• No results found

On the Nonexistence and Existence of Solutions for a Fourth Order Discrete Boundary Value Problem

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2020

Share "On the Nonexistence and Existence of Solutions for a Fourth Order Discrete Boundary Value Problem"

Copied!
18
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

doi:10.1155/2009/389624

Research Article

On the Nonexistence and Existence of Solutions for

a Fourth-Order Discrete Boundary Value Problem

Shenghuai Huang and Zhan Zhou

School of Mathematics and Information Science, Guangzhou University, Guangzhou, Guangdong 510006, China

Correspondence should be addressed to Zhan Zhou,[email protected]

Received 16 July 2009; Accepted 16 October 2009

Recommended by Patricia J. Y. Wong

By using the critical point theory, we establish various sets of sufficient conditions on the nonexistence and existence of solutions for the boundary value problems of a class of fourth-order difference equations.

Copyrightq2009 S. Huang and Z. Zhou. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

1. Introduction

In this paper, we denote byN,Z,Rthe set of all natural numbers, integers, and real numbers, respectively. Fora, b∈Z, defineZa {a, a1, . . .},Za, b {a, a1, . . . , b}whenab.

Consider the following boundary value problemBVP:

Δ2pn2un2 ΔqnΔun1fn, un, nZ1, k,

u−1 u0 0uk1 uk2.

1.1

Here,k ∈N,pnis nonzero and real valued for eachn∈Z0, k1,qnis real valued for eachn∈Z1, k1.fn, uis real-valued for eachn, u∈Z1, k×Rand continuous in the second variableu.Δis the forward difference operator defined byΔun un1−un, andΔ2un ΔΔun.

We may think of1.1as being a discrete analogue of the following boundary value problem:

ptxtqtxtft, xt, t a, b,

(2)

which are used to describe the bending of an elastic beam; see, for example, 1–10 and references therein. Owing to its importance in physics, many methods are applied to study fourth-order boundary value problems by many authors. For example, fixed point theory 1, 3, 5–7, the method of upper and lower solutions 8, and critical point theory 9, 10 are widely used to deal with the existence of solutions for the boundary value problems of fourth-order differential equations.

Because of applications in many areas for difference equations, in recent years, there has been an increased interest in studying of fourth-order difference equation, which include results on periodic solutions 11, results on oscillation 12–14, and results on boundary value problems and other topics 15, 16. Recently, a few authors have gradually paid attention to applying critical point theory to deal with problems on discrete systems; for example, Yu and Guo in 17considered the existence of solutions for the following BVP:

ΔpnΔun−1qnun fn, un,

ua αua1 A, ub2 βub1 B. 1.3

The papers 17–20show that the critical point theory is an effective approach to the study of the boundary value problems of difference equations. In this paper, we will use critical point theory to establish some sufficient conditions on the nonexistence and existence of solutions for the BVP1.1.

Let

an qn1−2pn pn1,

bn pn−1 4pn pn1−qnqn1. 1.4

Then the BVP1.1becomes

Lun fn, un, n∈Z1, k,

u−1 u0 0uk1 uk2, 1.5

where

Lun pn1un2 anun1 bnun an−1un−1

pn−1un−2. 1.6

(3)

2. Preliminaries

In order to apply the critical point theory, we are going to establish the corresponding variational framework of BVP1.5. First we give some notations.

LetRkbe the real Euclidean space with dimensionk. Define the inner product onRk as follows:

For BVP1.5, consider the functionalJdefined onRkas follows:

Ju 1

After a careful computation, we find that the Fr´echet derivative ofJis

Ju Mufu, 2.6

(4)

Expanding out Ju, one can easily see that there is an one-to-one correspondence between the critical point of functional J and the solution of BVP 1.5. Furthermore, u u1, u2, . . . , ukT is a critical point of J if and only if {ut}kt21 u−1, u0, u1, . . . , uk, uk1, uk2T is a solution of BVP 1.5, where u1

u0 0uk1 uk2.

Therefore, we have reduced the problem of finding a solution of1.5to that of seeking a critical point of the functionalJdefined onRk.

In order to obtain the existence of critical points ofJ onRk, for the convenience of readers, we cite some basic notations and some known results from critical point theory.

Let H be a real Banach space, JC1H,R, that is, J is a continuously Fr´echet

differentiable functional defined onH, andJ is said to satisfy the Palais-Smale condition P-S condition, if any sequence{xn} ⊂ Hfor whichJxnis bounded andJxn → 0 as

n → ∞possesses a convergent subsequence inH.

LetBr denote the open ball inHabout 0 of radiusrand let∂Br denote its boundary.

The following lemmas are taken from 23,24and will play an important role in the proofs of our main results.

Lemma 2.1Linking theorem. LetHbe a real Banach space,HH1

H2,whereH1is a

finite-dimensional subspace ofH. Assume thatJC1H,Rsatisfies the P-S condition and the following.

F1There exist constantsσ,ρ >0such thatJ|∂Bρ∩H2 ≥σ.

F2There is ane∂B1∩H2 and a constantR0 > ρsuch thatJ|∂Q ≤ 0 andQ BR0 ∩

H1{re|0< r < R0}.

ThenJpossesses a critical valuecσ, where

cinf

h∈ΓmaxuQ Jhu, 2.7

andΓ {hCQ, H|h|∂Qid}, whereiddenotes the identity operator.

Lemma 2.2Saddle point theorem. LetHbe a real Banach space,HH1

H2,whereH1/{0}

and is finite-dimensional. Suppose thatJC1H,Rsatisfies the P-S condition and the following.

F3There exist constantsσ,ρ >0such thatJ|∂Bρ∩H1 ≤σ.

F4There iseH1and a constantω > σsuch thatJ|eH2≥ω.

ThenJpossesses a critical valuecω, where

cinf

h∈Γu∈maxBρ∩H1

Jhu, 2.8

andΓ {hCBρH1, H|h|∂Bρ∩H1id}, whereiddenotes the identity operator.

Lemma 2.3Clark theorem. LetH be a real Banach space,JC1H,R,with J being even,

bounded from below, and satisfying P-S condition. SupposeJθ 0, there is a setKHsuch that

Kis homeomorphic toSj−1(j1dimension unit sphere) by an odd map, andsup

KJ <0. ThenJhas

(5)

3. Nonexistence of Nontrivial Solutions

In this section, we give a result of nonexistence of nontrivial solutions to BVP1.5.

Theorem 3.1. Suppose that matrixMis negative semidefinite and forn1,2, . . . , k,

zfn, z>0, forz /0. 3.1

Then BVP1.5has no nontrivial solutions.

Proof. Assume, for the sake of contradiction, that BVP1.5has a nontrivial solution. ThenJ

has a nonzero critical pointu∗. Since

Ju Mufu, 3.2

we get

fu, uMu, u0. 3.3

On the other hand, it follows from3.1that

fu, uk

n1

unfn, un>0. 3.4

This contradicts with3.3and hence the proof is complete.

In the existing literature, results on the nonexistence of solutions of discrete boundary value problems are scarce. HenceTheorem 3.1complements existing ones.

4. Existence of Solutions

Theorem 3.1 gives a set of sufficient conditions on the nonexistence of solutions of BVP 1.5. In this section, with part of the conditions being violated, we establish the existence of solutions of BVP1.5by distinguishing three cases:f is superlinear,fis sublinear, andf is Lipschitzian.

4.1. The Superlinear Case

In this subsection, we need the following conditions. P1For anyn, z∈Z1, k×R,

z

0fn, sds≥0, and

z

0fn, sdso|z|2, asz → 0.

P2There exist constantsa1>0, a2>0 andβ >2 such that

z

0

(6)

P3MatrixMexists at least one positive eigenvalue.

P4fn, zis odd for the second variablez, namely,

fn,zfn, z,n, z∈Z1, k×R. 4.2

Theorem 4.1. Suppose thatfn, zsatisfiesP2. Then BVP1.5possesses at least one solution.

Proof. For anyu u1, u2, . . . , ukT ∈Rk, we have

Fu k

j1

uj

0

fj, sdsa1

⎛ ⎝k

j1

ujβ

⎞ ⎠a2k

a1

k2−β/βk

j1

uj2

⎞ ⎠

β/2

a2ka1k2−β/2a2k.

4.3

LetA1a1k2−β/2, A2a2k. We have, for anyu u1, u2, . . . , ukT ∈Rk,

FuA1A2. 4.4

Since matrixMis symmetric, its all eigenvalues are real. We denote byλ1, λ2, . . . , λkits

eigenvalues. Setλmaxmax{|λ1|,|λ2|, . . . ,|λk|}. Thus for anyu u1, u2, . . . , ukT ∈Rk,

Ju 1

2Mu, uFu

≤ 1

2λmaxu

2A

1uβA2

−→ −∞ asu −→ ∞.

4.5

The above inequality means that −Ju is coercive. By the continuity of Ju, J attains its maximum at some point, and we denote it by u, that is, Ju cmax, where cmax

supuRkJu. Clearly,uis a critical point ofJ. This completes the proof ofTheorem 4.1. Theorem 4.2. Suppose thatfn, zsatisfies the assumptionsP1,P2,andP3. Then BVP1.5

possesses at least two nontrivial solutions.

To proveTheorem 4.2, we need the following lemma.

(7)

Proof. Assume that{un} ⊂Rkis a P-S sequence. Then there exists a constantc1such that for

Due toβ >2, the above inequality means{un}is bounded. SinceRkis a finite-dimensional Hilbert space, there must exist a subsequence of{un}which is convergent inRk. Therefore, P-S condition is satisfied.

2 E, thenRkhas the following decomposition of direct sum:

RkX

1

(8)

By assumptionP1, there exists a constantρ >0, such that for anyn∈Z1, k,z,

That is to say,Jsatisfies assumptionF1of Linking theorem.

(9)

Letu∈Rkbe a critical point corresponding to the critical valuecofJ, that is,Ju c. Clearly,u /0 sincec >0. On the other hand, byTheorem 4.1,Jhas a critical pointusatisfying

Ju supuRkJuc. Ifu /u, thenTheorem 4.2holds. Otherwise,u u. Then cmax Ju Ju c, which is the same as supuRkJu infh∈ΓsupuQJhu.

Choosinghid, we have supuQJu cmax. Because the choice ofe∂B1∩X2∈Q

BR0∩X1

{re|

0< r < R0}is arbitrary, we can take−e∂B1∩X2. Similarly, there exists a

positive numberR1> ρ, for anyu∂Q1, Ju≤0, whereQ1 BR1∩X1

{−re|0< r < R1}.

Again, by the Linking theorem,Jpossesses a critical valuec0≥σ >0, where

c0 inf

h∈Γ1

max

uQ1

Jhu, Γ1

hCQ1,Rk|h| ∂Q1id

. 4.16

If c0/cmax, then the proof is complete. Otherwise c0 cmax,supuQ1Ju cmax. Because J|∂Q≤0 andJ|∂Q1 ≤0, thenJattains its maximum at some point in the interior of setsQand Q1. ButQQ1⊂X1, andJu≤0 foruX1. Thus there is a critical pointu∈Rksatisfying

u /u,Ju c0cmax.

The proof ofTheorem 4.2is now complete.

Theorem 4.4. Suppose thatfn, zsatisfies the assumptionsP1,P2,P3,andP4. Then BVP

1.5possesses at leastl distinct pairs of nontrivial solutions, wherel is the dimension of the space spanned by the eigenvectors corresponding to the positive eigenvalues ofM.

Proof. From the proof ofTheorem 4.2, it is easy to know thatJ is bounded from above and

satisfies the P-S condition. It is clear thatJ is even andJ0 0, and we should find a setK and an odd map such thatKis homeomorphic toSl−1by an odd map.

We takeK ∂BρX2,whereρandX2 are defined as in the proof ofTheorem 4.2. It

is clear thatKis homeomorphic toSl−1l1 dimension unit sphereby an odd map. With

4.13, we get supKJ < 0. Thus all the conditions ofLemma 2.3are satisfied, andJ has at leastldistinct pairs of nonzero critical points. Consequently, BVP1.5possesses at leastl distinct pairs nontrivial solutions. The proof ofTheorem 4.4is complete.

4.2. The Sublinear Case

In this subsection, we will consider the case where f is sublinear. First, we assume the following.

P5There exist constantsa1>0, a2>0, R >0 and 1< α <2 such that

Fua1uαa2,u u1, u2, . . . , ukT ∈Rk, uR. 4.17

The first result is as follows.

Theorem 4.5. Suppose thatP5is satisfied and that matrix M is positive definite. Then BVP1.5

(10)

Proof. The proof will be finished when the existence of one critical point of functional J defined as in2.3is proved.

Assume that matrixMis positive definite. We denote byλ1, λ2, . . . , λkits eigenvalues,

where 0< λ1≤λ2≤ · · · ≤λk. Then for anyu u1, u2, . . . , ukT ∈Rk,uR, followed

byP5we have

Ju 1

2Mu, uFu

λ1u2−a1a2

−→∞ asu −→ ∞.

4.18

By the continuity ofJ on Rk, the above inequality means that there exists a lower bound of values of functionalJ. Classical calculus shows thatJ attains its minimal value at some point, and then there existusuch thatJu min{Ju|u∈Rk}. Clearly,uis a critical point of the functionalJ.

Corollary 4.6. Suppose that matrix M is positive definite, and fn, z satisfies that there exist constantsa1>0,a2>0and1< α <2such that

z

0

fn, sdsa1|z|αa2,n, z∈Z1, k×R. 4.19

Then BVP1.5possesses at least one solution.

Corollary 4.7. Suppose that matrix M is positive definite, andfn, zsatisfies the following.

P6There exists a constantt0 >0such that for anyn, z∈Z1, k×R,|fn, z|≤t0.

Then BVP1.5possesses at least one solution.

Proof. Assume that matrix M is positive definite. In this case, for any u

u1, u2, . . . , ukT ∈Rk,

|Fu| ≤k j1

uj

0

fj, sds

k

j1 t0u

jt0 ku. 4.20

Since the rest of the proof is similar toTheorem 4.5, we do not repeat them here.

WhenMis neither positive definite nor negative definite, we now assume thatMis nonsingular, and we have the following result.

Theorem 4.8. Suppose thatMis nonsingular,fn, zsatisfiesP6. Then BVP1.5possesses at

least one solution.

Proof. We may assume that M is neither positive definite nor negative definite. Let

(11)

0< λ1 ≤λ2 ≤ · · · ≤λmandlmk. For anyj ∈Z−l,−1∪Z1, m, letξjbe an eigenvector

ofMcorresponding to the eigenvalueλj,jl,l1, . . . ,−1,1,2, . . . , m, such that

ξi, ξj

⎧ ⎨ ⎩

0, asi /j,

1, asij, 4.21

LetX1andX2be subspaces ofRkdefined as follows:

X1span{ξi, i∈Z1, m}, X2span

ξj, j ∈Z−l,−1. 4.22

ThenRkhas the following decomposition of direct sum:

RkX

1

X2. 4.23

LetJube defined as in2.3. ThenJC1Rk,R. By4.20,

|Fu| ≤t0 ku,u∈Rk. 4.24

Suppose that{un} ⊂Rkis a P-S sequence. Then there exists a constantt1such that for

anyn∈Z1,|Jun| ≤t1andJun → 0 asn → ∞. Thus, for sufficiently largenand

for anyu∈Rk, we have|Jun, u| ≤ u.

LetunxnynX1X2. We have, by2.6, for anyu u1, u2, . . . , ukT

Rk,

Jun, uMun, uk

j1

fj, unj·uj. 4.25

Thus for sufficiently largen, we get

Mun, xnk

j1

fj, unj·xnjxn

t0

k

j1

xnjxn

t0 k1xn,

Mun, xnMxn, xnλ

1xn 2

.

(12)

Thus,

λ1xn 2

t0 k1xn, 4.27

which implies that{xn}is bounded.

Now we are going to prove that{yn}is also bounded. By4.25,

Mun, ynk

j1

fj, unj·ynjyn

≥ −t0 k1yn,

Mun, ynMyn, ynλ

−1yn 2

.

4.28

Thus we have

λ−1yn 2

≥ −t0 k1yn. 4.29

And so

λ1yn 2

t0 k1yn≤0. 4.30

Due to λ1 < 0,{yn} is bounded. Then {un} is bounded. Since Rk is a

finite-dimensional Hilbert space, there must exist a subsequence of{un}which is convergent in

Rk. Therefore, P-S condition is satisfied.

In order to apply the saddle point theorem to prove the conclusion, we consider the functional−Jand verify the conditions ofLemma 2.2.

For anyyX2,y y1, y2, . . . , ykT, we have

Jy−1

2

My, yFy

≥ −1

2λ−1y

2t

0 ky

≥ 1

2λ1

t0 k

2 .

4.31

(13)

For anyxX1,x x1, x2, . . . , xkT,

So far we have verified all the assumptions ofLemma 2.2and hence−Jhas at least a critical point inRk. This completes the proof.

Consider the following special case

Δ4un2 fn, un, nZ1, k,

It can be verified thatMis positive definite, then we have the following corollaries. Corollary 4.9. Suppose that there exist constantsa1>0, a2>0and1< α <2such that

z

0

fn, sdsa1|z|αa2,n, z∈Z1, k×R. 4.35

Then BVP4.33possesses at least one solution.

(14)

4.3. The Lipschitz Case

In this subsection, we suppose the following.

P7Assume that there exist positive constantsL,Ksuch that for anyn, z∈Z1, k×

R,

fn, zL|z|K. 4.36

Whenfn, zis Lipschitzian in the second variablez, namely, there exists a constant

L >0 such that for anyn∈Z1, k,z1,z2∈R,

fn, z1−fn, z2≤L|z1−z2|, 4.37

then condition4.36is satisfied.

Theorem 4.11. Suppose thatP7is satisfied and M is nonsingular. IfL < λmin min{λ1,λ−1},

where λ1 and λ−1 are the minimal positive eigenvalue and maximal negative eigenvalue of M,

respectively, then BVP1.5possesses at least one solution.

Proof. Assume that{un} ⊂ Rkis a P-S sequence. ThenJun → 0 asn → ∞. Thus for

sufficiently largen, we getJun ≤1. SinceJun Munfun, then for sufficiently largen,

Munfun1. 4.38

In view of4.36, we have

fun2k

j1

f2j, unjk

j1

LunjK2

L2k

j1

unj22LKk

j1

unjK2k.

4.39

It follows, by using the inequality√abc≤√abcfora≥0, b≥0, c≥0 and H ¨older’s inequality, that

funLun 2LK1/2k1/4un1/2Kk1/2. 4.40

By a similar argument to the proof ofTheorem 4.8, we can decompose Rk into the following form of direct sum:

RkX

1

(15)

whereX1andX2can be referred to4.22. Thusuncan be expressed by

the P-S condition is verified.

Now we are going to check conditionsF3andF4for functional−J. In fact, by4.36,

for some positive constantω.

For anyxX1,x x1, x2, . . . , xkT, we have

(16)

Finally, we consider the special case thatfn, zis independent of the second variable

z; that is,fn, zgnfor anyn, z∈Z1, k×R, the BVP1.1becomes

Δ2pn2un2 ΔqnΔun1gn, nZ1, k,

u−1 u0 0uk1 uk2.

4.48

As inSection 2, we reduce the existence of solutions of BVP4.48to the existence of critical points of a functionalJ1defined onRkas follows:

J1u 1

2Mu, uG, u,u u1, u2, . . . , uk

TRk, 4.49

where Mis defined as in2.4, andG g1, g2, . . . , gkT. Then we can see that the critical point ofJ1is just the solution to the following system of linear algebraic equations:

MuG0. 4.50

By using the theory of linear algebra, we have the next necessary and sufficient conditions.

Theorem 4.12. i BVP4.48has at least one solution if and only ifrM rM, G, where

rMdenotes the rank of matrixMandM, Gis the augmented matrix defined as follows:

(17)

Acknowledgment

This work is supported by the Specialized Fund for the Doctoral Program of Higher Eduction no. 20071078001.

References

1 A. R. Aftabizadeh, “Existence and uniqueness theorems for fourth-order boundary value problems,”

Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, vol. 116, no. 2, pp. 415–426, 1986.

2 C. P. Gupta, “Existence and uniqueness theorems for the bending of an elastic beam equation,”

Applicable Analysis, vol. 26, no. 4, pp. 289–304, 1988.

3 R. P. Agarwal, “On fourth order boundary value problems arising in beam analysis,”Differential and Integral Equations, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 91–110, 1989.

4 C. P. Gupta, “Existence and uniqueness theorems for some fourth order fully quasilinear boundary value problems,”Applicable Analysis, vol. 36, no. 3-4, pp. 157–169, 1990.

5 R. Ma and H. Wang, “On the existence of positive solutions of fourth-order ordinary differential equations,”Applicable Analysis, vol. 59, no. 1–4, pp. 225–231, 1995.

6 Z. Bai and H. Wang, “On positive solutions of some nonlinear fourth-order beam equations,”Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, vol. 270, no. 2, pp. 357–368, 2002.

7 Q. Yao, “Positive solutions of a nonlinear elastic beam equation rigidly fastened on the left and simply supported on the right,”Nonlinear Analysis: Theory, Methods & Applications, vol. 69, no. 5-6, pp. 1570– 1580, 2008.

8 M. Ruyun, Z. Jihui, and F. Shengmao, “The method of lower and upper solutions for fourth-order two-point boundary value problems,”Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, vol. 215, no. 2, pp. 415–422, 1997.

9 F. Li, Q. Zhang, and Z. Liang, “Existence and multiplicity of solutions of a kind of fourth-order boundary value problem,”Nonlinear Analysis: Theory, Methods & Applications, vol. 62, no. 5, pp. 803– 816, 2005.

10 G. Han and Z. Xu, “Multiple solutions of some nonlinear fourth-order beam equations,”Nonlinear Analysis: Theory, Methods & Applications, vol. 68, no. 12, pp. 3646–3656, 2008.

11 X. Cai, J. Yu, and Z. Guo, “Existence of periodic solutions for fourth-order difference equations,”

Computers & Mathematics with Applications, vol. 50, no. 1-2, pp. 49–55, 2005.

12 R. P. Agarwal, S. R. Grace, and J. V. Manojlovic, “On the oscillatory properties of certain fourth order nonlinear difference equations,”Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, vol. 322, no. 2, pp. 930–956, 2006.

13 E. Thandapani and I. M. Arockiasamy, “Fourth-order nonlinear oscillations of difference equations,”

Computers & Mathematics with Applications, vol. 42, no. 3–5, pp. 357–368, 2001.

14 E. Schmeidel and B. Szmanda, “Oscillatory and asymptotic behavior of certain difference equation,”

Nonlinear Analysis: Theory, Methods & Applications, vol. 47, no. 7, pp. 4731–4742, 2001.

15 Z. He and J. Yu, “On the existence of positive solutions of fourth-order difference equations,”Applied Mathematics and Computation, vol. 161, no. 1, pp. 139–148, 2005.

16 B. Zhang, L. Kong, Y. Sun, and X. Deng, “Existence of positive solutions for BVPs of fourth-order difference equations,”Applied Mathematics and Computation, vol. 131, no. 2-3, pp. 583–591, 2002. 17 J. Yu and Z. Guo, “On boundary value problems for a discrete generalized Emden-Fowler equation,”

Journal of Differential Equations, vol. 231, no. 1, pp. 18–31, 2006.

18 L. Jiang and Z. Zhou, “Three solutions to Dirichlet boundary value problems for p-Laplacian difference equations,”Advances in Difference Equations, vol. 2008, Article ID 345916, 10 pages, 2008. 19 L. Jiang and Z. Zhou, “Multiple nontrivial solutions for a class of higher dimensional discrete

boundary value problems,”Applied Mathematics and Computation, vol. 203, no. 1, pp. 30–38, 2008. 20 D. Bai and Y. Xu, “Nontrivial solutions of boundary value problems of second-order difference

equations,”Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, vol. 326, no. 1, pp. 297–302, 2007. 21 R. P. Agarwal, Difference Equations and Inequalities: Theory, Methods, and Applications, vol. 228 of

Monographs and Textbooks in Pure and Applied Mathematics, Marcel Dekker, New York, NY, USA, 2nd edition, 2000.

(18)

23 P. H. Rabinowitz,Minimax Methods in Critical Point Theory with Applications to Differential Equations, vol. 65 ofCBMS Regional Conference Series in Mathematics, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, USA, 1986.

References

Related documents

Nowhere in all 91 pages, is there proper recognition or discussion of the complexity of much (post qualifying) social care, such as in child welfare and safeguarding work, and

A wide variety of diagrams can be created throughout the various key stages of the learning process and they may be used to represent the level of learning..

The French consul, in his assessment of Midhat Pasha’s ideological shift away from the promotion of liberty, equality, and citizenship, argued that Midhat Pasha

A comparison of pregnancy and implantation rates following embryo transfer after in vitro fertilization with oocytes donated by paid donors versus infertile women sharing

Most psychological research that I learned about as an undergraduate was quantitative; but qualitative methods, like interviews, were sometimes used and in fact I later used

4.10 A diagrammatic representation of the relationship between the lexical items ‘tea’ / ‘war’ and the canonical conceptual oppositions on which they are

• To deliver three groupwork programmes in Calderdale Women’s Centre, which address the impact of domestic violence on positive parenting and relationship building.. Year

In par- ticular, log crop yield is the natural logarithm of the crop output divided by its area planted, normalised to mean 1; rainfall and temperature are measured as