JLdP\eHGIMcS1QBU McSPGI`A\/WmW. HONPJIW\eHHJAU*MeX'HNPJLVJoU#JWIGJLV
McS<HONPJ EU JLVJASP`LJ!MeX[SPM/GIVJXMcUHONPJ\/ E EJA\^U\/SP`LJMYX[HONPJ ENPJASPMPF!JASPMcS1Q
BS Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGMPS SPM^GVJ*GIV\^S!GFo EMcU HO\/S^H9XbJA\eHODEU#J*HMJASPVODEU#JHONE\eH'\^S!Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGMPS
SPKEV&HONPJ dRWIMc-E\/WMc PHGF!DEF-QX'_,JR\/U#J&MPSl\<UDPd/d/JLK%HJAUU\eGS F MrTPGSPdWMPSXW.%KEMe_SENPGmWW _,J
Fo\ .h-EJL`LMcF JVHODP`LalGS \ WIMc`A\/WhF!GSPGF!DEF DESE\^-XWJHM SPKHONPJWHUDPJ3WIMe_,JLVHR M/GS/H!MeX
HONPJCW\/SPKEV`A\/ EJRQ*Me_,JLT/JAU GX*_,JRVMcF!JLHGF!JLV!F!MeT/JRDE ENPGmWmW 'HONPJASz_ JoFo\ .2\AT^M/GIK d^JLHHGSPd
VHODP`La<\/SPK SPK dRWIMc-E\ W<F!GSPGF!DEF-QUr*NPGIV \Y`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJMYX DE ENPGmWmW F!MeT/JLV*Fo\^SPGXbJLVHVGIHVJWX
\eV*HNPJAUFo\/W$DP`LHODE\eHGMPSPVGSVGF!DXW\eHJLK2\/SESPJA\/WIGSPdQ
(&GqDPVGMPSZWIGF!GIHJLK\ed/dcU JLdc\eHGIMcS (1\ GIV \F!MPKEJWEMeX \/ XW\e`LG\/S dcU#Me_*HN1Q U#Me_*HON
MeX'VOF McM/HNMc- #JL`LHVGS \ q\/ XW\e`LG\/S JWIKhGIVDESPVHO\/-XWIJo\/SPK2HONPJX U\Y`LHO\/W9 E\eHHJAUSPVMeX (1\
\/U#JHNPJlU#JLVODXWIHWMYX HONPGIV<GSPVHO\/-PGmWIGIH.RQ r NPJVHO\/SPK \/U K GF XWJAF JAS/HO\YHGIMcS MeX(1\GIVSPM/GIV.
\/SPK2\!_*\A.<MeX'U#JLK DP`LGSPdHONPJGS $DPJASP`LJ!MeX SPM/GIVJ!NE\eV-JLJASl`LJAS^HOU\ WHMoHONPJ!DESPKEJAU#VHO\^SPKEGSPd
MeX'GIHV&JLT/JAS^HODE\/W9-EJANE\ TPGIMcDEUGS7W\eHHGI`LJ V -E\eVJLKF!McKEJWIV8QZ NE\eH&NE\/ E EJASPV _NPJAS%HONPJAU#J!GIVSPM
DESPKEJAU WI.PGSPdhW\eHHGI`LJNE\eVU#JAFo\eGSPJLK`LMcS^HOU#MeT/JAU#VG\ W PGShW\/U#d/J& E\/U#H*-JL`A\/DPVJR\ VODPGIHO\^-XWJSPM^GVJ
U#JLK DP`LHGIMcS HJL`LNESPGEDPJoNE\ T/J SPM^H-EJLJAS2\ Tr\eGmW\/-XWIJRQ
u*NE\/ PHJAU ,d/GIT/JLV*\/S!GS^HOU#MPK DP`LHGIMcSoHM&Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGIMcS<\/SPK<VHMP`NE\YVHGI`*Mc PHGF!GIVO\YHGIMcS1Q
ZhJ`LMcSPVGIKEJAU+HONPJ&DPVJ*MeX NPJADEU#GIVHGI`LV \/ E EU#M)cGFo\YHJF!JLHONPMPKEV HMVMNWT^J NE\/U KoMc PHGF!GIVO\eHGMPS
EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V)QCPHMc`LNE\eVHG`2Mc PHGF GV\eHGIMcS EU#MP-XWJAF V \/U#J2GS^HOU#MPK DP`LJLK &GS _NPGI`LN HONPJ2JE\e`LH
Tr\ WDPJ MeX HONPJ XBDESP`LHGIMcSh-JLGSPd2Mc PHGF GVJLKhGIVRSPM/H&acSPMe_ JE\e`LH WI. \^SPK]F!DPVH -JoJLVHGFo\YHJLK
\/SPKl EU#JLTPGIMcDPVVMRWDPHGIMcSlF JLHONPMcKEV&\/U#JU JLTcGIJL_,JLK6Q
u*NE\/ PHJAU GV&`LJAS^HOU#JLK2\/U#McDESPKh\< E\/U#HGI`ADXW\/UVHMc`LNE\eVHGI` Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGIMcS%HJL`LNESPG! DPJ
\/SESPJA\/WIGSPdQ r*NPGIV<GIVW\e`LNPGJLT^JLK-^.`NPMPM/VGSPd \/S \e`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJ XDESP`LHGMPS *\/SPK HONPJl\^ E EU#M/V
EU#G\eHJo\e`L`LJA PH\/SP`LJ XDESP`LHGIMcSzGVXbMcDESPK2XbMcU\WSPDEF!-EJAUMeX,KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcSPV MeX HONPJ!JLVHGF \eHJLV8Q
JASP`LJ EVHMP`NE\YVHGI` \^SESPJA\/WIGSPd GV HO\/aeJAS!HMR-EJ&HNPJd/JASPJAU\/WIGV\eHGIMcS<MeX VGF!DXW\eHJLKl\^SESPJA\/WIGSPd
HMoVHMc`LNE\eVHG`&MP PHGF!GIVO\eHGIMcS% EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V8Q
u*NE\/ PHJAU V ^ co\/U#J&`LMPSP`LJAUSPJLK_*GIHON<H#_,MR\/ E XWIGI`A\eHGIMcSPVMeX9VHMP`NE\eVHGI` \/SESPJA\ WGSPdQ
r*NPJ& EU#Mc-E\/-PGmWIGIVHGI`HU\ T/JWmWGSPd!VO\/WIJLVOF \/SW EU Mc-XWIJAF GIV*\F McKEJWMeX \e`A\eKEJAF G`Tr\ WDPJ&_NPG`LN GV
aPSPMr_S<HM6-JRNE\/U K PXMPU*_NPGI`LNl\ d/MPMcK`LNE\/U\e`LHJAU#GIVO\eHGIMcS GV& EU#MeTPGKEJLK6Q"`GmW JWIKh EU#M#JL`LHV
\/U#J2`LMcF XWJ EU#MJL`LHV_NPGI`N EU MrTPGIKEJ]\KEJAF!McSPVHOU\eHGIMcS MeX!HONPJ]DPHGmWIGIH#.4MYXRVHMP`LNE\eVHGI`
\/SESPJA\/WIGSPdGSl\ `LMcFoF JAU#`LG\/WVJLHHGSPd;Q
u*NE\/ PHJAU V b t!`LMcSP`LJAS^HOU\eHJMcS(1\ \/SPK%HONPJ&GFo EMcU HO\/SP`LJ&MeX'SPM/GIVJU#JLK DP`LHGIMcS1Q
\SPJL_ \/SPK<JW`LGIJAS/H*SPM/GIVJU JLK DP`LHGIMcS<HJL`LNESPGEDPJ&GIV,KEJLV`AU#G-EJLK XMcU M)1VW\eHHGI`LJ%(1\ _NPGI`LN
Fo\ . -EJ\/ E XWIGJLK GS \/S^. KEGF!JASPVGIMcS1Q \V. F PHM/HGI`2Tr\/WDPJLV2\/SPK `LMcUU#JL`LHGIMcSHM]V`A\/WIGSPd
JE EMcSPJAS^HVXbMcU,GIVM/HOU Mc PGI` ((\ \/U#JXMPDESPK6Q r*NPJoU#JASPMcUFo\/WIGIVO\eHGIMcS MeX (1\ GIV&`LMcSPVGKEJAUJLK
\/SPK HONPJ "PJLK EM/GS^H6SPM/GIVJhU#JLK DP`LHGMPS GIV<X MPDESPK ,_NPGI`NWIJA\eKEV<HM]`LMPSPVGIKEJAU\eHGIMcS MeX\/S
J JL`LHGIT/JSPM/GIVJU#JLK DP`LHGIMcS1Qr*NPJ U#VH'JLT^JAU GF XWJAF JAS/HO\YHGIMcSoMYXqSPM^GVJU#JLK DP`LHGIMcS M)1V W\eHHGI`LJ
! #"$%&'(*)+-,/.0123456,/7*8-29:;<=>,?:;.@
23.BAC,/0D0929:<==,?:;%2FE$'G0H7I<+J)<7I8K0L,NM87/7O:=0L'GP
QBR
2TS"%,D2VU+A!T7/7
`& PHGF!GIVO\eHGIMcS Fo\ .6-JoKEJLV`AU#G-EJLK\eVSPKEGSPd%HONPJ!JcHOU JAFo\/WTe\/WDPJoMeX \ X DESP`LHGIMcS1Q
X'MPSPJ`LMcSPVGIKEJAU#V\ VGFo XWIJ X DESP`LHGMPS VO\ . /W XW
HONPJoF!GSPGF!DEF MeX9VODP`LNl\ X DESP`LHGMPS
Fo\ . -EJ%XbMcDESPK T/JAU#. DPGI`LaRWI.RQ *Me_,JLT/JAU ,HONPJ2F!McU#J2`LMcF XWJ HONPJ%X DESP`LHGMPS HONPJ F McU#J
KEGW`ADXWIHWHNPGVo\/SE\ W.PVGIVW-JL`LMcF!JLV ' E\^U#HGI`ADXW\/U WI. GSHONPJW`A\YVJWMYX S T VB`LMcFo XWIJLHJl EU#MP-XWJAF V8Q
kDEU HONPJAUF!McU J /GSoVMcF!J`A\eVJLV'MPSPJ Fo\ .!SPM/H*-EJ&\/-XWIJHM J \Y`LH WI.oJLTr\/WDE\eHJHONPJ XBDESP`LHGIMcS hQ
BS HONPGIV*`LNE\/ PHJAU+HONPJHMc PGI`&MeX S T VB`LMcFo XWIJLHJASPJLVVGIV,GS^HOU#MPK DP`LJLKl\eV*\/U#JVMcF JHJL`LNNV
SPG! DPJLV&_NPG`LNl\^U#J&KEJLVGIdcSPJLK2HMoVMNWT^JZS T VB`LMcFo XWIJLHJR EU Mc-XWIJAF!V8Q*CPHMP`NE\YVHGI`&Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGMPS
GIV*HONPJAS KEJLV`AU#G-EJLK \/SPKHONPJ&VO JL`LG `R`LNE\/WmWIJASPd/JR M/VJLK2-/.oVHMc`LNE\eVHG`&MP PHG F!GIVO\eHGIMcS% EU#Mc-NV
WIJAF!VGV `LMcSPVGIKEJAU#JLK6Q
Y 3 Y 0 [Z/{9&R 9'
\^]_\^]`\ a ;!b?jl@bj%@B>
ZhJFo\ .2`LMcSPVGIKEJAUo E\/U#HGHGMPSPGSPd Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGIMcS EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V GS^HM%H_,M%VJLHV _NPGI`LN_ J _*GmWW
KEJLV`AU#G-J6\eV JA\eV. \/SPK ONE\^U#K Q &'\eV. EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V\^U#J!McSPJLVXMPU_NPGI`N%_,J!`A\/S SPKhHONPJ
VMRWDPHGIMcSzGS \<HGF!JW EMNW.ESPMcF!G\/W+GS2HONPJoVG! LJoMYX HONPJW EU Mc-XWIJAF-Q \^U#Kh EU#Mc-XWIJAF!VR\^U#J!McSPJLV
MeX*HONPJW EU Mc-XWIJAF GjQJRQ<HONPJoHGF JWU#JEDPGU JLK]HMSPKHONPJoVMRWDPHGIMcShdPU#Me_*VJE EMPSPJAS/HG\/WmWI.McU
XB\eVHJAU+_*GIHON HONPJ EU#Mc-XWIJAF VG! LJ Q
S T VB`LMcFo XWIJLHJGIV\^S!GFo EMcU HO\/S^H'`W\eVV+MeX EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V,_NPGI`N<\/U#J 0,/:4. HM!-EJ&NE\/U#K
VJLJE E`LNE\/ PHJAU%*Q $h\/S^.W`LMcF!-PGSE\eHMPU#G\/WMc PHGF!GIVO\YHGIMcS2 EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V&\/U#JZSUTVB`LMcFo XWIJLHJ
VODP`LN2\eV&HONPJ!HOU\ T/JWmWIGSPdlVO\/WIJLVOF \/S2 EU#Mc-XWIJAFjr*C*T &\/SPKh EU#GF!J!XB\e`LHMcU#GIVO\YHGIMcS1QU\ WIHONPMcDPdPN
HONPJLVJ EU Mc-XWIJAF!V \^U#J-EJWIGIJLT/J!HMW-JRNE\/U#K HONPGIVNE\eVSPJLT/JAU-EJLJAS% EU#MeT/JLK6Q
S T VB`LMcFo XWIJLHJh EU#Mc-XWIJAF!Vl\^U#J SPM/H<HONPJhNE\/U#KEJLVH6 EU#MP-XWJAF Vl EM/VVG-XWIJRQ r*NPJAU#J2\/U#J
EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V!_NPM^VJoVMRWDPHGIMcSU#JEDPGU#JLVR\/S JE EMcSPJAS^HG\/W'HGF JWHM_U#GIHJRQ *Me_,JLT/JAU HONPJ GFaV
EMPU#HO\/SP`LJ!MeX,HONPJo`W\eVV&MeX"S T VB`LMcFo XWIJLHJW EU Mc-XWIJAF!V VGSP`LJ<HONPJL.2\/U#J!VGFo XWIJWHMWVH\eHJo-EDPH
KEGW`ADXWIH&HM!VMRWIT/J EVNPMcDXWIK SPM/H-JRSPJLdRWIJL`LHJLK6Q
\^]_\^] a
;t @bj >@ s*g k/j=bqj+= =mOgkh;'=9k/@B> je@BiE>
r*NPJ*`W\eVV'MeXNE\/U#KW EU#MP-XWJAF V'GIV,GF EMcU#H\/S/H eVGSP`LJGIH'KEJ SPJLV,_NPJAS GH+GIV SPMZWIMcSPd^JAU XbJA\eVG-XWIJ
HM%VJA\/U#`LN%XbMcU&JE\e`LH!VMRWDPHGIMcSPV8QO\UWHNPMcDPdcN GH!GIVo EM/VVG-XWJHM SPK \/ShJE\e`LH VMRWDPHGIMcSHM
\hNE\/U K EU#MP-XWJAF ,HONPJVG! LJlMeXHONPJl EU#Mc-XWIJAF HONE\eHoFo\ .]-EJ%VMRWIT/JLK _*GmWmW&\/WI_\ .PVo-EJT/JAU#.
WIGF!GIHJLK6Q *JASP`LJ\ EMc EDXW\/U \/ E EU#Mc\Y`N2GIV HMVJLH\"PJLKhHGF!J XMcU&\^S \ Wd^McU#GIHONEFHMlUDES
\/SPK2HO\/aYJRHNPJ -JLVHVMRWDPHGIMcS XMcDESPK _*GIHONPGS2HONE\eH&HGF!JRQIr*NPGIVR\^ E EU#Mc\e`LN%GV&MPSXW.2VJASPVG-XWIJ
_*GIHON% EU#Mc-XWIJAF!VXbMcU,_NPGI`LNl\<SPJA\/U VBMc PHGFo\ WVMRWDPHGIMcS%GIV DPVJXDXWjQCPMPF!JR EU#MP-XWJAF V VDP`N%\eV
EU#GF!JXB\e`LHMcU GV\eHGIMcS cU J DPGU#J\/S JE\e`LH'VMNWDPHGMPS \/SPK<GH,GIV,HONPGIVU#JEDPGU#JAF!JAS^H HNE\eH*Fo\/aeJLV
GS/HJAUSPJLHVJL`ADEU#GIH.<VMoKEGW`ADXWIH&HMo-EU#JA\^aQ
BS HONPJ&SPJcH*H#_,M&VJL`LHGIMcSPV _ J `LMcSPVGIKEJAU,VMcF J NPJADEU#GIVHG`LV E`LMcSP`LJAS^HOU\eHGSPd!McS VGF!DNV
W\eHJLKl\/SESPJA\ WGSPd \eV*HNPGVNE\eV-EJLJAS HONPJ&VODE- #JL`LH*MeX9HONPJ&_,McUa EU#JLVJAS^HJLKGSHONPJXbMRWmWIMr_ GSPd
`LNE\/ PHJAU#V8Q
Y 3 & $ ,+!'* )
\&SESPJA\/WIGSPdGIV\o EU Mc`LJLVV&-^._NPGI`N%\oFo\eHJAU G\ W VODP`LNl\eV dRW\eVV GIV NPJA\eHJLKlHMW\ F!McKEJAU\eHJ
HJAFo JAU\eHODEU JHM]U#JAF!MeT/JKEJXbJL`LHVW\^SPK VMeXbHJASHONPJ2Fo\eHJAU G\ W'XbMcU!_,McUa/GSPdQ GUaP E\eHOU G`La
JLH&\/WjQbN^9DPVJLK2HONPGIV EU#Mc`LJLVV \eV GSPV PGU\eHGIMcS%XbMcU*\/S Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGMPSlHJL`NESPG!EDPJ VGFRDXW\eHJLK
\/SESPJA\/WIGSPdQ"`&SPJ `LMcSPVGIKEJAU#V&HONPJ&Mc PHGF GV\eHGIMcS2 EU#Mc-XWIJAF \eV\!HONPJAUFo\/WV.PVHJAF GS J DPGmWIG-NV
U#GDEF\eH&\od^GT^JAS2HJAFo JAU\eHODEU#JRQ X'HONPGIV&V.cVHJAF GIV\/WmWMe_,JLK2HM<`LMcMRW V WIMe_"WI. HONPJAS2\eH LJAU#M
VMRWIT/JLK6Q*CPGF!DXW\eHJLKh\/SESPJA\/WIGSPdlGIV&\W Me_ JAUX DXW ?d/JASPJAU\/WMP PHGF!GIVO\eHGIMcS%HJL`LNESPG! DPJ!HONE\eHNE\eV
XbMcDESPK \/ E XWIGI`A\eHGIMcS GSlFo\/S^. EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V8Q
\^] 6]`\
:<;'=k g 9t *b @BiE> b?kg W;*b?@'>
\V.PVHJAFNPJWIK \eH\"PJLK]HJAF EJAU\eHDEU#J _*GmWmW,Mc`L`ADE ^.h\VHO\YHJ _*GIHON2JASPJAU#d/.
\e`L`LMcU KEGSPd<HM!HONPJ! EU#Mc-E\/-PGmWIGIH .
#RQ
_NPJAU#J
#
GIVHONPJ&GS/T^JAU#VJHJAFo EJAU\YHODEU#J \/SPK"!$# GIV l+MRWIH AF \/SES V`LMcSPVHO\/S^H8Q BS HONPJ
XbMRWmWMe_*GSPd%_ J!`LNPM/VJ!$# XbMcU`LMcS^T/JASPGIJASP`LJRQ!ZhJ!_*GmWmW \eHHJAFo PHHMVGF!DXW\YHJW\ V.cVHJAF
XbMcU,_NPGI`LNHONPJ&VH\eHJLV*\/U#J&`LNPM/VJAS%\e`L`LMcU#KEGSPdoHM HONPGIVUDXWIJRQ
Z NPJASlDPVGSPd $2McS^HJZu*\/U WIMWF JLHONPMcKEV _,J_*\/S^H*HM JW`LGIJAS/H WI.%VO\/Fo XWIJ!HONPJKEGIVHU#G_V
-EDPHGIMcS%MeX'VH\eHJLV*MeX'HNPJV.PVHJAF VMoHONE\YH_,JRF \A.<JLVHGFo\YHJR\ T/JAU\Yd/J DE\^S/HGIHGIJLV VDP`N%\eV
HONPJ&\ T/JAU\ed/J,JASPJAU#d^.oMeXHONPJV.cVHJAF-Q bH+_ MPDXWKSPM/H,-EJ&JW`LGIJAS^H HMR\eHHJAFo PH'HM GFo XWIJAF!JAS/H
J1Q RQ,KEGU#JL`LH W. GSPVHJA\eK<GH+GIV `LMPS/T/JASPGIJAS^H,HMDPVJ&\%$z\^UaeMeTR EU#MP`LJLVV8Q@r*NPJGSPGIHG\/WVHO\eHJ,MeX
HONPJ&V.PVHJAF GIV*`LNPM/VJASU\^SPKEMcFIWI.6\^SPKHONPJ&V.PVHJAF GIVHONPJAS\ WWIMe_,JLKHMoFo\/aeJ&\!HOU\/SPVGIHGIMcS
MeXbHJAS `A\/WmWJLKh\<F!MeT/J XU#MPFMcSPJVHO\eHJ HM6\^SPM/HONPJAU E_ GHN \< EU#Mc-E\^-PGWIGIH#.l_NPGI`LN%KEJA EJASPKEV
McSXWI.McS<HONPJ&VHO\eHJLV,GS/T^MRWIT/JLKlGS%HONPJF!MeT/JRQ
k McU+JA\e`LN<F!MeT/JHNE\eH,_ J& EU#Mc M/VJ E_,J`NPMPM/VJ&HM \Y`L`LJA PH*HONE\eH,F!MeT/J_ GHN\d^GT^JAS
EU#Mc-E\^-PGWIGIH#. &% ',XbMcU*\<F!MeT/JXBU#McF VHO\eHJ(% HMWVHO\eHJ)Q,Z JGFo EM^VJ!HONPJ`LMcUU#JL`LH
JEDPGWIG-EU#GDEFKEGIVHU#G-EDPHGIMcS%TcG\ HONPJ&`LMcSPKEGIHGIMcSMYX[KEJLHO\YGWIJLKh-E\/W\/SP`LJ ?_NPGI`N GIV
&% &% * +% #RQ
& 1QRQGIVHONPJAS<VO\eHGV JLK EU#MeTPGKEJLK
&% ,
-%
. 0/1 #RQ^
_NPJAU#J)2 GIV*HNPJJASPJAU#d/.<KEGJAU#JASP`LJR-JLH _,JLJAS HONPJ&VHO\eHJLV3%\/SPK4%@Q
\^] 6]
=Ejekcgs*g pb@B> b 652p`b 87*=k b?p9 g k/@bj/; >
Z NPGmWVHoJGQ,RQ_^lJASPVDEU#JLVoHONPJAUF \/W'JEDPGmWG-EU#GD?F \eH!GS^T/JAU#VJWHJAF EJAU\eHDEU#J 9GIHoKEMPJLVoSPM/H
XBDXWWI. KEJLHJAUF!GSPJlHONPJ<XbMcUF MYX ZQr*NPGIVWF!JA\/SPVoHNE\eH!HONPJAU#Jl\/U#Jl\ ScDEF!-EJAU MeX KEGJAU#JAS^H
1
0
Metropolis: Min(1,e )
-
β
x
Glauber: 1
1+e
x
β
x
k9GIdcDEU#JoRQ r*NPJUW\/DE-EJAU*\^SPK $ JLHU#Mc EMNWGIV\Y`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJXBDESP`LHGIMcSPV8Q X[_,J&\/U#JVGFRDXW\eHGSPd
\ HONPJAUFo\/WqV.cVHJAF\eH*GS^T/JAU#VJ!HJAF EJAU\eHDEU#J \^SPK F!JA\eVDEU#JHONPJ J JL`LHMeX'\<F!MeT/J&HMW-J
2 HONPJAS _ JFo\ .2`NPMPM/VJ<HMh\e`L`LJA PHoF!MeT/JLV _*GIHON \l EU#MP-E\/-PGmWGIH#. d/GIT/JAS-/. HONPJ6\^-EMeT/J
XBDESP`LHGIMcSPV
W\/U#d/J*\eV9 EM^VVG-XWIJ 9GIV9HM`NPMPM/VJ 2 9XbMcU 2
e_*GIHON \eV VOFo\/WmWE\eV' EM/VVG-XWJRQ
r*NPGIVGV HONPJ$2JLHOU#MP EMRWIGIV\/WId/McUGHNEF \/SPK%GV KEJ SPJLKz-^.
2
XbMcU 2
0/1 XbMcU 2
#RQc
VGSP`LJ!JGQqRQ^!JASPVODEU JLVHONE\YH *Q \ KEG JAU JAS/H`NPM^G`LJ!MeX GIVHMoGSPVGIVH&HONE\eH 2
2 RQr*NPGIVUWJA\YKEVHM!HONPJ W\/DE-JAU*\e`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJ!UDXWIJ d^GT^JASl-^.
2
0/1
#RQb
_NPGI`LN NE\eV!HONPJl-JASPJ HoMeX-EJLGSPd \^SE\/WI.cHGI`RQ l+M/HON\e`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJlUDXWJLV\/U#J<GmWmWDPVHOU\eHJLK GS
dcDEU#JoNQRQ
\^] 6]
:= s*=k8b?j 9kc=h>ei/;+= 9pB= >
X&_,Jl\/ E XWI. HONPJVGF!DXW\eHJLK4\^SESPJA\/WIGSPd \/WId/McU GHNEF '_,JlNPMc JlHM2VGF!DXW\eHJ2\2V.PVHJAF GS
HONPJAUF \/W,J DPGmWIG-EU#GDEFx\eH!VMcF JHJAFo EJAU\eHODEU#JRQZhJ`LMcSPVGKEJAU VHO\/U#HGSPd HONPJV.PVHJAF \eHo\
HJAFo JAU\eHODEU J HONPJ!V.PVHJAF _*GmWmW9Mc`L`ADE ^.lHNPJRdPU#McDESPKlVHO\eHJ McU J DPGITr\ WJAS^H WI.hNE\ T/J!VMRWIT/JLK
HONPJ Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGIMcS2 EU#MP-XWJAF EU#MeTPGIKEJLK _,J!NE\AT^JU#JAFo\eGSPJLK2GSlJEDPGmWIG-EU GD?F-Q Me_ JLT^JAU EHM
VHO\ .GS2JEDPGmWG-EU#GDEF KEMe_S%HM LJAU#MHJAF EJAU\eHDEU#JoU#J DPGU#JLV!\/S%GS SPGHJ6\/F McDES/HMeX,HGF!JRQ
BS6X \Y`LH JAF \/S JAFo\/S _^Rf VONPMe_,JLKHONE\eH*GX'McSPJ Tr\/U#GIJLVHONPJHJAFo EJAU\YHODEU#J\e`L`LMcU KEGSPd
HM
WS
#RQt
_NPJAU#J GIV\`LMPSPVHO\/S^H9_NPGI`N<F!DPVH'-EJ`LNPM/VJAS!HM-J*VOD W`LGIJAS^H WI.CW\/U#d/J ^HONPJAS!HONPJ V.cVHJAF
_*GmWmWMc`L`ADE ^.oHONPJ*dPU#McDESPKoVH\eHJ*_*GIHON EU#Mc-E\/-PGmWIGIH .2 /\eV+HONPJHGF!J*HONEU#MPDPdcN!HONPJ*VGF!DXW\eHGIMcS
MQ
QS^XbMcU#HDESE\eHJWI. EHONPGIV&GIV SPM^HF!DP`N%DPVJ EVGSP`LJ!_,JRSPJLT/JAU*NE\ T/J!\/S<GS SPGIHJW\/F!MPDES/H
MeX*HGF!JRQ7r*NPJAU#JNE\ T/J6-JLJAS \lSPDEF!-EJAU MeX*VODPd/d/JLVHGIMcSPV X McUd/MPMcKV`LNPJLK DXWJLV _NPJASHGF!J
GIV3WIGF!GIHJLK * * @fRb +/ Q $ M^VHoSPM/HO\/-XWIJlGIV<HONPJV`LNPJLK DXWIJ _NPG`LN Fo\eGS^HO\eGSPV\2`LMcSPVHO\^S/H
HONPJAUF McKE.ESE\/F!GI`lV EJLJLK _fRt *Rb Q r*NPJl EU#GSP`LG XWIJhGIV6\2VGF XWJEVGXMcSPJ`A\/SESPM/HoVHO\ .hGS
JEDPGWIG-EU#GDEF McSPJ VONPMcDXWIKh\eHHJAFo PH HMoVHO\ .\eH&\ "cJLK HNPJAUF!MPKE. SE\/F G` KEGIVHO\/SP`LJ XBU#McF
JEDPGWIG-EU#GDEF-QUr*NPGIV WIJA\eKEVHM!HONPJ&VODPd/d^JLVHGIMcSHM DPVJ
$
#RQq
_NPJAU#J \^SPK 8\^U#J*HONPJU JW\ \eHGMPS!HGF!J&\/SPKWNPJA\eH+`A\/ E\e`LGIH#.RMYX HNPJ*V.PVHJAF /U#JLV EJL`LHGIT/JWI.RQ
GIV9HONPJ,HONPJAUF McKE.ESE\/F!GI`,VO EJLJLK P\*`LMPSPVHO\/S^H MPSPJ'`LNPMcM/VJLV HMKEJLHJAUF GSPJ HONPJ'MeT/JAU\ WWPVO JLJLK
MeX HNPJ&`LMcMRWIGSPdQ BS EU#GSP`LG XWIJoHONPGIV*GIV*HONPJ&MP PHG Fo\/WV`LNPJLK DXWJ!HMoDPVJRQ *Me_,JLT/JAU ^GHU#J DPGU#JLV
HONE\eH _ JaPSPMe_ HONPJU#JW\)E\eHGIMcS HGF!J&MeX9HONPJV.cVHJAF _NPG`LNGIV&SPM/H*VGFo XWIJ!HMoF!JA\eVDEU#JRQ
pJLJLV l,\/WmW * 9\/WIVMWDPVJLK2\V`NPJLK DXWIJ!_NPGI`N%DPHGmWIGVJLKhHONPJU#JW\)E\eHGIMcS<HGF!JRQ
BS HONPGIV!HONPJLVGIVWF!DP`N F!McU#J<VGFo XWIJV`LNPJLK DXWJLV<NE\AT^J6-JLJAS DPVJLK '-E\eVJLK F!McU JoMcS
GS/HDPGHGMPS \^SPK_NE\eH\/ E JA\/U#V*HMR_,McUaoHONE\^S EN/.PVGI`A\/W EU#GSP`LG XWIJLV8Q
Y
3 9,$&?{9
CPGF!DXW\YHJLK4\/SESPJA\ WGSPdGIVWSPM/HoHONPJMPSXW. NPJADEU#GIVHGI`2\/WId/McU#GIHONEF ,\/SPK GIVW-^.]SPM]F!JA\^SPVoHONPJ
VGFo XWIJLVH8Q `HONPJAU'\/WId/MPU#GIHONEF!V NE\ T/J EU#MeT/JLKoDPVJX DXW?GSoKEGJAU#JAS^H'VGIHODE\eHGMPSPV c\/SPK HONPJ*`LNPM/GI`LJ
MeX'_NPGI`LNhNPJADEU#GIVHGI`oHMlDPVJ!GV\^SlGFo McU#HO\^S/HMcSPJRQZrqMd/GIT/Jo\ $\ T/MPDEU*MeX,HONPJ!KEGIT/JAU#VGIH#. \
\^]C]`\ a
gp b p9 gk/@bj/;
r*NPJ%ZhMRW8\/WId/McU GHNEF ^8t ANf&GIVl\2Tr\^U#G\/S/HMYX VGF!DXW\eHJLK \/SESPJA\/WIGSPd KEJLVGIdcSPJLK XbMcU
JW`LGIJAS^HVGF!DXW\eHGIMcS2MeX,HONPJ bVGSPd2F!McKEJWjQIr*NPJ VGSPd F!MPKEJW9GIV\F!GI`AU#M/V`LMc PGI`WF McKEJW9MeX
\ XbJAUU#McFo\YdcSPJLH_NPJAU#J!JA\e`N%VGIHJ MeX\W\eHHGI`LJW M/VVJLVVJLVR\ VO PGSh_NPGI`LN2`A\/S2-EJ JLGHNPJAU&DE
McU+KEMe_S1Q\K \e`LJAS^H*VO PGSPV EU#JXbJAU,HMo-J E\/U\/WmWIJW _*GIHON\ "PJLKJASPJAU#d/. EJASE\/WIH#. X McU,-JLGSPd
\/S^HG_V E\/U\/WmWIJWjQZ\ H WIMe_ HJAFo JAU\eHODEU#JLV VGFRDXW\eHJLKz\^SESPJA\/WIGSPd%GIV&GSPJ<`LGJAS^Ho\eHVGFRDXW\eHGSPd
HONPJ bVGSPdF!McKEJWjQ X'_,J&`LMcSPVGIKEJAU&\oF MrT^JHM $ G 2\!VGSPdNWJ VO PGS HONPGIV*_*GmWmW'F!M/VH WIGaeJWI. -J
U#J#JL`LHJLK VGSP`LJF!M/VHVO PGSPV _*GmWW,-EJ<VODEUU#MPDESPKEJLK]-/.2Fo\/S^.lM/HNPJAUVO PGSPVR EM^GS^HGSPd2GS2HONPJ
VO\/F J&KEGU JL`LHGIMcS1Q
r*NPJ,ZhMRW6\/WId/MPU#GIHONEF \ T/M/GIKEV9HONPGIV@WIMr_ HJAFo EJAU\YHODEU#J EU Mc-XWIJAF -^."$ G E PGSPd`WDPVHJAU#V
MeX'VO PGSPV!\eHHNPJRV\/F!JHGF JRQ r NPJ \ Wd^McU#GIHONEFFo\eGS^HO\eGSPV\ HONPJAUFo\/W VJWIJL`LHGIMcShUDXWJ q_*GIHON
JA\e`LNF!MeT/J-EJLGSPd<VJWIJL`LHJLK2GSl\oFo\^SESPJAU,VMoHONE\YH JLT^JAU#.6 EU Mc EM/VJLK F!MeT/JGIV \e`L`LJA PHJLK6Q
CPGFRDXW\eHJLK \/SESPJA\/WIGSPd GIVoGSPJW`LGIJAS^HW\eH[WMe_ HJAFo EJAU\eHODEU#JLV VH\A.PGSPdlGSMcSPJ<`LMcSNV
dcDEU\YHGIMcS XMPUR\OWIMcSPdHGF!JRQ r*NPGIVoGIVoVGF!GmW\/U HM2HONPJ`LMcSP`LJA PHoMeX\OWIMc`A\/WF!GSPGF!DEF GS
Mc PHGF!GIVO\YHGIMcS1Q BFo\ed^GSPJ!HONE\YH_,JR\^U#JVJLJAa^GSPdHMWF!GSPGF!GIVJ /W +VONPMe_S GS dPDEU#JRQ^*QNQ
r*NPJ*V.cVHJAF VHO\^U#HV9GSoVMcF!J*GSPGIHG\/W`LMcS dPDEU\eHGIMcS (W
P\/SPK\ XHJAU9\SPDEFR-JAU+MeX F!MeT/JLV+HONPJ
V.PVHJAF GIVGS%VHO\eHJ<W Q"r NPGV&GIV&\CWIMP`A\/W9F!GSPGF!DEF \^SPKlHONPJ V.cVHJAF_*GmWmW'NE\ T/J&HM\e`L`LJA PH
\hSPDEF!-EJAU!MeXDES^XB\AT^McDEU\/-XWIJlF!MeT/JLV!HM2JLV`A\/ JlHONPGIVF!GSPGFRDEFEQX&HONPJlHJAFo EJAU\YHODEU#J<GV
WIMe_ GIH_*GmWmW HO\^aeJ\CWIMcSPd<HGF!J HMoJLV`A\/ J!HONPGIV`LMcS dPDEU\eHGIMcS1Q SlHNPJ bVGSPdF!MPKEJW HONPJAU#J
GIVRSPM%KEGJAU#JASP`LJ<-EJLH#_,JLJAS2HONPJoV.PVHJAFNE\ TPGSPd \/WmW'V PGSPV!DE 2McU&\/WmW+VO PGSPVKEMe_S1QI\*HWIMe_
HJAFo JAU\eHODEU JLV /VGF!DXW\eHJLKW\^SESPJA\/WIGSPd!_*GmWmWSPM^H'-EJ\/-XWIJHM&VO\/F XWJ-EM/HON HONPJLVJ*VHO\eHJLV9VGSP`LJ
HONPJL.l\/U JVJA E\/U\eHJLKl-^.l\/SJASPJAU#d^.l-E\/UU#GIJAUQ%bHGV XbMcU*HNPGV&U#JA\eVMcSHONE\YH*HONPJHJAFo EJAU\YHODEU#J
V`LNPJLK DXWIJRGS VGFRDXW\eHJLK \/SESPJA\/WIGSPd<GVVMoGFo McU#HO\^S/H8Q
\^]C]
: b 7 >r=Fb?kci/;
\ HO\/-ED VJA\/U#`LN ^ * Ncc GIV*\/So\eHHJAFo PH9HM!\AT^M/GIKoHONPJ EU#MP-XWJAF MeXd/JLHHGSPdVHODP`La GSCWIMP`A\/W
F!GSPGFo\*Q `&SPJ`LMcSPVHOUDP`LHV*\IWIGIVHMeX HONPJ! EU#JLTcGIMcDPV 2`LMcS dcDEU\YHGIMcSPV*MeX HNPJ&V.cVHJAF_NPGI`LN
\/U#JHO\/-McM \^SPKlFo\ .WSPM/H*-EJ&TPGIVGIHJLKlGSHNPJ SPJPHF!MeT/JRQ@r*NPGIV*_*\ .o_,J F \A.<-EJXbMcU#`LJLKHM
y
2
y
1
y
0
y
E(y)
!#"%$&'"($)*)*)+-, +&. '/&0)*21+3546*78
"( '0&$8:9.&<;=>?$$@A)B&<CD E3F5G H& I;> >%. 'J '"( K> *C("($ E&(LM1*6INFLM>
8 ')O"DP"QR4TS=> 'UV;M$?$W V*+$&'"Q$X)BY)*)+Z[4D\'Z["D.E;M$$]&M7^ H"7$
&*_`.+a> H$&7"($b)*Y)*)+Zc4<d(
egfFhfih j=klmcnpo(qcm[rls
,t> 'K)K0$ ')* 'DU)u$"( .v" '"($[Z;V p0J&0& p"*)*&(C VLw&)x> =8 ')*V'zy
'DV&D_["(?&K&*"* ?>7^&K&D_["(&{, I" |Lw &H>& =;> >U80
&(LM)*&(C E3F'"($$ .}a> B)B&<CD ayw 6=&U&. 'Z".a>I;V K)K"T8v>&&D K> *
&(LI> +$&'"Q$ >7^&>&&.g~"D8$&'"($ '">> '"D v7"( .-&> v>&0^
>"(/;P '">&& v> %)*&(C ayw K&"(E& ' >"(K> L?&:>"Q"%YD$? Z
$&7"(${)*)u)Z "D.&V)K"D8H$&'"($g)*Y)/"NFLb>'"U7 I"(>? CD .gZa> 'E"=)K0$
"($&J?a>);> >"( '0=&$8KLw"TC&"D7$? H)B&<CD M;M$$g&$C > H0&7$ ')+
M>M"00&"(>/;R"QC '8U0&0$"V;=> 'U&)K0 ')* =;M"(P .v".U>
&(LpD$?&7"($ '">> '+;M"(E&/L '"Q7$? ~"D8>"'CD A"00$ .$?&'"($= '">
> 'M;|?a>E '"Q&"7$ I IDZ(ZM> = >&D? I&QLW)B&<CD ayw "($&K"BY)uy
0&"D"(0^ P;=> 'E*)*$"( .+" '"($[Z["(>R> $0M&u)K"Q Pa> p"($&>)
Y 3 { *?{ ,&
T'U JLTcGIMcDPV WI. E_,JNE\ T/J&\eVVODEF JLKWHONE\YH HNPJ*XBDESP`LHGIMcS_,J_*GIVON<HM!Mc PHGF!GIVJ W eGIVaPSPMe_S
JE\e`LH WI.RQ@\ F!McU Jd/JASPJAU\/WVGIHODE\eHGMPS acSPMe_S\YV*VHMP`NE\YVHGI`&Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGMPS EGIV_NPJAU J /W
GIVoSPM/HRaPSPMe_S 9-EDPH F \A.h-JWJLVHGF \eHJLK6Q7r*NPJAU#J<GV!VMPF!JWDESPKEJAU WI.PGSPd XBDESP`LHGIMcShHNE\eH_,J
_*GIVON HMWMP PHGF!GIVJ \^SPKlMcDEU JLVHGFo\eHJLVMeX9HONPGIV&\/U#JKEGIVHU#G-EDPHJLKh\/U#McDESPK%HONPGIV&Tr\/WDPJ /W
-EJLGSPd2HONPJWF JA\/S%Tr\/WDPJ<MeX*HONPJ!JLVHGFo\eHJLV)Q X*_,JW\eVVODEF JRJA\Y`N2JLVHGFo\eHJoHMl-EJoVH\eHGIVHG_V
`A\/WmWI.oGSPKEJA EJASPKEJAS^H EHONPJAS _,J*Fo\ .R`LMPSPVGIKEJAU'JA\Y`NoF MrT^J GSPKEJA JASPKEJAS/H WI. \/SPKW\/WIVM!\ T/JAU\ed/J
U#JA JA\eHJLKlJLVHGFo\eHJLV*HMRdP\eGSlF!McU J EU#JL`LGIVJRaPSPMe_"WIJLKEd/JMeX W Q
&'\e`LN2JLVHGF \eHJo`A\/S -EJ<HONPMcDPdcN^H&MeX\YVd/GITPGSPd2HONPJ<DESPKEJAUWI.cGSPdhTe\/WDPJVODE- #JL`LHHM
VMcF JRSPM/GIVJRQr*NPJoSPM/GIVJ!GS%HONPJ!JLVHGFo\eHJLV&SPJLJLKEV&HM-EJoaeJA PHVOFo\/WmW GX WIMe_HJAF EJAU\eHDEU#JLV
\/U#JHMo-EJ&VGF!DXW\eHJLK _NPGmWJ!\eH NPGIdcN HJAFo JAU\eHODEU#JLV WIMe_ DE\/WIGIH#.WJLVHGFo\eHJLV*Fo\ .W-JDPVJLK6Q
r*NPJoKEGW`ADXWIH#.hGS2HONPJ< EU#Mc-XWIJAF GV!SPMe_ HOU\/SPV#XbJAUU#JLK%XBU#McF HONPJ `LMcFo XWIJcGIH#.hMeXHMl\/WIVM
`LMcSPVGIKEJAU#GSPdlNPMe_ EU#JL`LGIVJR\^S<JLVHGFo\eHJ&GIV&SPJLJLKEJLK VMW\eV,HMW\ T/M/GIK<VO EJASPKEGSPdlDESESPJL`LJLVV\/U#.
J McU#H8Q
\^]C]`\
n kc=9@Bg +>lgs je@ @B>b?je@Bg =jY;+g '>
CPHMP`NE\YVHGI`!Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGIMcS%_*\eV&-EMcUSPJRMPDPHMeX \^SlGIKEJA\-^.-pMP-E-PGSPV $2McSEU#M */ Qr*NPJL.
`LMcSPVGIKEJAU#JLK2VMNWTPGSPdWHNPJ EU#Mc-XWIJAFMYX SPKEGSPd
/W #RQf
_NPJAU#J GIVVMcF!J2F!McSPM/HMPSPG`%XBDESP`LHGIMcS MeX W *HONPJ%VMRWDPHGIMcS HM -EJ%XMPDESPK \/SPK GIVl\
E\/U\^F!JLHJAUQ GIVSPM/H XMPDESPK KEGU#JL`LH W. -EDPH&`A\/SMPSXW.2-EJ!JLVHGFo\YHJLK6Qr*NPJLGUHJL`NESPG!EDPJoHM
VMRWIT/J HONPGIV EU Mc-XWIJAFGIV`A\/WmWJLK2VHMc`LNE\eVHGI`\/ E EUM PGFo\eHGIMcS1Q \ ScDEF!-EJAU MeX9Tr\/U G\^S/HV MeX'HONPGIV
V`LNPJAF!JNE\ T/JVGSP`LJR-EJLJAS KEJLT/JWIMc EJLK A *bRt b * cGSP`WDPKEGSPd \ d/JASPJAU\ WGIVO\YHGIMcSHMo-J\/-XWIJ
HMoH\e`aNWIJ&VHMP`NE\YVHGI`&Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGMPSl EU#Mc-XWIJAF!VbRb Q
CPHMP`NE\eVHGI`WMc PHGF GV\eHGIMcS GVo\%F!McU#Jod^JASPJAU\/W'VGHDE\eHGIMcS 9_NPJAU JW_,Jo_*GIVON HM SPK
HONPJF!GSPGFRDEF MeXVMcF!J!XBDESP`LHGIMcS '-EDPH!_NPJAU JWHONPGIV XBDESP`LHGIMcS]F \A.hNE\ T/JWF \/S/.hF!GSPGFo\*Q
cDPVH*\eV,_,J&Fo\ .o`LMcSPVGIKEJAU,McU KEGSE\^U#.oMc PHGF!GIVO\YHGIMcSF!JLHONPMPKEV,HM X \/WmWGS/HMRH#_,M`A\YHJLd/McU#GIJLV V
JE\e`LHF!JLHONPMPKEV\/SPKlNPJADEU GVHGI`LV"V'VHMc`LNE\eVHGI`Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGMPSlF!JLHONPMPKEV*`A\/S\ WVMW-EJ&`W\eVVJLK
\eV*KEJLT^JWMP EF!JAS/HVXU#MPFHONPJLVJ H _,M!`A\eHJLd^McU#GIJLV*MeX F!JLHNPMcK6Q r,_,MoMeX9HONPJKEJLT^JWMP EF!JAS/HVMeX
\ScDEF!-EJAUMeXNPJADEU GVHGI`LVoJcGIVH HMHO\e`LaNWJ VHMP`NE\eVHGI`oMc PHGF!G! A\eHGIMcS EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V
* Xc /8q /)f /_*GIHON Tr\/U .cGSPdW\eKETe\/S^HO\ed/JLV,\/SPKWKEGIVO\YKETr\/S^HO\ed/JLV)Q k?McU9JE\/Fo XWIJ&`LMcSPVGKEJAU
HONPJoVHMc`LNE\eVHG` `LMcFo E\/U#GIVMPSh\/WId/McU#GIHONEF c q_NPGI`N GIVR\KEJLT^JWMP EF!JAS/H!MeX*\/Sh\/WId/MPU#GIHONEF
-^.'\/S\/SPK $hDEa \eG ^8f QZ GIHONhHNPGVo\/WId/MPU#GIHONEF McSPJFo\/aeJLV!\ SPDEF!-EJAU MeX*JLVHGFo\YHJLV
MeX*HONPJoJASPJAU d/.hMeX,HONPJW`ADEUU#JAS/H VHO\eHJ
\/SPKMeX*HONPJWSPJL_ VHO\eHJ
Q X\/S/.2MeX
HONPJ%JLVHGFo\eHJLV MeX HNPJlJASPJAU#d/. MYX HONPJlSPJL_ VHO\YHJl\/U#JdcU JA\eHJAU!HONE\^SHONPJl`LMcUU#JLVO EMPSPKEGSPd
JLVHGFo\YHJ!MeX HONPJ!JASPJAU#d^. MYX'HONPJo`ADEUU#JAS^H&VHO\YHJ HNPJAS2HONPJ!`ADEUU#JAS^H&VHO\eHJRGIVaeJA PH\^SPKhHONPJ
EU#Mc M/VJLK F!MeT/JoU#J#JL`LHJLK6Q bHGIVEDPGHJW`WIJA\/U HONE\eH&HNPGV!GIVR\^S2JW`LGIJAS/HoF!JLHNPMcK XMPU&NPGdPN
HJAFo JAU\eHODEU JLV -EDPH*_*GmWmW9U#J JL`LHFo\/S^.oXB\ T/McDEU\/-XWIJF!MeT/JLV*\eH WIMe_HJAFo EJAU\YHODEU#JRQ
$h\/S/. MeXHONPJNPJADEU#GIVHG`LV\/U#J*KEJLT/JWIMc EF JAS/HV+XBU#McF VGF!DXW\eHJLK\/SESPJA\/WIGSPd )f Nc ^
b/ Q&CPGF!DXW\YHJLKh\/SESPJA\/WIGSPd c ^ 'NE\eV&-EJLJAS2VONPMe_S cc 9HMWVMRWIT/J!VHMP`NE\eVHGI`Mc PHGF!G! A\eHGMPS
EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V _*GIHON] EU Mc-E\/-PGmWIGH#. EU#MeTcGIKEJLK HONPJSPM/GIVJGShHNPJJLVHGFo\eHJLV!\eH!HGF!J<VHJA &GV
aeJA PH-JWIMr_ ,_NPJAU#J RQ
$2McKEG JLK VGF!DXW\eHJLK \/SESPJA\ WGSPd \/WId/McU#GIHONEF V *)f b/ HO\^aeJWGS^HM \e`L`LMcDES^HoHONPJ
_*GIKEHON MeXHONPJ<KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcSMYXHONPJ<JLVHGFo\eHJLV HM F \/aeJ<VODEU#J<HONE\eHHNPJWJLVHGF \eHJLVMYXHONPJ
JASPJAU#d/.o\/U J VGdPSPG `A\^S/H WI.oKEGJAU#JAS^H -JXMcU J\Y`L`LJA PHGSPdRMPU9U#J JL`LHGSPd!\&F!MeT/JRQ CPMPF!J*MeXHONPJLVJ
F!JLHONPMPKEV*NE\ T/J -JLJASVONPMe_S HM!`LMcS^T/JAU#d/JHM HONPJ&dRWIMc-E\/WF!GSPGF!DEFMeX HONPJ XBDESP`LHGIMcSl-JLGSPd
Mc PHGF!GIVJLK2DESPKEJAU*d^GT^JAS`LMcSPKEGIHGIMcSPV^Rq b/ Q
CPHMP`NE\eVHGI`R\/SESPJA\/WIGSPd _^/c [GIV\/S%JPHJASPVGIMcS%MeX'VGF!DXW\eHJLK]\/SESPJA\ WGSPd%HMoVHMP`LNE\eV V
HGI`<Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGIMcS EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V8Q HKEGJAU#V&XBU#McF HONPJW\/-MeT/Jo\/ E EU#Mc\e`LNPJLVGS H#_ MlaYJL.z\^U#JA\eV8Q
k9GU#VH WI. HONPJ!d/JASPJAU\/W `LMPSP`LJA PH&MeX'HONPJ!M/HONPJAU\/ E EU#Mc\Y`NPJLVGIVMcSPJ MeXF!GSPGF!GIVGSPd2HONPJRSPM^GVJ
EU#JLVJAS^HGS%HONPJ JLVHGFo\eHJLV8QbH&GIVJAS/HGU#JWI.2SE\eHODEU\/WqHONE\eHHONPJRSPM/GIVJo EU#JLVJAS/HGSlHNPJJASPJAU#d/.
JLTr\ WDE\YHGIMcSPVoVONPMcDXWIK -EJlDPVJLK \eVo\2 EM/VGIHGIT/JJ JL`LH VGSP`LJMcSPJlFo\ .2HONPGSEahMeXVGFRDXW\eHJLK
\/SESPJA\/WIGSPd\eV*\oSPM/GIV. DPJASP`LN1Q'CPJL`LMcSPK*WI. HONPGIV\/ E EU Mc\e`LNo`A\/S-JF!MPKEG JLK%HM!d/GIT/J&JE\e`LH
VGF!DXW\eHGIMcS2MeX*\<HONPJAUFo\ W9V.cVHJAF-Q[\ WIHONPMcDPdPNlHNPGV GIVRSPM/H&VO JL`LG `A\/WmW. UDXWIJLKMcDPH-/.%HONPJ
M/HONPJAU \/ E EU#Mc\e`LNPJLV ESPM\eHHJAFo PH*NE\eV-EJLJASlF \eKEJ&HMoVO\YHGIV#X.<HONPGIV*`LMcSPKEGIHGIMcS1Q
\^]C]
iEiE=?s9j=b 'iE=s9kcg7*b 79@bpb@bje@B= >2@ > jYg9i^;!b> jr@Bi> t'> jY= >
BSHNPJWVHMc`LNE\eVHGI`Mc PHGF GV\eHGIMcS`LMcS^HJPHHONPJl EU#MP-E\/-PGmWGIH#.
2 MeX \Y`L`LJA PHGSPd]\
F!MeT/J9_NPM^VJ'JASPJAU#d^.&`NE\/SPd^J9GV82 GIV'SPM/HHONPJ+VO\/F!J'\YV HONPJ, EU#Mc-E\/-PGmWIGIH#. MYX\e`L`LJA PHGSPd
F!MeT/JLV _NPM/VJ JASPJAU#d/.`LNE\/SPd/J*\/ E JA\/U#V+HM -J 6Q@r*NPJLVJ\^U#J,H _,MKEGIVHGSP`LH DE\/S^HGIHGIJLV ^VGSP`LJ
MeX&JLVHGFo\eHGSPd HONE\eHoHONPJJASPJAU d/. `NE\^SPd/JGIV _NPJAS GIHVoHUDPJlTe\/WDPJlGIV 2 3Q r*NPJAS HONPJ
EU#Mc-E\^-PGWIGIH#.MeX'\e`L`LJA PHGSPd6\ F!MeT/J&_NPM/VJ&HUDPJ&JASPJAU#d/.<`NE\^SPd/J&GIV 2 GIVd/GIT/JAS%-/.
2
2 #RQ*
r*NPGIV,XbMcUF!DXW\!GIV\/ E XWIGI`A\/-XWIJ!HM!VHMP`NE\eVHGI`&Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGIMcS<GS d/JASPJAU\/W -EDPH,VM!XB\/U,NE\eV,McSXWI.
-EJLJAS `LMcSPVGIKEJAU#JLKl-^.Ik9GSEa l,\/WmW ^/c Q X _,J*`A\^S!`NPMPM/VJ 9VODP`LN HONE\eH
XbMRWmWIMe_*V
J1QRQ^ HONPJAS_,J&_*GmWmW[-J!GF XWJAF JAS/HGSPdl\!d^JASPJAU\/WIGIVJLK2T/JAU#VGIMcS MeX'VGF!DXW\YHJLK \/SESPJA\ WGSPd
e
N)-A! 23A AC8=7*,/7CA!-A!%A! .>+,D2M@C,/7CA!+'0H. 23+=7 %=0I01.
=@CA!+'0H. ,?7
Q
-0 7!,I2 7/,I2
CPHMP`NE\eVHGI`Mc PHGF!GIVH\eHGIMcSl EU Mc-XWIJAF!V\/U#J McSPJLVGS%_NPGI`LNl_,J&_*GIVON%HM< EJAU XbMcUF \/S
Mc PHGF!GIVO\YHGIMcSo_NPJAU#J*JE\e`LH'acSPMe_"WIJLKEd/JMeXHONPJ,XBDESP`LHGIMcSoHM-EJMc PHGF!GIVJLK<GV,SPM/H \ Te\eGmW\^-XWJRQ
bH&GIV!\eVVODEF!JLK2HONE\YH&GSP`AU JA\eVGSPdRWI.] EU#JL`LGIVJoJLVHGFo\eHJLV&MeX,HONPJ XDESP`LHGMPSh\/U#Jo\ Tr\eGmW\/-XWIJ 9-EDPH
HONE\eHHONPJLVJ JLVHGFo\eHJLV \/U JGSP`AU#JA\eVGSPdRWI.hJE EJASPVGT^JRQZr*NPJH\eVOa<GIV&HM EJAUXbMcUF \/SMP PHGF!G_V
VO\eHGMPS<HONE\eH*GIVSPM/H EU#McNPG-PGIHGIT/JWI. JE EJASPVGT^JRQ
r*NPJ&\/ E EU#Mc\e`LN!MeXVHMc`LNE\eVHGI`\^SESPJA\/WIGSPd GV*\ d/JASPJAU\ WGIVO\YHGIMcSoVGF!DXW\eHJLKl\^SESPJA\/WIGSPd
HM<VHMP`NE\YVHGI`!Mc PHGF!GIVO\eHGIMcS2 EU#MP-XWJAF V8Qar NPJRMPU#GId/GSE\/W@k9GSEa l,\/WmW ^/c \/WId/McU#GIHONEF McSXWI.
d/GIT/JLV&\/S2\/ E EU#M)PGF \eHGIMcSHMoHOUDPJ!HONPJAUF \/WVO\/F XWGSPdQr*NPGIV&HJL`LNESPG! DPJoFo\ .l-J \YK \/ PHJLK
HMod^GT^J&J \e`LH W.HNPJAUFo\/WVO\/F XWGSPd \/SPKHONPGIVGIV*KEJAF!McSPVHU\eHJLKGSl\ U\/SPd/J&MeX9`A\eVJLV)Q
3 Y { *?{ !+* ) Z 2&|x 5 *
ZhJ,NE\AT^J \/WU#JA\eKE.&VJLJAS VJL`LHGIMcSoNQcQ HONE\eHHONPJ,\e`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJ* EU#MP-E\/-PGmWGIH#.MYX\F!MeT/J9_NPM/VJ
DESPKEJAU WI.PGSPdJASPJAU d/.W`LNE\/SPd/J GIV 2 GIV
2
2 b*Q
GIVoHONPJl EU#MP-E\/-PGmWGIH#.HONE\eH!_,J`NPMPM/VJ<HMh\e`L`LJA PHW\2F!MeT/J<_NPM/VJ<JASPJAU#d/.`LNE\/SPd/J<GV
JLVHGFo\YHJLKlHM<-EJ 2\/SPK 2 +GVHONPJ! EU#Mc-E\/-PGmWIGIH .2KEJASPVGIH#.MeX'JLVHGF \eHGSPdWHNPJJASPJAU#d/.
`LNE\/SPd/JlMYX\hF MrT^JHM]-EJ _NPJAS GHVWHOUDPJTr\/WDPJ2GIV 2 hQk9GSEa \/SPKMl,\/WmW^/c `LNPM/VJ
!XbMcU
%\/SPK <M/HONPJAU#_ GVJRQ3r*NPGIV`LNPM/GI`LJ<VHJAF!VXBU#McF HONPJ!`LMcSP`LJA PH
MeX'\! EU#Mc-E\/-PGmWIGIVHGI` DPJASP`LNhV'HONE\YH*_,J \e`L`LJA PH&\/WmW F!MeT/JLV,_NPGI`LN
G
X*_,JoNE\ T/JRF!MPU#Jo EU#JL`LGIVJWJLVHGFo\eHJLV&MeX,HONPJ!JASPJAU#d/.2`LNE\/SPd/J HONPJAS2_,J!_*GmWmW \e`L`LJA PHXbJL_,JAU
DES^XB\AT^McDEU\/-XWIJoF!MeT/JLVUV*J DPGITe\/WIJAS/HoHM3WIMe_,JAU#GSPdlHONPJ!HJAFo JAU\eHODEUJRQCr*NcDPV `NE\/SPd^GSPd%HONPJ
EU#JL`LGIVGIMcS%MeX9McDEU+JLVHGFo\eHJLV*MeX82 \/WmWIMe_*V&DPV*HMW JAUX MPUF\/S\/SESPJA\ WGSPdQ
k9GSEaW\/SPK-l,\/WmW^/c `LMcSPVGIKEJAU#JLK%HONPJ& E\/U#HGI`ADXW\/U,`A\eVJMeX -JLGSPdW\ \/DPVVG\^S<KEGVU#G_V
-EDPHGIMcS
2
b*Q
CEDE-PVHGIHODPHGMPSMeX9HONPGIVGS^HMoJ1Q *Q_*GIHON HONPJ&`LNPM/GI`LJMeX \^-EMeT/J&d/GIT/JLV
2
hJAU X
2
b*Q^
r*NPGIV*GIV*VOaYJLH`NPJLKGS dQ?*Q ^_NPGI`N<GmWmWDPVHOU\eHJLVHONPJ EUGSP`LG XWIJo-EJANPGSPK2VHMP`NE\YVHGI` \^SESPJA\/W_V
GSPdQrM \eVVODEU JHONPJAUFo\/W J DPGmWIG-EU#GDEF HONPJ \e`L`LJA PH\/SP`LJ EU#MP-E\/-PGmWGIHGIJLV2FRDPVHoMc-EJL. JGQ
RQ^
2
2
/ b*Qc
_NPJAU#J
#
GV HONPJGS^T/JAU#VJ&HJAFo EJAU\YHODEU#J&\/SPK"2 GIV*HONPJ&JASPJAU#d^.oKEG JAU JASP`LJR-EJLH#_,JLJAS
HONPJ%VHO\eHJLV!GS HNPJ F!MeT/JRQ Q VGSPdHONPJ]k9GSEa sl,\/WmW`LNPM/GI`LJlMYX KEMcJLVSPM/Hod/GIT/J2\/S
\e`L`LJA PHO\^SP`LJW EU#Mc-E\/-PGmWIGIH#.]_NPGI`LN2VO\eHGV JLVJ1Q *QcJE\e`LH WI. 9-EDPH`WIM/VJW.\/ E EU#M)cGFo\YHJLV&GIH8Q
Q VGSPdWJ1Q *Q^!\/SPKJE E\/SPKEGSPdGS"2 _,J&Mc-PHO\eGS
/10
/10!
"
$#&%('
)
#&%('
)
*2
,+
*02
b*Qb
_NPJAU#J
*
f
/
b*Qt
GIKEJAS/HG JLV<HONPJJ JL`LHGIT/JGS^T/JAU#VJHJAF EJAU\eHDEU#JRQKr*NPJVOFo\ WW,`LMPJW`LGIJAS/H
/&MYXHONPJ
`ADE-PGI`&HJAUF GS<JGQE*Q_bFo\/aYJLV'HONPGIV*\!U\eHONPJAU+d/MPMcK<\/ E EU#M)cGFo\YHGIMcSoHMRHUDPJHNPJAUFo\/W?VJWIJL` V
HGIMcS1Q
rM%`LMcS^HOU#MRW HONPJ<HJAFo EJAU\eHODEU#Jo_,JoSPJLJLKHM -J6\/-XWIJ<HM`LMcS^HOU#MRW0>Q3r*NPGIVoFo\ . -J
\e`LNPGIJLT/JLK4-^. F \/a/GSPd]\ ScDEF!-EJAU MeX VHO\eHGIVHGI`A\/WmWI. GSPKEJA EJASPKEJAS^HJLVHGFo\eHJLVoMeX)2 XBU#McF
HONPJ &\/DPVVG\/S KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS1Q=r NPJlF!JA\/STr\ WDPJ%MeX \2VJLHRMYX %JLVHGFo\eHJLV!GIV &\/DPVVG\/SXWI.
KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHJLKh\/U McDESPK"2 P_*GIHON<VHO\/SPK \^U#KKEJLTcG\eHGMPS
0
0
1
0
1
convolution
f(x-
∆
E)
A(x)
P (
accept
∆
E)
x
x-
∆
E
1
β
1
β
G
,
∆
E
Glauber function
Fink & Ball rule
!#"%$%&'("%$%)' '(*,+- &&."% "$%&/'0 $21&(3 "
4
$56')&'$7/8:9<;*=?> @;A"B'A "%$%1C'($D &(EFHGJILKNMPOQOQRTSUV9<FCG=W"$5 &3&.X$D&
&(EB8:9<;W=
4
$PC$5 - D&!"%$P$%&ZY[9<;\ZFHG/=VB ^]_X'. )'( $P' _E`$D&a"
'("%&C"P&
4
HE<&@&1C'"%&b
4
_c_"d$5 )"5'.1C )"%e gfhE
4
)"% _$5"2'("&[ "%$%1C'($D 2&0EiFHGJI($P 2 PjN $%3 _3. "%
$% 1C %'($5k ^ &1 "
lbmZnpo q
c
o rNs
9<
q
=
'!t"$5' u.7v3('7Xwcv"H"5'1Cx1 $5&!y'("%&v'("$5 Z'(!3('.$5'( a$5'($
EQ&-'. zc{$5 J .$5%'0g1$C$5 & 1|!*3 "$5 a!"%$5$%&}&(E$5 #'L3 %'(. /&0E$5
"%$%1C'0$% ")$%&
4
'!")'a]-'"%"%'{ 3 #~E$_"&.$)"%&EQ&)c
n
.2&$% -$5'0$,E<&2'H"51&&$5
' '("% !* a& "5&!v$P'( ' $%&Z1 '0"5
s
'!v&.$5&. lbm %'($P _$5'
%"%$gc'0& B"d$5%"d&$$D&^ )1C&$5'.$?EQ&?$5 )&'"%$%-$5%'L3 ^"5'0 "P1C'
& 1#IW"% -"% W
6 [6_)?
fhE
4
@1H'( 2'!~jN $& )&(E8:9<;W=N$%&-6'!C2'0N~(LI
4
, '& 2$D&"5'0$%"E<76$5
! $5'( !C'(' g&!$D&bI( *I ¡'($%7?¢v g&
4
$5'($bEQ&W"%1X'0$% !C' '(
4
'#1C'.( '1 ,&(E?!jN .$,£&. "_&(EB'0 $5' _E¤$%&bI"5#'(",$5 6]'
&¥ $5&&"'( $5' C% "{9T"% $%&w=_fhE
4
^"%"%$^$P'($K MPOQOQRTSU EQ&&
4
MeX HNPJLVJUDXWIJLV EHONPJAS _,J_ GWmW NE\ T/JVO\eHGV JLKJGQE*Qc;Q k?McU+J \^Fo XWIJ&JGQE*Q_,McDXWIKhWJA\YKlHM
*
2
2 b*Q*
BS HONPJ`A\eVJ*_NPJAU#J 2 "42 HONPGIV GIV*\&KEJ VB`LMPS/T/MNWDPHGMPS EU#Mc-XWIJAF X McU Q
r \/a/GSPdhk McDEU GJAU V \/ XW\e`LJHU\/SPV#XbMcUF!V,MeX'-EM^HON<VGIKEJLV ?_ JNE\ T/J
*
b*QA
_NPJAU#J&HNPJZk MPDEU#GIJAUV \/ XW\e`LJ HOU\/SPV#XbMcUF GIVKEJ SPJLKz-^.
b*Q/
BS HONPJ`A\YVJ&MeX9HONPJUW\^DE-EJAU\e`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJ!UDXWIJ J1QRQb P_*GIHON h\YV*HONPJ \^DPVVG\/SKEGIVHU#G_V
-EDPHGIMcS JGQ?*Q ^HONPGIV -JL`LMcF!JLV
&
b*QA
r*NPJ&KEGW`ADXWIH#.GIV*HONE\eH F!DPVH*-J\o EU#Mc-E\/-PGmWIGIH#. \/SPKHNcDPV"WIGIJGS<HONPJU\/SPd/J XbMcU
\/WmW &Q3r*NPJAU JoGIVRSPMlMP-/TPGIMcDPV_*\ .lHMJASPVDEU#JoHONE\eH HONPGIV`LMcSPKEGIHGIMcS GIVVO\YHGIV JLK VG SP`LJWJ1Q
*Q ,XBDXWmW. VO EJL`LG JLV Q ZhJ*DPVJ\UWIJLVV,U#JLVHOU G`LHGT^J\/ E EU#Mc\Y`N!-EJWIMe_ _NPG`LN<\/WmWMe_*V9VMcF!J
XBU#JLJLKEMcFGSMPDEU,`NPM^G`LJ MeX \^SPKlNPJASP`LJ_,JFo\ .W`LNPMPM/VJ&GIH \YV\ EU#Mc-E\/-PGmWIGIH .RQ
3 & $ ,) * 2?w ,
6]C]`\
5h=+=Ek8b?p&ib>r=
BS HONPJXbMRWmWMe_*GSPd\/SE\/WI.PVGIV_,J&_*GmWmW[-JR\eHHJAFo PHGSPdoHM!`LNPMcM^VJR\/S 'VDP`N HONE\eH
VO\eHGV JLVWKEJLHO\YGWIJLK -E\/W\/SP`LJ ,J1Q'*Qc;Q ZhJ_*GmWmW \YVVODEF!JHONE\YHoHONPJXBDESP`LHGIMcS 2 GV
aPSPMr_S<J \e`LH W.RQ u,McF!-PGSPGSPd<J1Q *Qco_ GHN<JGQ Q_ JNE\ T/J
2
/1
2 b*Q8^
ZhJFo\/aeJ<HONPJ<VODE-PVHGIHODPHGMPSPV 2
/ 2 \/SPK
d/GITPGSPd
2 2 b*Qc
\V\!VMRWDPHGIMcS ?_,J&HOU#.
_NPJAU#J l\/SPK \/U#JXBDESP`LHGIMcSPVHMW-EJ `NPM/VJAS1Q CEDE-PVHGHDPHGSPdWHONPGIVGS/HM<JEDE\eHGIMcSl Qco\/SPK
U#J V \/UU\/SPd/GSPdo_,J%SPK
2
! 2 2 ! 2 2 2 b*Q8t
_NPJAU#J
! 2 2
2 2 b*Q8q
& 1Q*Q)t!GIVVO\eHGV JLKh_NPJAS 2
2
&\^SPK ! 2 2
6! 2 2
\/U#JJLT/JAS X DESP`LHGMPSPV8Q'Z J NE\ T/JSPM^H VDP`L`LJLJLKEJLKlGS<HO\/a^GSPdRHNPGV*F!M^VH,d/JASPJAU\/W?`A\eVJ X DEU#HNPJAU
HONPJNE\/U Kl E\/U#H-JLGSPdHMRJASPVDEU#JHONE\YH XMcU,\o EU Mc-E\/-PGmWIGH#.RQ
6]C] s*= iP@ ,i]ib>e=
ZhJSPMe_ Fo\/aYJoHONPJ<HOU\/SPVGIHGIMcSzHM \OWIJLVV!d/JASPJAU\/W+`A\eVJ XMPU&HONPJoJAUU#McU&KEGIVHU#G-EDPHGIMcS1Q2ZhJ
`LMcSPVGIKEJAU,HNE\eH 2 GIV\ XDESP`LHGMPS<MeX "42 \/WIMcSPJ EF!JA\^SPGSPd!HONE\YH'HONPJKEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS
MeX JAUU#McU 2 ^GIVGSPKEJA EJASPKEJAS^H&MeX 2 GIHVJWX Q'ZhJ&`LNPMPM/VJ&HONPGIV*GSl E\^U#H*-EJL`A\/DPVJ GX[_,J
\/WmWIMe_ HONPJ!XbMcUF MYX HM%KEJA EJASPKMcS 2 HONPJAS2HNPJAU#JoGIVRSPM2U#JA\eVMcS XbMcUSPM^H\/WmWMe_*GSPd2GIH
HMoKEJA JASPKhMcS VMcF!J M/HONPJAU Tr\/U#G\/-XWIJ HONPJ `A\eVJo\/-MrT^J-EJLGSPdlJLVVJAS/HG\/WmWI.lGIKEJAS^HGI`A\/W9HM<HONPJ
F!M/VH d^JASPJAU\/W`A\eVJ EM/VVG-XWIJRQ
k McU HONPGIV,`A\eVJ P_,J*`NPMPM/VJHONE\eH 2
"42
+\/SPKWVDE-PVHGIHODPHJ&GS^HMJ1Q
*Q)qHMod/JLH
! 2 2
2 2 b*Q8f
r*NPGIV&GIV \^SJLT/JAS6XDESP`LHGIMcS%GS%HONPJVJASPVJHONE\YHGX'_,JVODE-PVHGIHODPHJ W 2 2
GS^HM
HONPGIV E_,J%SPK
! 2 2
/W 2 /W 2 8W b*Q *
! 2 2 b*Q/
r*NPJAU XbMcU#J
2 2 2 b*QE
GIVR\<VMNWDPHGMPShHMJ1Q*QLc6 EU#MeTPGIKEJLK GIVJLT/JAS1QCr \/a^GSPdOk McDEU GJAUV \/ XW\e`LJ<HOU\/SPV#XbMcUF VMeX
HONPGIV_ JNE\ T/J
ZhJlVHGmWWNE\ T/J2VMPF!Jl`LNPM/GI`LJhGS
*VGSP`LJ HONPJ2McSXWI.4U#JLVHU#GI`LHGIMcS _ J2NE\ T/JlVMXB\/U
VO JL`LG JLK GIV HONE\eHGH GIVJLT/JAS
hF!DPVH-EJoJLT^JAS VGSP`LJ 2GIVJLT/JASQ GIT/JAS2GIH&GIVKEJLVGU\/-XWIJ
HMoU#J#JL`LH\eV+XbJL_F!MeT/JLV*\eV* EM/VVG-XWJ _,J`NPMPM/VJ
9HM -JGIKEJAS^HGI`A\/WmW.
-EJWIMe_ VMcF!J&HONEU JLVONPMRWIKXbMcU 6Q JASP`LJ_,J&KEJ SPJ
b*QR^ _NPJAU#J
XMPU \^SPK XbMcU
Q r*NcDPV _ JNE\ T/J
XMPU '(
b*Q/c ZhJ'SPJLJLKHM JASPVDEU#J'HONE\YH 2
2 `LMPUU#JLVO McSPKEV
HMW\< EU#Mc-E\^-PGWIGIH#.RQr*NPGIVF!JA\/SPV*HONE\YH
2 X MPU*\/WmW 2 \^SPKlVGSP`LJo_,J\/U#J GSNV
VGIVHGSPd<McS<J1Q *Qc!HONPJAS
2 / b*QRb
XbMcU*\/WmW02 hQ JASP`LJ_,JNE\ T/J
2 / b*QRt
r*NPGIV"WIJA\eKEV,HMoU#JLVHU#GI`LHGIMcSPV,McS \^SPK "2 ^VGSP`LJ-EM/HON<\/U#J& EM^VGIHGIT/JRQ CPGSP`LJ&_,J
\/U#J&`LNPMPM/VGSPd XMcU
_,JNE\ T/J 2 /1 b*QRq
_NPGI`LNRF JA\/SPV DPGIHJ,U#JA\eVMcSE\^-XW.qHONE\eH <F!DPVHXB\/WmWcM)W\eHWIJA\eVH9\eVXB\eVH9\eVHONPJ+KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS
MeX9VHO\eHJLV _,J\/U J\eHHJAFo PHGSPd HM!VGFRDXW\eHJRQkU#McF JGQ?*QRt _,JNE\ T/J
/1
/W 2 /W (W /1 b*QRf
CPGSP`LJ o\eV PGIHGV&U#JA\eVMcSE\/-XWIJ&HMW\eVVODEF!J&HONE\eH GIV*`LMcSP`A\ T/JHONE\eH,GIV
/W 2 2 W 2 b*Q *
u,McF!-PGSPGSPdWHNPGV_*GIHON<J1Q *QNfd^GT^JLV
2
/1
X McU 2 b*Q^/
rqMo`A\/WI`ADXW\eHJHNPJZWIGF!GIHHONPGIV& XW\e`LJLVMPS
_NPGI`LN<XbMRWmWMe_*VXU#MPFJGQ?*QR^*Q&kU#MPFHONPGIV E_,J%SPK b*Q^/
_NPJAU#J GIVVMcF!J&`LMcSPVHO\/S^H P_NPGI`NEWJA\YKEVHM
'( b*Q^R^ JASP`LJ
&GIV6-McDESPKEJLK XbMcU!\/WmW '(
Q]CPGSP`LJ
GIVWSPM/H!dcDE\/U\/S/HJLJLK]HMh-J
-EMPDESPKEJLKoXbMcU9\/WmW <FRDPVH'-EJ*`LNPM/VJAS HM&JASPVODEU#J HONE\eH9HONPGIV'`LMPSPKEGHGMPS<McS
lGIV*F!JLH8Q Q*VGSPd
HONPJ&Z GIJASPJAU V Mc ^X F!JLHONPMPK q * _ JF \A. KEJ SPJ
b*Q^/c
_NPJAU#J ,GIVSPMcSNV LJAU M6\/SPKl-McDESPKEJLK%XMPU
E\/SPK%VGF!GmW\^U WI.XbMcU
XbMcU Q
CPGSP`LJ GIVW-EMPDESPKEJLK XbMcU '(
_,JlSPJLJLK HMhHO\/aeJ\e`L`LMcDES^HoMeX&HONPJl MRWIJ
`LMcS^HO\eGSPJLKJE XWGI`LGIH WI.lGS<J1QE*Q/cQqZhJ&`LNPM/VJ
+HM `LMcS^HO\eGS\! EMRWIJ&MeX MP E EM/VGIHJU JLVGIK DPJ
\eH
E_,J&`A\/S`A\^SP`LJWHONPJJ JL`LH*MYX[HONPJ! EMRWIJ GS JGQ*Q cQ X
_,J&JASPVODEU J HONE\eH ,GIV-EMPDESPKEJLKlXbMcU '( Q'CPGSP`LJ
,F!DPVH-JJLT/JAS _ JNE\ T/J
b*Q^Rb _NPGI`LNd/GIT/JLV b*Q^Rt
CPMRWDPHGIMcS MeXHONPGIV,J DE\eHGMPSCWIJA\eKEV,HM&HONPJMc PHGFo\ W \e`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJ&UDXWIJXMPU Q bH,Fo\ .!VJLJAF
HONE\eH+HONPJAU#J&GIV,VHGmWmWVMcF J*XBU#JLJLKEMcF GS<HONPJ`NPM/GI`LJ&MeX Q@r*NPGIV*GIVSPM^H HNPJ&`A\eVJ PVGSP`LJ&HONPJ
`LMcSPKEGIHGIMcS McS J1Q *Q^N^+_*GmWWqKEJ SPJ Q
ZhJSPMe_ d/M!McS<HM KEGV`ADPVVVMcF!J E\/U#HG`ADXW\/UXBDESP`LHGIMcSPV Q
3 +$ #
S\/F!J
2
rqMc \YH
XbMcU 2
M/HONPJAU _*GIVJ
XbMcU XbMcU XbMcU
u,McS^T/MRWIT/JLK & McSPJAS^HG\/WIV
XbMcU
XbMcU
r \/-XWIJ*Q @r*NPJ&Mc PHGF \/W`NPM/GI`LJ&MeX HONPJ\e`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJ EU Mc-E\/-PGmWIGH#. YXMcU,\!d^GT^JAS<JAUU#McU
KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS DPVGSPdlMPDEU&F!JLHONPMPK6QRCPMcF JWF!McU#J `LMcFo XWIGI`A\eHJLKJ \^Fo XWIJLVR\/U#J XbMcDESPK2GS
HO\/-XWIJ!*Q
MeX,HONPJoJE EMcSPJAS^HG\/W'KEGIVHU#G-EDPHGIMcS '\/SPKhHNPJ \/DPVVG\/S%KEGVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcSGS2VJL`LHGIMcS*Qc;Q*Q S
VJL`LHGIMcS*QcQ^z_ J2`LMcSPVGKEJAU HONPJ OF!MPKEG JLK \/DPVVG\^S KEGIVHU#G-EDPHGIMcS &_NPGI`LN EU#MeT/JLVHM
-EJ2F!DP`N F!MPU#JWHU#McDE-XWIJLVMcF!JRQ pJLVODXWIHV XMcU HONPGIVoHJL`LNESPGEDPJ2_NPJAS \/ E XWIGIJLK HM]-PGF!MPK \/W
KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcSPV\^U#J&VODEFoFo\^U#GIVJLKGSHO\/-XWIJ!*Q*Q
6]C]`\ !
s*g '=qje@`b?p @B>Ajek/@ 7 9je@Bg
ZhJ&KEJ SPJ!HONPJ&JE EMcSPJAS^HG\/W KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS%\eV
2
/1 b*Q^Rq
_NPGI`LN-WIJA\eKEVHM b*Q^Rf ZhJ&`LNPMcM^VJ
b*Q^ *
b*Qcc r*NPGIVUWJA\YKEVHM
\& E XW.PGSPdJGQ?*Q^R^ *Q@pJ V \/UU\/SPd/JAF!JAS^H,d/GIT/JLV b*Qcc
r*NPJ&GS^T/JAU#VJ HOU\/SPV#XbMcUF \eHGIMcS `A\/S-EJ! EJAU XbMcUF!JLK2-/.<GSPVO EJL`LHGMPSlHMRd^GT^J
XbMcU
XbMcU
b*Qc ^
ZhJoSPM/HJ!HONE\YHHONPGIV!\e`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJ!XBDESP`LHGIMcS2MPSXW.2U#JAFo\eGSPV! EM/VGIHGIT/J XMcU\/WmW 2_NPJAS
\eV\^S/HGI`LG E\eHJLK J1Q *QRq Q
6]C]
5b '>e> @`b 9@B> jek/@ 7 9je@Bg
ZhJl\eHHJAFo PH!HM SPK4\2HNPJAUFo\/W*\e`L`LJA PHO\^SP`LJ UDXWIJ<XbMcU!HONPJ &\/DPVVG\/SKEGIVHOU G-EDPHGMPS JGQ
*Q QkU#McF HONPGIV_,J%SPK
b*QcRc
r*NPGIVXBDESP`LHGIMcSlNE\eV&\/S JLVVJAS^HG \/W VGSPdPDXW\^U#GIH.2\eH EVM *\^SPK
,`A\/SESPM/H VHOU#GI`LH WI.
-EJ `NPM^VJAS1Q bdPSPMcU#GSPdWHNPGV KEG<`ADXWH#. _,J`NPMPM/VJ
b*Qc b
_NPGI`LN-WIJA\eKEVHM
b*Qc t
CPGSP`LJ FRDPVHKEJL`A\ .]\eV
\YV JGQ9*Q^N^ _,JF!DPVHRNE\ T/J _NPGI`LN-WIJA\eKEVHM XbMcU XbMcU
b*Qc q
\ WIHONPMPDPdcN
*GIV&SPM/H-McDESPKEJLK]\eH -^.l\ XMPU#HODPGIHMcDPV`A\/SP`LJWmW\eHGIMcS%MeX'HJAUF V\
HONPJAUF \/W \Y`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJ*UDXWIJ,XbMcUHNPJ &\/DPVVG\/S `A\eVJ NE\eV'-JLJAS XMPDESPK6Q r NPGV9`A\^SP`LJWW\eHGMPSo_*\eV
_NE\eH&\/WmWIMe_ JLK k9GSEa l \ WW _^/c 'HMWV EM/HHONPGIVVMNWDPHGMPS1QZr*NPGIVR\e`L`LJA PH\/SP`LJoUDXWIJW\/ E EJA\^U#V
T/JAU#.VGF GW\/UHMWHONPJ $2JLHOU#MP EMRWIGIV UDXWJ J1Q RQc ?\/SPK2JAFo ENE\eVGIVJLV&HONPJ \/DPVVG\/S2-EJLGSPdl\
0
2
− 2
σ
σ
x− E
∆
f(x− E)
∆
k9GIdcDEU#J2*Q-\ VOaeJLH`N MeX HNPJlF!McKEG JLK \^DPVVG\/S KEGIVHU#G-EDPHGIMcS1Q S M/HJHONE\YHoHONPGIVWGIV\
-PGF!MPK \/W KEGIVHU#G-EDPHGIMcS_*GIHON \/DPVVG\/S<HO\eGmWIV8Q
6]C]
g 9@ =65 b +>r> @`b @B> jrk^@ 7 9je@Bg
S Mr_HONE\eHq_ J*NE\ T/J,\F!JLHNPMcK _NPGI`N!_,McUa/V_,JWmWPXbMcU\ScDEF!-EJAU MYX JAUU#McUqKEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcSPV VJLJ
HO\/-XWIJLV**Q c*Q /HONPJ EDPJLVHGIMcS\/U#GIVJLV cKEMPJLV,GIH _,McUa XMPU'\/WmW`NPM^G`LJLV MeX 7r*NPJ&\/SPV_,JAU+HM
HONPGIV,GIV\ UF OSPM P-/.oTPGU#HODPJMeX[\ KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS<_,J&NE\ T/J`A\ WWIJLKHONPJ&F!MPKEG JLK \^DPVVG\/S
KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS1Q \UWHNPMcDPdcN HONPGIVKEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS _ GWmWSPM/H-EJDPVJLK X McU<\ dcU#JA\eHWSPDEF!-EJAU<MeX
\/ E XWIGI`A\eHGIMcSPV ?GIH`A\^DPVJLV EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V XbMcU,McDEU*F JLHONPMcK6Q bH*GIVd/GIT/JAS-/.
2
2
b*Qc f
_NPJAU#J GV\2`LMcSPVHO\/S^H8Q r*NPGIV6-PGF!MPK \/WKEGVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS GIVWVOaYJLH`NPJLK GS dcDEU#J Q*Q r*NPJ
k MPDEU#GIJAU V \/ XW\e`LJ!HOU\^SPV#X MPUF MeX J1Q'*Qc f GIV
.
b*Qc *
r*NPGIVUWJA\YKEVHM
b*Qb/
S\/F!J
2
l+GF!McK \ W
2
2
X McU
X McU X McU
l+GF!McK \ W & E EMcSPJAS^HG\/WIV
/ /1 XbMcU XbMcU XbMcU
r \/-XWIJ*Q@`& PHGFo\/W\e`L`LJA PH\/SP`LJUDXWIJLV,XbMcU'-PGF!MPK \/WKEGIVHOU G-EDPHGMPSPV"V9VGF!GmW\/U*HMHONPJF!MPKXV
G JLK&\/DPVVG\/S KEGVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS JGQ Qc f P-EDPH*XbMcU+_NPGI`LNHONPJF!JLHNPMcK%McDPH WIGSPJLKlGSVJL`LHGMPS
*Q^ Q GV VODP`LJLVV#XBDXW
MeX LJAU#McJLV X MPU '(
_NPGI`NGV DPVHJASPMcDPdcN HM V`ADE E EJAUMPDEUF!JLHONPMPK6Q \*HHONPGIV
EM^GS^H_,JoSPM/HJ!HONE\YHHONPJ \/DPVVG\^SlKEGIVHU#G-EDPHGIMcS] EU MrT^JLK HU#McDE-XWIJLVMcF!J VMGH GIV EJAUNE\/ PV
SPM/H VODEU EU#GIVGSPdHONE\eHGIH!GIV!HONPJ6F McKEG JLK \^DPVVG\/S KEGVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS HNE\eH&XB\/WmWIV!X MPDXWQ7r \/-XWIJ
*Qz`LMcS/H\eGSPV6\2VDEFoFo\/U#.MeX&M/HONPJAU<-PGF!McK \ WKEGIVHOU G-EDPHGMPSPVhVRVGF!GmW\/U<HMhHNPJ F!MPKEG JLK
\^DPVVG\/S<_NPGI`LNKEMWSPM/H VOD JAU,HONPJ&VO\/F J EU#Mc-XWIJAF!V8Q
\HONPJAUFo\ W \e`L`LJA PH\/SP`LJhUDXWIJlXbMcU HONPJ F McKEG JLK &\/DPVVG\/S KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcS`A\/S -J
XbMcDESPK6Q Me_,JLT/JAU P_,JFRDPVHU#JWIG S DPGIVON2HNPJGSPVGIVHO\/SP`LJ HONE\eH XbMcU %-EJWIMe_VMcF!J
HONEU#JLVNPMRWIK6Q X9_,J`LNPM/VJ&HONE\YH
P_NPJAU#J *\/SPK \/U J`LMcSPVHO\/S^HV PHONPJAS
_,J%SPK XbMcU XbMcU b*QbE
r*NPGIVGV&VaeJLH`LNPJLKlGS dcDEUJR*Q^ Q S M/HJ&HONE\YH*HONPGIV&GIV \<U\eHONPJAUMcKEK2\e`L`LJA PHO\/SP`LJ!UDXWIJ VGSP`LJ
GIH*GIV SPM^HF!McSPM/HMcSPGI`A\/WmW.KEJL`AU JA\eVGSPd \eV*GIV*HONPJ `A\eVJXbMcU+M/HONPJAU,`LNPM/GI`LJLVMYX Q
\ WIHONPMPDPdcNGIH*GIVVO\eHGIV#Xb.cGSPd<HONE\eH*\<UDXWIJ`A\/S-J&XbMcDESPK HNPGV GV&\IWIJLVVHONE\/S% EJAU XbJL`LH
VGIHODE\eHGMPS1QlZhJNE\ T/JW\/S\/ E EU#MP\e`N _NPGI`LNh_,McUa/V _ JWmW,GS]F \/S/.2VGIHODE\YHGIMcSPV8Q *Me_,JLT/JAU
HONPJAU#J&GIV`WIJA\/U WI. \!VGHDE\eHGIMcS<GS_NPGI`LN%GH KEMcJLV&SPM/H*_,McUa;Q@r*NPJU#JLVODXWIHV&U#JA McU#HJLKGS%HO\/-XWIJ
*Q VONPMe_ `WIJA\/U WI.lHNE\eH*-PGF McK \/WIGIH#.MeX9HONPJ&KEGIVHGU#G-EDPHGIMcS%GIV SPM/H,GSGIHVJWX'HNPJ&`A\/DPVJ&MeX9HONPJ
KEGW`ADXWIH#.RQCu*DEUU#JAS^H WI. SPM_*\A.2NE\eV&-EJLJASzXMcDESPK2HMKEJLHJAUF!GSPJo_NPGI`LN2KEGIVHOU#G-EDPHGIMcSPV _*GmWW
−βσ 0
x
2
2
0
1
A(x)
k9GIdcDEU#J**Q^6\ VaeJLH`LN&MeXHONPJ,HONPJAUFo\/WE\e`L`LJA PHO\^SP`LJUDXWIJ,XbMcUHNPJF McKEG JLK \/DPVVG\^SKEGIVHU#G_V
-EDPHGIMcS1Q r*NPGIV\e`L`LJA PHO\^SP`LJRUDXWIJGIV& EJAU#`ADXWIG\/UGSHNE\eH,GHGIV SPM^HF McSPM/HMcSPGI`A\/WmWI.lKEJL`AU JA\eVGSPd
3 !#"$% &'
r(*)+-,-./(-+/,-0 *0&(-124335,*687-0:9;+-<=(*243?>@1A1B<6824C*10&(*240+/<-1$9D3$2E>-FD1G0:+H6#2EI417*)+E.-)1A339DJE1AFDK
6+/)L1G7*)1AMA9D3181A3:09N682401A3+4O 2 QPSR +-)05(-1MB243:1+4OT05(-11AU*7*+/<-1B<V09N24FC*9D305)L9W>*,-0:9;+-< 05(-9D39;3
MAFD1B2E)FDKX<-1AMA1A3352E)LK=39N<-MA18YS182E)18<-+E0$2E>-FD180+Q39N6,-FW2Z01[2#05(-1B)6824F3:K/30:1B6\9]O
^31A1
052E>-FD1[_@PN` aY?(-1B)1 b9D3$05(-1#Y9DC*05(+4OT05(-1#1B))+/)aC*9D305)9N>*,-09D+/<c2E<-Cd9D30&(-1G9N<VJE1B)31#01B6e
7*1B):2405,*)1EPfg<#05(-1 h2E,-3:39N2E<MB243105(-9D3T9D3<-+E0S<-1AMA1A3352E)K -39N<-MA105(-1 h2E,-33:9W2V<C*9D305)9N>*,-09D+/<
Og24FDF;3a+4i=Og24301B)j05(*2E<Q1AU*7*+/<-1B<V09N24FkPSl+4YS1AJE1B) V+/,*)S61A05(-+-CmC*1A3MB)9N>*1AC2E>*+4JE1Y9DFDFn>*1AMA+/6H1
FD1A33$2E<-CmFD1A33?1QMA9;1B<V0$,*<-F;1A3:3 C*1AMB)L1B2431A3$240SF;1B2Z30h2Z3TOg2430243 X9N<-MB)1B243:1A3BP
o
1MA+/<-3:9;C*1B)j05(-1$2E,-339N2E<C*9D30&)9N>*,-09D+/< p1%P-_*Pq_.E1B<-1B)240:1ACOr)L+/6)2E<-C*+/6s3&2E6e
7-FD9N<-. ^1%P_*PqtAPuR9N<*ImvwS24FDF ]x4y z24C*C )1A33:1AC=05(-19;3:35,-1+4OMA(-+/+E3:9W<-.Q05(-1352E687-FD13:9 A1>EK
69N<-9N69D39N<-.m05(-1$MA+/687*,-0&2409D+/<*24FMA+E30S+4O24MAMA1B7-09N<-.[<-1B,-05)2ZF{6H+|JV1A3 }Op+/)~Y?(-9DMA(42 AP
(-,-3 *05(-1AKQMA+/<-39DC*1B)1AC%<-C*9N<-.
Y(-9;MA(=6H9W<-9N69D31A3
A E
_*PqE_V
(-1$3+VFW,-0:9;+-<m+4O05(-9D3?9D3.E9DJE1B<m>VK
N`tE
_*PqExV
