Hedging Linear Risk
Hedging Linear Risk
gi ng L in ea r R is k
Overview
Risk that can be measured can be
managed. This chapter turns to the
active management of market risks.
Hedging consists of taking position that lowers
the risk profile of the portfolio.
Farmers can use futures to hedge the price risk of
their product.
The objective of hedging is to find the optimal
Terminology
Static hedging
, which consists of
putting on, and leaving, a position
until the hedging horizon.
Dynamic hedging
, which consists of
continuously rebalancing the
portfolio to the horizon. This can
create a risk profile similar to
A thought on Hedging
It’s important to note that if the objective
of hedging is to lower volatility, hedging will eliminate downside risk but also any upside potential.
The objective of hedging is to lower risk,
not to make profits, so this is a double-edged sword.
Whether hedging is beneficial should be
Unitary Hedge
Consider US exporter expecting to receive 125,000,000 JPY in seven mths.
OTC is not available cannot get perfect position.
Use futures instead. CME lists YEN contract with face value of 12,500,000 YEN which expires in 9 mths.
Exporter places order to short 10 contract, with
the intention of reversing the position in seven months when the contract will have two mths until maturity.
Since the amount sold is the same as the
Futures Hedging
Suppose that the yen depreciates sharply, or
that the dollar goes up from Y125 to Y150.
This lead to a Loss on the anticipate cash
position
Y125,000,000 x (0.006667- 0.00800) = -$166,667
This loss, however, is offset by a gain on the
futures, which is
(-10)x Y12,500,000x {0.006711- 0.00806} = $168,621
The net is a small gain of $1,954.
Basis
Define Q as the amount of yen transacted and S and
F as the spot and futures rates, indexed by 1 at the initial time and by 2 at the exit time.
The P&L on the unhedged transaction is Q[S2 – S1] instead, the hedged profit is
Q[(S2 – S1)– (F2 – F1 )] = Q[(S2 – F2)– (S1 – F1 )] = Q[B2 – B1]
Where B = S - F is the basis. The hedged profit
depends only on the movement in the basis.
Hence, the effect of hedging is to transform price
risk into basis risk.
A short hedge position is said to be long the basis,
Basis Risk
Basis risk arises when the characteristics of the
futures contract differ from those of the underlying position.
Give an example.
For most commodities, basis risk is inevitable. Basis risk is higher with cross-hedging (using
totally different asset to create the hedge position)
Basis risk is lowest when the underlying position
Optimal Hedging
Suppose a fund manager holding a
portfolio of corporate bond that should out perform the index.
She fears that the interest rate will
increase.
Due to transaction costs, she cannot sell
the whole portfolio and buy it back later.
Optimal Hedging
Define ΔS as the change in the dollar value
of the inventory and ΔF as the change in the dollar value of one futures contract.
The manager is worried about the future
movement in the price, ΔS
If the manager goes long N futures
contracts, the total change in the value of the portfolio is
Optimal Hedging - MVHR
The variance of the total profit is equal to
Differentiating with respect to N
Setting the above equation to zero and solving for
N we find
Optimal Hedging - MVHR
Here S consists of the number of units (shares,
bonds, bushels, gallons) times the unit price (stock price, bond price, wheat price, fuel price).
Define Q to be the number of units of S and let s
be the unit price S = Qs
Define Qf to be the number of units of F and let f be the unit price of the future F = Qf f
Optimal Hedging - MVHR
Hence
N
*can be expressed as
Where
β
s,fis the coefficient in the
regression of
Δs/s
over
Δf/f
.
Thus, the best hedge is obtained from
a regression of the change in the value
of the inventory on the value of the
Variance of the Profit
Substituting N* into
Hedge Effectiveness
We measure the quality of the optimal
hedge ratio in terms of the amount by which we decreased the variance of the original portfolio:
Hedge Effectiveness
We can also express the volatility of the
hedged position from using the R2 as
This shows that if R2 = 1, the regression is a
perfect fit and the resulting portfolio has zero risk. In this situation, the portfolio has no basis risk.
However if R2 is very low, the hedge is not
Examples; Airline
An airline knows that it will need to purchase 10,000
metric tons of jet fuel in 3 months. It wants some protection against an upturn in prices using futures
The company can hedge using heating oil futures
contracts traded on NYMEX.
The notional for one contract is 42,000 gallons. As there is no futures contract on jet fuel, the risk
manager wants to check if heating oil could provide an efficient hedge instead.
The current price of jet fuel is $277 per metric ton. The
Application of Optimal Hedging: Duration Hedging
Modified duration can be viewed as a
measure of the exposure of relative changes in prices to movements in yields
D* is the Modified Duration and D*P is called
the dollar duration.
We can write the change in the cash position
Application of Optimal Hedging: Duration Hedging
The variance of the cash position is
The variance of the future position is
The covariance is given by
Application of Optimal Hedging: Duration Hedging
Alternatively,
N
*can be derived using
which is zero when the net exposure,
Using future to modified the portfolio’s duration
More generally we can use N as a tool
to modify the total duration of the
portfolio, If we have a target duration
of
D
V.
Application of Optimal Hedging: Beta Hedging
We now turn to equity hedging using stock
index futures. Beta, or systematic risk can be viewed as a measure of the exposure of the rate of return on a portfolio i to movements in the “market” m:
where β represents the systematic risk, α the
Application of Optimal Hedging: Beta Hedging
Thus we can write as an approximation
Now assume that we have a stock index with a
beta of 1, then
We can then write the total portfolio payoff as
Beta Hedging - Effectiveness
The optimal hedge with stock index futures
is given by the beta of the cash position times its value divided by the notional of the futures contract.
The quality of the hedge will depend on
the size of the residual risk in the market model. For large portfolios, the