DRAKE, Robert <http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4673-5531>
Available from Sheffield Hallam University Research Archive (SHURA) at:
http://shura.shu.ac.uk/16150/
This document is the author deposited version. You are advised to consult the
publisher's version if you wish to cite from it.
Published version
DRAKE, Robert (2017). e-Roster Policy: Insights and implications of codifying nurse
scheduling. Health Informatics Journal.
Copyright and re-use policy
For Peer Review
! " #$ % # & ! & '
( $ ) * ! & + , # - . "& ** % $ / 0 , ( $
1 2 % ** , * , , , , 2 +*
!#
3 2 % % * % $ , 2 & & 4 & 5
& " 0 65 "7, $ 2 % %
2 & & ( 0 2 2 0 , & * $
% * * & & & 0 &
% * & & & * & 8 9 8, * $ % $
* & % % % ** &
% # % * 2 0 # 0 # ,
& 0 % 2 & * % * $
: & & * % & , ; 0 0 , % * % + 2 %
% ; * & $$ % ; & 2
< % 2 % & & 0 % , 2& 2 % 0 &
# $ ** $ *
/ $ , $ 0 & ; 0 &
0 # % & * $ * $ & $ < *
For Peer Review
! " # $ ! % & % '( )* + #
$ # ' , " - " . - "
" " " % " / #'0!* "% 1" ,
2 # #"% , -3 4 3" 5 . 0
# , # # # * 6 - # .
" " # " % " # # 7 *
8 # # # , # # - .,
- . % ## 9 * #"% % ,
" # % * 6 " $ : #
: # # *
" # : 1" # , ; %
# %" * # ,
" < " &# = &=!
" " > * , # " ,
" - " 4 % . 4! ) * 1" ,
:# # , " # , " 1" ## "
&= # #*
6 " % $ %
# ? * 6 , $ " # " $ ,
, 1" % " , (, , ' * 6 , @ =
" :# @ = < $ $
- A . 0 * 6 " , : "
For Peer Review
# "# , % # # % " * 6 -# .
7 , , " % "
% " % # 9 * 1" $ 1"
# 0, < $ $ :# 0 *
" $ % " % " "
# # " # " < * 4 # "
" , # "
, % ,
% > * 4 " ,
, # " , * 6 " , % % $ % " %
< , % # % >, ) * 8
: # , 1" # " #
@ = , # % " $ 9 * = ,
: " % " 1" / /
, " $ % " , #
%B ? *
For Peer Review
6 # : % # #
* , # " * , ,
# , # 1" $ * 6
# # # : # #
# *
6 # 1" '( * 6 " C
1" " , , # D
% " : ' # 0)* 2 ,
% # " # : '' *
6 " % "# $ : #"% % # % !* 3
, " # '0 " " '( 9 ' = '( >* 6
" " % " % '* 6 "
"# ; # " " E , "
# * : " * *"
" # # " "
* " " " $ 6 " = "
" @ = , " *
6 # " % #"% %
*
For Peer Review
# # # "#
% # * 6 1" , # " % : $
, 6" F* 6 -& . "
# #
# * & $ : # : , 9(G
# # , : (G % !* 8 : # , "
8 " 6 " 5
- <9G # " 6 "
- 7'G # 8 " 6 " ,
- 7'G " # 8 " 6 " ,
1" , " " # :# , "
" # , - 6 " "
"## # 1" # .*
, # " H I *
# % "# :# %B # '0 *
6 * 6 % # : *
- %B . " "
*6 " = " " @ =
# # # *
% $ *
% 1" E # "
, " # % '7 * 6 %
" " # # % , % " $
$ # " * I
For Peer Review
" " # '9 * 2 , "
% " , :# %B # ,
% # $ 1" *
6 %B # B % E
- J8 %" J 7< # !
- JK % " J 00 # !
- J J 0 # !
- J ;% J ') # !
- J4 # J # !
$ : # : " %B * 2 $
# 1" :# , -K "
## # " , .* , @ #
, '< * @ #
:# / /, / 1" % /* 6 1"
# " 1" , " , : % " :#
# * 8 : # , 1" # # #
# 5
- 6 " $ 1"
- 6 # " 1" " % , # %
- 6 : " " % 1"
- 6 "
- 6 # % ## 1" 1"
For Peer Review
6 # " 1" " , # "
" * , # : %
# $ " # # " *
2 , " $ # " /+ / ,
/ / / / * = , # %
%B , % # * 2 ,
:# " " % " # " 5
- " % ## 1" #
- " % ## 1" # #
- " % % " #
- " % # #
: # # # % @ = , " "
:# $ , " 9 # ! ## 0
# !* @ = :# " # % % " " 5
- "
- "
- 1"
- @ #
6 :# , -6 # % ,
% . ) # ! -6 % "
" . ) # !* 6 # %B
" 5
- 07 #
For Peer Review
- # ? #
- # % 9 #
& $ " # " , " ,
-" % # 1" '7 " , ## # , " #
# # .* , # # "
" % * 2 # *&
" " E # " '7 # !
# " '( # !* # # "
# " # , -+"
# % 1" #
.*
6 # % %B # * = 1"
@ = # % "
= # % # , " % ; B"
* 6 " " #"
; " , " # # % ,
$ , $ $ 4 B "## & *
6 %B : / :
1" # / > # !*4 " :# %B
# - %B ., - ## # . -1" . %
# % %B * = # " % " %
? # ! # % % 0< # !,
: # 5 - : % " % " , %"
# # * = : % ## 1"
; . # !*
For Peer Review
6 # % %B 5
- 4 % 1"
- 4 @6K 1" # L " $ $# !
- # # # "
- 4
3 , @ = ; = # % % %"
% + " % % % +
= " ; + 8 '> # !*
# $ # , %B " " % ; # *
6 $ # " # " , #
# * 6 # %B , / " % # %
% " /* , # "
" # 42 *
6 %B , :# - # " %
" ., $ " #
" M0(*9 # *
6 # " , / "# "
% # # % " , 4 /
# !*
! ! "
For Peer Review
@ # : # " , #
* 8 # - , $% . "%$# * 6
# # 5
- :
- 4
- 1"
- 8 : %
, # 1" #
# , " " , " - . - .
# % 0!* # #
* @ # , " " " ,
% , 1" , ## " * 2 ,
@ # # * 2 :# , /
# " #
" 1" / '< #0 *
# " "
@ " 1"
" % '> , % " # # "
" " " " ') * < #?>
- # " , # # :
.* 2 , , $ , # # " %
- # : . # *
" 4 &= :# " 9 * +"
, " % # # " % , %
For Peer Review
" # # : < % " # 4*
" , " " $
% , " % " " * 8 # % , 1"
" , " # # * 6
# *
$ $
" % , $ # " " ', 0 - . "
# : , !* + # , "
# * -8 . " % * 8
- . 1" " !, - . " ! - . B" !* 6
" # # 1" " * 8
: # , / 1" % / 1" 0< # !, " '0 # !,
: % 7 # ! " ' # ! :# :# * ,
1" # " , # # % "
" " ## * 1" , # # 1" < ,
: % 1" % , % % #
" *
= , " " 1" "# # #
$ * 2 # , " " % "
- ., - . - .* 1" , %
# " '? * 2 # , @ = ,
, # % # - .
* , # # # " "
, % " " # % 0( *
Governance: The meta-objective
For Peer Review
6 , / , , "
# ## / 0 * K$ # # , " $ , 0
%B " E / % " /, / / /# # /, %
# # " " * 8 : # , / ;%
/ %B M0*0 %
# '( 7; 9 0' * = , "
%B # " :# # *2 ,
, -8 % N # #
" . #>!, " " , # , " # $
, % # , % "
" " " "# # , $ * 1" ,
= 2 0 # " , " " ,
# # ''( # @ , % *
, % # " , # , "
* 6 / " / % #
"# A , # , ;
< * 2 , + 9 , - " , ## %
, : , % # # . #)(>!* 6
@ # % % :# " * ,
# # " % 0!
# * " , " 1"
, "%$ # / $
A / # 1" *
= , O ' $ "
@ = , , 1" " " , #
" * 6 1" $ # $
, # 1" * 2
For Peer Review
, %" # E "
$ * " " "
" " 00, 07, 09 *
1" , = 2 0 # " "
" , " " , 1" # %
# : " :# 1" " *
"% 1" , " $ % $#
" : " ? * , " % % "
# : 5
- - . " : % 1" %
## 1" # % # : E
- # 4$ % # A # %
" #" # : " " # # :
0< E
- " , "% $% #
- " " 1" " ; # ,
$ # "% "
6 , # : " #
? * 8 : # , # 42 " " % #
# " % " # * , "
" " % E
- + 9 , , " " % @
= , / " ## % ## ! %
" "# / #)(<! 2
For Peer Review
- % / / % " ! / /
/ / " !, $ / / " ,
% " " " # ?
- # : " " # 1" "
" *
6 " , , -# # " # . # )!
" " : # *
2 , # # $ # # " "
" @ '< " " " / $ /*
, , - " . #7, #), #?, #9), #)<!,
, % 4 " #
1" " #" % < * 1" , : "
" % A
, $% *
6 # $ * 2 ,
:# " , " # " #
" # :# % * 2 , ,
% " % $ # " % "
:# % " , " * & ,
, ## % $ , " * "
## : " , % %
" # *
6 # : # " " %
# # * " , #
# " : " " % " # # : $ ,
For Peer Review
* @ , $ " , % A "
"% #" # , " " $ # "
## 1" !, " * " , #
" , " % " " %
, $ $ " *
2 #" # # : " $ $
%" " 1" " # " # *
For Peer Review
[1] Carter, “Operational productivity and performance in English NHS acute hospitals: Unwarranted variations,” Department of Health, London, 2016.
[2] T. Hockley and S. Boyle, “NHS Safe Staffing: Not Just a Number,” Policy Analysis Centre, Lymington, 2014.
[3] L. McIntyre, “Good Practice Guidance: Rostering,” NHS Improvement, 2016.
[4] C. C. Lo, C. C. Lin, C. T. Wang, T. J. Dai and D. Wong, “Artificial immune systems for intelligent nurse rostering,” in Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management, 2007 IEEE
International Conference, 2007.
[5] R. G. Drake, “The nurse rostering problem: from operational research to organizational reality?,” Journal of Advanced Nursing, vol. 70, no. 4, pp. 800-810, 2014a.
[6] R. Silvestro and C. Silvestro, “Towards a model of strategic roster planning and control: an empirical study of nurse rostering practices in the UK National Health Service,” Health Services Management Research, vol. 21, pp. 93-105, 2008.
[7] E. K. Burke, P. De Causmaeker, G. Vanden Berghe and H. Van Landeghem, “The state of the art of nurse rostering,” Journal of Scheduling, vol. 7, pp. 441-499, 2004.
[8] P. De Causmaecker and G. Vanden Berghe, “A categorisation of nurse rostering problems,” Journal of Scheduling, vol. 14, pp. 3-16, 2011.
[9] R. G. Drake, “The 'Robust' roster: Exploring the nurse roster process,” Journal of Advanced Nursing, p. Accepted for publication 18 Jan 2014, 2014b.
[10] NHS Employers, “Electronic rostering: helping to improve workforce productivity,” NHS Employers, 2007.
[11] M. Mercer, J. Buchan and C. Chubb, “Flexible nursing - Report for NHS Professional,” Institute for Employment Studies, Brighton, 2010.
[12] T. Snow, “Concern over the knock-on effects of growing gaps in nurse roster,” Nursing Standard, vol. 26, no. 42, pp. 12-13, 2010.
[13] I. Nonaka and H. Takeuchi, The knowledge-creating company, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995.
[14] J. C. Wyatt, linical knowledge and practice in the Information Age: a handbook for health professionals, London: Royal Society of Medicine Press Ltd, 2001.
For Peer Review
[15] I. Nonaka, “The knowledge-creating company,” Harvard Business Review, Vols. Nov-Dec, pp. 96-104, 1991.
[16] M. Boisot and B. Cox, “The I-space: a framework for analyzing the evolution of social computing,” Technovation, vol. 19, pp. 525-536, 1999.
[17] B. Johnson and B. A. Lundvall, “"The learning economy",” Journal of Industrial Studies, vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 23-42, 1994.
[18] T. H. Davenport, R. G. Eccles and L. Prusak, “Information politics,” Sloan Management Review, no. Fall, pp. 53-65, 1992.
[19] S. Turner, J. Higginson, C. A. Oborne, R. E. Thomas, A. I. G. Ramsey and N. J. Fulop, “Codifying knowledge to improve patient safety: A qualitative study of practice-based interventions,” Social Science & Medicine, vol. 113, pp. 169-176, 2014.
[20] P. Mayring, “Qualitative content analysis,” Forum: Qualitative Social Research, 2000.
[21] K. Heikkila and S. Ekman, “Elderly care for ethnic minorities - wishes and expectations among elderly Finns in Sweden,” Ethnicity and Health, pp. 135-146, 2003.
[22] D. R. Thomas, “A general inductive approach for analyzing qualitative evaluation data,” American Journal of Evaluation, vol. 27, no. 2, pp. 237-246, 2006.
[23] J. Ritchie, L. Spencer and W. O'Conner, “Carrying out qualitative analysis,” in Qualitative research practice, J. Ritchie and J. Lewis, Eds., London, Sage, 2008, pp. 219-262.
[24] M. Milne and R. Adler, “Exploring the reliability of social and environmental disclosures content analysis,” Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 359-383, 1999.
[25] J. Guthrie, R. Petty, K. Yongvanich and F. Ricceri, “Using content analysis as a research method to inquire into intellectual capital reporting,” Journal of Intellectual Capital, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 282-293, 2004.
[26] New South Wales (NSW) Health , “Rostering Resource Manual (Version 2.1),” August 2016. [Online]. Available: http://www.health.nsw.gov.au/Performance/Rostering. [Accessed 21 March 2017].
[27] J. Denis and P. Lehoux, “Organizational theories,” in Knowledge translation in health care, 2nd ed., S. E. Straus, J. Tetroe and I. D. Graham, Eds., Oxford, Wiley Blackwell, 2013, pp. 308-319.
[28] R. Drake, “Nursing workforce planning: insights from seven Malaysian hospitals,” British Journal of Nursing, vol. 22, no. 2, pp. 95-100, 2013.
[29] A. O'Sullivan, “The nursing roster: It's all about me!,” 15 January 2012. [Online]. Available: http://tinyurl.com/NT-roster.
For Peer Review
[30] K. Bail, R. Cook, A. Gardner and L. Grealish, “Writing ourselves into a web of obedience: A nursing policy analysis,” International Journal of Nursing Studies, vol. 46, pp. 1457-1466, 2009.
[31] G. Scally and L. Donaldson, “Clinical governance and the drive for quality in the new NHS in England,” British Medical Journal, vol. 317, no. 7150, pp. 61-65, 1998.
[32] L. Donnelly, “New NHS spending scandal: £3.3 billion wasted on agency doctors,” 22 May 2015. [Online]. Available: www.telegraph.co.uk/news/nhs/11625615/New-NHS-spending-scandal-3.3-billion. [Accessed 20 August 2016].
[33] A. Walid, “Knowledge of IT project success and failure factors: Towards an integration into the SDLC,” International Journal of Information Technology Project Management, vol. 3, no. 4, pp. 56-71, 2012.
[34] J. Glaser, “Management's role in IT project failures,” Healthcare Financial Management, vol. 58, no. 10, pp. 90-92, 2004.
[35] K. Lyytinen and R. Hirschheim, “Information systems failures: A survey and classification of the empirical lietrature,” Oxford Surveys in Information Technology, vol. 4, pp. 257-309, 1987.
[36] H. Huang, W. Lin and Z. Lin, “An evolutionary algorithm based on constraint set partitioning for nurse rostering problems,” Neural computing and applications, vol. 25, no. 3, pp. 703-715, 2014.
[37] M2 PressWIRE, “SMART: NHS Workforce Solutions Community secure 12 new contracts in first quarter of 2010; Best of Breed e-rostering solutions a hit with NHS trusts,” M2 PressWIRE, 5 May 2010.
[38] Allocate Software , “Annual report 2012,” 2012. [Online]. Available:
http://www.allocatesoftware.com/interactive/2012-report/. [Accessed 13 June 2014].
[39] A. Strauss and J. Corbin, Basics of qualitative research, 2nd ed., Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications, 1998.
[40] R. Cowan, P. A. David and D. Foray, “The explicit economics of knowledge codification and tacitness,” Industrail and corporate change, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 211-253, 2000.
[41] E. Von Hippel, “"Sticky information" and the locus of problem solving: implications for innovation,” Management Science, vol. 40, no. 4, pp. 429-439, 1994.
[42] Merseycare, “SA01-03 Policy on Policies Rev Jan 2013,” 2013. [Online]. Available:
http://www.merseycare.nhs.uk/Library/Who_we_are/Policies_and_Procedures/SA01%20-%203Policy%20on%20Policies%20Rev%20Jan%202013.doc. [Accessed 13 06 2015].
[43] Department of Health, “Improving Working Lives Standard,” Department of Health, 2000. 2
For Peer Review
[44] R. Flynn, “Clinical governance and governmentality,” Health, Risk & Society, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 155-173, 2002.
[45] F. Nietzsche, On truth and lies in a non-moral sense, New York: Aristeus Books, 2012.
[46] F. Sousa, A. Aparicio and R. Laureano, “Different contributor profiles in an organisational wiki,” in OSDOC '10 Proceedings of the workshop on Open Source and design of communication, New York, 2010.
For Peer Review
! ! " "
# $ % $
& ' (! " % ! &
) * + ,
-% $ % ! -! .
) / 0 $
) & . ! ' (! &
) (1 ($ - & 2 ! 2 ! .
) & 2 ! 2 ! .
/ ,, 3
) & 4( ! 4( !
/$ $ # 5 $
& 4( ! 2 ! & &
/ 0 5 $ & % ! ' (!
/ 6 5 $
& 4( ! 2 ! & .
' & ! " ' (! &
' & 4( ! 4( !
' ( 7 ) 0
& ! " 4( ! &
' - , -! -!
+ /$ $ & ! " -! &
+ 8
& % ! 2 !
9 ( $
& ! !
For Peer Review
9 9 - 0 / & ! ! "
6 $ / 66 $ / & ! ! .
0 ' $ ) & 2 ! % !
: , # -$ & ! " ! &
; ( $ / 66 $
( & 2 ! 2 ! & "
% / . & . 2 ! " ! . &
$ ' $( & 4( ! . 2 ! &
$ 7
& ! " ! & "
$ $ 7 ( / . & . 2 !
-$ 6
& ! -! "
5 6 $ & 2 ! . % !
5 6 $ & ! . !
< $ $ 6* ' ( 7 $ 6
% $ & 4( ! " ! &
< ) $ & 4( ! 4( ! .
, < . & . 4( ! " -! . .
$ ,, $ ( /
& 2 ! . 2 ! "
$ $ / 66 $
& ! !
& ! . !
6 5 $
& -! 2 ! "
For Peer Review
$ ,, $ $ $
$( . & . 2 ! 2 ! &
$ # = 1 $ 5 $
. & . ! ! &
$ $ . & . % ! " 2 ! & .
) 5 $
. & . 2 ! " 2 ! & "
> 5 $ & -! " -! &
6
! ! " "
& ! ! "
* + 1 7 0 3
4( ! 4( ! "
# $ $ ( / & 2 ! 2 ! "
# ( $ (
& 2 ! 2 ! & &
For Peer Review
2For Peer Review
! " #
"" $ " % $
" #%! &
' ( ) * "
+ %
, $ ( ! $ %! ( - . /- $ 0%)
(
# . ( ) #
1 ( 2 3 #
, # #%! &
( # # 0 ( - #
(
"" $ " % $ )
)
4, % # (- (
5 1 $ . / $ ( )6 )# (
5 1 $ .
)6
)!
5 1 $ . $
)0
) 5 #
$ ) . ( # $
7" ) 6 )
&
)#
5 1 $ 8 9 $ " )#
, $ ( ) %# (
)
' " $ ) ( (
For Peer Review
" ( !
( !
/ ) " !
" "
) "
. ( %
; ( 2 3
1 2 3
