Chief Minister’s
School Reforms Roadmap
School Reforms Roadmap
•
To improve quality, access and governance in education at school
level, the chief minister launched School Reforms Roadmap in April
2011.
•
Roadmap activities involve submission of monitoring report for
every district against various parameters which include staff
absenteeism, student attendance etc.
•
Data is submitted to a centralised database maintained by the
PMIU-PESRP, it is analysed and used for creating district-wise and
division-wise ranking on quarterly basis.
Programme Monitoring and
Goals for the Roadmap
•
Every child enrols in school
•
Every child is retained in school
•
Every child learns and makes progress
3
The Chief Minister is expecting
improvement in the following areas
Access
Quality
Governance
Approach
•
Identi
fic
ati
on o
f Para
meters
•
Select
io
n of
Targets
•
Result
Based
Ap
praisa
l
•
Out
put
& O
utco
me
Analy
sis
Follow up on Parameters
PMIU
6
Monthly
Quarterly
Quarterly Indicators
Governance
Access
Teacher Presence
Student Attendance
School and Student Cleanliness
Non-teaching Staff Presence
Functioning of school Facilities
District Review Committee Meetings
Curtailing illegal Fee
District Staff School Visits
Missing facilities & Up-gradation
funds utilization
FTBs
16
16
14
4
16
6
2
6
3
4
Quality
Teacher’s Guide
DTE Visits
DSD Assesment
2
4
4
Various Targets
PMIU
10
Uniform
90%
100%
Trajectory
I-Uniform Targets
1. Schools Inspected by EDO and his Staff
2. DRC Meetings
3. Timeliness of data
4. Curtailing Illegal collection
5. Missing Facilities & Up-gradation – funds utilization
6. Provision of FTBs
7. Teacher guide presence and use
District Specific Trajectory
II-District Specific Trajectory
1. Teachers’ Presence
2. Non-Teaching Staff Presence
3. Student Attendance
4. School Cleanliness
5. Functioning of School Facilities
6. Aggregate mean score of DSD exams
Teacher Presence – Trajectory
Q1’13 Q4’12
Q3’12 Q2’12
Q1’12 Q4’11
Q3’11 Q2’11
Baseline
Chart Title
89
88
87
86
85
84
83
88.0
88.0
88.0
87.5 87.0
86.3
84.1
Method
to
PMIU
16
SAHIWAL FAISALABAD MIANWALI RAJANPUR NANKANA SAHIB MULTAN KHUSHAB LAYYAH SIALKOT NAROWAL JHANG M.B.DIN CHINIOT OKARA PAKPATTAN GUJRAT BAHAWALNAGAR RAWALAPINDI RAHIMYAR KHAN BHAKKAR HAFIZABAD ATTOCK BAHAWALPUR CHAKWAL GUJRANWALA LODHRAN SHIEKHUPURA LAHORE JHELUM MUZAFFARGARH KASUR T.T.SINGH KHANEWAL SARGODHA D.G. KHAN VEHARI SAHIWAL FAISALABAD MIANWALI RAJANPUR NANKANA SAHIB MULTAN KHUSHAB LAYYAH SIALKOT NAROWAL JHANG M.B.DIN CHINIOT OKARA PAKPATTAN GUJRAT BAHAWALNAGAR RAWALAPINDI RAHIMYAR KHAN BHAKKAR HAFIZABAD ATTOCK BAHAWALPUR CHAKWAL GUJRANWALA LODHRAN SHIEKHUPURA LAHORE JHELUM MUZAFFARGARH KASUR T.T.SINGH KHANEWAL SARGODHA D.G. KHAN VEHARI 82.43 75.99 82.20 74.59 79.00 81.12 84.33 77.64 81.10 81.40 83.82 83.38 83.02 85.37 81.53 83.00 82.19 85.42 82.22 86.94 82.90 83.37 82.23 84.20 81.86 82.28 81.27 84.38 83.36 82.17 83.49 86.61 82.63 80.06 82.33 81.19 82.43 75.99 82.20 74.59 79.00 81.12 84.33 77.64 81.10 81.40 83.82 83.38 83.02 85.37 81.53 83.00 82.19 85.42 82.22 86.94 82.90 83.37 82.23 84.20 81.86 82.28 81.27 84.38 83.36 82.17 83.49 86.61 82.63 80.06 82.33 81.19 1.57 2.59 1.61 2.78 2.15 1.80 1.22 2.36 1.81 1.75 1.32 1.40 1.47 1.01 1.73 1.47 1.62 1.00 1.61 0.69 1.49 1.40 1.61 1.24 1.67 1.60 1.78 1.21 1.40 1.62 1.38 0.76 1.54 1.98 1.59 1.79 1.57 2.59 1.61 2.78 2.15 1.80 1.22 2.36 1.81 1.75 1.32 1.40 1.47 1.01 1.73 1.47 1.62 1.00 1.61 0.69 1.49 1.40 1.61 1.24 1.67 1.60 1.78 1.21 1.40 1.62 1.38 0.76 1.54 1.98 1.59 1.79 84.44 82.20 83.87 76.96 79.88 81.36 84.04 76.95 80.35 80.55 83.16 82.65 82.15 84.60 80.21 81.65 80.68 81.38 76.24 84.58 77.88 78.68 77.17 80.68 77.68 78.76 77.93 82.14 81.10 79.69 81.44 85.62 80.65 77.70 80.54 79.29 84.44 82.20 83.87 76.96 79.88 81.36 84.04 76.95 80.35 80.55 83.16 82.65 82.15 84.60 80.21 81.65 80.68 81.38 76.24 84.58 77.88 78.68 77.17 80.68 77.68 78.76 77.93 82.14 81.10 79.69 81.44 85.62 80.65 77.70 80.54 79.29 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 76.15 70.58 58.60 51.45 50.44 48.03 40.80 24.12 23.79 8.29 6.21 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 76.15 70.58 58.60 51.45 50.44 48.03 40.80 24.12 23.79 8.29 6.21 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 80.86 73.40 80.59 71.81 76.85 79.32 83.11 75.29 79.30 79.65 82.50 81.98 81.55 84.36 79.80 81.53 80.58 84.42 80.61 86.25 81.41 81.97 80.62 82.96 80.19 80.68 79.49 83.18 81.96 80.55 82.11 85.86 81.09 78.08 80.74 79.40 80.86 73.40 80.59 71.81 76.85 79.32 83.11 75.29 79.30 79.65 82.50 81.98 81.55 84.36 79.80 81.53 80.58 84.42 80.61 86.25 81.41 81.97 80.62 82.96 80.19 80.68 79.49 83.18 81.96 80.55 82.11 85.86 81.09 78.08 80.74 79.40 3.58 8.80 3.28 5.15 3.02 2.04 0.93 1.66 1.06 0.90 0.66 0.67 0.60 0.24 0.41 0.12 0.10 (3.04) (4.37) (1.66) (3.53) (3.29) (3.44) (2.28) (2.51) (1.93) (1.56) (1.04) (0.85) (0.86) (0.67) (0.23) (0.45) (0.38) (0.20) (0.11) 3.58 8.80 3.28 5.15 3.02 2.04 0.93 1.66 1.06 0.90 0.66 0.67 0.60 0.24 0.41 0.12 0.10 (3.04) (4.37) (1.66) (3.53) (3.29) (3.44) (2.28) (2.51) (1.93) (1.56) (1.04) (0.85) (0.86) (0.67) (0.23) (0.45) (0.38) (0.20) (0.11)District
Calculation for District
Specific Targets
Trajectory
Score
Comparative
Score
District Ranking
for
Activities
with
Curtailing Illegal Fee/Funds
–
Sep 2012
%
K
H
U
SH
A
B
B
A
H
A
W
A
LN
A
G
A
R
B
H
A
K
K
A
R
C
H
A
K
W
A
L
D
.G
. K
H
A
N
FA
IS
A
LA
B
A
D
JH
A
N
G
K
A
SU
R
K
H
A
N
EW
A
L
LA
H
O
R
E
LO
D
H
R
A
N
M
A
N
D
DRC Meetings
–
Jul to Sep 2012
%
A
tto
ck
B
ah
aw
aln
ag
ar
B
ah
aw
alp
ur
B
ha
kk
ar
C
ha
kw
al
C
hin
io
t
D
.G
.K
ha
n
Fa
isa
lab
ad
G
ujr
an
w
ala
G
ujr
H
at
afiz
ab
ad
Jh
an
Jh
g
elu
m
K
ha
ne
w
al
K
hu
sh
ab
La
ho
re
La
yy
ah
Lo
dh
ra
n
M
.B
.D
in
M
ian
w
ali
M
uz
aff
arg
arh
N
an
ka
na
S
ah
ib
O
ka
Pa
ra
kp
att
an
R
.Y
.K
ha
n
R
aja
np
ur
R
aw
alp
in
di
Sa
hiw
al
Sa
rg
od
ha
Sh
eik
hu
pu
ra
Sia
lko
T.T
t
.S
in
gh
Ve
Timeliness of data
–
Sep 2012
%
Provision of FTBs –
Sep 2012
%
JH
A
N
G
LO
D
H
R
A
N
M
A
N
D
I B
A
H
A
U
D
D
IN
O
K
A
R
A
JH
EL
U
M
B
H
A
K
K
A
R
M
U
LT
A
N
N
A
N
K
A
N
A
S
A
H
IB
C
H
A
K
W
A
L
C
H
IN
IO
T
PA
K
PA
TT
A
N
T.T
.S
IN
G
H
SA
R
G
O
D
H
A
R
A
W
A
LP
IN
D
I
K
H
A
N
EW
A
L
B
A
H
A
W
A
LN
A
G
A
R
R
A
H
IM
YA
R
K
H
A
N
SA
H
IW
A
L
VE
H
A
R
I
G
U
JR
A
N
W
A
LA
M
IA
N
W
A
LI
K
H
U
SH
A
B
LA
H
O
R
E
K
A
SU
R
M
U
ZA
FF
A
R
G
A
R
H
R
A
JA
N
PU
R
FA
IS
A
LA
B
A
D
LA
YY
A
H
SH
EIK
H
U
PU
R
A
A
TT
O
C
K
B
A
H
A
W
A
LP
U
R
H
A
FIZ
A
B
A
D
G
U
JR
A
T
N
A
R
O
W
A
L
D
.G
. K
H
Teacher Guide–
Sep 2012
%
JH
A
N
G
C
H
IN
IO
T
G
U
JR
A
N
W
A
LA
H
A
FIZ
A
B
A
D
K
H
U
SH
A
B
LO
D
H
R
A
N
M
A
N
D
I B
A
H
A
U
D
D
IN
SA
R
G
O
D
H
A
SIA
LK
O
T
VE
H
A
R
I
T.T
.S
IN
G
H
R
A
W
A
LP
IN
D
I
SA
H
IW
A
L
B
A
H
A
W
A
LN
A
G
A
R
O
K
A
R
A
PA
K
PA
TT
A
N
FA
IS
A
LA
B
A
D
B
H
A
K
K
A
R
N
A
N
K
A
N
A
S
A
H
IB
R
A
H
IM
YA
R
K
H
A
N
JH
EL
U
M
K
H
A
N
EW
A
L
G
U
JR
A
T
M
U
ZA
FF
A
R
G
A
R
H
A
TT
O
C
K
C
H
A
K
W
A
L
LA
YY
A
H
B
A
H
A
W
A
LP
U
R
M
U
LT
A
N
M
IA
N
W
A
LI
K
A
SU
R
N
A
R
O
W
A
L
D
.G
. K
H
Missing Facilities & Upgradation – Funds
Utilization
%
A
TT
O
C
K
B
A
H
A
W
A
LN
A
G
A
R
B
A
H
A
W
A
LP
U
R
B
H
A
K
K
A
R
C
H
A
K
W
A
L
C
H
IN
IO
T
D
.G
. K
H
A
N
FA
IS
A
LA
B
A
D
G
U
JR
A
N
W
A
LA
G
U
JR
A
T
H
A
FIZ
A
B
A
D
JH
A
N
G
JH
EL
U
M
K
A
SU
R
K
H
A
N
EW
A
L
K
H
U
SH
A
B
LA
H
O
R
E
LA
YY
A
H
LO
D
H
R
A
N
M
.B
.D
IN
M
IA
N
W
A
LI
M
U
LT
A
N
M
U
ZA
FF
A
R
G
A
R
H
N
A
N
K
A
N
A
S
A
H
IB
N
A
R
O
W
A
L
O
K
A
R
A
PA
K
PA
TT
A
N
R
A
H
IM
YA
R
K
H
A
N
R
A
JA
N
PU
R
R
A
W
A
LA
PIN
D
I
SA
H
IW
A
L
SA
R
G
O
D
H
A
SH
EIK
H
U
PU
R
A
SIA
LK
O
T
T.T
.S
IN
G
H
VE
H
A
R
I
-
10.00
20.00
30.00
40.00
50.00
60.00
70.00
80.00
90.00
100.00
Fun
ds n
ot y
et t
ran
sfer
Schools Inspected by EDO & his staff –
Sep’
2012
%
90% Target
B
H
A
K
K
A
R
C
H
IN
IO
T
D
.G
. K
H
A
N
FA
IS
A
LA
B
A
D
G
U
JR
A
T
H
A
FIZ
A
B
A
D
JH
A
N
G
JH
EL
U
M
K
H
A
N
EW
A
L
K
H
U
SH
A
B
LA
H
O
R
E
LA
YY
A
H
M
A
N
D
Activities
Teachers' Presence –
Sep 2012
SA
H
IW
A
L
C
H
IN
IO
T
K
H
A
N
EW
A
L
LO
D
H
R
A
N
M
U
LT
A
N
B
A
H
A
W
A
LP
U
R
O
K
A
R
A
G
U
JR
A
T
D
.G
. K
H
Non-Teaching Staff Presence –
Sep 2012
SA
H
IW
A
L
LO
D
H
R
A
N
JH
EL
U
M
M
U
LT
A
N
K
H
A
N
EW
A
L
SA
R
G
O
D
H
A
C
H
IN
IO
T
H
A
FIZ
A
B
A
D
M
A
N
D
I B
A
H
A
U
D
D
IN
D
.G
. K
H
Student-Attendance –
Sep 2012
JH
EL
U
M
T.T
.S
IN
G
H
SA
H
IW
A
L
FA
IS
A
LA
B
A
D
M
A
N
D
I B
A
H
A
U
D
D
IN
R
A
W
A
LP
IN
D
I
LA
H
O
R
E
K
H
A
N
EW
A
L
G
U
JR
A
T
A
TT
O
C
K
SA
R
G
O
D
H
A
SIA
LK
O
T
C
H
IN
IO
T
M
U
LT
A
N
VE
H
A
R
I
H
A
FIZ
A
B
A
D
G
U
JR
A
N
W
A
LA
JH
A
N
G
N
A
R
O
W
A
L
LO
D
H
R
A
N
LA
YY
A
H
PA
K
PA
TT
A
N
B
A
H
A
W
A
LP
U
R
M
U
ZA
FF
A
R
G
A
R
H
K
H
U
SH
A
B
O
K
A
R
A
B
A
H
A
W
A
LN
A
G
A
R
M
IA
N
W
A
LI
R
A
H
IM
YA
R
K
H
A
N
R
A
JA
N
PU
R
C
H
A
K
W
A
L
K
A
SU
SH
R
EIK
H
U
PU
R
A
N
A
N
K
A
N
A
S
A
H
IB
B
H
A
K
K
A
R
D
.G
. K
H
Schools' Cleanliness – Sep
2012
M
U
LT
A
N
SA
H
IW
A
L
M
.B
.D
IN
T.T
.S
IN
G
H
LA
H
O
R
E
FA
IS
A
LA
B
A
D
JH
EL
U
M
G
U
JR
A
T
D
.G
. K
H
Functioning of Facilities –
Sep 2012
SA
R
G
O
D
H
A
M
A
N
D
I B
A
H
A
U
D
D
IN
VE
H
A
R
I
SA
H
IW
A
L
LA
H
O
R
E
G
U
JR
A
T
C
H
A
K
W
A
L
T.T
.S
IN
G
H
LO
D
H
R
A
N
JH
EL
U
M
FA
IS
A
LA
B
A
D
K
H
A
N
EW
A
L
PA
K
PA
TT
A
N
A
TT
O
C
K
M
U
LT
A
N
O
K
A
R
A
SIA
LK
O
T
C
H
IN
IO
T
R
A
W
A
LP
IN
D
I
G
U
JR
A
N
W
A
LA
K
A
SU
R
N
A
N
K
A
N
A
S
A
H
IB
JH
A
N
G
LA
YY
A
H
K
H
U
SH
A
B
SH
EIK
H
U
PU
R
A
B
A
H
A
W
A
LP
U
R
B
H
A
K
K
A
R
H
A
FIZ
A
B
A
D
N
A
R
O
W
A
L
B
A
H
A
W
A
LN
A
G
A
R
M
IA
N
W
A
LI
M
U
ZA
FF
A
R
G
A
R
H
R
A
H
IM
YA
R
K
H
A
N
D
.G
. K
H
Overall – District Ranking – Sep’12
%
SA
HIW
AL
M
.B
.D
IN
JH
EL
UM
FA
ISA
LA
BA
D
KH
AN
EW
AL
T.T
.SIN
GH
LA
HO
RE
CH
IN
IO
T
RA
W
AL
AP
IN
DI
VE
HA
RI
M
UL
TA
N
LO
DH
RA
N
SA
RG
O
DH
A
LA
YY
AH
GU
JR
AT
HA
FIZ
AB
AD
M
UZ
AF
FA
RG
AR
H
JH
AN
BA
G
HA
W
AL
PU
R
N
AR
O
W
A
L
O
KA
RA
PA
KP
AT
TA
N
SIA
LK
O
T
GU
JR
AN
W
AL
A
KH
U
SH
AB
M
IA
N
W
AL
I
N
AN
KA
N
A S
AH
IB
D.G
. K
HA
N
RA
JA
N
PU
R
SH
IEK
HU
PU
RA
BA
HA
W
AL
N
AG
AR
AT
TO
CK
BH
AK
KA
R
RA
HIM
YA
R K
HA
N
KA
Top 5 Districts
1- Sahiwal
2- M.B.Din
3- Jhelum
Lowest 5 Districts
32- Attock
33- Bhakkar
34- R.Y.Khan
35- Kasur
District Teachers' Presence Non-Teaching Staff Pres.
Student Attendance
School visits by Admn.
DRC Meetings
Timely backup
received Cleanliness
Functioning
Facilities Curtailing Illegal fee
Provisio n of FTBs
Teacher Guide usage SUM
SAHIWAL 15.55 3.90 15.29 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.89 5.88 2.00 3.97 2.00 74.48
M.B.DIN 15.08 3.81 15.24 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.87 5.90 2.00 4.00 2.00 73.90
JHELUM 15.22 3.86 15.43 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.59 5.80 2.00 4.00 1.97 73.88
FAISALABAD 15.07 3.78 15.24 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.81 5.79 2.00 3.94 1.98 73.61
KHANEWAL 15.37 3.83 15.17 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.39 5.79 2.00 3.98 1.97 73.50
T.T.SINGH 15.15 3.19 15.41 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.87 5.83 2.00 3.99 2.00 73.44
LAHORE 15.21 3.35 15.20 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.84 5.88 2.00 3.95 1.87 73.31
CHINIOT 15.47 3.81 15.08 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.09 5.72 2.00 3.99 2.00 73.17
RAWALAPINDI 15.11 3.43 15.22 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.03 5.70 2.00 3.98 2.00 72.46
VEHARI 14.17 3.72 15.05 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.03 5.89 2.00 3.97 2.00 71.83
MULTAN 15.29 3.83 15.06 16.00 4.00 1.00 2.90 5.75 2.00 4.00 1.95 71.79
LODHRAN 15.33 3.90 14.79 14.94 6.00 1.00 1.93 5.80 2.00 4.00 2.00 71.69
SARGODHA 13.63 3.82 15.15 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.14 5.90 2.00 3.98 2.00 71.62
LAYYAH 14.90 3.58 14.76 16.00 6.00 1.00 1.64 5.63 2.00 3.94 1.96 71.40
GUJRAT 15.23 1.68 15.17 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.41 5.87 1.94 3.91 1.97 71.19
HAFIZABAD 13.54 3.81 14.98 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.28 5.57 2.00 3.92 2.00 71.10
MUZAFFARGARH 15.04 2.41 14.60 16.00 6.00 1.00 1.77 5.52 2.00 3.95 1.96 70.25
JHANG 12.65 3.79 14.92 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.07 5.67 2.00 4.00 2.00 70.10
BAHAWALPUR 15.28 3.77 14.62 14.03 6.00 1.00 1.65 5.62 2.00 3.92 1.96 69.85
NAROWAL 15.08 3.75 14.86 16.00 4.00 1.00 1.61 5.57 2.00 3.90 1.94 69.71
OKARA 15.27 3.28 13.85 14.31 6.00 1.00 1.77 5.74 2.00 4.00 1.99 69.21
PAKPATTAN 12.79 2.27 14.67 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.25 5.78 2.00 3.99 1.99 68.73
SIALKOT 15.10 3.72 15.10 12.01 6.00 1.00 1.71 5.74 2.00 3.85 2.00 68.22
GUJRANWALA 14.85 1.61 14.95 12.21 6.00 1.00 1.77 5.69 2.00 3.97 2.00 66.05
KHUSHAB 8.14 3.09 14.56 16.00 6.00 1.00 1.97 5.62 2.00 3.96 2.00 64.34
MIANWALI 11.85 1.76 12.69 16.00 6.00 1.00 1.23 5.53 2.00 3.96 1.94 63.96
NANKANA SAHIB 15.08 3.60 6.64 16.00 6.00 1.00 1.85 5.68 2.00 3.99 1.98 63.82
D.G. KHAN 15.22 3.81 6.38 16.00 6.00 1.00 2.40 5.08 2.00 3.86 1.93 63.69
RAJANPUR 14.61 3.65 8.22 14.42 6.00 1.00 1.83 4.82 2.00 3.95 1.91 62.41
SHIEKHUPURA 14.90 2.80 6.99 16.00 6.00 1.00 1.41 5.62 2.00 3.93 1.75 62.41
BAHAWALNAGAR 11.06 2.89 13.19 12.63 6.00 1.00 1.34 5.54 2.00 3.98 1.99 61.63
ATTOCK 11.09 3.78 15.17 7.75 6.00 1.00 2.07 5.78 2.00 3.93 1.96 60.53
BHAKKAR 7.09 3.80 6.52 16.00 6.00 1.00 1.23 5.60 2.00 4.00 1.98 55.21
RAHIMYAR KHAN 11.96 2.77 10.29 7.43 6.00 - 2.02 5.49 2.00 3.98 1.97 53.91
KASUR 11.23 1.66 7.18 13.60 4.00 - 1.40 5.68 2.00 3.95 1.94 52.66
