* 1 2 3 : 14 / 10 / 93 : 20 / 2 / 94 : 10 / 4 / 94 : ! "#$% &$# ' ( ) * +, ( - # $./ 0123 , 04 5 * 6) 1379 8, ( # 9# 6 ( 0' # 59( : ; ) <# => ?@ A # ) . - # C 1384 C EF 0#$@" , "( ( . / 8F 8 > / G E , ' ! $H 0 $ ; ) 3 ( 3 ' F I( : C, & J # . 8, ( # 9# 6G9% % K ( ) <# LM$/ ( 02N $; 9 , O 3 ( $NI( , # & P' ; # )C # @' 9 # 0 / . O 3 Q 8 9( 6 R S T3,U $( ( V% K ) 3 . : " W K / $( 0A9/ " W L 6 2# 0# ( ( 8F ) 3 ) ) 3 ! ( 8 # 59( , 0@Z [ &$Z\4 1Z.' ) 3 ( : ; 8 # 59( 8 , ] #^ C _4 `\W C A' ( NS & V' , 3 . K92a53 , 8 I% 0' 0 I 8 # 2 / 6 3 `5* 8 > / , 8 @' 59 6) # ) ,F . , b c C 3 0A9/ " d$M IM ?9\e% " `5* 6 ' > ?9\e% , ) 2( . : 9 $ & 4 ? f 8, ( # 9# ' > ; C ( +$R$ C .3 , 0\ +$R$ IM ) <# : 1 -/ ( hN% ? f ) 8 # 59( :( , 3 ! ( : P' , _9P2% 60S c i"R @' 59 0 * $ ; 2 -( hN% ? f 0 $ ; TJ( ) 8 @' 59 (: 0 J% , 0 8 $% i"R %$/ ` 2 ( *$% , : 3 -8 > / ( hN% ? f : ) > / : R 4 4 -# 9-# ) j ( hN% ? f > ) : , 0 / 8 2/ / , 05# 8 2/ / ) / h C 9=( :, A% ( k$( : @. : 8, ( # 9# 9 $ & 4 0 ( 0\ f ( ) <# / > 53 8F 3 ( , _/ T9 & P' i"R -$\" , 0 2 =3 . / , 8 $% `! , 0 $ ; TJ( 0 , TJ( ( , , & 123 0 ! ( 9 , e =' ?9 , 0 * $ 0 $Z . Z( ) ' G=/ l I( 8, ( ) <# > , C ?N! 6 ) " 9 3 ( 8F ( 8 [53 ' -$e% @ ( & P , 0 $( . : 8, ( 6) <# $ ; TJ( 8 # 59( 6 ! 4 6 ; ; 60 : . ! " # $! : & ' ()* + . ,+ -' ( + . /! 1394 2 1 ) 1 :( 23 -13 . 1 . 7 8 ' 9 : ; <) = ! >) 2 . & ?@ AB: >) C@:-D ;8 EF >) 3 . (F @= G. 8 )D ; ! ?F 8 CF >)8 EF >) * : # >) H/- =G 345 ) = ! < ' 9 78 . J ; : : 09128070913 Email: [email protected]
!" #$%& '$ !( ) $ $ * + , - .$ / 0" 1 -$ " 2 + $ : '$ ) 4$ 51 2 6 2 & !" #$%& 7 8 $9 : ;<1 !" ) > / ( 4 / @ '$ ) . - $01 B1 @ / @ ( ;) C< D 1 017 $/E C< @ " 2 2 99 ) 1 ( . '$ !( 2 & ) > / ( !" '$ ) + F GH #$I& G"$ " J F + .$K4$L +M 1 9/ 1 N ) (Decentralization $ 6 . ' O-$PG& + " ' $K/ +M 1 Q M + $ $ @ . -$,6 +M 1 2M R& @ S G< $ @ 6 .$ / NT " '$ ) U R<"$V@ *< W C MH ) 1 .( XY M 1 Z & 1 + 91 $K/ + : X 1 + ) -(Deconcentration [ S1 (Devolution) @ \\ ] (Delegation) ) @ \\ ( ; \ " \\ +$ ) (Privatization ) 2 .( D $( + ^0 %& ( ;) +$" " 1 $;GO +M " #$& 2 $Y& 7 $ N @ & 2$ + +M 1Z & 1 G & 4@ & ) 1 .( ( ;) G9" _ 01 + %9H ( +$" ( ;) "` E & &$O ,4$ -$PG& +$"
_ 01 ( ;) C< G4@ 9 1 ( ;) 8 "@ $90 +$" _ 01 1 : +$ & O $ G4@ a$Kb& . _ 01 $ ( ;) , & ,4$ -$PG& .$H ( +$" 2M R& @ T $GH 2+ & 1 $ c "` ) 3 .( ( ;) N +$" @ 9/ 1 N+ .$ / " M d $e" $ 6 . f@ + *< $ 7 ,4$ & ] @ &$ M E N $ 6 ] @ ( ;) C< M $ 6 C< + N ($) ) 4 1 $ &$ ) ( ;) 9 ) 3 1 .( @N @ 7 4 @ C< $ M " N $e" ( ;) ) $ 1 9&$ $ G* $> @ ( D $0 + -$ / @ 6 @ G4@ C< N ) /$ G 4@` @ 4 / 1# / 9&$ ( g$9G . ) $ +$ $I I9 ) Internal Market ( +$ K6$ ) (Quasi-Market G4@ C< @ . K6 + %9 +$ $ C< @ & +$ $O h @ 1 ) +$ @ #i 1 - ; T $ G4@ @ Kj $ " ( ;) @ / C< . 4$ @ 2 &$ O$ 4@ $ G) ' $%& @ ]RG"$ " ;1@ ] @ ( ;)C< 6 . $k ) ) CP& 4@ @ 2 6 C< @ ) 1 : ;<1 $ @ 2 6 $k '$ ) 2 9 CP& ( ;) ) 1 9H $ ) 5 -1 .( a$S1 n&N 7 / $ o1 $ " , GH
%& @ 6$ G6 & & < 6 2 p 6
6$ 9 + g )-$j E " . @ !" #$%& '$ ) $e" $& 4$" h9V 0" 1 $ q ;) 2 $ 192 0" 1 # " $& @ /$ G $;GO R9 H ) 83 -1379 ( ' P + *< X %91 &$O g ; 4@ 4$ 27 / 11 / 1380 6 w I !" $9*< @ 2 $( $ $ +$" " +
$& @ 4$/ 6 @ * M 15 H O . & O @ '$ ) $e" '$ ) $Y91 & !" 9&$ &$K G*V ]B1 & P& 9 H$%& @ ... , '$ ) @ &$ G6 Y 6 GH $ M & E9 $V ) 6 .( # $Yd $& _k` 4@ R9 H @ /$ G $;GO 0" 1 &y$" 6 3 ;1 + ( @ 5 + ( $& 9d 9 X ) $9 $ 01 ;1 C $ M 9&:<* $ & Rd 2+ & 6 ) 7 .(
XI9V $& &$O G
"$ " * 0" 1 $ $* $ *& S& KO $& @ ($) & &$O 0" 1 # " $e" *&2 q$;G) !"'$ ) . ] @ XL / $*& 1$04$b 2 G $ @ W51 9 :)$6 $e" $ $ R<"$V @ 4 / S ) ! @ ) zb" ( X $ " 2 d " ) 6 ( ( / GK4 '$04$b @ " - 9 8>@ M & &$Y @ ' W { " X $ $e" ) 8 .( C @ V 2 6#$I& * 9 + $ & 2$1 ' W + | $H @ ' 9 @ ' $e" 2 & 12 P09 $ O 4$ 8H$9 .$K4$L & ) 12 -9 .(
$ @ * 0" 1 # $Yd $& &$ $V -$"
-$" 4@ N $ @ 1384 "$ " @ $& $e" * 0" 1 4$" h9V $ $& @ ( ;) $ QK1 !( $ @ +$" Ed -$K& 4@ +$" _O G .! / 6 . , 4@ XY + $ $06 1 N " 4 / " @ $ O $e" & B4 h 1 ) :<* N J O $ N GK4 & ( $ @ ) & H $ + %9 6 1 $ ( ;) C<
@ & 6 GH $ &$K G*V $ &$ $
O $ &$O - 6 1 9G6 ( 6 $ @N ) # <G" O T F ( ;) . @ "$ " D 1 1 4@ T $e" Ed 9K ) @ !" #$%& $G)$" +$" ,& V " $ KY . Z > + 1 @ "$ " ,6 9/ 1 $ $e" . T >$ C @ V $ @ ,6 7 / " ~ I1 $ . 2 \ S 04$b E 04$b + N $\ 6 @N _ G< f@ 9d . f+ $ $ $ 0 \\ (Trustworthiness) C @ \\V \\S $\\ \ @$\ 7 $O7 $6 ) (Credibility \,17\ $O \\\ (Dependability) \\\ X \\\ 017\\\ $O Transferability) ( \\\\\\ \\\\\\ 517\\\\\\ $O Conformability) ( ) 14 -13 ( 6 9/ •$ 4 C @ V#$I& 6 . 2 $\ \ N \" \ K $\; @ 2 $* $9" " + . 7 $\\62 \\6 \\" $9\\" 2 \\P09 $\\ O '$\\ I1 ( f M\\ @ $\\ \\ \\ +$ \\ { $G" $ QK1 '$K1$, $" @ $ @ $ $e" $G\\" $ \\Y1 ,\\6MV# \\ /2$R\\*& $\\ ) 18 $G" $ ( . ' $* \^ + \6$& + \, R* @ V Z \> $\ QK1 \ $G" $ @ \\( H \\ \\ \\ X PG\\ $\\* $\\ X ;1 + " +$ $G" $ $ 8 $\O@ KW@
@NX \H @ . \ K1@ X\YH \ \9n 2 + \\\R \\\, ' $\\\* + 7\\\($ $\\\ @ €$\"• + X\/ 8\ b H + S& 2 $ R* @ V $G" $ $\,&$ V $G\" $\"$96 $ $ \GH$ & $G)$\" K $\; $\ @ ( ;) C< #$I& . 8 2 @N Z$K\6 \bP& " $1$ 6 . 2 $I&N+ + @ + \ ' ( $ 8\\ _\\ G< 8 $\\9 #$\\I& \\" \\6 @N \" 7O \ \ C @ V . f M\ + 7\($ $\ $\\\\\ G) _\\\\\ G< 8F$\\\\\P C @ \\\\\V K $; f M\ h $G& ( @ H O $ & 6 51 2 6 N " $ . 2 f@ J\\ F+ $\\ g d $\\Yd7\\ 1 \\S (Framework Analysis) 8 & \6 \9 ) 15 -14 .( 2 $ 6$96N h9V7 $6 f@ $ \ $ & \( '$/ > g d $Yd $"$96 \ " N S1@ *P& * @ -@ X " 1 ) 15 -14 (. ( '$/ > g d $Yd #@ \ 2 @ \ + 2 $SG" $ H 7,6 @ _\ G< $\ \ & \ \6 9 +$ $ $ R* @ V j $K w,09\ \4$ \GY ' \%&8\ 2 \99 K $; 6$ ' $* @ $ & 6 . g d $\Yd \ Z > + H$> $ @ # $Yd $Y&$ . $ & QK1 \ + \" ' $\K/ 2 \\ & + 2 $SG\\" J\\ F+ '$/ \\> $\\ $\\ # & MH Word 6#$I& . Z \> $\Yd \ $Y& f M @ $"$96Z > + * @ ( . @ \ \"$ " \ PH # /7 y '$ \) $e\" \\ 1 \\* !\\"#$\\%& &$G\\" $ $\\Yd > \ +p \6 \ Z \> \ + * @ ( Z PKF & 6 9 ) -@ 1 .( $*& ( '$/ > @ \& ( R +$ 2 9 $*& '$/ > + R +$\ \ 7\ $01 \ & # \/ \ $Y& @ '!,\* +@ \ \ I9 & Rd @ PH " 2 $e" . 1 : !" # $ % & $ & ! #'( )*$ + , ! " # $ " # $ % O PA) Q R ) ! ( -+ 7S T?) B UJV -+ 7 " TUJV -C - .W # Q R PA) X 9#,Y ) -C ( -99Y) ) , UJV -8 ) ZO ? ' ' ) " Q R PA) -" V ; Q R .! ! [O PA) \ ) = )R ] ^! ! ( @ ? ! ? P @ = " _) -. ' ` "/CF -. : $ / !" ) # $ % ( $ H $ $ QK1 7 y " + (!)Z > 6 : : , $ 23 45" 6 7$ 89 $ ` 4@ \ " $ \ & $ $G \ Y 2M R \ K \ O \
9 \ \ $ & RG<" ) @ / L GK4 ( H$> N 2 & @ C\< 7\ / $\^H \6 @ \ ‚\/$ \ \\( ;) \\ 2 \\ . $\\ O \\ .$\\K P1 C V 2 M Ow & / \ 2 6 G6 ] ;O$9 2 \\ \\ Y12 P4$\\ $\\,&$ V+ \\) %& @ \\ . " 2 9*& 9 $1 Q \6 G\6 & $G" $ E # C V $ O V + N w & 2 \ ' \/ M\ & $\,&$ N' %&@ 6$ 6$ 2 96M & $ " ) # 1 ) .( \ O GH$ GS $ $ K $; $ 2 \6 $9G\" $ & \6 \ \ !/+ " " .... " \62 $SG\" . T \ " # " $;G) " K $\; 2 & \6 " M\G& V 7\) 2 $ \6@ 2 6 K $; H2 $ 6 6$ .( <" $ Q 6#!/ ‚\/$ \& \ \) \6
@ 2 \,& \6 \;O$9 !\( @ $,&$ V
.$H ( & $e & $,&$ V $O 2 \& -$\K& \ 9 M K N+ wV@ ;O$9 6 \ ) $ , J F & . " \ Q \6 \ < .$0O @ O $ 9 ,H n&N+ G* $ 1$ 9 ƒ ) 9 . \ O R w \ |@ X9 \ " ) # 2 .( 8\O \^0 $9\" ;O$9 Z > @ ;O$9 ) .!j 1 \K 5 '$\ " ( T$S6 L & ) 1$ \) d .$P O K&:<* .!j Y01 $G\" $ \Y01 1$ ) d @ ( ;)C< 6$ (. $\9 $ \" \ $9\" \ Y1 $ \& \;O$9 \ Z \> J\ O _ 01 ;O$9 ) @ X\I $\ S ( \OX \%91@ \;;<1f+ \ N \& & 2 ,& FZ > $ QK1 . \ 4$\" E\ $\ +' \ 01 $ O ) O $ @ 6#$R9 @+ $ ‚\/$ $\ \ \6 $,&$ V ,H $9 \" \ G\* @ 2 K&' 9 8H 1 \ 2$ \ 9 ,H' 9 . 9 \ P/ #$R \ ^0 O \ $ \ + \ 9 M 1$ &\ 2 R .!j \\ $ \ 6 .! /$ $H + $ + \ %& $G\" $ @ &$\ ]B1 g$ „@ g$ w @ " ... 2 $SG\" & & •$\ 4$ O '$ ) 9 M 2 \* . $\,&$ V2 \Y/ \ \O '$ \) \ $ G6 ] 2 6 $G\" $ Q\" 1 7\ / \4@ \ . $ O $ & 6 P09 2 " $,&$ V \ C M\H $\ 01 C MH $ $ \H ) # M\4 .!j\ $\ $G\" V @ \ & \;<* \01 G6 $,&$ V $\\ S \\6 \\ '$\\ "51 \\9H @ \\ & ( $\\9 $,&$ V @ $ 1 \) $ @ & C M\H 2 . -: 2 $ 4&89 , $ XL / ^0 G\6 & & RG<\"$\ O 2 \6 & 7 / $ N $O C4$d$ $ . :)$6 9GK $ O ' $%& @ J\ O $\ Z$ .$^0 @ K& H F \;;<1@ \ / 1 :)$\6 01 \ 1 $\%& $\ ` & \ @ W \6 . " bd 4$ X9 ' $%&'$ "51 O X& 1 + @ \" a \ X e\ E\ \ '$ "51~$96 $
\\ & \\"E\\ &$, @N " ) # 3 ( \\ $\\ ` 4@ $G" $ ) + -@ / $ ) $& 1$ 7 $ 1 O+ & $*& \& . _0\>7\ 4 \ $\ OX %91 ) .!j 9 M ^0 ,&•$ 4 $ ( + \\0 $\b) $\\,&$ V X\\*d \\6 V \\ 2 \\6 . \\) C< 4@` & PG0 $ $\ D\"$9 \) # \/ ‚\\/$ $\\ $b) $\\,&$ V \\ 2 \\ $\\,&$ V ;O$9 \ ) ;O$9 Q 6 ƒ 9 $S 0 $ & GH R -$K& @ N + @ 9\6$ $ . / $ \ $& 1# \ %& $G" $ \ O ' $ \ @ \ ` W
\\ \\> \ \\ _0 \ \\ \ \\ $G" $ \ \\ \ + $ 9 O \ * G ) \ \ \ Y0 \ \ N . .!j / \ \ Y1# /$ $,&$ V'$K4$b 8O ) V# 4@ 8O ‚\/$ $\,&$ V+$\ & \ \ 2 \6
$\,&$ V+ \ $\ ) ' $%G& & G& $G" $ $ & K4$b . " & $G" $ M\ \ R \ \ & 1 & $ d " O M + G ]L 6 2 \& \ \" 2$\ $\Yd \ - \V 6 " ) # 4 .( y + , $,&$ V $\ + F $ S C $ 7 / \O…\ K 8\O ) V# \ \ 9G\ & ‚/$ $ a P @ 2 \6 \) V )51$ $,&$ V@ $ $*H 6 @ 4$ . + $\,&$ V'$\K4$b 8\O \ \) V # / 9n $G" $ " $ ‚/$ 2 6 $,&$ V G6 $ \9 „ P $" \;O$9 $Y9\* V…\ K \0 $\ C MH 2 > $1 9 $ & K . : $ :& % ( $ $ ; ) P \" $\,&$ V \ ' $\%& M\ $\ $& 9G6 . 0\" \^0 9G\6 \ \ @ $,&$ V † \ @ 2 \,& 4$) $ $ $,&$ VQ @ ` - KO 9 + G 4@ 99,& ) \ 0O \ \G
$\\V \\ + $\\ & &$\\Oa \\P $,\\6N $\\,&$ V
\\ ] \\6 ( 2 \\/@ E\\d \\R 7 $\\ \\1 $I&N $1 $ @ 2 4$) $,&$ V \ \& .! / @ b \6+ @ 2 \6 $\ M € & O$ $& 9G6 ] . $\ \ ` $G\" $ 4@ 7 $ 1 9G6 @ f+ \ ND\ 7 4 0H $ Nf$0 @ B6 9 $ & R& 9n @ I1 $ 99 ‡S \;O$9 2 \& \ \ 0H $\ $9 7 1 0 & & $ I G&
#$\&Q\PH ;O$9 #$I
@ $ 01 " B1@ 2 6ˆ / 6 N 2 & \ & \ @ $ N \ . \ \ \O@ $ \ '$
2M\ R& $\ $\,&$ V \ @ & 7 1
' \( \S9 $\
H
.
K $; + )
& & 9/ $ & 6
$S"$ $96N 7 $H H 2 6f \ T F+ $9 $ $ 7 1 $,&$ V 2 6 . 2M R& R $ @M & 6 . H $ @ \ - \ 0 /$^ 9&$ $\,&$ V '$ $P "+ + 4 2M R& $ $ 7 1 & 6 . \6 X\" \ M & $ $\ g]\ \H OT F \ \& N @ $\ 7L$* -Z \> $\ QK1 L 7L$* $"$ 4$ $\ O \ \& $ $\ K D\ 1 1 \ @ K ) 9" V & . \ \6ˆ /$
$\ $ \& K& \>$ $\ @ & \9d +$ & B1 $ @
#$I& OT F 6 %& \9 ) .!j\ 2 L @ '$ "51$ MRG ) $ .( 7\ 1-$
2M\ R& $\ $\,&$ V @ & $\ _\ G< 7) \1 ‚\/$ CP&@ _ $k@ 2 \6$ \ \ 2 \ ‚\/$ @ $ + $\,&$ V 4$\) &$\6 $\ h $\G& \ + + \99 . " 2 )y$ $Y9 # YS& $ $ 9G $\ '$ \\) -@`\\ ‰ $G\\" $ " ) # 5 .( \\ \\4$)
& @ &7 1 @ $,&$ V
\K \, D\ L $G" $ '$O@ $ N \ ) V M @ & $ d -&N \ K91@ J \*1 $ \Y \4$) $\* 7 $\ $\"@ $ & . : < !" < =)><? ) % ( $ :& ( $,&$ V$ QK1 7 y @ + G" Z > 6 9 : : ==?" # " >& 89 =)>? ) $ :& % ( ( 9 + ^0 1 9&$ $ 5 '$ " 6 \( ;) $\ ) 2 H$ ;;<1C& @ 1+
& K& G \)$ \ %& ;;<1 G ) \\H$%& ( ' @ \\>M\\ & \\6 $\\ \\ $\\ a$1 %& $ @ C< $ 7 / f+ \ N G\ $\ 99 K . 7\ 1 \ \KI $G\" $ \ \& 0 O / $1 $,&$ V . " \OX \< † V 2 $ @ X9 B4 $,&$ V @ X\) \P/ \ O \6 \ &# 0 X )N @ XGH 6$ + GY 0 " ) # 6 .( : @ " /A 5 B B " 1 $ $G" $ D4$L 4$\" \ $\ OZ > $\ \;O$9 \ \ 9G\6 ] $\9 9 ^1 $,&$ V &$ -$" 9G\6 & \0 $ . b 6 9d N 2$\1 8H$9 $ \ 1 \)' \ G* & . " 2$RG" @N ,H bd \0 -$\" &# 0 4$ X6$ 2$R* $ +N ‰ )$ XG $I9 X " ) # 7 (. $ $,&$ V 2 6_ 01a P &$O $ H$> J %& 2 L@ ~$K4 J S 6J $ & ) V $ \& . $\ $Y& \O$H $\ \)a \P R V O S9( @ \& '$ $,\6 \\ $\\ \\) ` p \\b $G\\" $ 4@ \\ \\& & @ ` 0" $G" $ 4@ \ \& $\ \4$) $\ $,&$ V 9 $ & ^1 $ a P . : C$ / !" : * C$ / #
a \P $\,&$ V & &$\O L $ $GH 7 4 $
~$ B6 9 # /@ <" $ Q 6 $V G6 G4 / 9 _\ G< 8 @ H'$ $,6 $ ]4 $ \6X \H ‚/ G\* \4$) \ D\"$9 \9 + ` $\,&$ V $G" $ 4@ X \H & & . " & O P C H G $ & 9 X & 1 \GH \^1E\d$\ + $\,&$ V d X 9 $,6 " " ) # 8 .( $\ & &$\Oa P 0O G $,&$ VQ" 1 $/ 2 6 $\ \)$\Y&NX\ +$ 9 $ $P " & $* $* Q 6@ $G" ) & . @ &$S\;9 $ M G\" @ B\6 9 $ ( G" ) . \P 1 \ $,&$ V , /+ $ +'$ $,67 4 \ @ 2 N ) C\< \ \ ]\ @ \( ; \ C MH @ $ a P 6-$ $VD G4 \/ 2 6 7O \ $\ $\ X PG # <G" C ]4 " G @ $\,&$ V $V \ \) V M\ \ 01 4@`\ .$^0 @ $ G" )E 9/ $ $G" $ p b $ . " '$ ) $ " " %& 2 6 H$ $\ $\ \j @ \ \R @ X NJ\ .$\0O @X 6$ X & 1$ ) X\ k $\ 9 " ) # 9 ( . $ DE : < * F !" -*$ GC ) # $ % " H I ( : 5/$ /*$ / J $ K L" #/ J 5/$ / % $ " $9 $ " # <G" #$%& B\6 \ 9 X \H \GY $ Q 6@ G* ) V \ 2 @N O# <G" 4$ \6 Q\" 1 b\" @ $\ ( ;) @ \G GH$\ \ 9 # \/ $\ $ Q 6 2 1 6 6 . " XG $G" V . & $ $ #$I C\< $ $G\" V \ X $\ #$I& R N GH$\ _;& GH$ $ 9 $\ &X " ) # 10 .( \ @ \P 1 \6 QK1 \ \ , / H 7B\6#@ \1@ ) V $ \ $\Y91 \\) ' \\O \\G + \\ $\\ \\ \\& " 2 . \ \ G"$ \ + 1 \ '@$S $ 1 $ \
0\\>@+ \\G4@ \\ @ $\\9 $ 0\\>@7 \\K1 & @ O 0>@ " # <G" \, 6 $*&' $* 9G6 7 $ 1 0>@ 0\>@ K\6 M\ d \ \O $\9 $ <G" \67 K1 " $9 $ . " 4 \/ $\I \ 2 @ & @ G* : $\ @ X \9 G \6 " 79" V$ 2 .$9o b X 9 " G 679" V 7\ $O#@ 7\ " " ) # 6 ( C\< \ G4@ C $9 ( ;) 6 @ . : B M N:' ' $ G) K '$KW# / # \/ N H$ $96N & f@ $ $Y C< '$ ) ] @ $ @ \H \01 $G\"@ _\(_ $\k@7) 1 ( ;) ' $\%&@ OX %91 $ @ \4$) N \ & X \;1 9 # \/8\O \^0 @ \ _ G< p b" Y01 ) \ &$\ \6 ( \ + 2 $SG" ( ;) C< \ PH # \/7 y R + @ "$ " $e" . " $\ $\ @ G\6 & $G\" O X S4$\\< N $ \\9 + $ \\ " ) # 9 ( " . X \\< \\ † V 2 $ @ X9 B4 $,&$ V O @ X) O P/ \ &# \ 0 X\ \)N @ XG\H GY 0 6 6$ + " ) # 6 .( &' () * '+ @ "$ " PH # /$ 04$b ~$\" \ $e" 2+ & @ \ "$ " W51 T \ \ $e\" !"#$%& $Y& ) $ G\* $\> !" 0>@ 4$ b) k$S ) ( 4 16 ( #$%& &$ T $ !\\" ) \\ S $\\ \\" G" @ ) ( 16 4 ( $\\ + \62 $\*& \ \ \ T \ , " 2 9& @ "$ " T ( $e" d$ Nh $G&+ %& 6 @ $ " 2 @ . 7\ y C @ \Vh $\G& \\0G @ \\ \\"$ " \\ \\ ,6 #$\\%& $e\\" * !" $*& . \ PH # \/7 y \"$ " @ \ 1 &$G\" $ '$ \) $e\" $\Yd Z \> & Z > + * @ ( . 7 4 \ )+ 1y$ p b" 7 y + $ X \;1 $^H @ K\ & \G4@ C\< \ X $\ \ & $ $G" $ ) $ H $ ( \4@ $\ @$\ R& %& X GH $ QK1 7 y 9/ 1 7 y ^0 @ G"$ " $^H R ] X \ & „ . \ 8 $\ 2$\R& $\ $\ ^O y C \ @ X\ X \6 \R - \ 0 \\G4@ \\ #$\\%&_0\\> \\& . \\b \\ 9 +7 / M & R '$04$b # \/$\ \ PH +$" @ PH $6 $e" G6 2 \& . \04$b E\ \ @ 2$R* $ +N $e" \( 1 \" 2 \6 #$I& $
@ \ + 7\KO &$\ M 2 &
\ + \ $e\" 9 $ & " : $\& 1 \( / \ R +$ 8H$9 $^1 M\ $\,&$ V \, / C $\V &$ M $ G/ 7 $O ~ G" $,&$ V G6 '$KW @ M\ @ ) K & 9 M ( ;)C< \ 1 B1 $Y& @ ( ;)C< Q" 1@ &$ \\62 & \\O \\ $ ) 17 .( E\\ \\R \\04$b @ W51 $*& YS g d $Yd \ $e\" \\" 2 \\ &X \\" 1 !\\"#$\\%& \\, / . \\ @ \\ \\ 2 \\ & \\ g d $\\Yd 7\\ /@ $e\\" 01 " 2 6 51 N PH 2 99 . $\ \04$b N \\ b \\6 \\ \\ 1 @ \\ \\ \\" 2 \\ & @ G6 ] $e" \Kj W51+ K ( 6 2 N S9 $ " 2 99 ) 8 .( \( ;)C\< 1 + 2 $SG" k \ H \ $\& 1 @ G4@ C< \ G" \ 2 $S \ RG . @ \ ]
4$0H $ G\ & G& ) $K&@ \ X\ ( 2 + \H \ \ \6$ \G4@ C< '!,* . \ \ \ 5 4 '$\ @ Z > $e" " 2 62 $6 ) 1 18 .( @ , V $, f M $ ) 6 G,& 2 $ 2 & \& + 7KO 4@ ) @$ \ C\< + '$ \) ( ;) & 6 ' P 8>@ %91 X C\< Q\ @ G4@ ( ;)@ ' $Y KY @ $ $\ O $P0& @ " @ > $e" ) 20 -19 (. @ \\ $\\ C @ \\V \\ #$\\I& \\ @ $\\ \\ @ . K $; QK\> 2+$\ $ & \6 K $\; @ \& & $\ GS 6 $ .$H ( $* $ \6 \ . C @ \V $G" $ Q 2$R*& $ #$\I& \Y1 ,\6MV# / $G\" $ T \0 7\ $ F " , 6 $\ 2$R*& 0 $1 6$K& * ,6MV# / $ . C V KO $ YS •$ 4 R* @ V ( ˆ H -@ I1 & 6 C @ V @ N \ $e\" 6 O B4 @ DP/ * 7 4 ( ;) $ JH $\& \ I1 E 4@ Q" 1$Y&N $ # <G" @ " 2 . $\ \9d \ $\ O \) 6 @ $G\" $ 4@` $ & > $& ( ;) ( ;) 6 @ \ 9 N H + O T F @ $e\" 9G6 $> N h $G& . K $; ^0 \PG0 $ & \6 @ \ \"$ " & \9H@ G \ 7\ y \ $e\" 2M R& $ N_O 1@ *& _O G ƒ $) @ "$ " $ H 7,6 !" #$%&+ . >$ C @ V $I&N+ ) $9" ) $ O @ $e\" ( \ \ @ ) "$ " & ] ( 7\ y " , " G6 M 1 * @ $\ \6 Y ' +@ $G)$"+ ƒ $)@ 1 6$ 2 &$ - SB ,6MVf+ N . , - .'/ @ JH !\" #$\%& $e" + 7\KO ] @ 4$0H $ @ $ N $ $ M ,H #$%& KY \\ H k $\\I @ \\G4@ C\\< \\ #+y $\\ \ !\" #$\%& . \ ' $\ G) C M\H ' $Y KY 7) \1 8\H \O $\P0& $\ @ $G"@ _(_ $k@ ... \ H k'$ \O + +$\" @ Y 9G $e" . * 01 2 $ 9 & \ C @ V#$I& Y & M M/#$ 1 + GH O' * $ K $; \ ,*1 & \9 $ & . \ \\9/$\\ 1$\\P P 1p \\F+ \\*< 7\\($ \\4$P " 2+ \\& @ \\ 2 \\ &@ M\\ \\ '$ \\) $e\\" $G" $ &$G" $ ,\6MV# \ /2$R*& 0 $1 $ Y1 " 6MV# / 2$R*& g ; G6 Y '$ ) @ , -$\" Y1 &$ 1387 \ $\ 983 / 132 $\ @ \"
,\*1 &$ \( " 2 6#$I& 2$R*& $
6 .
References
1. Witter S, Ensor T, Thompson R, Jowett M
(2000). Health economics for developing
Countries: a practical guide. 1th ed. MacMillan Education, London.
2. Saltman R, Bankauskaite V, Vrangbaek K.
Decentralization in health care: strategies and outcomes.1th ed. UK: McGraw-Hill Education; 2007.
3. Perrot J. Is contracting a form of
privatization? Bull World Health Organ. 2006; 84(11): 910–13.
4. Marc R, Hsiao W, Berman P, Reich M. Getting
health reform right: a guide to improving performance and equity. 1th ed. New York: Oxford University Press; 2004.
health systems. Bull World Health Organ. 2006; 84(11): 859–66.
6. Barati_Marnani A, Gudaki H. Comparative
Study on Privatization of Health Care Provision on Contract Basis. J Health Adm. 2005; 8(21): 105-10.
7. Akbari F, Joudaki H, Mahmoudi M, AkbariSari
A, Namazi A. Exploring the extent and nature of outsourcing in public hospitals affiliated with
Tehran University of Medical Sciences,
Iran. Health Inf Manag. 2012; 9(3):397-405.
8. Liu X, Hotchkiss DR, Bose S. The impact of
contracting-out on health system performance: a
conceptual framework. Health Policy.
2007;82(2):200-11.
9. Roeintan A, Geraili B, Joudaki H, Farhadi H,
Adavi S. Improving management and utilization of resources by outsourcing health care services to private sector in Aligoodarz Health Network. 2002. In Proceedings of the First Conference of Hospital Resources Management; 2003 Jan 8-9; Tehran, Iran. Ministry of Health and Medical Education, Deputy of management development, resources and Parliament Affairs; 2003. P. 279.
10. Tabibi SJ, Kakhani MJ, Ehsani Chimeh E. An
evaluation of the outsourcing strategy in supportive services in the hospitals affiliated to the Ministry of Health and Medical Education. J Health Adm. 2008; 10(30):59-66. Persian.
11. Omrani MD, Mostafavi H, Khazar S, Ghalami
S, Farajzadeh F. Laboratories Performance after Outsourcing in the Hospitals of Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences. Med Lab J. 2013; 7(2): 42-8.
12. Tourani S, Maleki M, Ghodousi-Moghadam S,
Gohari MR. Efficiency and effectiveness of the Firoozgar teaching hospital's pharmacy after
Outsourcing Tehran, Iran. J Health Adm.
2010; 12(38): 59-70. Persian.
13. Mays N, Pope C. Qualitative research in health
care: Assessing quality in qualitative
research. BMJ. 2000; 320(7226): 50-2.
14. Elo S, Kaariainen M, Kanste O, Polkki T,
Utriainen K, Kyngas H. Qualitative content analysis a focus on trustworthiness. SAGE Open. 2014; 4(1):1-10.
15. Srivastava A, Thomson SB. Framework
analysis: a qualitative methodology for applied policy research. Journal of Administration & Governance. 2009; 4(2): 72-9.
16. Reinhardt UE, Cheng TM. The world health
report 2000-Health systems: improving
performance. Bull World Health Org. 2000; 78 (8): 1064.
17. Avery G. Outsourcing public health laboratory
services: A blueprint for determining whether to privatize and how. Public Administration Review. 2000; 60(4):330-7.
18. Siddiqi S, Masud TI, Sabri B. Contracting but
not without caution: experience with outsourcing of health services in countries of the Eastern Mediterranean Region. Bull World Health Organ. 2006;84(11):867-75.
19. Preker AS, Harding A, Travis P. Make or buy
decisions in the production of health care goods and services: new insights from institutional economics and organizational theory. Bull World Health Organ. 2000;78(6):779-90.
20. Preker AS, Harding A. The economics of public
and private roles in health care: Insights from institutional economics and organizational theory. International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/The World Bank; 2000.p.1-23.
Hossein Joudaki*1, Mahmood Heidari2, Bijan Geraili3
Received: 04.01. 2015 Revised: 10.05. 2015 Accepted: 01.07. 2015
Abstract
Introduction: Outsourcing of hospital care was widely used after the implementation of the Third Socio-economic Development Plan in 2000. A return in policy occurred since 2006. Contracts between private sector and hospitals were cancelled, and the Ministry of Health employed the private sector staff. Outsourcing did not achieveits primary goals of downsizing health sector and improving efficiency. This study aimed to describe the lessons learned from the experience.
Method: We conducted a qualitative study. Data were gathered by documents analysis and
observations of the hospitals of medical university in Tehran and ten interviews with stakeholders and key informed persons. These people include hospital managers; headquarter experts, contractors, and hospital staff. "Framework Analysis"is used to understand and analyze data.
Results: We classified the factors related to unsuccessfulness of outsourcing into four categories (themes) and eight subcategories (sub-themes): 1- Factors related to employers (hospitals) including weakness in designing and monitoring contracts and hospital managers' interference with the activities of the other side of the contracts (private administration) 2- Factors related to private firms including low management knowledge and skills and pursuing short time benefits 3- Factor related to workers including workers protests 4- Factors related to policy space (upper level than hospital) including the gap between work status of formal employees and private sector workers and problems related to management.
Conclusion: Unsuccessfulness of outsourcing was related to factors resulted from weak governmental hospital management system. In fact, private sector abilities and efficiency were restricted by weak hospital management potentials in public hospitals. Performing reforms in public management system is essential for successfulness of outsourcing.
Keywords: Outsourcing, Private sector, Purchasing, Contracting, Hospital
Citation: Joudaki H, Heidari M, Geraili B. Outsourcing of Hospitals Services: Lessons Learned from the Experience.
Journal of Health Based Research 2015; 1(1):13-23.
1. PhD, Department of Health Economics and Planning, Social Security Organization, Tehran, Iran. 2. BSc, Children’s Medical Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
3. PhD Student, Department of Education Management, School of Psychology and Education, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
*Correspondence: Department of Health Economics and Planning, Social Security Organization, Azadi Ave, Tehran, Iran.
