GRUPPO CARIGE
GRUPPO CARIGE
GRUPPO CARIGE
GRUPPO CARIGE
1
25 May 2010
Agenda
Carige Group at a glance
Key financial highlights
Key financial highlights
FY09 results
1Q10 results
Strategic Priorities
g
Banca Carige Group today
Fondazione CR
Genova e
Imperia
Market
CEP
Groupe BPCE
~50,000 small
shareholders
Assicurazioni
Generali
44.06%
44.06%
37.99%
37.99%
Banca Carige
Banca Carige
SpA
SpA
14.98%
14.98%
2.97%
2.97%
Insurance
Banking
Finance
Banca Carige
Banca Carige
SpA
SpA
Cassa di Risparmio di Genova e Imperia
Cassa di Risparmio di Genova e Imperia
Trustee
Insurance
Banking
Finance
• Banca Carige
• CR Savona
• Carige Vita Nuova (life)
• Carige Ass.ni (non life)
• Carige AM SGR
• Creditis (Consumer
Trustee
• Centro Fiduciario
• CR Carrara
• BM Lucca
• B. Cesare Ponti
credit)
Main Companies Only
5,895
EMPLOYEES
665 BRANCHES
(*)&
414 INSURANCE OUTLETS
842 CONSULTANTS
1.9 M CUSTOMERS
(
1.2 M BANKING; 0,7M ASSURANCE)
EQUITY
3.8 € BILLION
3
Operational and accounting data as at 31 March 2010
(*) Including the 22 MPS branches
Growth through a long season of acquisitions
Year
Capital collected
Mln. Euro
Year
Acquisitions
Mln. Euro
1994-95 IPO
105
1993-95-99 Cassa di Risparmio di Savona
228
1996-97
Bond conversion into new shares
61
1991-06-09 Insurance companies
473
1997
Capital increase underwritten by La Basilese
46
1999-2009
Banca del Monte di Lucca
80
1998
Capital increase underwritten by
institutional investors
116
2000
21 branches from Banco di Sicilia
60
1999
Capital increase underwritten by CNCEP,
CDC, WestLB
236
2001
61 branches from Gruppo Intesa
277
2003-06
Capital increases and issue of subordinated
convertible bonds
521
2002
42 branches from Gruppo Capitalia
127
2006
Issue of a LT2 loan
500
2003
Cassa di Risparmio di Carrara
174
2008
Capital increase
957
2004-2010
Banca Cesare Ponti
69
Issue of subordinated loans (Tier 1, Lower
Tier 2, Upper Tier 2, Tier 3)
510
2008
79 branches from Intesa Sanpaolo
853
2009
Issue of a LT2 loan
100
2008
40 branches from UniCredit Group
115
2010
Issue of convertible bonds
392
2010
22 branches from Monte Paschi
130 *
Total
3,544
Total
2,586
* Amount subject to price adjustment
GRUPPO CARIGE
4
Carige purchased 22 branches
from Monte dei Paschi di Siena
ex MPS branches
All the 22 ex MPS branches are located in Tuscany.
22 BRANCHES
22 BRANCHES
Other Carige’s branches
Direct
Deposits
Indirect
Deposits
28
p
€871m
€667m
Loans (*)
€850
Price (**)
€130
15
21
3
3
1
1
€850m
€130m
Employees
Customers
1
1
1
1
data as at 30 Sept 2009
156
59,000
1
2
1
(*) Average amount (Jan Sept 2009)
1
(*) Average amount (Jan-Sept 2009)
(**)Subject to adjustment
5
Total branches in Tuscany
79
A more and more diversified network
ex Unicredit
branches
ex ISP
branches
new
branches
The network today (*)
ex MPS
branches
branches
branches
643 22
branches
56/
21
46/
35
1
/1
5
9
71/
64
branches
665
2
522
79
643
40
22
1
56/
21
28/
20
79/
21
2/
8
5/
12
254/
14
France
1989
2007
2009
137
39/
40
22/
8
9/
35
17
3
5
TODAY
96%
48%
100%
72%
39%
71%
11/
23
3
26
38%
69%
% of
Branches
in Liguria
% of Branches
in
Northern Italy
Banking branches 665
Insurance outlets
414
63/
52
GRUPPO CARIGE
6
in Liguria
Northern Italy
Operational data (*) ex MPS branches includedAmong the top Italian banking Groups
37.8
29 6
#5Market Cap
(1)(€b)
• Ordinary shares 2.7 €b #8
Total Assets FY09 (€b)
929
29.6
5.6
5.2
3 2
2 9
#5 y • Savings shares 0.5 €b #8625
225
136 122
60 44
5
3.2
2.9
2.4
2.1
1.6
1.3
0.9
(1) Data as at 12 May 2010122 60 44 36 26 25 23
Domestic Branch Network FY09 (#)
#8
C/I (%) FY09
#4 ( ) y #85,991
4,696
3,088
2,291
1 955
42.9% 55.6% 55.7% 56.9% 58.1%64.2% 66.5% 66.8% 69.1% 69.8% 70.7%2,291
1,955
1,286
795
643
575
515
278
7
Among the top Italian banking Groups
12.6%
* Net of the AFS reserve established against the revaluationof the equity investment in the Bank of Italy
Loans to Customer FY09 (€b)
ROE (%) FY09
565
7.2%
5.6%
4.1% 4.0%
3.0% 2.9% 2.7% 2.4% 2.4%
1 5%
#8 #2374
152
98
95
1.5%
98
95
45
33
23
20
18
18
Tier 1 ratio (%) FY09
Core Tier 1 ratio (%) FY09
#7 #6 * Data as at 3Q09 12.6% 8.7% 8.6% 8.5% 8.4% 8.0% 7.9% 7.7% 7.5% 7.2% 6.6%
8.1% 8.0% 7.6% 7.4%
7.1% 7.1% 7.0% 6.6%
6.2%
#7 #6 Data as at 3Q09GRUPPO CARIGE
Operational data and accounting data (FY09 report)8
Agenda
Carige Group at a glance
Key financial highlights
Key financial highlights
FY09 results
1Q10 results
Strategic Priorities
g
Focus on retail
Private
&
Other
by area (*)
by segment
South
Affluent
2.4%
Mass
Market
26.8%
Small
Business
Public
Entities
4.4%
Other
9.5%
L
O
A
N
S
Liguria
37.7%
Centre
18.5%
&
Isles
6.3%
10.1%
Large
Corporate
9.6%
SME
37.3%
S
LOANS TO CUSTOMERS FY09 : 23.1 €b
(*) by customers’ residence
North
37.5%
T
O
T
A
L
by area
by segment
Other
South
&
Isles
L
D
E
P
O
Affluent
&
Mass
Market
48.5%
Private
20.4%
Other
20.3%
Centre
12.5%
5.6%
O
S
I
T
S
TOTAL DEPOSITS FY09 : 46.9 €b
3 b 2009
Corporate
10.8%
Liguria
59.8%
North
22.0%
GRUPPO CARIGE
10
Data as at 31 December 2009Operational data and accounting data (FY09 report) Small business = turnover<1 m ; SMEs= <100 m€; Large Corporate= >100 m€
Customer based funding
1Q10
€m
%
I
b
k d
i
1 229 5
4 6
Funding
Interbank deposits 5%Interbank deposits
1,229.5
4.6
money market deposits
and current accounts
680.4
2.5
other deposits
549.1 2.1
Customer deposits
22,332.1 83.5
short term deposits
14 985 8
56 0
Customer deposits 83% Subordinated Securitisation 1% Covered Bonds 4%
short term deposits
14,985.8
56.0
medium/long term deposits
and bonds
7,346.3
27.5
EMTN programme
938.0 3.5
deposits
50.0
0.2
bonds
888.0 3.3
Retail bonds
EMTN programme 4% Subordinated loans 4%Subordinated loans
966.6
3.6
floating rate bonds
956.7
3.6
convertible fixed rate bonds
9.9
0.0
Securitisation
290.7 1.1
RMBS performing securities
290.7
1.1
300
New issues for 1.6
€b in FY09 (0.8 €b
net of expired
bonds)
New issues for 0.6
€b in 1Q10 (0.7 €b
net of expired
bonds)
p
g
Covered Bonds
1,000.0
3.7
TOTAL FUNDING
26,756.9
100.0
100 200€m
Funding as at 31 March 2010 includes
‐
Jan‐09 Feb‐09 Mar‐09 Apr‐09 May‐09 Jun‐09 Jul‐09 Aug‐09 Sep‐09 Oct‐09 Nov‐09 Dec‐09
Funding as at 31 March 2010 includes
further:
-90.3 million from the securitization carried
out in 2001, derecognised in the financial
statement pursuant to the exemption
allowed by IFRS 1 on first time adoption
11
issued bonds expired bonds Data as at March 2010
-500 million of covered bonds eligible for
RePo
No pressure on liquidity
Current Debt Maturity Profile
Capital market operations
Operation
Issue
Date
2008
Capital increase
957 € m
March
Tier 3
100 € m
June
451 €m2,130
1,635
1,623
1 800
2,000
2,200
Lower Tier 2
100 € m
June
Tier 1
160 € m
December
Covered bonds (*)
500 € m
December
5 callable in 2011
1,635
1,437
1,067
970
1,623
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
1,600
1,800
PL Securitization
853 € m
December
Upper Tier 2
150 € m
December
2009
110
326
410
235
20
0
200
400
600
800
Lower Tier 2
100 € m
June
Covered Bonds (*)
1,000 € m
November
2010
C
ibl b
d
400 €
F b
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Institutional
Totale
€m
Convertible bonds
400 € m
February
Total
4,320 € m
(*)
On a 5 € b plafond
CustomersGRUPPO CARIGE
12
Data as at March 2010 Operational dataSound assets
Intangible
assets
1 7
Other
4.4
12%
Total asset breakdown
Financial assets (*)
Net
loans
to
customers
Financial
assets
7.8
21%
Tangible
assets
1.1
3%
1.7
4%
12%
Debt
securities
94%
Mutual
funds
2%
22.3
60%
21%
2%
Hedge
funds
<1%
Equity
and
private
equity
3%
Securitization
1%
Gross loan splitting
(*) Data do not include the stake in Bank of Italy and
the notional value underlying customers’ index linked policies
Total 6.8 €b
Total assets 37.3 €b
1%
3%
Debt securities and securitisation
bad loans 4% mortgage loans to individuals 37%
A
19%
AAA
5%
BBB
7%
Other
2%
short tem 21% 37% consumer credit 4% loans to corporate 58% m/l term 75%AA
67%
13
Gross loans to customers 22.9 €b
Data as at 31 March 2010
Sound credit policy
Bad loan ratio (%)
NPL ratio (%)
8.7% 6.7% 2.0% 4.0% 6.0% 8.0% 10.0%4.0%
2.2%
0.0%
2.0%
4.0%
6.0%
2.0%Dec 07 Dec 08 Mar 09 Dec 09 Mar 10 Gross NPL ratio Net NPL ratio
0.0%
Dec
07
Dec
08
Mar
09
Dec
09
Mar
10
Gross
bad
loan
ratio
Net
bad
loan
ratio
Gross NPL growth on December 2008
Carige Group
‐
Dec 09
+10.1% +19.8% +31.2% +40,7% +35.9% +40.6% +47,6% 50000 60000 70000
System
‐
Dec
09
(132.8€b;
+52.6%)
+10.5% +15.8% +26.1% +34.4 % +12 6% +8 7%+95,7% 600 700 800 900Carige
Group
Dec
09
(1.9€b;
+47.6%)
+14.4% +16.6% ... ... ... +20.4% +36.5% +59.4% +70,4% 0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 ‐1.1% +0.6% +12.6% +8.7% +0.8% ... ... ... ‐6.2% +8.3% +4.6% 95,7% 0 100 200 300 400 500GRUPPO CARIGE
14
Operational data and accounting data (FY07 report – FY08 report – 1Q09 report – 1H09 report – 3Q09 report - FY09 report – 1Q10 report)
Source: B.I.P. Bollettino Statistico
08 Mar 09 June 09 Sept 09 Dec 09
Sofferenze Incagli Ristrutturati Past due
Robust capital ratios
Capital Ratios (%)
FY09 FY09
TOTAL CAPITAL RATIO 10.03%
TIER 1 RATIO 7.87%
Core TIER1 RATIO 7.06%
14.00%
8 00%
10.00%
12.00%
T1 min
T1 recommended
4.00%
6.00%
8.00%
T1 Carige Group
TCR min
TCR recommended
TCR Carige Group
2.00%
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
Core T1 Carige Group
15
Agenda
Carige Group at a glance
Key financial highlights
Key financial highlights
FY09 results
1Q10 results
Strategic Priorities
g
FY09
– Growth of Deposits and Loans
46 9
TOTAL DEPOSITS
€bGROSS LOANS TO CUSTOMERS
€b + 8.8%
FY08
46.9
43.1
FY09
23.1
21.1
+ 9.5%FY08
FY09
DIRECT DEPOSITS
€bFY08
FY09
LOANS TO INDIVIDUALS
of which:
+ 15.9%25.7
22.2
€bLOANS TO INDIVIDUALS
€b + 1.2%7.2
7.3
CUSTOMER DIRECT DEPOSITS LOANS TO CUSTOMERS=98%
FY08
FY09
INDIRECT DEPOSITS
€bFY09
FY08
LOANS TO CORPORATES
+1.3%21.2
21.0
change €bLOANS TO CORPORATES
€b +17.5%11.6
13.7
17
FY08
FY09
Operational data and accounting data (FY08 report – FY09 report)
FY09
FY09 –
Steady net profit
O
CO
S
-0.1% -5.6%1,018.8
1,078.7
PROFIT
CORE REVENUES
(*)€m €m
313.1
308.7
FY08
205.4
205.5
FY09
FY08
FY09
Gross profit +1.4%
Effect of interest
rate change
-250 €m
100.7
636 7
+4.8%COSTS
OTHER REVENUES
€m €m …-48.1
+4.8%636.7
607.5
From acquisitions
74.3 €b of direct
ti
t
FY08
FY09
FY08
FY09
change (*) Core revenues = Net interest income + Net commissions + Dividends
operating costs
FY09 –
Results of the Group’s companies
Change FY09/FY08
201.1
‐
10%
...
…
15.5
10 5
9.7
‐
34.3%
‐
47.2%
‐
52.8%
‐
48.0%
10.5
4.0
0,9
1.7
Cassa
di
Savona
Cassa
di
Carrara
Banca
del
Lucca
Banca
CARIGE
Risparmio
di
Risparmio
di
Monte
di
Cesare
Ponti
CREDITIS
SGR
4 9
7.2
19 2
Carige Vita Nuova
0,76.3
Carige
Assicurazioni
4.9
‐
24.1
19.2
‐
26.6
‐
30.8
IAS
No
IAS
2008
2009
IAS
No
IAS
19
Operational data and accounting data (FY09 report)
Data as at 31 December 2009
€m
Agenda
Carige Group at a glance
Key financial highlights
Key financial highlights
FY09 results
1Q10 results
Strategic Priorities
g
1Q10
– Growth of Deposits and Loans
22 9
€b
GROSS LOANS TO CUSTOMERS
€b46.6
TOTAL DEPOSITS
€b20.8
22.9
43.5
+ 6.9% + 10.2%1Q09
1Q10
DIRECT DEPOSITS
€bLOANS TO INDIVIDUALS
of which:
1Q09
1Q10
DIRECT DEPOSITS
€bLOANS TO INDIVIDUALS
€b+ 2.3% CUSTOMER DIRECT DEPOSITS LOANS TO CUSTOMERS
=98%
22.4
25.5
+13.5%7.2
7.4
INDIRECT DEPOSITS
€bLOANS TO CORPORATES
€b1Q09
1Q10
7.2
1Q09
1Q10
12.1
13.7
21.1
21.1
change €b €b +13.6% -0.1%21
1Q09
1Q10
1Q09
1Q10
1Q10 –
Steady net profit
PROFIT
CORE REVENUES
251.2
233 0
-28.9%
-7.2%
PROFIT
€mCORE REVENUES
(*) €m75.0
56.4
233.0
1Q09
1Q10
Gross profit -24.7%Effect of interest
rate change
-102 €m
45.1
32.1
1Q09
1Q10
COSTS
OTHER REVENUES
€m €m +31.9%20.0
156.1
156.6
+0.3%From acquisitions
18.7 €b of direct
ti
t
15.1
change (*) Core revenues = Net interest income + Net commissions + Dividends
operating costs
1Q09
1Q10
1Q09
1Q10
Agenda
Carige Group at a glance
Key financial highlights
Key financial highlights
FY09 results
1Q10 results
Strategic Priorities
g
Our mission
Carige Group aims to be a national financial conglomerate equipped to
provide banking, financial, insurance and pension solutions, focused on
retail, pursuant to the development of resources and structures
and the enhancement of an integrated multi-channel distribution system
g
y
Quality of
• Complete offer of
• Widespread
Specialisation of
• Distribution
Conglomerate
National
resources and
Quality of
Multi-channel
structures
Retail
F
i
• Complete offer of
banking, financial
and insurance
products and
services
A
ti
i t
• Widespread
presence in Italy
especially in
certain areas and
strong presence in
Liguria
• Distribution
system based
on branches,
mobile and
remote
channels
• Specialisation of
distribution and
production structures
• Unitary management
of the Group’s
key-i
• Focusing on
families, SMEs
and local public
entities
• Widespread and
• Aggregation point
for smaller banks
Liguria
• Focused on the
relationship with
local communities
channels
expertises
• Professional
development of
human resources
• IT system in line with
intensive use of
technology
GRUPPO CARIGE
24
• IT system in line with
best practice
Growing results from the acquired banks
Year of
the deal
CAGR
Loans and
Deposits (€ b)
P
d l
2009
Net Income
(€ m)
P
d l
2009
P
d l
C/I
(%)
2009
P
d l
ROE
(%)
2009
Banca del Monte
Banca del Monte
11.2%
Pre-deal
2009
21.0%
Pre-deal
2009
4.0
Pre-deal
2009
61 5
86.5
-25 p.p.Pre-deal
2009
8.0
+5.3 p.p.∆
p.p.
1999
Banca del Monte
Banca del Monte
di Lucca
di Lucca
(#21
(#21 branches
branches))
2.0
0.7
10.5%
0.6
15 5
61.5
-8.5 p.p.3.9%
2.7
+5.3 p.p.1999
Cassa di Risparmio
Cassa di Risparmio
di Savona
di Savona
(#50
(#50 branches
branches))
5 9%
2.8
4.1
16 9%
5.7
15.5
71.4
62.9
-9.4 p.p.8.9
3.6
+4.4p.p.2003
Cassa di Risparmio
Cassa di Risparmio
di Carrara
di Carrara
(#34
(#34 branches
branches))
5.9%
3.0
2.1
16.9%
4.1
10.5
73.6
64.2
10.7
6.3
p p2004
(Dec)
Banca
Banca
Cesare Ponti
Cesare Ponti
(#4
(#4 branches
branches))
9.4%
1.1
1.7
…
0.9
91.6
-17.1p.p.74.5
3.1
+6.1p.p.25
“Pre-deal” data refer to the last Annual report before the acquisition. “Pre-deal” data of Banca Cesare Ponti refer to 2004 Annual report.
(#4
(#4 branches
branches))
-0.6
-3.0
Source: Companies data
…and from the purchased branches
Year of
the deal
CAGR
Loans and
Deposits (€ b)
Total revenues
(€ m)
C/I
(*)
(%)
7 0%
2000
2009
7.7%
2002
2009
2002
2009
-20.5p.p.∆
p.p.
2000
Banco di Sicilia
Banco di Sicilia
(#21
(#21 branches
branches))
7.0%
7.6%
0.8
0.5
7.7%
10.1
16.9
-13.6p.p.2001
2009
2002
2009
5.5%
2002
2009
66.4
45.9
2001
Banca Intesa
Banca Intesa
(#61
(#61 branches
branches))
2.0
3.6
43.7
63.6
59.0
45.4
p p2002
2009
2003 2009
2003
2009
2002
Capitalia
Capitalia
(#42
(#42 branches
branches))
2.2%
2.5
2.1
4.2%
49.1
2002
2009
2003 2009
38.3
50.6
74.4
-23.8 p.p.March
2008
Intesa
Intesa
Sanpaolo
Sanpaolo
Deal
-5.8%
6.0
6.4
2009
94.0
84.8
2008
2009
+2.6 p.p.58.1
55.5
2008
2009
10.9%
2008
Sanpaolo
Sanpaolo
(#79
(#79 branches
branches))
Dec
UCB
UCB
+2.2%
1 5
1 5
-22.0 p.p.68.1
90.1
28.9
…
GRUPPO CARIGE
26
(*): direct costs only
CAGR= compound average growth rate
Operational data
2008
(#40
The last two acquisitions show a high potential…
Employees/Branch
Customers/employee
Total intermediation/
employee (€/m)
4.7
4.1
5.0
Employees/Branch
387
273
293
/
p y
29.4
15.7
13.0
employee (€/m)
Liguria
Extra
Liguria
Of which ex
ISP/UC
Liguria
Extra Liguria Of which ex
ISP/UC
Liguria
Extra Liguria Of which ex
ISP/UC
Deposits/employee
(€/m)
43%
Loans/ total
intermediation
264
Contribution*/employee
(€/000)
17.6
7.6
4.8
29%
43%
25%
264
138
84
Liguria
Extra Liguria Of which ex
ISP/UC
Liguria
Extra Liguria Of which ex
ISP/UC
Liguria
Extra Liguria Of which ex
ISP/UC
27
Data as at 31 December 2009
* Contribution = revenues – direct costs
…to exploit
The ex ISP/UC branches:
•
are essentially retail;
•
have quite limited volumes of loans;
•
have relatively high rent costs;
Actions
Objective
Focus on
•
are relatively overstaffed.
New
customers’
acquisition
•
Campaigns/commercial
actions
•
HR
•
Products
The objective is to bring into alignment the
performance of these branches to those of
Liguria, increasing, at the same time, the
local penetration.
Higher
retention
•
Layout/logistics
•
HR
•
Pricing/conditions
The project being carried out is focused on ex
ISP/UC branches but it also regards other extra
Liguria branches. It aims:
of the existing
Enhancement
portfolio
•
Products
•
HR
•
to point out the short and medium term
priority
on each branch
•
to allow a constant monitoring
of the
Profitability
•
Volumes remix
•
Loans repricing
•
Funding repricing
•
HR
to allow a constant monitoring
of the
outcomes
•
to encourage the managerial approach
evolution
of the coordination between the
different levels of area manager
Costs
•
HR
•
HR
•
Rentals renegotiation
•
Branch relocation
GRUPPO CARIGE
28
The investment in the insurance companies…
In 1997, Banca Carige took over two insurance companies, one
operating in Life sector (Carige Vita Nuova, former Basilese Vita
Nuova) and one operating in Non life sector (Carige Assicurazioni,
Nuova) and one operating in Non life sector (Carige Assicurazioni,
former Levante Norditalia), for an overall consideration of €472.6
million, €271.4 million in the Life Company and €201.2 million for the
Non life Company .
p
y
The total investments made by the bank to take the control of these
The total investments made by the bank to take the control of these
two companies and to strengthen them are lower than the multiples
paid in the last main market transactions.
…the life company…
Transaction multiples in Life Sector
Year Target Bidder Quota Price (€m) Premiums Price/ EquityPrice/ Goodwill (1)/ Premiums
2005 Bipiemme Vita Fondiaria - SAI 46.0% 94.3 40.0% 3.93X 29.8%
2007 Arca Vita BPER 20.0% 53.0 43.9% 2.13X 23.3%
2007 MPS Vita AXA 50.0% 831.1 51.0% 3.73X 37.3%
2007 Berica Vita (Pop Vicenza) Cattolica Assicurazioni 50.0% 20.9 16.3% 1.28X 3.6%
2007 Vicenza Life (Pop Vicenza) Cattolica Assicurazioni 50.0% 23.2 26.8% 2.43X 15.8%
2007 BPV Vita Fondiaria - SAI 50.0% 530.0 147.2% 4.94X 117.4%
2007 DWS Vita Zurich Investment Life Spa 100.0% 97.3 121.2% 2.30X 68.6%
2008 UBI Vita AVIVA 50.0% 65.0 41.9% 1.57X 15.2%
2008 Quadrifoglio Vita S.p.A. MPS 50.0% 92.5 52.8% 1.77X 22.9%
2008 Quadrifoglio Vita S.p.A. AXA MPS Assicurazioni Vita S.p.A. 100.0% 141.5 40.4% 1.35X 10.5%
2008 Chiara Vita S.p.A. Helvetia SA 70.0% 79.6 119.1% 2.25X 66.1%
2008 CredemVita Credem 50.0% 50.0 16.9% 1.49X 5.6%
2008 BCC Vita Cattolica Assicurazioni 51.0% 44 72.6% 1.82X 32.8%
Average
60.8%
2.38X
34.5%
Carige Vita Nuova
Banca Carige
100%
271.4
28.6%
1,63X
11.0%
Carige Vita Nuova Pro Forma (2)
Banca Carige
100 0%
203 4
21 4%
1 22X
3 8%
Carige Vita Nuova Pro Forma (2)
Banca Carige
100.0%
203.4
21.4%
1,22X
3.8%
(1) Goodwill assessed as the difference between Price and Equity
(2) Investments excluding the surplus gained by Carige Assicurazioni by selling to the Parent Company Banca Carige 80% of its stake in Carige Vita Nuova (68 €m) in 1999 and 2000
…and the non life company
Transaction multiples in Non life Sector
Year Target Bidder Quota Price (€m) Premiums Price/ EquityPrice/ Goodwill (1)/ Premiums
2006 Liguria Assicurazioni Fondiaria - SAI 100.0% 148.1 84.4% 2.96X 55.9%
2006 Toro Assicurazioni Investitori Istituzionali 10.0% 327.4 115.4% 1.36X 30.8%
2006 Fineco Assicurazioni Fondiaria SAI 51 0% 56 0 >250% >5 >200%
2006 Fineco Assicurazioni Fondiaria - SAI 51.0% 56.0 >250% >5 >200%
2006 Toro Assicurazioni Generali 55.5% 2,139.0 136.6% 2.68X 85.7%
2006 Toro Assicurazioni Generali 33.5% 1,318.4 139.7% 2.74X 88.7%
2006 Duomo Assicurazioni Mapfre 50.0% 473.0 89.6% 2.37X 51.7%
2007 Aurora Assicurazioni Unipol 29.2% 657.2 67.9% 2.02X 34.2%
2007 Novara Assicura AVIVA 50.0% 250 >250% >5 >200%
2007 Toro Assicurazioni Generali 1.5% 61.0 139.8% 2.75X 88.9%
2007 Nuova Tirrena Groupama 100.0% 1,250.0 153.7% 4.52X 119.6%
2007 MPS Danni AXA 50.0% 181.4 >250% >5 >200%
2008 Padana Assicurazioni SpA Helvetia SA 100.0% 44.0 45.5% 0.25X neg.
2008 Credem Assicurazioni Reale Mutua Assicurazioni 50.0% 18 143.2% 2.92X 94.2%
2009 UBI Assicurazioni BNP/ FORTIS 50.0% 120 150.8% 4.04X 113.5%
Average
115.2%
2.60X
76.3%
Carige Assicurazioni
Banca Carige
98.4%
201.2
37.9%
1,42X
11.2%
Carige Assicurazioni Pro Forma (2)
Banca Carige
98.4%
338.8
63.8%
2,39X
37.1%
(1) Goodwill assessed as the difference between Price and Equity
(2) Investments including settlement costs (losses) and the surplus gained by selling to the Parent Company 80% of the stake in Carige Vita Nuova (68 €m) in 1999
The bancassurance is growing well
Life Premiums
996
996
92% via
banking
branches
588
153
284
€m
1999
2008
2009
1Q10
Stock premiums /
Total deposits
3.5%
5.0%
6.4%
7.0%
GRUPPO CARIGE
32
The non life business needed some intervention:
on the portfolio…
Portfolio mix
Portfolio mix
1999
2009
41.5%
51 1%
10.1%
18.2%
7.4%
51.1%
71.7%
Number of motor insurance contracts
Number of motor insurance contracts
Motor ins. Other car ins. P&C Ins. Motor ins. Other car ins. P&C Ins.