A B S T R A C T
A
n ap p
r o a ch
c o mb in
i
ng
airq
u al i
ty me a s u r eme nt s,G I S
te chni q
u e, r ecep
to r a nd
d is
pe r si
o n m od
eli
ng
to ap po rtio n the
i mp
a ct of
in cin e r ato r sou r c e s toi
nd
ivid
u alsl i
vin
g i
ns u r r o u n
d i
ng
n ei g h b
orh
ood
sis
p
res e nted
. Th i
s te ch
ni q
uei
s ap
p
l i
ed
t o a He al
th a nd C
le anA i
rS
tu d y in v e stigatin
g the r espi
r ato ry ef f
e cts of
ai
r emi
s si
o n s a s s o ciated w ith3
ty pe s of
w a stei
n ci
n e r ato r s -b i
om
ed i
c al
wa st e a nd m
u ni
ci p
al
wa s te
i
n ci
nera to rs, a nd
a ha zard
o us w asteb
u r ni
ng f
u r n a ce.Six
c om m
u ni
tie s
w e r eg
r o up
ed i
n thr e ep
air s
wit
h o ne stud
y com mu ni
ty s u r r ou nd in
g
e a ch w a ste
i
n cin e r a
to r s o u r c e a nd
o n e c om
m u nit
y lo c ated
afe
w k i lomete r s aw ay a s a c o ntrol
.H
um
a n sub
j
e c t s r ec ord
ed
the
ir
p
e ak
re spir a
t oryfl
ow ra te twic e a
d
ay
alo
ng
wit
h
oth
eri
nf
orm
ati
o ni
n ad ia
ry f
o r3 5 d
aysp
e r ye a rf
o r thr ee ye a r s.Si m
ulta n e o u sl y, at a n am b i
e ntm
o ni
t orin
g
sit ein
e ach
c omm
u ni
ty
, PM
2
.5
, PM
10
, aci d g
ases a nd
tr a c em
e tals
we rem
ea su red
tw ic e ad
ay al
ong
wi
th h
ou rl
y win
d
speed
a nd d ir
e c ti
o n a t a10 m
e te r t ower.Su
b
j
ect s and
sam p l i
ng
t owers w e rep h
ysi
cal l y g
ri d de
d
wi
th aG I S
te ch
ni q
u e.T h
eC h
em i
cal
M
as sB
al
a n c e r e c ep
to rm
ode
l i
ng
wa s u s ed
wi
th
ai
rq
u al i
tyd
ata tod
ete rm i
n e th
ec o ntr
i b
uti
o n of
thei
n cin e r a
to r s o u r c e to e a ch
mo ni
t ori
ng
site.T h
ed is
p
ersio n
m ode
l in
g
p
red i
ctionsw
ere c om p
ared w i
th C
M
B
s ou r c e c ontri b
u ti
on e s ti m ate s a nd
the air
m
o ni
t orin
g
m
e a su rem
en t s t o s c al
em
od
el i
ng
e s ti m ates and
t o s ep
a r atein
ci
n e r at or s o u r ce c ontri b
uti
ons.T h
e ai
rq
u al i
ty
as s e s sm
e ntw i
ll be
u s ed
to in v e stig
ate r elatio n sh
i ps w ith thep
e akfl
ow
A C K
NO
W
LE D G
EM
E NT S
I
wo ul d l i k
e tog i
v em
y sp
e ci
al
th
a nk
s to Dr .D
o n al d F
o x,
w h
oh
a sg
r e at pati
e n c e a nd
k i
nd
n e ssi
ni
n str u ctin
g m
e,i
nl i
ste ni
ng
tom
y stum b l i
ng E
ng l i
sh
, a nd in
h
el p i
ng m
e to ad
ap
tm
ys elf
to the n ew
e n vi
r o nm
e nt. Iw
o ul d
al
s ol ik
e to th
a nk
Pr of
.K
am
e n s a nd D
r.Sh
yf
o rt
h
eir
gui d
a n c ein
th i
s rep
o rt. Th
ey a r ek
n own tob
e n ot o nl
y te a ch
e r s of
te a ch i
ngk
n ow l
ed g
e,b
ut al
s o t ea ch
er s of g
ui d in
g
s tud
e n ts.A d d i
ti
o n al
th
ank
s a r ed
ue toD
r.D
o n al d L
au ri
a and
D
ar r ah D
eg
n anf
o r th
eir
ef f
o rts and
e n c o u r ag
em
e n t.I
th
a sb
ee n tw
en ty
th
re em
onth
s si
n c eI
c am
eh
e ref
r om T
aiw
an,w h i
ch i
sh
al f
a n e a rth
a
w
ay
.I
ti
s a s um m
e rin
C h
ap
el H i l l w h
e nI w
a sw
ri
ti
ng
up
th
e r ep
ort.I h
ave s e en th
er e
fr e s
h i
ng
sp
ri
ng
s, c ol
orf
ul
a utum
n s, ch i l l
yw i
nte rs, a nd
of
c o u r s e,h
ot s v im m
e r s of C h
ap
el
H i l l
. I am
g
r atef
ul
th
at Ih
a v e th
e wo nd
e rf
ul
e xp
e ri
e n c ei
nm
yl i f
e - e sp
e ci
al l
yb
e c aus eh
e reI m
etm y f i
anc e e.F
a r ew
el l
,
m y
tw
e nti
es! T h
a nk y
o u al l !
T A B L E
O
FC O N
T EN
T SA b
str a cti
A
ck
now l
ed g
em
e ntsi i
Ta
b l
e of C
o nte ntsi i i
L i
st of T
ab l
esi
vL
i
st of F i g
u r e s vL
I
ntr od
ucti
on1
A
.Wa s
teM
anagem
e ntO p
ti
o n s 1B. O b
j
e ctiv e ofH
e alth a nd
C le a n A ir Stud
y 1C
.S
tud y
D e si g
n of
He al
th
a nd C le a
nA ir
S
tud y
2
I I
. Pu rp
o s e of T h i
sR
ep
o rt7
I I
I.C
om
b in e
d A p p
r oa ch T
oE
stim
ateE
xp
o sur e8
I V
.A i
rQ
u al i
tyM
e as u r em
en ts10
V
.G
e og
r ap h i
c al
Inf
o rm
ati
o nS
y stem
15
V
I .C h
em i
c al
M
a s s Bal
a n c eR
e c ep
to rM
od
el i
ng18
V I I.
G
a u s si
anD i
sp
e r si
o nM
od
el i
ng
2 0
V
I I I.D
ataSe
ts2 3
I X
.S
c ale
Fa cto rD
ete rm
i
n ati
o n2 5
X
.A p p l i
c ati
o n to Ind i
vi d
u al S
tud
y Pa rtic
ip
a nts2 7
X I
.C
o n clu s
io n
a nd D i
s cus si
o n3 3
R
ef
e r e n ce s3 5
A p p
e nd i
xA
-M
a
p
sU
s ed f
o r th
ePa r
tic
i p
an t si
nB i
om
ed i
c al
W
a steI
n ci
n e ra torC
om m
uni
ti
es(
H
unte r s vi l l
e a nd C
or n el iu s
)
3 7
A
pp
e nd i
x B- Pol
a rCo o r
d i
n ate s of
th
e Pa r ti
c
i
pa ntsi
n Bio
m
ed ic a
l
Wa s
teIn c
in
er ato rC
om
m
uni
ti
es3 9
A p p
e nd i
xC
-A
n Ex am
p l
e of
M
ete o r olo
g i
cal
DataU
s ed i
n IS C S
T4 3
A p p
e nd i
xD
- In cin e r a
to rI m p
a ct o n PM
2
.
5 f
o r e a ch p
a rtic
ip
a ntl
o c atio n
. . . .4 4
L I
S
TO
F T A B L ES
Ta
b l
e 1. T heS
o u r c eC
ha r a cteri
stic s of
Bi
om
ed i
c alW
a ste In ci
n e r ato r inye a r 1 a n
d
ye a r2
2 1T
ab l
e2
.S
cali
ng F
a ct or De t erm i
n atio
n 26
T
ab l
e3
.E
xam p
le of
Inci
nera t or Im p
a c t onP
M
2.5
3
1L I S T
O
F F I G U R E SF
i g
u r e1
.G
eogr ap
h i
c alR
eg i
on s of
M
e ck l
e nb
u rg
a nd S
ta nl y C
o u nty i
nN
orth
C
a r ol i
n a4
F i
g
u r e 2. T he Relativ e L o c atio n s o f theS
ixS
tud yC
om mu nitie s5
F i g
u r e3
. He alth a ndC
leanA i
rS
tud y D
esi g
n6
F
i g
u r e4
. F lowC
ha rtS h
owi
ng
M
e th
od
s t oO b
tai
nI
nd i
vi d
ual Exp
o su reE
sti m
a tef
r omA i
rQ
u al i
tyM
e a s u r em
e nts, Re c epto r a nd
D is
p
e r sio nM
od
el ing
9
F
i g
u re5
. VA P S S
am
p
l i
ng S y
stem
12
F i g
u re6
.C
on c e ntr ati
on s of F i
n eP
a rti
c ul
a teM
a ssi
nB i
om
ed i
c al
W
as teI
n ci
n e r ato rS
tud
y a nd C
o ntrol C
om mu ni
ti
e si
n199 2
13
F i g
u r e7
.C
on c e ntr ati
o ns of F i
n eP
a rti
c ul
ateM
a s si
nB i
omed i
c al
W
a steI
nci
n e r ato rS
tud y
and C
ontrol C
om mu ni
ti
esi
n199 3
13
F
i g
u r e8
. ZnC
o n c e ntr ati
on s a s aF
u n cti
o n of
W
i
nd
Di
r e cti
o ni
nB
i
omed i
cal
W
as t eI
nci
n e r at or a nd C
o ntr ol C
omm
u ni
tie s 14
F
i g
u r e9
.Sp
ati
al
Rel
ati
onsh i p
s of
th
e Inci
ner at or, Ai
rS
am p l i
ng S
tati
on,a n
d P
a rti
ci
pa ntL
o cati
on si
nB i
om
ed i
c al
W
a ste In ci
n e r at or a nd
C
on tr ol C
omm
u ni
ti
e s17
F
i
gu r e10
.L i
nkageb
etwe e n ISC ST
,C
M
B a nd A i
rQ
u ali
tyM
e a s u r em
e nt atC
om m
u ni
tyM
oni
t ori
ng Si
te2 4
F i g
u re1 1
.D i
sp
e rsi
onP
a t t er n of I
nci
nera to rR
el
ati
ve t oL
oca ti
ons of
P
a rti
ci p
a nts o nM
ay 2
,19 9 2 D
ayS
am p l i
ng P
eri
od
wi
th
W
ind
D i
re c ti
onf
rom SW
29
F i gu r e 1 2. D is
p
e r sio n Pat te r n of In ci
n e r ato r Relativ e toL
o c ati
o n s of
Pa rt
i
ci p
a nt s o nM
ay 20
, 19 9 2
Day S
am p l i
ng
Peri
od
wi
th
W
i
nd
D
i
r e ctio nf
rom N
E3 0
F i g
u re13
C
om p
a r si
on of A
r eaP
ol l
uti
on a nd I
nci
ner at o rI m p
a c t onD i f f
e rentL
oc ati
onsf
o rM
ay20
,199 2 D
ayS
am p l i
ng Peri
od
. . .3 2
F
i g
u re 14
.C
om p
a r si
o n of A
r eaP
oll
uti
o n a nd
In ci
n e r ato r Im p
a c t o nI. I
N
T RO
D U C T I O NA .
W
a steM
a n ag
em
e n tO
p t io n sT he ge n e r atio n o
f
w a ste si
si
n e vi
tab l
e.W
i
th
the adv a n c eme nt of i
nd
u stri aliz a
tio n , the
v o
l
um e and
ty p
es of
was te a r ei
n c re asi
ng d
ram atic al l y
.T h
e m anag
eme nt of
w a stesi
s n eed
ed
t o c o ntr o
l
th
e ad
ve rse ef f
e c t s the w ast e may c a use.M
a ny ma n ageme nt ap proa che s
h
a v eb
e e nd
ev el
op
ed
.T he
s e ap proa ch
esi
n cl
ud
ed is
posal
op
tio n s s u ch
as s eg
r eg
a ti
o n te ch
ni q
u e s,d
e str u ctio n op
ti
on s s u ch
asin c
i
n e r ati
o n a nd p
yr ol
ysi
s, a nd p
rev e n tio n op
tio
n s su ch
as wa stem in
i hi
i
z atio n
.N
ew te ch
n ol
og
ie sf
o r was te tr e atme nt a nd d is
po s a
l
c o ntin u e
to e v ol
v e(
F
ox e ta
l
.,
19 9 3
;T
ch
ob
a nog
lo us et al
., 19 7 7
)
.I
n cin e r a
tio nis
of
te np
r efe r r e
d
to othe rw
a stetreat
m
en t ord i
sp
o s al
al
te r n a ti
v esb
e ca us e of i
ts ef f
e c tiv e
v ol
ume r ed
uc ti
o n a nd
che
mic
al
to xic
it
yd
e str u ctio n c ap
ab
il
itie s,p
a rtic ula rl yf
o r t oxi
c o rg
a nic w a st e.T
he v ol
um
e of
m
u nici p
alw
a ste c a nb
e r ed
u c ed b
ym
o re tha n9 0
pe r c e ntb
yi
n ci
ner ation. En e rg yin
thef
o rm
o
f
ste am
or ele ctric
i
ty c a n als
obe
d
e ri
v ed f
r omi
n cin e r a
tio n.M
o r e r ec entl y
,i
n c rea s ed h
a ul
d i
s ta nc e s t o av ai l
ab l
el
a nd fi l l
si
t es,in c
re a s ed
r eg
ul
a t ory
re s tri
ctio ns o nla n
d fi l l
s, and in
creas ed
f
uel
c ost sm
ak
ein c
i
ner a ti
onm
o rep
op
ul
a r.A l
th
oug h i
nci
n era ti
onh
a s many
ad
vant ag
es, th
ee n v
ir
onm
e ntal
and h
e al
th ef f
e c t s as s ocia
ted
wi
th the emis
sion s of i
n ci
n e r ati
o n a r e th
ep ri
m a ryc o n c e r n s
i
n add
iti
o n to the
r eq
ui
r em
ent of
s op h i
stic at ed f
a ci l i
ty d
esi g
n a nd
op
eration s.T h
ea s s e s s
m
e n t of
theri
sk
s a ss ocia
ted
wi
th in cin
er ationm
ay a ssis ti
nd
e v elop i
ng
ap p
ropri
at er e
g
ulat ory g
ui d
eli
ne s and i
n th
e op
e r a ti
o n s and
sit
in
g
of
su ch f
a ci l i
ty(
K
el
ly
,19 8
4 ;P
eavy e ta
l
. ,19 8 5
)
.B.
O b
j
e cti
v e of H
eal t h a nd C
le anA i
rS
tud y
m
a n agem
e n t pr o c e s s e s. T he ri sks may in clude hum
a n he alth ef fe cts a nd e n vir o nm
e ntalq
u al i
tyd
eg
r ad
a ti
on, and
th
ey
c onti
n ue t ob
e th
e sub
j
e c t of m
any i
n v es ti g
a ti
ons.T h
eA g
e n cy
f
orT
oxi
cS
ub
sta n c e s and D i
sea s eR
eg i
s try(
A T S D R
)
h
a sb
e e nf
u nd i
ng
a3
-ye a r
(
19 9 2
- 199 4
)
re se a r c
h p
r oj
ect,l
o cal l y k n own as theH
e alth
a ndC
le a n Ai
rS
tud
y, to e xpl
o r e th
e he al
th
e
f f
e cts of w
as tei
n ci
n e r at or s.T
he pu rp
o s e of
thi
s pr oj
e cti
s toi
n v es tig
ate thep
r e v ale n c e a nd
i
nci d
e nce of
ac ute r e sp i
r ato ry eff
e ctsi
n r e si d
e n ts li
vi
ng n e a r w a stei
n ci
n e r ato r s. As a s ub
-p
r oj
e ct of
th
eH
eal
th
a nd C l
e a nA i
rS
tud y
, thi
s tech
ni
c al
r ep
o rt aim
s atd
e vel
op i
ng
ate c
h
ni q
u ef
or e s ti m
a ti
ng
th
e ai
rp
ol l
uti
on e xp
o s ure of
th
ep
ar ti
ci p
antsl i
vi
ng
ne a r ani
nci
ner at or .C
.S
tud
y
D
e si g
n of H
e al t h a nd C
le a nA
irS
tud yT h
re e ty p
e s of
was t ei
nci
nera t ors werei d
en ti f i
ed f
o r th i
s stud y
: ab i
omed i
cal
wa s tei
nci
n erator, am
u ni
ci p
al
was t ei
nci
n er a t or, a nd
ah
azard
o us wast eb
u r ni
ng f
u r n ac e.T h
eb i
om
ed i
cal w
ast ei
nci
n e ra t orh
as two-s tag
e c ontrol l
ed
-ai
rh i g h
tem p
er atu r e
f
u r n a ce s wh i
ch
bu
m
b
o x ed
inf
e ctio u s wa ste in cl
ud i
ng m i
c r ob i
olog
ic al,
p
athologi
c al,b
lo od
tis s u e, n e ed l
e s a nd
o t
h
e ri
nf
e cti
o us n o nh
a z a rd
o u sh
o sp i
tal
wa st es. Th i
sf
a ci
li
ty i
sd
esi g
ned
to op
e r at e2 4 h
o u rs ad
ay
and i
sl
o cated i
n a sem i
-r u -ra
l
a r ea -H
u nte rsv
i l l
e co mm
u ni
ty i
nM
e ck l
e nb
u rg C
o u nty.T h
em
uni
ci p
al
w a stei
nci
nera t o ri
s a m ul
ti
-stag
eg
r a t ef
urn
a c e usi
ng
ref
us e was te a sf
u el
.I
to
p
e ra t e s2 4 h
ou rsp
erd
ay
and i
sl
oca t ed i
n an u rb
an are a -U N C
-C h
ar
l
o t t e areai
nM
eck l
e nb
u rg C
ou nty
.T h
eh
a z a rd
ou s wasteb
u r ni
ngf
u r n a ceh
a s ro ta ryk i l
n s u s ed f
o rm
anuf
a c tu r e of l i g h
t wei g h
t agg
r eg
ate and i
sp
erm i
t t ed
t o us e n atu r al g
as, c o al
and l i q
ui d
w
aste s a sf
u el
.I
ti
sl
o c ated i
n a r u r al
a r e a
-A qu a
d
ale c o mm
u nityi
nS
ta nl
yC
o u nty(
F
o x eta
l
.,19 9 3
)
.F i g
u re1
sh
ow s th
eg
e og
rap h i
c al
r eg i
ons of
M
e ck l
enb
urN
o r th Ca r ol in a.Fo r e a ch o
f
the thr e e wa st ef
a c i li
tie s, a pair of
c om m u ni
tie s wa s s ele cted wit
h o n estu
d
y com m
u nit
y ad
j
a cent t o th
ef
a cil
i
ty a nd o n e c o mm
u ni
tyl
oca ted
af
ewk i
lomet ers aw
ay
a s a c o n tr o
l
. F ig
u r e2
sh
ows the r el
ati
v el
o c ati
o n s of
th
e si
x c om m u niti
e s.I
nd i
vi d
u al
si
nthe s
i
x c om m
u ni
tie s w ere
re c rui
t ed b
a s ed
on a t el
ep h
o neb
asel i
ne su r vey.D
uri
ng
ap
eri
od
of
3 5 d
ay sp
e r ye a r, th
e s eh
uma n s ub
j
e cts r e c o rd
ed
thei
rp
e ak
r esp i
r ato ryf l
ow r ate twi
c e ad
ay
-i
n th
em
o r ni
ng
a nd
e v e ni
ng f
or thr e ey
ea r s. Th
ey als o ma
i
ntai
ned
o the ri
nf
o rm
ati
o n s u ch
a sr e s
p
ir ato ry sym
ptom
s, u s e of
med i
c ati
o n, a nd
a cti
vi
ty pattern
si
n ad i
a ryd
uri
n g th
e s am
e3 5
d
ay
sp
e ry
e arf
or th
r e ey
e a r s.Si m
ul
ta ne ousl y
, a t an am bi
ent ai
rq
uali
tym
onit o
ri
ng
si
t ei
ne a c
h
c om m
u ni
ty ,P
M
2
.5
,P
M
10
, a ci d g
a s e s and
tr a c e metal
s w e r em
e a s u r ed
twi
c e ad
aya
l
o ng w i
th h
o u rl y
wi
nd
sp
eed
and d i
re c ti
on. Fi g
ure
3
sh
ows th
e s tud
yde
si g
nm
atri
x w hi
ch i
na
d d i
tion t o th
ed i
a ry a nd
ai
r s am p l i
ng p
rog
ram i
n cl
ud
esba s
el i
n e c om m u ni
ty su r v eys,s
p i
rom
e try
s cre eni
ng
, a nd
a nasal
w ash i
ng
sub
s tud y
.A p p
roxim
a t el y 10 0 p
arti
ci p
ants were
lo c ate
d i
n e a ch
of
th
e six c o m mu ni
ti
e s. T he pai
r of
c om
mu nitie s a s s o ciated w ith theb io
m
ed i
cal w
a s t ei
nci
ner at ori
s u sed i
n th is
rep
ort.T h
e ti
mep
eri
od
of
s tud
yf
or the
b io
m
ed i
cal w
a s tei
nci
n e ra t ori
sf
rom A p ri l
t oJ
u ne of 19 9 2
,199 3
and 19 9 4
.T h
e s tud y d
e si g
nm
o ^
i
'
?
^
e
^
i
^ o
A
r
K
/
i
S
i
a n
lV
M
e ck l
e nb
u rg
F
ig
u r e 1.G
e og
r aS T A N L Y C O U N T Y
M
E C
K L E N B U R G C
O
U
N T
Y
M I L E S
T
1 & C
1
T
2 & C
2
T
3 & C
3
B io
m
ed ic a
l
W
ast
eIn c
i
n e r at
o rC
om m
uni
t
y
and C
o nt
r ol
C
om m
u ni
t
y
M
u nclp
al
W
a st
eIn c
i
nerat
orC
om m
u ni
t
y
and C
ont
rol C
om m
u nit
y
H
a z a rd
o u sW
a st
eI
nd
u st
ri
al F
ur n a c eC
om m
u nit
y
a nd
C
o nt
r ol
C
om m
u ni
t
y
F i g
ur e2
.T h
eR
el
ati
v eL
o cati
oS i
xS
tud y C
om m
nm
ti
e si
nT h
re eP
ai
r sOn
B I O M
E D
IC
A
L
(
B
W
I
)
+
B
-C O
N T R O L
N
A S A L
W
A
S
H
I
N
G
+
S P IR
O M
E T R
Y
O
n c e aY
e arM U N I C
I P
A L
(
M
W
I
)
+
M
-C O
N T R
O L
H A
Z A R D
O U S
(
H
W
I F
)
+
H
-C O
N T R
O
L
T E L E P H
O
N E
S
U
R V E
Y
-1 9 9 2
O
nl y
4 0 0
-50 0 H
o u seh
ol
d
sP
e rC
om m
u ni
ty
S P IR
O M
E
T
R
Y
O
n ce aY
e a r+
P
E
A K F LO
W
M EA S U R ES
a n
d R
esp
i
ra to ry
S
y
m
p
tom
sR
e c o rd
ed D
ai l
y
3 5 D
ay
sO
n c e aY
ea rE N V IR
O
N
M
E N T A L
A IR
S
A
M
P L IN G
3 5 D
ay
sO
nc e aY
e a rB I
O
M
E D IC
A LA P R
/
M
A Y
1 9 9 2
-9 4
M
U
N IC IP A
L
S E P
/
O C T
1 9 9 2
-9 4
H A
Z
A RD O
US
N O V
/
D E C
1 9 9 2
-9 4
n
. P UR
PO
S EO
F TH
I S Et E PO R
TT h
i
s r epo rtd
e v el
ops a te ch
ni
qu ef
o r e sti
m
ati
ng
th
e ai
r pol l
u ti
o n e x po s u r e of
th
ep
arti
ci p
ant sl i
vi
ng
n ear ani
nci
n e ra t o r.T h
e exp
o sur e a s se ssm
en t ca n th
e nb
e app l i
ed
t o th
eHea
l
th
a nd C l
e an Ai
rS
tud
y toi
n v e s ti
ga tei
ts r el
ati
o n sh i p
sw i
th p
e ak fl
ow
m
e a su r em
e nts.D
e t erm
i
n ati
on of
ai
rp
ol l
u ti
o n exp
o s u r e toh
um
a nb
ei
ng
si d
e al l y w
o ul d i
n v ol
ve th
ed
ete rm i
n ati
o n of d
o s e to ta rg
e t org
an of i
nte r e st.T
ech
ni q
ue s su ch
as th
ei d
enti f
ic a ti
o n of
b i
om
a rk
e r s a nd
oth
e ri
nte r n al d
o si
m
etrym
e a s u r em
e n ts a r eb
ei
ngd
e v el
op
ed
to ap pr o a ch
th i
si d
eal
(
L i
oy,19 90
)
.H
ow
e v e r, oth
e r te ch
ni q
ues are u sed
top
r o vi d
e su r rog
ated
ata to e sti
m
atee x
p
o s u r e to ai
rb
o r n e c o ntam
i
n a ntsi
n v a ri
ous si
tu ati
o n s s u ch
a sp
e r s o n al d
o si
m
ete r s a nd
i
nd
o or/
ou td
oo rm
o ni
t ors(
Sp
eng l
er e t al
,19 8 8
)
.U
si
ng
e sti
m
ated
ai
r em
i
s si
on sfr
om i
n ci
n e r ato r s a s a s u r r og
at e of
e xp
o s u r e, th i
s r ep
o rtpr o v
i d
e s a s c r e e ni
ng e xpo su r e a s s e ssm
e nt te ch
ni q
u e toi
n v es ti g
atep
ote nti
al
sh
o rt-te rm
ef f
ectso n
l
u ng f
u n c ti
onfr
om
th
e a tm
o sp h
e ri
c em
i
ssi
o n s of
ani
nci
ne r a t or.I
n th i
s r ep
ort o nl y
th
ec o
m m
u ni
ti
es a s s o ci
ated w i
th
th
eb i
om
ed i
c al w
a stei
n cin e r at or -H
im
te r s vi l l
e a nd C
or n el i
u s a r eu s e
d
. Be c au sem
any
r e c e nti
n ve s ti g
a ti
onsh
ave a s s o ci
ated
sh
ort-t er
m
exp
osu r e t o re sp i
r ab l
ep
a rti
c ul
atem
at te r(
PM
10
)
w i
th i
n c r e a s ed
r e spi
r ato ryd i
s e a s e s(
S
ch w
a rtz,19 9 3
;S
ch w
a rtz eta
l
.,19 9 3
)
a nd i
th
a sb
e e n r ep
o rted
th
atm
o rtal i
tyi
s str o ng l
y a s s o ci
ated w i
th
ai
rp
ol l
uti
o nw i
th
fi
n ep
a rti
c ul
a te s(
D
o ck
e ry et al
.,19 9 3
)
,p
a r ti
c ul
atem
at te ri
s th
ep
ol l
uta ntp
ri
m
a ri l y
i
n
. CO
M
B I N E D A P P RO
A CH
TO
E S T IM
A T E E X PO
S U R ET h i
s ap p
r o a ch
comb i
n e s ai
rq
u ali
ty me a s u rem
ent s.G
eog
r ap
hi
c al Inf
orm
ati
o nS y
s temte c
h
ni q
u e s(
G I S
)
, r e c ep
to r a nd d i
spe r si
o n mod
el i
ng
to ap po rti
o n th
ei
mp
a c t of
a ni
n ci
n e r ato rs o u r c e to lo c atio n s w he r e in
d
ivi du als l iv e in s u r r o u nd ing n ei g h bo rho ods.A
t the ai
rq
u ali
ty s am p
l ing towe ri
n e a ch c om
mu ni
ty, info rm
ati
o n ab
o ut chemi
c als
p
eci
e s of
ai
r emi
ssi
o n s a nd
wi
nd
sp
eed
a nd d i
r e cti
o n at th
e samp l i
ng
si
te wer e col l
e cted
.T
h
em
e asu r ed
ai
rq
ual i
ty
sam p l
es r ep
r e s e n ted
a c omb i
n atio n of
m ate ri
al
emi
t ted i
nt o theat
m
osp h
e r ef
rom m
ob i l
e a nd
st a ti
on a ry
s ou rc e si
n th
e reg i
o n as w el l
as a c ontri b
uti
onf
rom
t
h
e ai
rm
as s e s e nt eri
ng
th
e r eg i
o n a nd
th
ei
n ci
n e r ato rl
o c ated i
n the c omm
u ni
ty.C
o nd
u cted
w i
th
th
e ai
rq
ual i
ty m
eas u reme nt s.C h
emi
cal
M
a ssB
al
a n ce(
C
M
B)
recepto rm
od
el i
ng
al l
ow sus to e s t
i m
at e th
e c o n tri b
uti
o n of
th
ei
nci
n e ra to r t o th
e ai
rp
ol l
uti
on a t th
e ai
r sam pl i
ng
si
t e.In
d
u stri
alS
o u r c eC
omp
le xS h
o rtT
e rm(
ISC S
T)
d
isp
e r si
on model ing
c a n al
s o m ake sp
red i
cti
o n ab
o u t th
ei m p
act of
th
ei
nci
ne r ato r at th
e ai
r s ampl i
ng
si
t e.T
h
e r e c epto r a n dd
ispe r si
o nm
odelp
r ed i
ctio n s at the airq
u al itym
o nitori
ng l
oc ationa re c o
m p
ar ed
t od
et erm
ine th
e r el
ati
onshi p
s of
the two mod
el i
ng res ul
t s. A s c ali
ng f
a cto r,w h i
ch i
sC
M
B / I SC
r a ti
o,i
sd
e te rm i
n ed f
or sub
s eq
u e n t us e wi
th d i
sp
ersi
o n mod
el i
ng i
np
red i
cti
ng i
nci
neratori m p
ac ts a t o th
er outd
o orl
o c a ti
o n s.G
IS
techni q
u e s is us ed
t od
e te rm i
net
h
ed i
sta n c es and d i
re c ti
ons of i
nd i
vi d
u al
s and
ai
rq
ual i
ty
samp l i
ng
t ow e rs rel
ati
ve t o th
ei
n ci
n e r ato r, wh i
ch
al
lows us toi d
e nti f y
th
e r e c ep
to rl
oc ati
o n s.F i g
u r e4
sh
ow
s af l
ow
ch
artd
es cri bi
ng
them
e thod
t o ob
tai
ni
nd i
vi d
u al
e xp
os u re es ti
mat ef
r om th
e com b i
n ati
o n of
ai
rq
u al i
ty m
easu r ements, rec ep
t or a nd d i
sp
e rsi
on mod
el i
ng
. T he s e meth
od
s,d
ata req
ui
reme nts,a s s u
m p
ti
on s, a nd
r esult s a red
e s cri b
ed i
n th
ef
ol lowi
ng
ch
ap
te rsf
r o m I V t o X .A ir
Q
u ali
tyM
ea s u rem
entC
M
BM
od
el i
ng
vo
C
M
B
-e s t
i m
a t ed
C
ontri b
ution of
S
ou r ce a tS
am p l i
ng
Sit
eI
SC ST
-e sti m
a ted
Co
ntri b
ution of
S
o u r ce atS
am
pl i
ngSit
eI
SC
ST
M
od
el i
ng_
M
e tDat a
S
c al i
ng
Fac to r
I S
C ST
M
od
el ingE
xpos u r eEs t
i m
a teG
IS
D
i g i
tiz e rSo u
r ceC h
a r a cte ri
s ti
c isF i gu r e 4. F
l
ow cha rt show i
ngm
ethod
s to ob
tai
ni
nd i
vi d
u al
e xpo s u r e e sti
matefr
om
ai
rq
u al i
tyI
V
. A I RQ
U A L I T YM
E AS
U R EM
E N T SA
n airq
u ali
tym
o nit
o ri
ng
statio n c o n sisting
of a 10
-mete r mete o r olog ic a
l
towe r wi
th aw in
d
spe ed
a nd d i
r e c tio n s e n so r, a v e r s ati le airp
ol l
utio n s am ple
r(
VA
PS
)
mo u nted
at3
-m
ete r s , a n
d
a n in str ume nt sh
elte r ho u sing the mete o r o logi
c al
data log ge r a nd
the VA
PS
c ontr o
l l
e r a nd
pum
p system s wasl
o c ated i
n e a ch of
th
e c om
mu ni
tie s.T h
e s el
e c ti
on of
th
es
i
te of m
o ni
t ori
ng
s tation c onsi d
e r ed p
a rti
ci p
antl
oca ti
ons, th
ep
rev ai
li
ng
wi
nd
c ond i
tio
ns, and
t
h
e si
te cha r a c te ri
stic s s u ch
a s the e xte nt of
op
e n n e s s a nd p
o we r a v ai lab i l i
ty.W
i
nd
sp
e ed
a nd d i
r e ctio n inf
o rm
ati
o n we r e col l
e cted
o n anh
ou rl y b
a si
s.I
nteg
r ated
1
2- ho u r air s am p
le s we r e c ol
lect ed
wi
th V A PS
sta rting at
6
:3 0
am
(
d
ay s am
p li
ngp
e ri
od
)
a nd
6
:3 0 p m
(
nig h
t s am p
l ing p
e ri
od
)
f
o r3 5 d
aysi
n e a ch
of
the com mu ni
tie sf
o r a total of
7 0
s a
m
p le s pe r ye a r . Fi
gu r e 5 sh
ows a di
agr am
of
the V AP S
sys tem. T he V A PS
system
p
erm i
t s th
e c ol l
ecti
on of
si
z e s eg
reg
at ed p
arti
c ul
a t em
at t er a nd g
a s e ou s c ons ti
tu e nt ss
i m
ul
ta n e o u sl
y.A i
r e nte r s th
e system at3 2 l i
te r sp
e r mi
n ute(
1p
m)
.P
a r tic ul
at el
a rge r th
a n10
^u nw
as rem
ov ed
o n thei
mp
a c tio np l
at ei
n thei
nl
et.I
n th
eb
od
y of
the s
amp
le r, thef l
owi
s routed i
n th
r e ep
ath
s.T h
eri g h
t si d
e(
wi
th 10 1
pm f l
ow)
c o n si
s ts of
twod i f f
usi
o nd
e n ud
e rsan
d
aT
ef l
o n/ N y l
onfi l
t erp
a ck i
n s eri
es.T he
d i f f
usio
nd
e nud
er s remove a ci d g
a s e s(
C I
" ,N O
z ",
N O
3 ", a n
d S 0
4 ^')
a nd
am
mo ni
af
r om
thef l
owi
ng
ai
r str e am a nd
thefi l
te rp
a ck
c ol le ctsfi
n ep
artic
ul
a t em
at ter of 2
.5 |
im i
nd i
ame t er a nd l
e s s.T h
e c enterp
a th
(
wi
th 2 1p m fl
ow)
c o
l l
e c t s c o ars ep
a rti
c ul
a t em
a t t er of 2
.5 p m
t oI 0
\im
on aN
ucle o
p
or efi l
t er.T h
el
ef
t si de
p
a th
c ons
i
sts of
aq
u a rtzfi b
e rfi
lt erf
ol l
owed b
y ap
ol y
u r etha n ef
o am p
lug
(
PU
F)
tr ap
to c ol le ctm
at eri
al f
o r o rg
a ni
c a n al
ysi
s(
S
te v e n s e t al
.,199 3
)
.F
rom
the pa rtic ul
ate m at te r s amp l
e s ,P
M
10
a nd P
M
2
.5
wered
et erm i
n ed
and
th
efi l
t ers we r e a n al
yzed b
yX
-r ay F l
uore s c enc eS pe ctr o s c o
p
y(
X
R F)
to dete rm
in e elem e ntal c om po si
tio n of the am b ie nt pa rtic ulate mat te r.T
h
ed
e n ud
e r s am p l
e s we re a n aly
z edb
y Io nC
hr omatog
r ap h y(
IC
)
f
o r a ci dg
a s c omp
osi
tio n s(
M
uke rj
e e et al., 19 9 3)
.F i g
u re6
a nd 7
show s the PM
2.5
c o nce ntr atio n me asu r eme nts in the stud
y a n
d
c o ntrolco
m m
u ni
ty a s so cia
ted
wi
th
th
eb i
omed ic a
l
w a st ein
ci
ner at orin
the
fi
r st a nd
s econd
yea r of
t
hi
s stud y
.F
rom
th
e s eP
M
2
.5 m
e a s u rement s, the
g
e n e r al
si m i l
ari
ty b
e twe en th
e twoc o m
m
u ni
ti
e s s ug g
e sts them
aj
ori
ty
of
the
fi
n ep
a rti
c ulate mat te r w a s c om mo n to th
e s tud
y a nd
t
h
e control
c omm
u ni
ty
on on eh
a nd
.O
n e th
e o th
erh
a nd
, w e c a n s e e th
atin
s ome sam p l i
ng
p
eri
od
s, th
e conc en tra ti
onsin
s tud y
c om mu ni
ty areg
reate r th
an th
atin
co ntrol
com mu ni
tyb
uti
n o th
e r s am p l i
ng p
eri
od
s, th
e outcome s ap p
e ar c ontr a ry
.T he r
ef
ore th
ei m p
a c t of
th
ei
nci
n e r ator c an no tb
e s ee nf
rom
th i
sm
easu re.A
s e c ond m
ethod
to cl
a s si f
y th
e r e s ul
ts of
th
e air
qu al i
tym
o ni
t ori
ng i
s t o c onsi d
e r th
ein
fl
uen c e of w i
nd d i
re c ti
on on th
e c ons ti
tuen ts m e asu r ed
a t th
e s amp
li
ng
si
te.U
sin
g X
RF
a n al ys
i
s, el
em
e ntal c om p
o si
tio n s of pa rti
c ulate c a nbe
dete rmin e
d
. Ba s ed o n pr e vio u s stud ie s
t
h
a th
avem
e asur ed m
e t al
sin
th
e emi
s si
ons of
w as tei
nci
n e r ato rs,Z
n a s w el l
asP b
,K
and F
eh
a v ebe
enf
o u nd
tob
em
aj
o r c o n sti
tu e nts(M
uk
e rj
e e et al
.,19 9 3
)
. Fi g
u r e8
sh
ow s th
eZ
nco nc entr a t
i
onm
e asu r em
e nts as af
u n cti
on of
wi
nd d i
r e cti
oni
n the
two com m u ni
tie s
.T h i
sf i g
u re sh
ow
s th
a ti
n th
e stud y
c om mu ni
ty
, th
eh i g h
e s t c onc entra ti
ons of Z
n were ob
s er ved
w he n
th
ew i
nd d i re
c ti
on wa sf
r om
s outh
e a s t s e c t or ,w h i
ch i
s th
eg
e ner al d ir
ecti
o nf
r om
wh
e r et
h
eb i
om
ed i
c al
wa s t ei
nci
n e ra t or wasl
o c a t ed
t o th
em
oni
t ori
ng
si
t e.T h i
s sug g
es t s th
a t th
ee
l
ev ated Z
n c onc entr atio n s
we r e a s s o ci
ated
wi
th
th
eb i
omed ic a
l
w a stei
n ci
n e r ato r.10 urn I m pa cto r
P late
r
H C Path
T .
•
K
i
LT
C
oa r s eR
lte r1 0 > 2.5 um
Nu cle opor e
M
a s s, SE
M
< 2.5 um
N
0
2, S0
2, H C lDe n ude r
Io n C hr omatgr ap h
De n ude r
Tef lon F i lte r
S
ul fate,N
itr at eM
etalsM
a s s, X R F , I C80 t
^
70
k
o
I '
C
o ntr olC
om mu nity■ ■
St
ud yC
omidu nityJ
F
i
gu r e6
D
ay
a nd
N
i g h
tA i
rS
am
p l i
ng P
eri
od
s(
A p ri l 3 0
-J
u n e4
,
1 9 9 2
)
C
o n c e ntr atio n s of
Fi
n eP
a rti
c u la rM
a s si
n Bi
om
ed i
c al
W
a ste In ci
n e r ato rSt
ud y
a n
d C
o ntr ol C
om
m
u nit
yi
n19 9 2
T
O
tC
ontr ol C
om m
unit
y
St
ud y C
om m
uni
ty
D
ay
a nd N i g h
tA i
rS
am p l i
ng P
eri
od
s(
A p ri l 2 8
-J
u ne2
,
19 9 3
)
F i g
u r e7
.C
o n c en tr atio n s of F i
n eP
a rti
cul
a rM
a s si
nB i
om
ed i
c al
W
a steI
n ci
n e r ato rS
tud
y
a n
d C
o ntr ol C
om m
u ni
tyi
n19 9 3
E 6 0
™ 40
-o 2 0
« 1 0
SW W N
W
W
ind D ir e c t io n■
i
S ite T1[
^
S it e C1Num be r s in c e nte r of ba r s = Num be r of O bs e r v atio n s
(
N O bs)
F i g
u r e8
.Z
nC
onc e n tra ti
ons as aF
un c ti
on of
W
i
nd D i
re c ti
oni
nB i
om
ed i
c al
W
a st eI
n ci
ner ato r a nd C
ontr ol C
om
mu ni
ti
e sV . G E
O G
R A PH
IC
A L I N FO
RM
A T IO
NS
YS
T EM
C
om m
u ni
typ
a rtici p
a n t s in hom
e s lo c ated i
n al l di
r e cti
o n s s u r r o u ndi
ng
the in ci
n e r ato rwe r e u s e
d i
n the stud y
.C
ontrol
c om mu ni
ty p
a rti
ci p
a nt s w e r el
ocated
at ag
r e ate rd i
st an cei
na g
i
v e n s e cto r r el
ati
v e to th
ei
n ci
n e r ato r s o u r c e. Bef
o r e e ach 3 5
-d
ay s a
m
p li
ng pe riod
, e a ch
p
a rti
ci
pa nti d
e nti fi
ed
th
el
ocati
on of h i
s o rh
e r r e si d
e n c e o n a gri d d
ed
m ap
.A
pp
e nd i
xA
s
h
ows th
em
ap
s wh i
ch
w e re us ed f
o r th
ep
a rti
ci p
a ntsi
nH
u nter s vi l
le(
stud y
c o m mu ni
ty)
and
C
o r n eli
us(
c o n tr ol c o mm
u ni
ty)
. T hep
o la r c o o rd i
n ate s of
e a ch
of
th
e s eh
o me lo c ati
o n s a nd
t
h
e ai
rm
oni
t ori
ng
t ow er we red
e t ermi
n ed
rel
ati
ve t o th
ei
nci
nera t or wi
th G
IS
. T hi
si
nf
o rm
ati
on w a s c om b i
n ed w i
th d
isp
e rsi
o nm
od
el i
ng
t op
r ed i
ct the i mp
a c t of
thei
nci
n e r ato ron s
p
e ci fi
cl
o c a ti
onsi
n th
e vari
o u s12
-h
ou r s a
m p l i
ng p
eri
od
s of
th
e s tud y
.G I S i
s a sy
stem w i
th
sp
eci fi
c c apab i l i
ti
e sf
o r sp
ati
al l y
r ef
e r e n c ed d
ata a nd h
a s a se t of
o
p
er ati
o nsf
orm
a ni
pul
ati
ng d
ata s ets.G I S h
a s ap p l i
c ati
onsi
n th
efi
el d
of
n atu ral
r es ou rc e sm
a n ag
em
e nt,f
a ci l i
ti
e sm
a n ag
em
e nt, a nd d
em
og
r aph
y .I
t ha sb
e e n a to ol
u s ed i
n th
e s el
e cti
ono
f
w a sted
ispo s al
si
te s.T
hef
le xi b i
li
ty a nd
v e r s ati
l ity of G
IS
make thed
ata r etri e v al,m
a ni p
ul
a ti
ons and
an al y
si
s op
era tionsm
u chm
o r e acc u r ate a nd
ti m
e ef f
e cti
v e(
D
e vi
et al.,19 9 3
)
.I
n th i
s s tud y G I S
wa s u s ed
t o transf
orm
th
ep
arti
ci p
a n tl
o cati
onsi
nt o c o ord i
nate s tog
e t th
ei
r sp
a ti
al
r elati
on shi p
s.T h
e s t ep
s of d i g i
ti
za ti
o n usi
ng G I S
A
r ci
nf
o r s of
tw a r e are asf
ol l
ow s :a .
F i
x am
ap
on th
e el
ectroni
c tab l
e.b
.U
nd
e r thed i re
cto ry w ithA
r ci
nf
o r s oftwa r e, c om
ma nd
: AD
S
fi
l
e n am
e,c
D i g i
ti
z e th
el
oc ati
ons o n th
e map t o th
e c omp
ute r wi
th
ad i g i
ti
z e r.e.
C
om m
a nd
: BU I L D
fi
l
e n am
eP O I
N
T
f.
C
om m
a nd
: AD D X
Yfi
l
e n am
ed
.C
om m
a nd
: TA B L E S
.g
.C
om m
a nd
:S E L E C T
fi
l
e nam
e.P AT
h.
C
om m
a nd
:D U
M
P b
.
-y
i l
e n am
e.PA
T F IX
ED
A f
te r the se pr o c ed
u r e, theC
a rte sia n c o o rdi
n ate s of th
e lo c atio n s a r e sto r ed in a d isk ind i
gi
ti
z e r u nit, wh i
ch
canb
el
o ad
ed i
nt o a sp
r e ad
sh
eetl i
keE
XC
E L tob
e tr a n sf
o rm
ed
top
ola rco o r
d i
n atesi
n me tri
c u ni
t s.A p p
endi
x B sh
ow s th
ep
ol
a r coo rd i
n ates of
thep
a rti
cip
an tsi
nH
u ntersvi l l
e and C
or n el i
us.T h
e rew
e re t o tal l y 1 15
and 8 1 p
a rti
ci p
an tl
o c ati
o nsi
nH
u nte r s vi
l le a nd C
o r n eli
u s r e spe c ti
v el yf
o r the f ir st two ye a r s. F i gu r e 9 sho ws the sp
atialr elatio n s
h i
ps of th
ei
n ci
n e r ato r, air s am
p l ing
towe r, a nd p
a rtici p
a nt lo c ati
o n si
n th
e twoco
m m
u niti
es.6.0 0
4.5 0
3.0 0
1.5 0
0.0 0
- 1 5 0
-
3
.0 0
- 4
.5 0
6. 0 0
- 4
.
5
0- 3
.0 0
- 1
.5 0 0.0 0 1.
5
0 3.0 0 4.5 0 6.0 0- 6 0 0
1
—
\—
r 1—
I—
r<
•*
• • •
*
•S
a
m p l i
n
g
T
o
w
e r
S
a
m
p l i
n
g
T
o
w
e r
• • .
• *
^
T
—
rI
n
c
i
n e r a
t
o
r
J \ I L
6.0 0
4.5 0
-3.0 0
1.
5 0
0 .0 0
1.
5
0-
3
.
0 0
- 4
.5 0
-
6
.
0 0
- 4
.
5 0
-
5
.0 0
- 1
.
5 0
0 0
0K M
1.
5 0
3
.00
4.5 0
6.0
0-
6
.0
0
F i g
u re9
.S p
ati
al R
el
a ti
onsh i p
s of
theI
n ci
n e r at or,A i
rS
am
pl i
ngS
tatio n,a n