Gas Dehydration Using
Glycol
Manning and Thompson, Volume I
Chapter 8
Outline
•
Introduction
•
Process Description
•
Design Methods
•
Design Examples
•
Troubleshooting
NATCO Glycol Dehydration Unit
The NATCO glycol dehydration process removes water vapor from natural gas. Removing water vapor prevents hydrate formation and corrosion, and maximizes pipeline efficiency.
Why Should We Dehydrate Gas?
•
If left in gas, water can cause:
–
Solid hydrate formation under certain conditions.–
Corrosion, especially in the presence of CO2or H2S.–
Slugging (two-phase flow) and erosion.–
Increase in specific volume and decrease in theheating value of gas.
–
Freezing in cryogenic and refrigerated absorptionplants.
•
Sales gas contracts and/or piping specifications
have a maximum water content (typically 7 lb
mper MMscf).
Methods of Dehydration
•
Liquid Desiccants (glycols):
–
Desiccant is substance that has an affinity for water–
Usually the choice of dehydration method is betweenglycol and solid desiccants.
–
Glycol dehydration is by far the most commonly usedMethods of Dehydration
•
Solid Desiccants (alumina, silica gel, molecular
sieves):
–
Characterized by porous structure that contains verylarge internal surface areas (200-800 m2/g) with very
small radii of curvature (0.001-0.2 mm)
–
Strong affinity for water–
Capacities between 5-15% by weight–
Can dry gas to less than 0.1 ppm of water or a dewpoint of –150 °F.
Methods of Dehydration
•
Expansion Refrigeration:
–
Also known as low-temperature extraction (LTX).–
Employs Joule-Thompson expansion (isothermalexpansion) to dry the gas and recover condensate.
–
J-T expansion requires large pressure drops.–
Because of large pressures drops, LTX is used onlywhen the prime objective is condensate recovery.
•
Calcium Chloride:
–
Anhydrous calcium chloride absorbs 1 lbm H2O per lbmGlycol vs. Solid Desiccants
•
Advantages of glycol over solid desiccants:
–
Lower installed cost (Kohl and Riesenfeld, 1979)• 50% less at 10 MMscfd • 33% less at 50 MMscfd
–
Lower pressure drop (5-10 psi vs. 10-50 psi for drydesiccants).
–
Glycol dehydration is continuous rather than batch.–
Glycol makeup is easily accomplished.–
Glycol units require less regeneration heat per poundof water removed.
–
Glycol units can typically dehydrate natural gas to 0.5lbm H2O/MMscf
Glycol vs. Solid Desiccants
•
Disadvantages of glycol over solid desiccants:
–
Water dew points below -25 ºF require stripping gasand a Stahl column.
–
Glycol is susceptible to contamination.Comparison Continued
•
Advantages of solid desiccants:
–
Dew points as low as –150 ºF.–
They are less affected by small changes in gaspressure, temperature and flow rate.
–
They are less susceptible to corrosion or foaming.Comparison Continued
•
Disadvantages solid desiccants:
–
Higher capital cost and higher pressure drops.–
Desiccant poisoning by heavy HC’s, H2S, CO2, etc.–
Mechanical breaking of desiccant particles.–
High regeneration heat requirements and high utilitycosts.
•
Bottom Line:
–
Glycol dehydration is by far the most commonly process.Choice of Glycol
•
Ethylene glycol (EG)•
Diethylene glycol (DEG)•
Triethylene glycol (TEG)•
Tetraethylene glycol (TREG)•
TEG has gained almost universalacceptance as the most cost-effective choice because:
– TEG is more easily regenerated
– TEG has a higher decomposition temperature of 404 ºF while DEG is 328 ºF.
– Vaporization losses are lower than EG or DEG
– TEG is not too viscous above 70 ºF.
EG
DEG
TEG TREG
TEG dew point depressions range from 40 – 150 oF while
inlet pressures and
temperatures range from 75 – 2500 psig and from 55 to 160
oF, respectively.
Flow Diagram for TEG Dehydration
(Typical of Wellhead Unit)
Remove Liquid and
solids
Wet Glycol Needs Reconcentration Remove
Water Vapor
Preheat Rich Glycol & Cool Lean Glycol
Reboiler boils water out of
Flow Diagram for Glycol System
Skimmer Added to Remove Condensate Additional Heat Exchangers Added to Reduce Fuel Consumption & Protects Glycol PumpGlycol Absorber with Integral
Scrubber
50% of All Dehydration Problems are Caused by Inadequate Scrubbing of Inlet Gas Absorber Section Usually Contains 4 to 12 Bubble Cap Trays TEG Circulation Rates of 1.5 to 4 gal per lbm water removed Gas GlycolSkimmer or Flash Tank
•
Purpose:– Knock Condensate out of Glycol
•
Operating Parameters:– Two-Phase Separator with 5-10 minutes retention time required.
– Or Three-Phase Separator with 20-30 minutes liquid retention time.
– Optimum Conditions are 100-150 ºF and 50-75 psig.
– Better condensate-glycol separation is obtained with horizontal flash tanks; vertical separators require less platform space.
Rich Glycol & Condensate Feed Rich Glycol to Reboiler
Filters
•
Purpose:– Prevent pump wear, plugging of heat exchangers, foaming, fouling of contactor trays, cell corrosion and hot spots on the fire tubes.
•
Operating Parameters:– Keep solids below 100 ppm
– Sock filter designed to remove 5 micron and larger particles
– Sock filters are designed for an initial pressure loss of 3 to 6 psi and change out at 15 to 25 psi.
– Activated charcoal filters used to remove condensate, surfactants and treating chemicals.
Glycol Pump
•
Purpose:– Returns LP lean glycol to HP contact tower.
•
Operating Parameters:– Contains only moving parts in unit
– A spare pump should be provided since dehydration stops when glycol circulation stops.
– Typically a positive displacement (PD) pump.
– Can be HP gas, HP liquid, or electric motor driven.
Surge Tank
•
Purpose:– Reservoir to handle a complete drain-down of TEG from the absorber-tower trays.
•
Operating Parameters:– Should be designed to operate at half full under normal operation.
– A gas blanket is recommended to prevent oxygen contamination.
Reboiler
•
Purpose:– Provides heat necessary to boil the water out of the rich or wet glycol.
•
Operating Parameters:– Direct fired heaters often used onshore.
– Indirect heating offshore.
– TEG does not undergo thermal decomposition if temperature is kept below 400 ºF.
– U-shaped fire tube should be sized for 6000-8000 Btu/hr-ft2.
– Water comes off as steam.
Instrumentation – Lean Design
LAH on integral scrubber in contactor
TAH on glycol temperature in reboiler OR on stack gas temperature
BAL on flame in main burner LAL on glycol level in glycol flash tank LAH on glycol level in glycol flash tank Shutdown Panel
SDV on pilot fuel line (activated by shutdown panel) SDV on fuel line to main burner (activated by shutdown panel)
PCV on fuel line to main burner PI on fuel line to main burner
BSL flame sensor on burner (to shutdown panel) TSH on stack gas temperature (to shutdown panel) TIC on glycol in reboiler connected to TCV on fuel gas to main burner
TI on glycol in reboiler
TSH on glycol in reboiler (to shutdown panel) PSV on reboiler shell
Reconcentrator
LC on contactor TI on contactor PI on contactor PC on exit gas line Contactor CONTROLS ITEM High temperature shutdown TSH Temperature indicating controller TIC Temperature indicator TI Temperature control valve TCV
High level temperature alarm
TAH
Shutdown valve SDV
Pressure shutdown valve PSV
Pressure indicator PI
Pressure control valve PCV
Pressure control PC
Low liquid level alarm LAL
High liquid level alarm LAH
Level control LC
Burner flame sensor BSL
Low burner flame alarm BAL
Operating Temperatures
<200 (prefer 180) TEG entering pump
380 – 400 (prefer 380) 350 yields 98.5 wt% TEG 400 yields 99.0 wt% TEG Reboiler
210
190 with stripping gas Top of still
300 – 350 Glycol into still
100 – 150 (prefer 150) Glycol into filters
100 – 150 (prefer 150) Glycol into flash
separator or skimmer
5 – 15 warmer than gas Glycol into absorber
80 – 100 Inlet gas TEMPERATURE OR TEMPERATURE RANGE (ºF) PROCESS LOCATION
Process Operation
•
Contactor or Absorber:
–
Operating efficiency depends on the inlet gas flowrate, temperature, and pressure and also the lean glycol concentration, temperature, and circulation rate.
•
Inlet Gas Flow Rate:
–
Load (lbs water to be removed/hr) varies directly withfeed gas flow rate.
–
Most contactors have been designed conservativelyand can handle flow rates 5 to 10% above capacity.
–
Lower flow limit set by 5 to 1 turndown ratio of theProcess Operation
•
Inlet Gas Temperature:
–
Inlet gas may be assumed to enter the absorbersaturated with water vapor.
–
McKetta and Wehe’s correlation shows that at 1000psia, the water content increases from 33 to 62 to 102
lb H2O/MMscf as the temperature increases from 80,
to 100 to 120 ºF.
–
Pressure is not as severe: at 100 ºF, the water contentis 62, 72 and 87 lbmH2O /MMscf at 1000, 800 and 600
psia.
•
Entering TEG temperature and concentration:
–
The drying ability of the TEG is limited by thevapor-liquid equilibrium of water between the gas phase and the liquid TEG phase.
Dew Point Chart
Process Operation (cont’d)
•
Glycol Circulation Rate:
–
The water picked up by the glycol increases with inletglycol concentration, decreasing glycol temperature, higher circulation rates, and the number of contactor trays.
–
A glycol circulation rate of 3 gal/lbm water removed isconservative but commonly used in the past.
–
Recent energy conservation practices have loweredthe rate to 2 gal/lbm of water removed.
Process Operation (cont’d)
•
Dehydration Temperature:
–
While TEG can dehydrate natural gas at operatingtemperatures from 50 ºF to 130 ºF, the preferred temperatures range is 80-100 ºF.
–
Below 70 ºF, glycol is too viscous.–
Above 110 ºF, the inlet gas contains too much waterand the drying ability of the glycol is reduced.
•
Reconcentrator:
–
Usually operated at atmospheric pressure.Boiling Point of TEG Solutions
Normal range for ReboilerStripping Column
•
Purpose:
–
Increase glycol concentrationsup to 99.6 wt% by sparging stripping gas directly into the reboiler.
Optimum Values for Glycol Analysis
Design Method
•
Obtain Design Information
•
Select an appropriate combination of:
–
Lean glycol concentration–
Circulation rate–
Absorber trays•
Establish the required balances:
–
Material–
EnergyRequired Information
•
Inlet gas flow rate, pressure & temperature
•
Required water dew point or water content of
exit gas
•
Inlet gas analysis or inlet gas gravity & acid gas
content
Required Information
•
Other important considerations:
–
Available utilities–
Safety & environmental regulations for dischargingTEG-H
2O-VLE Comparison
•
Parrish et. al. (1986) compared existing VLE data for TEG-water-natural gas and found considerable disagreement.•
Dehydrated natural gas leaving absorber cannot contain less water than that which would be inequilibrium with entering lean glycol.
•
Equilibrium is never reached.•
In practice, the water dew point of dried gas leaving the absorber is 5-10 ºF higher than equilibrium dew point.•
Rule of thumb, dew-point depression is60 ºF for first four trays and 7 ºF for each additional tray.
Glycol Absorber (Contactor)
•
Sizing the absorber involvesspecifying:
– Type and number of trays
– The TEG circulation rate
– The column diameter
•
Sizing can be done by charts such asSivalls (1976) or Worley (1987) or more recently by Olbrich and Manning (1988):
– Actual trays: 4-12
– Lean glycol conc., w/o 98.5-99.9
– Circ. rate, gal TEG/lb H2O 1.5-6
– Temperature, ºF 80 and 100
Glycol Absorber Diameter
•
Diameter of Absorber:Vmax = maximum gas superficial velocity (ft/hr)
Ksb = Souders-Brown coefficient (ft/hr) = 660 ft/hr for towers 30” larger with
18” tray spacing.. rL = Glycol density (lbm/ft3)
rV = Gas density at column conditions
(lbm/ft3) V V L SB max K V r r -r = max V Q 4 D p = A V Q= max
Predicted Dew Point Depression
Predicted Dew Point Depression
2 & 2.5 Equilibrium Stages, 100 ºF and 600 psia
Predicted Dew-Point Depression
Predicted Dew Point Depression
1 & 1.5 Equilibrium Stages – 80 ºF, 600 psia
Predicted Dew Point Depression
Predicted Dew Point Depression
3 Equilibrium Stages – 80 ºF, 600 psia
Glycol Pump
•
Sizing Pump:– Use Reciprocating pump
– Assume pump efficiency of 70-80%
– Calculate temperature rise based on converting mechanical work into enthalpy change.
– Can use quick estimate for pump break horsepower
( )( )
( )(
)
hour
per
TEG
gallons
gph
psig
gph
10
2
.
1
kW
psig
gph
10
2
.
1
BHP
5 5=
´
=
´
=
-Glycol Flash Separator
•
Wet glycol is flashed at 50-100 psia and 100-150 ºF.•
Liquid retention times are 5-10 min. for gas-glycol.•
Liquid retention times are 20-30 min. for gas-condensate-glycol.•
Vertical Separator:– Height (ft) = 3.4 + (0.4) (gpm)
– Where gpm = gal TEG circulated/min
– Minimum height =4 ft – Maximum height =10 ft – Minimum diameter =1.5 ft
•
Horizontal Separator: – L/D ratio = 3 – Min. length = 3 ft – Min. diameter = 2 ftGlycol Stripping Still
•
Computer programs usually consider the stripping column as three theoretical trays:– Reboiler
– Packed stripping column
– Reflux condenser
•
Diameter of stripping column is based on the required vapor and liquid loads at the base of the column.•
An approximate diameter equation is where D = Still diameter (in)Q = TEG circulation rate (gpm)
•
Conservative design and field test datadictate that the packed section should be at least 4 ft high, and that this height be increased to 8 ft for a 1 MMBtu/hr unit (Sivalls, 1976)
Q 9 D=
Glycol Reboiler
•
Duty can be calculated as:where Qr= regenerator duty Btu/lbmH2O m = gal TEG/lbmH2O
•
A more detailed procedure is illustrated inthe design example below.
– Design duty is calculated requirement duty plus 5% of condenser and glycol exchanger duties.
– Vapor disengagement area is based on 14,000 Btu/hr-ft2heat flux across the vapor liquid
interface.
– Reboiler shell L/D ratio is 5.
– Minimum D is 1.5 ft, minimum L = 3.5 ft.
m 966 900
Qr = +
Glycol Heat Exchangers
Reflux condenser
glycol-glycol
Lean-glycol-dry gas
Glycol Heat Exchangers
•
Reflux Condenser Exchanger:
–
Design duty plus 5% for fouling.–
Seider-Tate correlation used for the heat transfercoefficient.
•
Glycol-glycol:
–
Design duty + 5% for fouling. Entering temperaturesfor the lean and rich streams known.
–
Set the “approach” or lean glycol in – rich glycol out =60 ºF to minimize preheat of the rich glycol.
–
Two or more heat exchangers should be placed inseries to avoid any temperature cross.
•
Lean glycol cooler:
–
Lean glycol outlet temp. should be 5-10 ºF hotter thanthe inlet gas to absorber. Therefore, the lean glycol is cooled from 180-200 ºF down to 110 –120 ºF.