© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. CONTENTS
Why a Course on Policy?
Information Security Policy Policy in Context
Regulatory Drivers Policy Standards
Policy Development
Writing Policies and Guidelines … and Summary
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. SECTION OBJECTIVES
1. Emphasize the importance of security policy.
2. Present the areas security policy addresses.
3. Look at policy as a layer within the context of Defense in Depth.
WHY POLICY?
Policy is the foundation for all the other elements in information security.
Without effective policies there is no basis for ensuring that security tools,
technologies, and processes are used appropriately to address risks.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. WHY POLICY?
Developing policy is an art, always specific to the organization in question.
No one can sell you pre-written policies.
There are processes, templates, and good information sources that can help.
WHY POLICY?
Security in many organizations today is too focused on technology and tools, and not enough on business requirements,
physical and information assets, and risk assessment.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. WHY POLICY?
Policy addresses all elements of security in your organization:
People
Communications
Processes and operations
Physical and intellectual property Technical infrastructure
WHY POLICY?
Security is
commonly handled from the bottom
up, but…
The most effective security structure begins from the top down Æ
Security Technologies
Security Standards & Guidelines Security Policies
Business Requirements
Exec Mgmt
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. WHAT IS POLICY?
Security policy is a set of documents that explain how an organization will protect its physical and electronic assets.
Policy states what will (or will not) be
done, how policy is to be carried out and enforced, and often why the policy exists.
WHAT IS POLICY?
Security policy addresses: Employee behavior
Business practices Risk management Operations
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. EMPLOYEE BEHAVIOR
Acceptable use policy
Email and communications policy Security awareness and education Access control policy
Regulatory compliance
Roles and responsibilities
BUSINESS PRACTICES
Acceptable use policy
External communications policy Transaction security policy
Privacy policy
Change management Security planning
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. RISK MANAGEMENT
Business asset valuation Risk acceptance policy
Mission Impact Assessment
Disaster recovery/business continuity policy
Internal controls
Audit and assessment policy
OPERATIONS
Acceptable use policy
Email and communications policy Network and security monitoring Incident response
Access control policy Physical security
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. TECHNICAL MEASURES
Anti-virus policy Firewall policy
Intrusion detection policy Application security policy
Identity management and provisioning Access control
Fraud detection
DEFENSE IN DEPTH
Is the practice of layering defenses to improve an organization’s security
posture.
Is a leading security principle in information assurance.
Applies to any or all layers in a security architecture.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. DEFENSE IN DEPTH
Defense in depth is an integrated set of
information security measures and actions, implemented to provide multiple layers of security across:
People
Technology Operations
DEFENSE IN DEPTH
People
Information security begins with
commitment from senior management Policies and procedures should cover all organizational aspects related to people
Training and awareness Personnel security
Human resources Physical security
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. DEFENSE IN DEPTH
Technology
Security measures should be deployed at network, platform, and application layers Security technology should be chosen to address stated policies based on identified risks
Technology is a means to implement security policy
DEFENSE IN DEPTH
Operations
Day-to-day activities to maintain security posture:
Security management
Monitoring and event management Readiness assessments and testing Certification and accreditation
Intrusion detection, alerting, and response Patch management
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. DEFENSE IN DEPTH
Security layers form a concentric set of boundaries:
Network Infrastructure
Computing Platforms
Application Environment
DEFENSE IN DEPTH
Multiple Controls Across Multiple Layers
Physical Security
Locks Biometrics PIV Credentials/ID Badges CCTV Disaster Recovery/COOP Guards RFID
Perimeter (Network Layer)
Boundary Routers VPN Firewalls Proxy Servers
Network IDS/IPS RADIUS NAC Gateway Anti-Virus Spam Blocker
Host (Platform Layer)
Host IDS/IPS Server Anti-Virus Server Anti-Spyware Desktop Anti-Virus Patch Management Server Certificates
Software (Application Layer)
Web Service Security Application Proxy Input Validation Database Security Content Filter Data Encryption Identity Management
Personnel (User Layer)
Authentication & Authorization PKI RBAC Training Two-Factor Authentication Biometrics Clearances
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. LEADING INFOSEC INVESTMENTS
Network Security
Distributed security controls
Policy and configuration enforcement (NAC) Event monitoring and management (SIEM) User Management
User provisioning/identity management Single sign-on
Content Security
Anti-virus/anti-spyware
Content filtering and spam control Data loss protection
INTRO WORKSHOP
9 Task: Build class company situation addressing industry, structure, operations areas, and user communities.
SECURITY POLICY
SECTION OBJECTIVES
1. Provide an overview of security policy.
2. Define and show the relationship between policies, standards, guidelines, and
procedures.
3. Identify categories and key components of security policies.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. INFORMATION SECURITY POLICY
Policies, Standards, Guidelines
Elements of Policies, Standards & Guidelines Policy Objectives
Policy Classifications Policy Components
Information Security Policy Framework Policy Support
Policy Development Lifecycle Delivery Methods
INFORMATION SECURITY POLICY
Without strong management policies, corporate security programs will be less effective and not align with management objectives.
Policies are the blueprint for the security framework
Policies, Standards and Guidelines enables the corporation to implement the specific controls processes and awareness programs to raise the level of information security and assurance.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. POLICES & STANDARDS
Policies
High Level “umbrellas” Low Level
Standards
Corporate-wide standards Local Guidelines
Procedures
Local repeatable processes
User Management Policies
All system users must be individually identified
OS Authentication
Unix, Windows users … Administrative access vs. general
How-To
Request an account Approve a new system
HOW THEY RELATE
Policy
Governance “Thou Shall”
What Management wants to achieve and why.
Standards
Desired Mechanisms
Technical specification of how to implement policy
Procedure
Steps to carry out
Detailed instructions
Guidelines
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. ELEMENTS OF A POLICY
Scope – What you are going to protect
High Level Policy Statement – 30,000 ft overview Accountability – personnel
Non- compliance – a statement pertaining to loss if compromised
Monitoring – how policies, standards or guidelines will be validated
Exceptions – in the event that a community of users cannot meet compliance
INFORMATION SECURITY POLICY OBJECTIVES
Foster information confidentiality
Outline data integrity responsibilities Define assets that require protection
How resources should be used efficiently and appropriately
Provide for system availability Raise awareness
Provide a foundation, a roadmap and a compass for information security audit, process,
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved.
WORKSHOP #1
9 Task: Draft security policy outlines for 3 of the following:
• Acceptable use • Data protection/privacy • Change management • Firewalls • Building access • Network authentication • Anti-virus • Intrusion detection • Information classification • Business continuity 33
ELEMENTS OF A STANDARD
Scope – How you are going to protect
Role & Responsibilities – defining, executing, and supporting standards
Guidance – references overriding policy statements
Baseline standards – high level statements for platform and applications
Technical Standard – product/version
specifications and associated descriptions
Administrative Standard - initial and ongoing administration of platform and applications
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. ELEMENTS OF A GUIDELINE
Guidelines should be based on industry best practices (whenever possible)
Purpose – to efficiently meet the standard and policy requirements
Intent – description of guideline’s objectives
Roles & Responsibilities – defining, executing and supporting guidelines
Guideline Statements – step by step process to implement policy elements
Operational Statements - defines the “how” of day to day operations
POLICY DEVELOPMENT LIFE-CYCLE
Planning:
•Requirements
•ID core corp. issues
•Solicit input from groups •Data collection
Development:
•Draft initial position statement •Security group interaction •Legal, ITSC, HR input
•Best practices
•Coordinated draft policy •Security council review •Policy approval Implementation: •Supporting docs •Roll-out •Awareness Periodic Review: •Incidents •Audit •Controls effectiveness Policy Mgmt
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. POLICY CLASSIFICATIONS Regulatory Public Internal Confidential Restrictive (Private)
HIPAA, FCRA, GLBA, SOX
Marketing materials
Trade secrets, proprietary ideas, HR Information
Non-public corporate financial reports
Corporate payroll information, credit card transactions,
customer data
POLICY CATEGORIES
Information Security
Computer security policy Program policy Issue-specific policy System-specific policy General Business HR policies Travel policy
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. COMMON POLICY COMPONENTS
Intent / Purpose
Scope and applicability
Policy authors and sponsors Roles and responsibilities
Effective and review dates Compliance measures
Supplementary information and resources
GENERAL POLICY CONTENT
Date of effective enforcement
Statement of intent and audience
Sponsor / authorizing corporate officer (or committee) Policy objectives and expectations
Exception and change request process Breach of policy response process
Review and expiration dates
Corporate boundaries outlined in policy
Prohibited activities, liability issues, legal requirements, due diligence, etc.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. POLICY DELIVERY
Email, Intranet, Paper, Training class Get everyone involved and interested Solicit feedback
Make “fun” policy delivery continual Enforce and reinforce
Part of security awareness and training
WORKSHOP #2
9 Task: Fill out the 3 outlines from WS#1 with the contents on the previous slide.
SECURITY POLICY
SECTION OBJECTIVES
1. Show policy’s role within an information security program.
2. Explain the steps in the management of the information security program.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. SECURITY MANAGEMENT FRAMEWORK
Information Security Management ISO/IEC 27001 & 27002
Enterprise Security Policies Standards & Guidelines
Compliance, Monitoring & Audits
Best Practices
You need to start with a foundation … Where implementation details are resolved by the business … Which are validated and watched to assure they are being implemented in practice …
And which are expressed as activities and practices that are of high quality …
Grounded in a comprehensive structure … 1 2 3 4 5 45
POLICIES & TECHNICAL ARCHITECTURE Policy Definition Policies Personnel Statutory Program Mgmt Security Incident Info Classification Systems Life Cycle Physical & Environ
Audit Telecom Logical Access Id / Auth / Auth Remote Access Computer Systems Support & Operations
Guidelines Standards
Tech Controls Risk Mgmt
Inventory Asset
Ownership Assessment Analysis
Technical Security Architecture
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. INFORMATION SECURITY PROGRAM
Technology Integration Operations, Administration & Control Audit & Review Process Prototyping & Elaboration Policy Design Assess
Deploy Manage &
Support
INFORMATION ASSURANCE MODEL Monitoring, Detection and Prevention Incident Response, Risk Mitigation Vulnerability Analysis, Audit & Review, Forensics Control Selection, Implementation and Operation Policy Protect Assess Detect Respond
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. THE ISMS (ISO 27001) MODEL
Establish the ISMS Maintain and Improve the ISMS Implement and Operate the ISMS Monitor and Review the ISMS Plan Do Check Act Information Security Requirements and Expectations Managed Information Security & Operations
49
POLICY
Policy is the hub of the wheel … its central focus.
It should be a reference point for actions taken and decisions made.
Policy should be used when activities “on the wheel” are undertaken.
Reviews should be conducted to ensure policy reflects business objectives.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. AUDIT, ASSESSMENT & REVIEW
Policy is a key component of audit activities: Evaluate current security picture
Compare against policy
Performed on a regular basis and after a security event or as defined by a
regulatory agency
Results of audit and review process are used in the next phase of the security process
SECURITY STRATEGIC PLANNING
Iterative policy development should be part of strategic planning cycles:
High level planning
Use policy as a benchmark and a compass New strategic initiatives always impact
policy
Looks at process, not technology Uses audit and review findings
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. TECHNOLOGY INTEGRATION
The way security technologies work together is driven by security policy (remember defense in depth):
Technical planning and implementation Based on policy
Uses audit and review as well as developed
process to determine technological requirements Tactical implementation of strategic goals
The swords and shields of information security
POLICY MANAGEMENT TOOLS
Apply security policies to systems
Validate computers and applications connecting to the environment
Detect policy compromise
Automatic remediation if out of compliance May maintain “white list” of applications
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. Operation, Administration and Control
Operational actions should be dictated by policy: Keeping the processes and technology running Responding to security events
Testing and practicing the right execution People play a key role
Uses technology, process and policy to provide input to the audit and review process
WORKSHOP #3
9 Task: Write a security awareness policy to communicate the information security program to employees. How would this differ for customers? (to be revisited…)
SECURITY POLICY
SECTION OBJECTIVES
1. Define and explain major regulatory requirements affecting policy.
2. Understand which and what type of regulations impact your organization.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. DUE CARE
What it is:
General principle addressing obligation of
business managers to act reasonably and in the best interests of their organizations
What it means:
Management can be held accountable for the efforts taken (or not taken) to comply with
regulations, including those governing privacy safeguards and related policies.
HIPAA
What it is:
Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996
A set of regulations governing health data privacy Affects medical service providers, insurance
companies, companies, schools, etc.
Intended to allow individuals to control access to and release of their personal medical information Specifies what must be protected, and who has to safeguard it, but not how data is protected
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. HIPAA
What it means:
Healthcare industry participants must ensure that personal data is only disclosed subject to patient consent
Applies to many health transactions that have been
automated in recent years, as well as manual processes Extends responsibility to data in transit over and between networks
Strongly implies needs for encryption, authentication, authorization, and other security provisions, but leaves implementation details to organizations.
HIPAA
What has to be done:
Effective in April 2003, affected organizations must implement procedures to comply with the Privacy Rule
Includes consumer/patient notification, preferences, and
explicit permission for release of protected health information (PHI)
Since 2005, these same organizations must achieve compliance with the Security Rule
Establishes guidelines for the minimum requirements to ensure confidentiality, security and integrity of electronically stored and transmitted health information.
Covers electronic and non-electronic forms of information Does not provide specific instruction on how organizations should safeguard PHI
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. GLBA
What it is:
Graham-Leach-Bliley Financial Services Modernization Act of 1999
A set of regulations governing financial data privacy Affects financial institutions and affiliated businesses working with personal financial data
Particularly addresses sharing of non-public personal information by financial institutions
Intended to allow individuals to control use and release of their personal financial information
Specifies what must be protected, and who has to safeguard it, and acceptable compliance guidelines
GLBA
What it means:
Financial institutions must disclose their privacy policies up-front and again at least annually
Requires FI’s to deliver privacy policy notices to consumers/customers to offer and describe opt-out provisions
Holds FI’s responsible for safeguarding customer data whether through normal business
operations, theft, fraud, or exceptional circumstances
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. SARBANES-OXLEY
What it is:
Public Company Accounting Reform and Investor Protection (Sarbanes-Oxley) Act of 2002
A set of regulations governing financial reporting requirements for companies
Reduces the time allotted for release of earnings and other financial report data
SARBANES-OXLEY
What it means:
Senior management now requires more up-to-date understanding of all financial information
Managers must certify and be accountable for the financial reports their companies issue
Managers must describe and evaluate their internal controls for effectiveness
All findings must be certified by external auditors Many former IT responsibilities elevated to
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. FISMA
What it is:
Federal Information Security Management Act (Title III of E-Government Act of 2002)
A set of organizational practices, roles, and
responsibilities for government agencies related to information security.
Applies to all federal agencies and contractors managing or maintaining federal systems.
FISMA
What it means:
All federal agencies submit annual reports on
security practices, controls, and level and extent of documentation.
Agency-level scores given based on factors such as consistent and comprehensive implementation of practices, and effective use of controls.
Responsibility for information security placed under federal CIOs, following standards and guidance produced by NIST.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. CALIFORNIA SECURITY BREACH NOTIFICATION
What it is:
SB 1386 passed in 2003 covering any person or business that conducts business in California
Requires businesses to give public notice of information security breaches resulting in disclosure of personal
information.
Notification only must occur to California residents;
however, 37 other states have now enacted similar laws Only exception is for encrypted data.
Statute applies regardless of where the data is physically stored or where the breach occurs.
EUROPEAN UNION DIRECTIVES
EU Data Protection Directive (1998)
Imposes data privacy requirements on entities that transport data across national borders.
Places data ownership and control in the hands of originating businesses.
Explicit permission for third-party data sharing
Disclosure/data sharing must be in the interest of the data subject
Applies to US companies that do business with the EU Rules in US Dept. of Commerce “safe harbor” privacy framework
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. EUROPEAN UNION DIRECTIVES
EU E-Commerce Directive (2000)
Creates minimum requirements for selling to EU consumers and businesses online.
Addresses both business practices and information transparency.
Mandatory business location and contact information Reproduce-ability of online contract terms
Prompt notice of order confirmation
Local additional imposed by some EU member states
EUROPEAN UNION DIRECTIVES
EU Electronic Communications Directive (2002) Creates a framework for an EU-wide effort to regulate unsolicited electronic mail or “spam.” Prohibits businesses without pre-existing
customer relationships to solicit consumers unless they opt in.
Makes illegal the common US business practice of sharing marketing leads between affiliated
companies.
Also constrains the use of “cookies” without explicit consumer notification.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved.
WORKSHOP #4
9 Task: Determine what regulatory or other governing principles apply to our organization. Write a customer or public notification communicating the relevant policy.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. SECTION OBJECTIVES
1. Define and explain major information security standards relevant to policy. 2. Identify sources of information to help
guide policy and standard development.
Examples of Standards
ISO/IEC 27001 and 27002 (ISO 17799) Common Criteria
NIST 800 Series of Special Publications NIST Federal Information Processing Standards (FIPS)
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. ISO/IEC 27001 & 27002
The ISO/IEC 27000 series is a comprehensive set of
controls comprising best practices in information security. It is an internationally recognized information security
standard, broad in scope and generic in applicability. It focuses on risk identification, assessment and
management. It is aligned with common business goals:
Ensure business continuity Minimize business damage
Maximized return on investments
It is about information security, not IT security. It is much more commonly applied in commercial organizations than in government.
ISO/IEC 27001 & 27002 (from ISO 17799)
Originally created as BS17799, this framework was first submitted in 1995, and revised in 1998, but was not
adopted by the International Standards Organization until 1999 .
Significantly revised in 2005, it was formally converted to two related International Standards
Organization/International Electrotechnical Commission (ISO/IEC) standards, 27001 & 27002.
ISO 17799 covers both security management practices and security controls.
Somewhat confusingly, what had been referred to as Part 1 and Part 2 in the 17799 standard were numerically reversed in the new ISO/IEC numbering, so that Part 1 becomes
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. THE STANDARD
Part 1 – Code of Practice
ISO 17799 (became ISO 27002 in July 2007) provides 133 security controls under 39 security
categories organized into 11 major clauses to identify the particular safeguards that are appropriate to their particular business.
These security controls correspond to hundreds of more detailed
technologies, measures, and elements of practice.
The standard stresses the importance of risk management and makes it clear that you do not have to
implement every single guideline; only those that are relevant.
Part 2 – IS Management Standard
ISO/IEC 27001 tells how to build an Information Security Management System. It defines a four-step process instructing you how to apply ISO/IEC 17799 and how to establish,
implement, monitor, and maintain an
ISMS.
It is a formal methodology for setting up an information security management system.
ISO/IEC 27001 establishes guidelines and general principles for initiating, implementing, maintaining, and improving information security management in an organization.
THE INFORMATION SECURITY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
ISO 27001 provides a comprehensive process reference for establishing and operationalizing and information security management system. “System” in this context means a set of explicit, standard, repeatable processes and activities, and not necessarily a hardware- or software-based
mechanism.
There are numerous vendor tools on the market intended to implement an ISMS according to the ISO 27001 standard.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. THE ISMS MODEL: PLAN-DO-CHECK-ACT
Phase ISMS Action Description
Plan Establish Establish ISMS policy, objectives, processes and procedures relevant to managing risk and improving information security to deliver results in accordance with an
organization’s overall policies and objectives. Do Implement and Operate Implement and operate the ISMS policy,
controls, processes and procedures. Check Monitor and Review Assess and, where applicable, measure
process performance against ISMS policy, objectives and practical experience and report the results to management for review.
Act Maintain and Improve Take corrective and preventive actions, based on the results of the internal ISMS audit and management review or other relevant information, to achieve continual improvement of the ISMS.
ISO/IEC 27001
Adopts a process approach for establishing, implementing, operating, monitoring, reviewing, maintaining and improving an organization's Information Security Management System (ISMS).
The approach presented in ISO 27001 encourages its users to emphasize the importance of:
a) understanding an organization’s information security requirements and the need to establish policy and objectives for information security;
b) implementing and operating controls to manage an organization's information security risks in the context of the organization’s overall business risks;
c) monitoring and reviewing the performance and effectiveness of the ISMS; and
d) continual improvement based on objective measurement.
Reflects the principles articulated in the Guideline for the Security of Information Systems and Networks, published in 2002 by the
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. ISO/IEC 27001 PROCESS APPROACH
Information security management system
General requirements
Establishing and managing the ISMS
Establish the ISMS
Implement and operate the ISMS
Monitor and review the ISMS Maintain and improve the ISMS Documentation requirements General Control of documents Control of records Management responsibility Management commitment Resource management Provision of resources Training, awareness and competence
Internal ISMS audits
Management review of the ISMS General Review input Review output ISMS improvement Continual improvement Corrective action Preventive action
The ISO 27001 standard presents a concise (process steps contained in just 10 pages) prescription for information security management.
ISO 27002 CLAUSES
The 11 clauses (with the number of main security categories included within each clause) are:
Security Policy (1)
Organizing Information Security (2) Asset Management (2)
Human Resources Security (3)
Physical and Environmental Security (2)
Communications and Operations Management (10) Access Control (7)
Information Systems Acquisition, Development and Maintenance (6) Information Security Incident Management (2)
Business Continuity Management (1) Compliance (3)
ISO 27002 also has a preliminary section of Risk Assessment and
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. COMMON CRITERIA
Provides a basis for evaluating security properties of IT products and systems. Sections:
1. Introduction & General Model
2. Security Functional Requirements 3. Security Assurance Requirements
COMMON CRITERIA – PART 1
Defines general concepts & principles
Presents constructs for expressing security objectives and defining requirements
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. COMMON CRITERIA – PART 2
Established a set of functional components as a standard way of expressing the
functional requirements for evaluated systems
Used for guidance when formulating
statements of requirements for security functions
COMMON CRITERIA – PART 3
Establishes a set of assurance components as a standard way of expressing the
assurance requirements for evaluated systems
Catalogs the set of assurance components, facilities & classes
Used when determining required levels of assurance
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. COMMON CRITERIA: RELATIONSHIPS
Countermeasures Threats Vulnerabilities Risk Assets value wish to minimize impose may be reduced by leading to may contain exploit to reduce may be aware of Owners Threat
Agents wish to abuse and/or damage give rise to
to
that increase
to
NIST 800 SERIES
A set of guidelines covering a broad range of security topics, from high-level planning and security practices, to detailed
treatment of specific technologies
The government’s take at “best practices”
Primary focus for Certification & Accreditation requirements, especially in the federal civilian arena.
Targeted at federal agencies, but useful commercially too.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. NIST 800 SERIES
General security practices:
800-14 (Securing IT systems) 800-16 (Security training)
800-18 (Security plans)
800-30 (Risk management)
800-34 (Contingency planning)
800-37 (Certification & Accreditation) 800-53A (Security assessment)
800-64 (Security in the SDLC)
800-100 (Information Security Handbook) 800-115 (Security testing)
NIST 800 SERIES
Focused security practices: 800-3 (Incident response) 800-9 (E-commerce)
800-21 (Implementing cryptography)
800-23 (Security assurance & acquisition) 800-40 (Patch handling)
800-44 (Securing public web servers) 800-88 (Media sanitization)
800-92 (Security log management) 800-95 (Secure web services)
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. NIST 800 SERIES
Security technology guidelines: 800-25 (Digital signatures)
800-31 (IDS)
800-32 (Federal PKI) 800-41 (Firewalls)
800-45 (Email security)
800-48 (Wireless network security) 800-77 (IPSec VPNs)
800-94 (IDS and IPS systems) 800-113 (SSL VPNs)
800-123 (Server security)
FEDERAL INFORMATION PROCESSING STANDARDS (FIPS)
Mandatory Security Standards: FIPS 140 (Cryptographic modules)
FIPS 186 (Digital signature standard)
FIPS 191 (Local area network (LAN) security)
FIPS 197 (Advanced encryption standard (AES)) FIPS 199 (Security categorization)
FIPS 200 (Minimum security requirements) FIPS 201 (Personal identity verification)
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved.
WORKSHOP #5
9 Task: Select an appropriate standard for use in implementing our organization’s security policies. Write a standard for vendor
selection, keeping Defense in Depth principles in mind.
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. SECTION OBJECTIVES
1. Define policy hierarchy.
2. Identify key policy documents. 3. Describe major policy topics.
4. Present functional policy scope. 5. Present technical policy scope.
POLICY DEVELOPMENT
Effective security policy implementation rests with the guidelines and procedures that translate security policies and
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. POLICY HIERARCHY
Information security policy applies at many inter-related levels:
Corporate or agency-wide
Department or business unit Functional processes
Technical measures
ENTERPRISE POLICY MANAGEMENT
Eliminate unwanted users, computers, and applications from the enterprise
Protect users, computers, and applications from compromise
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. KEY POLICY DOCUMENTS
Security Policies and Procedures Manual (SPPM)
Security Administrator Manual (SAM) Information Security Plan
SECURITY POLICIES AND PROCEDURES MANUAL
Consolidated security policy reference Serves as authoritative source/record Policies address what is to be done
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. SECURITY ADMINISTRATOR MANUAL
Administrative reference for security staff Emphasis on operational guidelines
Addresses major administrative procedures
Monitoring and alerting
Notification and incident response Backup and recovery
Systems and penetration testing
INFORMATION SECURITY PLAN
Enterprise-wide strategic and tactical plan May be part of corporate IT Plan
Should correlate directly to business strategic plan
Must be available and accessible First place auditors go to
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. POLICY COMPONENTS
Statement of Purpose Scope
Roles and Responsibilities
Effective Implementation and Review Dates
Specified Security Practices
POLICY TOPICS
Asset Classification and Control Access Control Privacy Organizational Practices Systems Development Incident Response Communications
Physical Security and Operations
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. SUGGESTED DEVELOPMENT PRIORITY
Information Security Policies
Overarching statement from senior mgmt
Cover the 11 domains, 39 control areas (ISO 27002)
Access & Identification Security Policies Technology & Communications Policies Support & Operations Security Policies
Physical & Environmental Security Policies
FUNCTIONAL POLICIES Acceptable use Incident response Disaster recovery Privacy Awareness Change management
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. ACCEPTABLE USE
Coverage and responsibility Internal and external uses Data ownership
Data protection requirements
Personal use of corporate systems
INCIDENT RESPONSE
Coverage: known and unknown threats Prioritization/criticality
Incident response team
Incident response procedures Discovery
Notification Escalation
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. DISASTER RECOVERY
Defining disasters Coverage
Recovery time
Supporting processes (e.g. backup, off-site)
DR team
Recovery procedures Test plan
PRIVACY
Scope
Internal and external requirements Data stewardship
Levels of protection needed
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. AWARENESS Policy distribution Awareness training Communication plan Compliance expectations Non-compliance consequences Sign-off 113
CHANGE MANAGEMENT
Scope and coverage
Change request procedures
Change management decision making Thresholds for escalation
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. TECHNICAL POLICIES Access control Anti-virus Identity management Intrusion detection/protection Application security Email Encryption
Web server configuration
ACCESS CONTROL
Mandatory/discretionary access
Role-based and/or resource-based Authentication and authorization Remote access
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. ANTI-VIRUS
Coverage (local, wide-area, remote) Potential points/sources of infection Use of AV software
AV gateways (e.g. email servers) Update requirements
Patch management Mobile devices
IDENTITY MANAGEMENT
User provisioning
User de-provisioning
Authorization and identification
Credentialing (issue and revocation) Password policies
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. INTRUSION DETECTION/PREVENTION
IDS/IPS placement within the architecture Event logging, monitoring, and correlation Intrusion notification and response
Internal and external protection Network IDS
Host IDS
APPLICATION SECURITY
Application coverage
Network-level protection (e.g. application proxy firewalls)
Coding requirements Parameter validation Session management Authorization
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. EMAIL Usage parameters Monitoring Archiving requirements Remote access Email integrity Attachment handling 121
ENCRYPTION
Required and recommended use
Strength required/approved algorithms Authentication
Accountability/Non-repudiation Data protection
Information in transit Information at rest
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. WEB SERVER CONFIGURATION
Server placement within architecture Required services and ports available Process permissions (e.g. “run-as”) General access control
Administrative access control
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. SECTION OBJECTIVES
1. Describe policy writing process. 2. Review major policy categories.
3. Outline one policy area from each category.
4. Understand by example guideline structure and content.
POLICY WRITING
Get broad involvement in the process Department representatives
Legal
Human resources
Information Technology Audit and compliance
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. POLICY WRITING
Gather the requirements that drive policy Business objectives Regulatory requirements Functional requirements Technical requirements User requirements 127
POLICY WRITING
Be clear
Policies should be well written State policies succinctly
Leave no room for misinterpretation Emphasize brevity where you can
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. POLICY WRITING
Avoid naming specific technologies
Classes of technology may be appropriate Vendors or products appear in standards
Granular policies and procedures may need to be tied to a specific technology (e.g. operating system)
Technical standards compliance may be specified for products (e.g. FIPS 140-2)
POLICY WRITING
Educate the organization
Even the most appropriate policies are
ineffective if they are not communicated and understood
Adherence requires awareness Policies need distribution
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. POLICY WRITING
Policies are living documents
Policy is a process, not a one-time initiative Review and revision cycles are part of policy Keeping current is essential
Interdependencies mean that changes in one area need to be examined for impacts to others
POLICY WRITING
Policies must be enforced
Non-compliance comes with consequences Actions back up words
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. POLICY WRITING
Tools are available to facilitate policy creation
PoliVec Policy Builder
NetIQ/PentaSafe VigilEnt Policy Center Symantec Enterprise Security Manager Information Shield PolicyShield
BindView (now also part of Symantec)
INFORMATION SECURITY POLICIES Data classification Acceptable use Data protection Privacy Risk Management
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. RISK MANAGEMENT Introduction Authority Purpose Objectives Target Audience Related Policies 135
RISK MANAGEMENT
Overview
Importance of Risk Management Governing regulations
Incorporating Risk Management into IT Processes
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. RISK MANAGEMENT
Risk Assessment
System identification and characterization Threat identification Vulnerability identification Control Analysis Likelihood determination Impact Analysis Risk determination 137
RISK MANAGEMENT
Risk Mitigation Options
Strategy
Controls and implementation Cost-benefit analysis
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. ACCESS & IDENTIFICATION POLICIES
Authentication Authorization PKI Biometrics Digital signatures 139
DIGITAL SIGNATURES
Purpose and objectives Background and scope
Applicability to electronic services Public Key technology and PKI
Usage of certificates Certification process
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. TECHNOLOGY & COMMUNICATION POLICIES
Firewall Anti-virus Email
Mobile Data Protection Encryption
Intrusion detection/intrusion protection Web server configuration
Network connectivity
WEB SERVER CONFIGURATION
Introduction Authority
Purpose and scope Target audience
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. WEB SERVER CONFIGURATION
Planning and management
Planning a web server deployment Security management staffing
Management practices System security plan Web server platforms
WEB SERVER CONFIGURATION
Secure installation and configuration Network placement
Installing and configuring the OS Testing the OS
Platform security resources and responsibility Installing and configuring the web server
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. WEB SERVER CONFIGURATION
Secure web access
Security of web content
Collection of personal information Active and dynamic content controls Authentication requirements
Data integrity requirements Encryption requirements
WEB SERVER CONFIGURATION
Web server administration Logging and monitoring
Backup and restore procedures Security/penetration testing plan Intrusion/compromise recovery Remote administration
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. WEB SERVER CONFIGURATION
Web server administration Logging and monitoring
Backup and restore procedures Security/penetration testing plan Intrusion/compromise recovery Remote administration
SUPPORT & OPERATIONS SECURITY POLICIES Incident response Event correlation Disaster recovery Business continuity Security awareness Change management
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. INCIDENT RESPONSE
Overview Purpose
Coverage and responsibility Current threat environment Need for incident response
Proactive and reactive postures
Incident response interaction with other areas
INCIDENT RESPONSE
Establishing an Incident Response Team Goals and objectives
Constituencies served IRT structure
Management support and accountability Standard operating procedures handbook Staffing the team
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. INCIDENT RESPONSE
Operations
Communications plan Logging and monitoring Incident notification
Legal obligations
Public/media disclosure policy Post-incident analysis
PHYSICAL & ENVIRONMENTAL POLICIES
Building/facility access Perimeter security
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. FACILITY ACCESS
Purpose and objectives Coverage and scope
Individual and management responsibility Zone classification
Access control provisions
Employee and contractor access rules Credentialing and revocation
GUIDELINES
Guidelines explain how policies and standards will be achieved.
Specific to operational practices and technologies
May include educational information Topical descriptions and definitions Tips and tricks, lessons learned
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. GUIDELINES: REAL-WORLD EXAMPLE
Take as an example, NIST Special
Publication 800-41, “Guidelines on Firewalls and Firewall Policy”
Introduction
Purpose and scope
Audience and assumptions Document organization
GUIDELINES: REAL-WORLD EXAMPLE
Overview of Firewall Platforms Intro to Firewall Technology Packet Filter Firewalls
Stateful Inspection Firewalls
Application Proxy Gateway Firewalls Dedicated Proxy Servers
Hybrid Firewall Technologies Network Address Translation Host-based Firewalls
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. GUIDELINES: REAL-WORLD EXAMPLE
Firewall Environments
Guidelines for Building Firewall Environments DMZ Networks
Virtual Private Networks Intranets
Extranets
Infrastructure Components: Hubs and Switches Intrusion Detection Systems
Domain Name Service (DNS)
Placement of Servers in Firewall Environments
GUIDELINES: REAL-WORLD EXAMPLE
Firewall Security Policy
Firewall Policy
Implementing a Firewall Ruleset Testing Firewall Policy
Firewall Implementation Approach Firewall Maintenance & Management
Physical Security Of The Firewall Environment
Periodic Review Of Information Security Policies A Sample Topology and Ruleset
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. GUIDELINES: REAL-WORLD EXAMPLE
Firewall Administration
Access To The Firewall Platform
Firewall Platform Operating System Builds Firewall Failover Strategies
Firewall Logging Functionality Security Incidents
Firewall Backups
Function-Specific Firewalls
PROCEDURES
Step-by-step recipe for how to implement and configure security measures
Explicit documentation from both the
vendor and the implementing organization Technology specific
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: REAL-WORLD EXAMPLE
Filtering (varies by type of firewall):
Physical location of packet (inside/outside perimeter) Source address
Destination address
Type of TCP/IP application (service, port) Relationship to other packets
Application function content (e.g., GET, PUT)
Action/Result:
Accept: allow packet to pass through Drop: deny access; no response
Deny/Reject: deny access; respond with ICMP echo
Logging
POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: REAL-WORLD EXAMPLE
Access control rules are processed in order Once a rule is satisfied, no other rules are
checked - packet is either accepted or denied depending on the rule
If no rules are satisfied, the packet is denied (default for most firewalls)
Complex and/or poor sequencing of policies rules that result in packets to be accepted may create security vulnerabilities
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. POLICY IMPLEMENTATION: REAL-WORLD EXAMPLE
WORKSHOP #7
SECURITY POLICY
WHY DO WE NEED POLICY?
Compliance
Exceed Industry Practices Response
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. WHY: COMPLIANCE
Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)
Health Care Industry
Graham-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA) Financial services institutions
“Reasonable man” measure
Businesses are legally obligated to install well-known safety measures to protect against well-known threats Limit liability
Complex system of federal, state, and sector-specific laws
WHY: INDUSTRY PRACTICES
Certification and accreditation Standards certification
ISO/IEC
Common Criteria
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. WHY: RESPONSE
Incident response
Event management, correlation, and response
Disaster response and recovery
WHY: RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk analysis and mitigation Audit and assessment
SECURITY POLICY
CERT (www.cert.org)
What is it?
Computer Emergency Response Team
Run by the Software Engineering Institute (SEI) at Carnegie Mellon
Tracks and publishes threats and vulnerabilities Maintains databases of practices and
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. US-CERT (www.uscert.gov)
What is it?
United States Computer Emergency Readiness Team
Run by US Dept. of Homeland Security
Federal agencies required to notify US-CERT of breaches within one hour of discovery
Point of interaction/communication between
federal cyber security interests, the public, and private sector entities
DITSCAP/DIACAP
What is it?
DoD Information Technology Security Certification and Accreditation Process
(superceded by DoD Information Assurance Certification and Accreditation Process
Primarily applies in the defense part of the public sector
Formal structure specifies six sections and 18 appendices
Many of the DITSCAP requirements are related to policy
© 2008 Security Architecture - All Rights Reserved. PRIVACY REGULATIONS
Alston-Bird (www.alston.com)
Intellectual Property and Privacy practices Online privacy library
Summary reports on global regulations and legislation
International Association of Privacy Professionals (www.privacyassociation.org)
Tracks information privacy practices, laws, and developments worldwide
Training and certifications in privacy (CIPP)
POLICY DEVELOPMENT
Charles Cresson Wood
Information Security Policies Made Easy (v.9)
www.infosecurityinfrastructure.com
Also titles on roles and responsibilities, e-commerce, security controls, etc.
SECURITY POLICY
Stephen Gantz CISSP-ISSAP, CEH, CGEIT
Principal Architect