Efficient bargaining versus right to manage: a stability analysis with heterogeneous players in a duopoly with quantity competition and trade unions

Efficient bargaining versus right to

manage: a stability analysis with

heterogeneous players in a duopoly with

quantity competition and trade unions

Fanti, Luciano and Gori, Luca

Department of Economics, University of Pisa, Department of Law

and Economics "G.L.M. Casaregi", University of Genoa

1 November 2011

Online at

https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/34434/

$ % &'($()( * + ' , -. / 0 ' "' #

!

"

# $ %

& ' (

( )

) *

& + & , & &

! +-'& ,./& 01%& 2%/

3 _{1 $[email protected] [email protected]& $ 4/5 616 '' %- /-5& *$ 4/5}

616 '' %- /7.

33 _{+ 1 $[email protected] [email protected]& $ 4/5}

/-'

"# $

* ) )

" ) *

2 '661 )

: )

$ ; <

; < *

# )

, = %57% >

?

%57'& @ ) %57. %571 %

) #

( (

8 ( (

$ )

( ) (

)

)

( )

%551& 2 '661 )

$ %

) )

& ' )

)

A )

*

, %575& %551& B %557& @ C '666& + (2D E

! '66.& @ = '667& 8 '6%%

*

@ %55% %557&

B '66%& '6%6

* ) , *

%57-* ; <

)

) )

)

* ) *

/

" )

*

" * (

) ; (

) < )

$ ) # > )

+ (! ?

$

) #

# > )

!

F #

# > )

!

) G )

( )

8

# F

( )

( )

) *

) ) E #

= '

= / *

) + (! = .

F

= 1

%# ! # &

A ' ₊

) ) ) p=1−q₁−q₂ p>0

1

q q₂ 1 2 )

)

) 0<w_i <1 (

) i i=

{ }

1,2 q_i

i i L q =

.

, %575& %551& + (2D E ! '66. L_i

i

- * * H , = %57%

) > ) )

* Π_i

(

w_i,L_i

)

= pq_i−w_iL_i

> ) ) ( * U_i

(

w_i,L_i

) (

= w_i−w°

)

θL_i

0

>

θ )

/ °

w ) ) A

0

= °

w = q_i =L_i !

$

(

)

[

]

β

(

_θ

)

−β

⋅ −

− −

= 1

1 _{i j i i} i _i

i q q w q w q

V %

) q_i w_i 0≤β ≤1 )

i

* % q_i w_i

) $

(

)

[

]

(

)

(

)

β

β + − − = ⇔ = − − − − − + − ⋅ = ∂ ∂ 1 1 , 0 1 1

1 j i

i j i i i j i i j i i i

i q w

w q q q w q q w q q V q V ' %

(

)

(

)

[

(

)

]

{

}

(

)

( )

(

(

)

)

(

1

)

1

1 1 , 0 1 1 1 1 < − − − + − = ⇔ = − − − − + − − − − ⋅ = ∂ ∂ j i j i i i i j i i j i i i i q q q q w w w q q w q q V w V β θ

βθ β

β θ β β θ ' '

" ' ' ' % w_i i#

( $

( )

= _{+β +}−_θ

₍

_−β

₎

1 1 1 _j j i q q q /

*2 * H > ) ) *

> ) ) (

* %551

)

! % * i

i

w ' ' :

i# * )

( ) # $

(

)

2 1 , 0 2

1 _{i i j i j i} j i

i

i _{w q q q q w} q w

q − − = ⇔ = − − − = ∂ Π ∂ . : * ' ' . i$

( )

_ββ₊

(

_θ−

₍

₋

)

_β

₎

= 1 2 1 j j i q q q 1 / 1

/ _C θ ₁

1

'# (

2 q_i,t i# t=0,1,2,... q_i,t+1 $

(

_, , 1

)

, 1

,+ =argmax , Θ , jt+

e t i t i q t

i q q

q

t

i

-1 ,t+ j e

q ) j t *

i t+1 Θ_i,t

(

q_i,t,qej,t+1

)

! * V_i,t

(

q_i,t,qej,t+1

)

i

(

_, , 1

)

, , +

Π_it q_it qejt :

. _{+ ( I)} 1

1 2

) * : E '66/& J '66K&

'6%6 i *

) ( ) $ = ∂ ∂ + = + + t t t t t t t q q q V q q q EB , 2 1 , 2 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 1 , 1

: α K %

= ∂ Π ∂ + = + + t t t t t t t q q q q q q RTM , 2 1 , 2 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 1 , 1

: α K '

0

>

α > 1#

t

V_1,

t

, 1

Π q1,t )

- * * ' '

' % / K %

$

(

)

(

)

(

)

(

(

)

)

{

[

(

)

]

}

(

−

)

+ + − = − − − − + + − − + − − − − + − − + = + − + β θ β β θ β β θ β β β β θ β β α β θ β 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 , 1 1 , 2 , 2 , 1 , 2 , 1 1 , 1 , 2 , 1 , 1 , 2 , 1 , 1 1 , 1 t t t t t t t t t t t t t t q q q q q q q q q q q q q q 7

._{" + ( *}

1

+

t

) ) , *

-1 , 1 1 ,

1 q q

q t+ = t = q2,t+1=q2,t =q2

7 $

(

)

(

)

(

)(

(

)

)

{

[

(

)

]

}

(

−

)

− = + + − = − − − − + + − − + − − − − + − − − 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 q q q q q q q q q q q q β θ β β θ β β θ ββ β β θ β β α β θ β 5

* E_EB

(

q*1, q*2

)

7

$

(

−

)

+ +

(

−

)

+ + = β θ β β θ

β 2 1

1 , 1 2 1 EB E %6

" ) + (!

E 0 *

(

)

(

)

(

)(

)

[

]

(

)

[

(

(

)

)

]

(

−

)

+ + − + − − + + ΑΒ − − + + + + − + − − ΑΒ − = = 0 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 3 2 1 1 2 2 2 22 21 12 11 β θ β β θ

β β θ β

α β

θ

β β β β β

θ β θ α J J J J

J_EB %%

) ) J_ii Jij )

%6

(

)

[

]

0

1 2

: ₂ >

− + + = Α β β θ β β

(

)

(

(

)

)

0

1 2 1 1 2 1 : 1 > − + + − − + + = Β −β θ β θ β β θ β θ β

J ) $

( )

= + = −αΑΒ

[

θ

(

−β

)

−θ_β

(

₊β_θ

₍

+₋β_β−

₎

)

+

(

+β

)(

+β

)

]

= 1 2 1 3 2 1 1 : 2 2 2 22 11 J J J Tr

T_{EB EB} %'

( )

_[

₍

[

₎

_]

_[

(

₍

)

]

₎

_]

0 1

1 1

1 2

: 11 22 12 21 <

− + + ⋅ − + − + + ΑΒ − = − = = β θ β β θ β β θ β α J J J J J Det

DEB EB %/

7 $

( )

EB EB

EB T D

F λ =λ2 − λ+ %.

8 7

) λa λb %.

$

(

)

[

(

)

]

(

)

{

}

(

)

[

]

[

(

)

]

(

)

[

]

[

(

)

(

)

(

)

]

(

)

[

]

[

(

)

]

(

)

[

]

(

)

(

)

[

]

(

)

[

(

)

]

(

)

(

−

)

>

+ + + + − + − + − + − + + ΑΒ = > − + + − + + ΑΒ = > − + + ⋅ − + + + + − + − ⋅ − + + ΑΒ − − + + ⋅ − + + + − + − + − = 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 ) ( 0 1 1 1 2 ) ( 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 ) ( 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 β θ

ββ θ β β β β β

θ β θ β α β θ

β β θ β

α β θ β β θ

β β β θ β θ β

θ β α β θ β β θ

ββ θ β β β β β

θ EB EB EB H iii TC ii F i %1 ) %1

K

0

=

EB

F & )

1

+ TCEB =0& ! (= *

) 1 HEB =0 DEB =1 TEB <2

8 %1

) A ) (

) E_EB

( 7 2 ΡEB

(

α,β,θ

)

! %6 +

0

=

EB

F %1 $

(

)

{

(

)

[

(

)

]

(

)

}

(

)

[

2 1

]

[

(

1

)

2

(

1

)

1

(

1

)

]

0

1 1 1 1 2 : , , 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 = + + + − + − ⋅ − + + ΑΒ − + + − + − + − = Ρ β θ β θ β β θ β α β β β β β θ β θ θ β α EB %-!

( )

_[

{

(

₍

)

₎

_]

_[

₍

[

₎

2 2

(

₍

)

]

2

₎

(

)

₍

}

₎

2

_]

2 2 2 1 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 , β θ β θ β β θ β α β β β β β θ β θ θ β α + + + − + − ⋅ − + + ΑΒ + + − + − + − = EB F %K ) α

) " $ 0<α <αFEB

( )

β,θ 2 ( 32 2 4 15 2 64 - 4 E_EB

2 % 1 "7# - ( 8 - 4

* α =αFEB

( )

β,θ ( $ α >αFEB

( )

β,θ 2 ( 32 2 4 15 2

64 - 4 E_EB 4 - (

) = Ρ_EB

(

α,β,θ

)

>0 0<α <αFEB

( )

β,θ Ρ_EB

(

α,β,θ

)

=0

( )

β θ α

α = FEB , Ρ_EB

(

α,β,θ

)

<0 α >αFEB

( )

β,θ @ %

*# #+#

*2 * "

' ' . 1 K %

( $

(

)

[

(

)

]

(

)

(

)

(

−

)

+ − = − + − + − − + = + + β θ β β β θ β β θ β β α 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 , 1 1 , 2 , 1 , 2 , 1 , 1 1 , 1 t t t t t t t q q q q q q q %7

: %7 $

(

)

[

(

)

]

(

)

(

)

(

−

)

− = + − = − + − + − − 0 1 2 1 0 1 1 2 1 2 1 1 2 1 q q q q q β θ ββ β θ

β β θ β

β α

%5

* E_RTM

(

q*1, q*2

)

%7

) $

(

−

)

+

(

−

)

+ = β θ β β β θ

β β1 ,3 1

3

RTM

7 H $

(

)

(

)

[

]

(

)

[

]

[

(

)

]

[

(

)

]

(

)

(

)

[

+ −

]

⋅

[

+

(

−

)

]

⋅

[

+

(

−

)

]

>

+ = > − + = > − + ⋅ − + ⋅ − + + − + − − = 0 1 3 1 2 1 1 ) ( 0 1 2 ) ( 0 1 3 1 2 1 5 1 4 1 2 ) ( 3 2 2 2 β θ β β θ β β θ β αβ β θ β αβ β θ β β θ β β θ

β αβ β θ β β θ β

RTM RTM RTM H iii TC ii F i '% 8 '%

) Ρ_RTM

(

α,β,θ

)

! %6 +

0 = RTM F $

(

)

[

(

)

]

[

(

)

]

[

(

)

]

(

)

(

)

[

1 4 1 5

]

0

1 3 1 2 1 2 : , , 2 2

2 _{+ − + =}

− − − + ⋅ − + ⋅ − + = Ρ β θ β β θ β αβ β θ β β θ β β θ β θ β α RTM '' !

( )

[

(

_[

₍

)

]

₎

2

[

2

(

₍

)

]

₎

[

2

(

_]

)

]

5 1 4 1 1 3 1 2 1 2 , β θ β β θ β β β θ β β θ β β θ β θ β α + − + − − + ⋅ − + ⋅ − + = RTM F '/ ) α

) % $ 0<α <αFRTM

( )

β,θ 2 ( 32 2 4 15 2 64 - 4 E_RTM

2 % 1 " 7# - ( 8 - 4

* α =αFRTM

( )

β,θ ( $ α >αFRTM

( )

β,θ 2 ( 32 2 4 1

5 2 64 - 4 E_RTM 4 - (

) = Ρ_RTM

(

α,β,θ

)

>0 0<α <αFRTM

( )

β,θ Ρ_RTM

(

α,β,θ

)

=0

( )

β θ α

α = FRTM , Ρ_RTM

(

α,β,θ

)

<0 α >αFRTM

( )

β,θ @ '

*# #+# ,# " F " > %K '/ 8 %(.

* ) ) ) ) E

β

θ " αFEB

( )

β,θ αFRTM

( )

β,θ )

( )

α,β

) θ

= θ =0 β =1 (

* ) 8 %(.

5

θ -_"

α β

) ) αFRTM

( )

β,θ θ

α

β ) θ E ) αFEB

( )

β,θ

( θ

- " 9 3) ,:( 8 2 % * 2

4 ; -< θ - - 2 3) , (

θ 4 3) " ,# 2 2 - 4 - 4 αFRTM

( )

β,θ "αFEB

( )

β,θ # 4 % 2

( )

α,β 9 = *4 1!:(

- % 9 3):( 3) 2 4 ; - * * % ( ( β

1 0 4 - *4 4 - θ >0 9

= *4 1!:(

- ' 9 ,:( , 2 2 - % α β - *4 4

2 > θ( ?2 θ % 9 = *4 : 2

4 ; - * * % 4 - *4 4 1 - ( ?2 θ

- 2 *2 9 = *4 1!: 2 4 ; - * * % @ " #

- %2 2 4 % % " ( ( 2 *2 4 β#A " #

1 - %2 2 4 % 2 *2 " ( ( % 4

β#(

- , 9 - % 3) ,:( ?2 θ % 2

-* 2

( )

α,β 4 4 4 3) * 2 4 ,

2 2 4 % 2 5 2 - * * 9

= *4 :( ?2 θ - 2 *2 2 - * 4 3) % "2 *2 #

2 4 , %2 2 4 % % "2 *2# ( ( 2 *2 " %#

4 β(

- _!

( )

α_,β ₎

( )

β θ

%6

" 8

( )

α,β θ =0.1

% 8

( )

α,β θ =0.5

%%

, 8

( )

α,β θ =1.5

.# !

) )

"

!

"

# $ %

& ' (

) #

; ( ) <

F (

* )

( )

( ( )

-: E G ! : : '66/ ! +

%'

9 " B '66%

) * 0 ) M ? E .- K/L%66

9 " + + B =E ) E 8 '6%6 ! ?

= $ = (C

: 2 %551 H + : $ +

H ) @

0 %551 H ) 2 .K

51L%66

+ (2D E ! : '66. + ( $

)

) .7

-7%L-5-+ : %7/7 @ N N

@ $ G

, * : B %57- + ) " )

'K %6KL%''

, = %575 H ( 0 55 %%'/L%%.'

8 2 9 2 '6%% :

0 /K 'K6L'76

8 2 ! '6%% + (

/% '//L'..

B B %557 2 -% %51L'6%

2 ! = 0 '661 H

@ 2 = ?* $ ?* H )

@

EE + , %55% , E

0 " /% K5L%66

, " = %57% A :

) K% 75-L567

? : 0 %57' 0

5' 1K-L151

@ = '667 H ( $

0 51 %'%L%.K

@ ) 0 G %57.

> ) O 0 55 '%1L'/%

@ ) 0 G %571 A $

= ) 0 7K %5KL

''1

@ C '666 (

$ ) P 2 K

'-%L'7%

@ %55% + + = 8 % 1K/L17%

@ %557 ) 0 ) M

? E // /71L/5.

8 '6%6 G

'K /16L/1K

J 0 , O A Q '66K :