The
The SPACE matrixSPACE matrix is a management tool used to is a management tool used to analyze a company. It is used toanalyze a company. It is used to determine what type of a strategy a company
determine what type of a strategy a company should undertake. Theshould undertake. TheStrategicStrategic Position & ACtion Evaluation matrix
Position & ACtion Evaluation matrix or short aor short a SPACE matrixSPACE matrix is a strategicis a strategic management tool that focuses on
management tool that focuses on strategy formulation especially as related to thestrategy formulation especially as related to the competitive position of an organization.
competitive position of an organization. The
The SPACE matrixSPACE matrix can be used as a can be used as a basis for other analyses, such as thebasis for other analyses, such as the SWOT analysisSWOT analysis,, BCG matrix
BCG matrix model, industry analysis, or assessing strategicmodel, industry analysis, or assessing strategic alternativesalternatives((IE matrixIE matrix).). What is the SPACE matrix strategic management method?
What is the SPACE matrix strategic management method?
To explain how the
To explain how the SPACE matrix works, it is best to reverse-engineer it. First, let's takeSPACE matrix works, it is best to reverse-engineer it. First, let's take a look at what the outcome of a SPACE matrix analysis can be, take a look at the
a look at what the outcome of a SPACE matrix analysis can be, take a look at the picture picture below. The SPACE matrix is broken down to four quadrants where each quadrant
below. The SPACE matrix is broken down to four quadrants where each quadrant suggests a different type or a nature of a strategy:
suggests a different type or a nature of a strategy:
• • AggressiveAggressive • • ConservativeConservative • • DefensiveDefensive • • CompetitiveCompetitive
This is what a completed SPACE
This is what a completed SPACE matrix looks like:matrix looks like:
This particular SPACE matrix tells us that our company should pursue an
This particular SPACE matrix tells us that our company should pursue an aggressiveaggressive strategy
strategy. Our company has a strong competitive . Our company has a strong competitive position it theposition it the marketmarketwith rapid growth.with rapid growth. It needs to use its internal strengths to develop
It needs to use its internal strengths to develop a market penetration and marketa market penetration and market development strategy. This can include p
development strategy. This can include product development, integration with other roduct development, integration with other companies, acquisition of competitors, and so on.
Now, how do we get to the possible outcomes shown in the SPACE matrix? The SPACE Now, how do we get to the possible outcomes shown in the SPACE matrix? The SPACE
Matrix analysis functions upon two internal and two ex
Matrix analysis functions upon two internal and two external strategic dimensions internal strategic dimensions in order to determine the organization's strategic posture in the industry. The SPACE matrix order to determine the organization's strategic posture in the industry. The SPACE matrix is based on four
is based on four areasareasof analysis.of analysis.
Internal strategic dimensions: Internal strategic dimensions:
Financial strength (FS) Financial strength (FS) Competitive advantage (CA) Competitive advantage (CA) External strategic dimensions:
External strategic dimensions:
Environmental stability (ES) Environmental stability (ES) Industry strength (IS)
Industry strength (IS) There are many SPACE matrix factors under
There are many SPACE matrix factors under the internal strategic dimension. Thesethe internal strategic dimension. These factors analyze a business internal strategic position. The financial strength factors often factors analyze a business internal strategic position. The financial strength factors often come from company accounting. These SPACE matrix factors can include for example come from company accounting. These SPACE matrix factors can include for example return on investment, leverage, turnover, liquidity, working cap
return on investment, leverage, turnover, liquidity, working cap ital, cash flow, and others.ital, cash flow, and others. Competitive
Competitive advantageadvantagefactors include for example the speed ofactors include for example the speed of innovation by thef innovation by the company, market niche position, customer loyalty, product quality, market share,
company, market niche position, customer loyalty, product quality, market share, product product life cycle
life cycle,, and others.and others.
Every business is also affected by the environment in w
Every business is also affected by the environment in which it operates. SPACE matrixhich it operates. SPACE matrix factors related to business external strategic dimension are for example
factors related to business external strategic dimension are for example overall economicoverall economic condition, GDP growth, inflation, price elasticity, technology, barriers to entry,
condition, GDP growth, inflation, price elasticity, technology, barriers to entry, competitive pressures, industry growth potential, and others. These factors can b
competitive pressures, industry growth potential, and others. These factors can b e welle well analyzed using the
analyzed using the Michael Porter's Five ForcesMichael Porter's Five Forcesmodel.model.
The SPACE matrix calculates the importance of each of these dimensions and places The SPACE matrix calculates the importance of each of these dimensions and places them on a Cartesian graph with X and Y coordinates.
them on a Cartesian graph with X and Y coordinates. The following are a few model
The following are a few model technical assumptions:technical assumptions: - By definition, the CA and IS
- By definition, the CA and IS values in the SPACE matrix are values in the SPACE matrix are plotted on theplotted on theX axisX axis.. - CA values can range from -1 to -6.
- CA values can range from -1 to -6. - IS values can take +1 to +6.
- IS values can take +1 to +6.
- The FS and ES dimensions of the model are plotted on the
- The FS and ES dimensions of the model are plotted on theY axisY axis.. - ES values can be between -1 and -6.
- ES values can be between -1 and -6. - FS values range from +1 to +6. - FS values range from +1 to +6.
How do I construct a SPACE matrix? How do I construct a SPACE matrix?
The SPACE matrix is constructed by plotting calculated values for the competitive The SPACE matrix is constructed by plotting calculated values for the competitive advantage (CA) and industry strength (IS) dimensions on the
Now, how do we get to the possible outcomes shown in the SPACE matrix? The SPACE Now, how do we get to the possible outcomes shown in the SPACE matrix? The SPACE
Matrix analysis functions upon two internal and two ex
Matrix analysis functions upon two internal and two external strategic dimensions internal strategic dimensions in order to determine the organization's strategic posture in the industry. The SPACE matrix order to determine the organization's strategic posture in the industry. The SPACE matrix is based on four
is based on four areasareasof analysis.of analysis.
Internal strategic dimensions: Internal strategic dimensions:
Financial strength (FS) Financial strength (FS) Competitive advantage (CA) Competitive advantage (CA) External strategic dimensions:
External strategic dimensions:
Environmental stability (ES) Environmental stability (ES) Industry strength (IS)
Industry strength (IS) There are many SPACE matrix factors under
There are many SPACE matrix factors under the internal strategic dimension. Thesethe internal strategic dimension. These factors analyze a business internal strategic position. The financial strength factors often factors analyze a business internal strategic position. The financial strength factors often come from company accounting. These SPACE matrix factors can include for example come from company accounting. These SPACE matrix factors can include for example return on investment, leverage, turnover, liquidity, working cap
return on investment, leverage, turnover, liquidity, working cap ital, cash flow, and others.ital, cash flow, and others. Competitive
Competitive advantageadvantagefactors include for example the speed ofactors include for example the speed of innovation by thef innovation by the company, market niche position, customer loyalty, product quality, market share,
company, market niche position, customer loyalty, product quality, market share, product product life cycle
life cycle,, and others.and others.
Every business is also affected by the environment in w
Every business is also affected by the environment in which it operates. SPACE matrixhich it operates. SPACE matrix factors related to business external strategic dimension are for example
factors related to business external strategic dimension are for example overall economicoverall economic condition, GDP growth, inflation, price elasticity, technology, barriers to entry,
condition, GDP growth, inflation, price elasticity, technology, barriers to entry, competitive pressures, industry growth potential, and others. These factors can b
competitive pressures, industry growth potential, and others. These factors can b e welle well analyzed using the
analyzed using the Michael Porter's Five ForcesMichael Porter's Five Forcesmodel.model.
The SPACE matrix calculates the importance of each of these dimensions and places The SPACE matrix calculates the importance of each of these dimensions and places them on a Cartesian graph with X and Y coordinates.
them on a Cartesian graph with X and Y coordinates. The following are a few model
The following are a few model technical assumptions:technical assumptions: - By definition, the CA and IS
- By definition, the CA and IS values in the SPACE matrix are values in the SPACE matrix are plotted on theplotted on theX axisX axis.. - CA values can range from -1 to -6.
- CA values can range from -1 to -6. - IS values can take +1 to +6.
- IS values can take +1 to +6.
- The FS and ES dimensions of the model are plotted on the
- The FS and ES dimensions of the model are plotted on theY axisY axis.. - ES values can be between -1 and -6.
- ES values can be between -1 and -6. - FS values range from +1 to +6. - FS values range from +1 to +6.
How do I construct a SPACE matrix? How do I construct a SPACE matrix?
The SPACE matrix is constructed by plotting calculated values for the competitive The SPACE matrix is constructed by plotting calculated values for the competitive advantage (CA) and industry strength (IS) dimensions on the
based on the environmental stability (ES) and financial strength (FS) dimensions. The based on the environmental stability (ES) and financial strength (FS) dimensions. The
SPACE matrix can be created using the following seven steps: SPACE matrix can be created using the following seven steps:
Step 1:
Step 1:Choose a set of variables to be used to gauge the competitiveChoose a set of variables to be used to gauge the competitive advantage (CA), industry strength (IS), environmental stability (ES), and financial advantage (CA), industry strength (IS), environmental stability (ES), and financial strength (FS).
strength (FS). Step 2:
Step 2: Rate individual factors using rating system specific to each dimension. RateRate individual factors using rating system specific to each dimension. Rate competitive advantage (CA) and e
competitive advantage (CA) and environmental stability (ES) using rating scale from -6nvironmental stability (ES) using rating scale from -6 (worst) to -1 (best). Rate industry strength (IS) and financial strength (FS) using rating (worst) to -1 (best). Rate industry strength (IS) and financial strength (FS) using rating scale from +1 (worst) to +6 (best).
scale from +1 (worst) to +6 (best). Step 3:
Step 3: Find theFind the average scoresaverage scores for competitive advantage (CA), industry strengthfor competitive advantage (CA), industry strength (IS), environmental stability (ES), and financial strength (FS).
(IS), environmental stability (ES), and financial strength (FS). Step 4:
Step 4: Plot values from step 3 for each Plot values from step 3 for each dimension on the SPACE matrix on dimension on the SPACE matrix on thethe appropriate axis.
appropriate axis. Step 5:
Step 5: Add the average score for the competitive advantage (CA) and industryAdd the average score for the competitive advantage (CA) and industry strength (IS) dimensions. This will be your final point on
strength (IS) dimensions. This will be your final point on axis Xaxis Xon the SPACE matrix.on the SPACE matrix. Step 6: Add the av
Step 6: Add the average score for the SPACE matrix enverage score for the SPACE matrix environmental stability (ES) andironmental stability (ES) and financial strength (FS) dimensions to find your final point on
financial strength (FS) dimensions to find your final point on thetheaxis Yaxis Y.. Step 7:
Step 7: Find intersection of your Find intersection of your XX andandYY points. Draw a line from the center of thepoints. Draw a line from the center of the SPACE matrix to your point. This line reveals
SPACE matrix to your point. This line reveals thethe type of strategy the company should type of strategy the company should pursue
pursue..
SPACE matrix example SPACE matrix example
The following table shows what values were
The following table shows what values were used to create the SPACE matrix dused to create the SPACE matrix displayedisplayed above.
Each factor within each strategic dimension is rated using appropriate rating scale. Then averages are calculated. Adding individual strategic dimension averages provides values that are plotted on the axis X and Y.
Where do I go next?
The SPACE matrix can help to find a strategy. But, what if we have 2-3 strategies and need to decide which one is the best one? The Quantitative Strategic Planning Matrix (QSPM) model can help to answer this question.
Should you have any questions about theSPACE matrix, you might want to submit them at our management discussion forum.
SWOT Analysis
SWOT analysis is a simple framework for generating strategic alternatives from a situation analysis. It is applicable to either the corporate level or the business unit level and frequently appears in marketing plans. SWOT (sometimes referred to as TOWS) stands for Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats. The SWOT framework was described in the late 1960's by Edmund P. Learned, C. Roland Christiansen, Kenneth Andrews, and William D. Guth in Business Policy, Text and Cases (Homewood, IL: Irwin, 1969). The General Electric Growth Council used this form of analysis in the 1980's. Because it concentrates on the issues that potentially have the most impact, the SWOT analysis is useful when a very limited amount of time is available to address a complex strategic situation.
The following diagram shows how a SWOT analysis fits into a strategic situation analysis.
Situation Analysis
/ \
Internal Analysis External Analysis
/ \ / \
Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities Threats |
SWOT Profile
The internal and external situation analysis can produce a large amount of information, much of which may not be highly relevant. The SWOT analysis can serve as an
interpretative filter to reduce the information to a manageable quantity of key issues. The SWOT analysis classifies the internal aspects of the company as strengths or weak nesses and the external situational factors as opportunities or threats. Strengths can serve as a foundation for building a competitive advantage, and weaknesses may hinder it. By understanding these four aspects of its situation, a firm can better leverage its strengths, correct its weaknesses, capitalize on golden opportunities, and deter potentially
devastating threats. Internal Analysis
The internal analysis is a comprehensive evaluation of the internal environment's
potential strengths and weaknesses. Factors should be evaluated across the organization in areas such as:
• Company culture • Company image
• Organizational structure • Key staff
• Access to natural resources • Position on the experience curve • Operational efficiency • Operational capacity • Brand awareness • Market share • Financial resources • Exclusive contracts • Patents and trade secrets
The SWOT analysis summarizes the internal factors of the firm as a list of strengths and weaknesses.
An opportunity is the chance to introduce a new product or service that can generate superior returns. Opportunities can arise when changes occur in the external environment. Many of these changes can be perceived as threats to the market position of existing products and may necessitate a change in product specifications or the development of
new products in order for the firm to remain competitive. Changes in the external environment may be related to:
• Customers • Competitors • Market trends • Suppliers • Partners • Social changes • New technology • Economic environment
• Political and regulatory environment
The last four items in the above list are macro-environmental variables, and are addressed in a PEST analysis.
The SWOT analysis summarizes the external environmental factors as a list of opportunities and threats.
SWOT Profile
When the analysis has been completed, a SWOT profile can be generated and used as the basis of goal setting, strategy formulation, and implementation. The completed SWOT profile sometimes is arranged as follows:
Strengths Weaknesses 1. 2. 3. . . . 1. 2. 3. . . . Opportunities Threats 1. 2. 3. . . . 1. 2. 3. . . .
When formulating strategy, the interaction of the quadrants in the SWOT profile becomes important. For example, the strengths can be leveraged to pursue opportunities and to avoid threats, and managers can be alerted to weaknesses that might need to be overcome in order to successfully pursue opportunities.
Multiple Perspectives Needed
The method used to acquire the inputs to the SWOT matrix will affect the quality of the analysis. If the information is obtained hastily during a quick interview with the CEO, even though this one person may have a broad view of the company and industry, the information would represent a single viewpoint. The quality of the analysis will be improved greatly if interviews are held with a spectrum o f stakeholders such as employees, suppliers, customers, strategic partners, etc.
SWOT Analysis Limitations
While useful for reducing a large quantity of situational factors into a more manageable profile, the SWOT framework has a tendency to oversimplify the situation by classifying
the firm's environmental factors into categories in which they may no t always fit. The classification of some factors as strengths or weaknesses, or as opportunities or threats is somewhat arbitrary. For example, a particular company culture can be either a strength or a weakness. A technological change can be a either a threat or an opportunity. Perhaps what is more important than the superficial classification of these factors is the firm's awareness of them and its development of a strategic plan to use them to its advantage.
GE / McKinsey Matrix
In consulting engagements with General Electric in the 1970's, McKinsey &
Company developed a nine-cell portfolio matrix as a tool for screening GE's large portfolio of strategic business units (SBU). This business screen became known as the GE/McKinsey Matrix and is shown below:
GE / McKinsey Matrix
Business Unit Strength High Medium Low
Medium
Low
The GE / McKinsey matrix is similar to the BCG growth-share matrix in that it maps strategic business units on a grid of the industry and the SBU's position in the industry. The GE matrix however, attempts to improve upon the BCG matrix in the following two ways:
• The GE matrix generalizes the axes as "Industry Attractiveness" and
"Business Unit Strength" whereas the BCG matrix uses the market growth rate as a proxy for industry attractiveness and relative market share as a proxy for the strength of the business unit.
• The GE matrix has nine cells vs. four cells in the BCG matrix.
Industry attractiveness and business unit strength are calculated by first identifying criteria for each, determining the value of each parameter in the criteria, and multiplying that value by a weighting factor. The result is a
quantitative measure of industry attractiveness and the business unit's relative performance in that industry.
Industry Attractiveness
The vertical axis of the GE / McKinsey matrix is industry attractiveness, which is determined by factors such as the following:
• Market growth rate • Market size
• Demand variability • Industry profitability • Industry rivalry
• Global opportunities
• Macroenvironmental factors ( PEST)
Each factor is assigned a weighting that is appropriate for the industry. The industry attractiveness then is calculated as follows:
Industry attractiveness = factor value1 x factor weighting1
+ factor value2 x factor weighting2
. . .
+ factor value N x factor weighting N
Business Unit Strength
The horizontal axis of the GE / McKinsey matrix is the strength of the business unit. Some factors that can be used to determine business unit strength include:
• Market share
• Growth in market share • Brand equity
• Distribution channel access • Production capacity
• Profit margins relative to competitors
The business unit strength index can be calculated by multiplying the estimated value of each factor by the factor's weighting, as done for industry attractiveness.
Plotting the Information
Each business unit can be portrayed as a circle plotted on the matrix, with the information conveyed as follows:
• Market size is represented by the size of the circle.
• Market share is shown by using the circle as a pie chart.
• The expected future position of the circle is portrayed by means of an
arrow.
The following is an example of such a representation:
The shading of the above circle indicates a 38% market share for the strategic business unit. The arrow in the upward left direction indicates that the business
unit is projected to gain strength relative to competitors, and that the business unit is in an industry that is projected to become more attractive. The tip of the arrow indicates the future position of the center point of the circle.
Strategic Implications
Resource allocation recommendations can be made to grow, hold, or harvest a strategic business unit based on its position on the matrix as follows:
• Grow strong business units in attractive industries, average business units
in attractive industries, and strong business units in average industries.
• Hold average businesses in average industries, strong businesses in
weak industries, and weak business in attractive industies.
• Harvest weak business units in unattractive industries, average business
units in unattractive industries, and weak business units in average industries.
There are strategy variations within these three groups. For example, within the harvest group the firm would be inclined to quickly divest itself of a weak
business in an unattractive industry, whereas it might perform a phased harvest of an average business unit in the same industry.
While the GE business screen represents an improvement over the more simple BCG growth-share matrix, it still presents a somewhat limited view by not
considering interactions among the business units and by neglecting to address the core competencies leading to value creation. Rather than serving as the primary tool for resource allocation, portfolio matrices are better suited to displaying a quick synopsis of the strategic business units.
BCG Matrix Model
The BCG matrix or also calledBCG model relates to marketing. The BCG model is a well-known portfolio management tool used in product life cycle theory. BCG matrix is often used to prioritize which products within company product mix get more funding and attention.
The BCG matrix model is a portfolio planning model developed by Bruce Henderson of the Boston Consulting Group in the early 1970's.
The BCG model is based on classification of products (and implicitly also company business units) into four categories based on combinations of market growth and market share relative to the largest competitor.
When should I use the BCG matrix model?
Each product has its product life cycle, and each stage in product's life-cycle represents a different profile of risk and return. In general, a company should maintain a balanced portfolio of products. Having a balanced product portfolio includes both high-growth products as well as low-growth products.
A high-growth productis for example a new one that we are trying to get to some market. It takes some effort and resources to market it, to build distribution channels, and to build sales infrastructure, but it is a product that is expected to bring the gold in the future. An example of this product would be an iPod.
A low-growth productis for example an established product known by the market. Characteristics of this product do not change much, customers know what they are
getting, and the price does not change much either. This product has only limited budget for marketing. The is the milking cow that brings in the constant flow of cash. An
example of this product would be a regular Colgate toothpaste.
But the question is, how do we exactly find out what phase our product is in, and how do we classify what we sell? Furthermore, we also ask, where does each of our products fit into our product mix? Should we promote one product more than the other one? The BCG matrix can help with this.
The BCG matrix reaches further behind product mix. Knowing what we are selling helps managers to make decisions about what priorities to assign to not only products but also company departments and business units.
What is the BCG matrix and how does the BCG model work?
Placing products in the BCG matrix results in 4 categories in a portfolio of a company: BCG STARS (high growth, high market share)
- Stars are defined by having high market share in a growing market.
- Stars are the leaders in the business but still need a lot of support for promotion a placement.
- If market share is kept, Stars are likely to grow into cash cows.
BCG QUESTION MARKS (high growth, low market share) - These products are in growing markets but have low market share.
- Question marks are essentially new products where buyers have yet to discover them. - The marketing strategy is to get markets to adopt these products.
- Question marks have high demands and low returns due to low market share. - These products need to increase their market share quickly or they become dogs.
- The best way to handle Question marks is to either invest heavily in them to gain market share or to sell them.
BCG CASH COWS (low growth, high market share)
- Cash cows are in a position of high market share in a mature market.
- If competitive advantage has been achieved, cash cows have high profit margins and generate a lot of cash flow.
- Because of the low growth, promotion and placement investments are low.
- Investments into supporting infrastructure can improve efficiency and increase cash flow more.
- Cash cows are the products that businesses strive for. BCG DOGS (low growth, low market share)
- Dogs are in low growth markets and have low market share. - Dogs should be avoided and minimized.
- Expensive turn-around plans usually do not help. And now, let's put all this into a picture:
Are there any problems with the BCG matrix model?
Some limitations of the BCG matrix model include:
• The first problem can be how we define market and how we get data about market
share
• A high market share does not necessarily lead to profitability at all times
• The model employs only two dimensions – market share and product or service
• Low share or niche businesses can be profitable too (some Dogs can be more
profitable than cash Cows)
• The model does not reflect growth rates of the overall market • The model neglects the effects of synergy between business units • Market growth is not the only indicator for attractiveness of a market
Portfolio Management based on Market Share and Market
Growth. Explanation of BCG Matrix. ('70)
The BCG Matrix method is the most well-knownportfolio management tool. It is based on product life cycle theory. It was developed in the early 70s by the Boston
Consulting Group. The BCG Matrix can be used to determine what priorities should be given in the product portfolio of a business unit. To ensure long-term value creation, a company should have a portfolio of products that contains both high-growth products in need of cash inputs and low-growth products that generate a lot of cash. The Boston Consulting Group Matrix has 2 dimensions:market share and market growth. The basic idea behind it is: if a product has a bigger market share, or if the product's market
grows faster, it is better for the company.
The four segments of the BCG Matrix
• Stars(high growth, high market share)
o Stars are using large amounts of cash. Stars are leaders in the business. Therefore they should also generate large amounts of cash.
o Stars are frequently roughly in balance on net cash flow. However if needed any attempt should be made to hold your market share in Stars, because the rewards will be Cash Cows if market share is kept.
• Cash Cows (low growth, high market share)
o Profits and cash generation should be high. Because of the low growth, investments which are needed should be low.
o Cash Cows are often the stars of yesterday and they are the foundation of a company.
• Dogs (low growth, low market share)
o Avoid and minimize the number of Dogs in a company. o Watch out for expensive ‘rescue plans’.
o Dogs must deliver cash, otherwise they must be liquidated.
o Question Marks have the worst cash characteristics of all, becau se they have high cash demands and generate low returns, because of their low market share.
o If the market share remains unchanged, Question Marks will simply absorb great amounts of cash.
o Either invest heavily, or sell off, or invest nothing and generate any cash that you can. Increase market share or deliver cash.
the BCG Matrix and one size fits all strategies
The BCG Matrix method can help to understand a frequently made strategy mistake: having a one size fits all strategy approach, such as a generic growth target (9 percent per year) or a generic return on capital of say 9,5% for an entire corporation.
In such a scenario:
• Cash Cows Business Units will reach their profit target easily. Their management
have an easy job. The executives are often praised anyhow. Even worse, they are often allowed to reinvest substantial cash amounts in their mature businesses.
• Dogs Business Units are fighting an impossible battle and, even worse, now and
then investments are made. These are hopeless attempts to "turn the business around".
• As a result all Question Marks and Stars receive only mediocre investment funds.
In this way they can never become Cash Cows. These inadequate invested sums of money are a waste of money. Either these SBUs should receive enough
investment funds to enable them to achieve a real market dominance and become Cash Cows (or Stars), or otherwise companies are advised to disinvest. They can then try to get any possible cash from the Question Marks that were not selected.
Other uses and benefits of the BCG Matrix
• If a company is able to use the experience curve to its advantage, it should be able
to manufacture and sell new products at a price that is low enough to get early market share leadership. Once it becomes a star, it is destined to be profitable.
• BCG model is helpful for managers to evaluate balance in the firm’s current
portfolio of Stars, Cash Cows, Question Marks and Dogs.
• BCG method is applicable to large companies that seek volume and experience
effects.
• The model is simple and easy to understand.
• It provides a base for management to decide and prepare for future actions.
Limitations of the BCG Matrix
Some limitations of the Boston Consulting Group Matrix include:
• High market share is not the only success factor.
• Market growth is not the only indicator for attractiveness of a market. • Sometimes Dogs can earn even more cash as Cash Cows.
• The problems of getting data on the market share and market growth. • There is no clear definition of what constitutes a "market".
• A high market share does not necessarily lead to profitability all the time.
• The model uses only two dimensions – market share and growth rate. This may
tempt management to emphasize a particular product, or to divest prematurely.
• A business with a low market share can be profitable too.
• The model neglects small competitors that have fast growing market shares.
Book: Carl W. Stern, George Stalk - Perspectives on Strategy from The Boston Consulting Group
-BCG Matrix Forum
Recent User Comments
J Winstanley -UK How to do BCG Plotting?
"Hello everyone, I'm a little bit confused abouthow to plot products on to the BCG matrix? Should I:
[1] Look at the definitions of the animals and place products on to the graph depending
upon what animal they most feel like [2] Look at the X and Y axis and place products on the graph and plot depending
upon market share and growth and completely ignore the animals during the plotting process. I assume that [2] is the right approach.
If [2] is the right approach then how do I determine market share and growth?
Lets say there are 100 people who want a TV. 10 of them have my TV at the end of one year. And 50 of them have someone elses' TV.
What is my market share and what is my growth? Do I have high growth and low share? Thanks..." 1 Juliet - Gha na Funding Stars
"I think the cash cows should fund stars if they
are cash hungry." 2
Yuri Lengue - A ngola BCG in Emerging or Fragmented Markets
"The tool is really great, but how to use it in fragmented industries where there is a lack of information making almost
impossible to make intelligent decisions. For instance how would market growth rate or market share be calculated under
such conditions?" Dr Isaac Ogbuka - Nigeria BCG Matrix: not in All Cases
"The matrix does not consider the place of traditional/generic products that companies maintain in their product lines that may have had high market share and market growth in time past, but currently do not. Sometimes, companies just
can keep the dogs (low growth, low market share) due to some intangible factors.
What needs to be done may not necessarily be to let go but to invest more in such products in
repackaging (innovation). This is because market expansion is a dynamic process that responds to identified opportunities and there are other basic factors that influence investment decisions and market expansion. The cost element is for instance an essential determinant." 0 Frank Bacchus - U SA Advantages and Disadvantages of
Portfolio Planning Tools
"What are the pros and cons of portfolio planning tools like the
BCG Matrix or the GE/McKinsey matrix?"
1
Best User Comments
Rob - Netherl ands
10% limit in BCG Matrix
"Generally in the BCG Matrix, when the market growth is more than 10%, it would be considered a star. Can anyone explain why they have chosen the (fairly high) limit of 10%??" 43 Manish Sijaria - In dia Superb explanation of PLC and BCG Matrix
"This explanation of BCG matrix is superb, in terms of penetrating the market as start ups. Clearly layouts the structure of SBU's and their expectations in the business product life cycle. "Very Good"!"
31
Nyle - U SA
Lack of Question Marks?
"If a business has no Question Marks (or
just one), what should it do?" 27
Thijs - Nethe rlands
Cola & Pepsi
"The matrix is misrepresenting in some cases. Example: Coca cola and Pepsi. Coca cola is market LEADER, as a result of which the relative market share of Pepsi is always smaller than 1. When the relative market share is smaller than 1, you will be at the right-hand side of the matrix. In that case, Pepsi will automatically be a Question mark or a dog. Everyone understands that Pepsi is a cash cow or star!" 25 Wallace G. USA - NY The BCG Matrix: Reloaded
"(How) could the the BCG Matrix be adapted to include synergy effects between business units?"
19 John BCG Matrix is "Totally useless (as a contemporary 16
T. - Greece useless! business tool)." Manoj
Sinha - India BCG Matrix
"Use it for a basic analysis.But other metrics are required if a deeper insight in business is
needed." 16 Shreya - In dia BCG Matrix in India
"Which industries or Firms in India are
using the BCG Matrix?" 10
arya - Indo nesia
Not useful for Competitive Analysis
"i am not sure if this matrix works to create a competition map, it does not work like swot chart. It's merely plotting the products you have within your company for evaluation purpose... It will depend on your analysis
though where you'll take it forward but for most cases it's totally junk for competition mapping." 10 Marty -Korea Real business
"One important thing in business would be how to allocate and manage limited resource to achieve maximum results. In that sense, the matrix is a good tool to see where is the business that a company should focus on to grow. But one thing that we need to
consider using the matrix is that real business is not simple to be explained by a 2x2 matrix. For example, a business can make more money and be more profitable than other businessses in a company's portfolio even if the market growth and the relative market share of the business is low." 7 Srinivasan Kannan - UA E Use of the Model
"This model is extremely useful if adapted suitably, to address a particular situation. For example, for a portfolio of products in a
firm, one can locate them in a 2 by 2 matrix on the Market Share vs Growth rate variables. The variables can then be changed to
margins vs growth rate and the products relocated. If we notice a shift in the location of a product from say,'?' to star(between the two matrices), we may like to explore the possibilities of investing in it's growth. Similarly, if a low share/low growth product, has high margins and consequently shifts between matrices, the strategy should be appropriate. Likewise, if a cash cow in the market share matrix shifts to dog in the margin matrix, we may decide to closely observe the product and restrict support for the same. This model is a useful tool if used appropriately. It does not replace our thought process but certainly structures the process of decision making."
Grand Strategy Steps
Summary
• Step One. Answer "what's your Theory of Business?"
• Step Two. Identify your Values, Beliefs, Attitudes and Capabilities. • Step Three. Write your Mission Statement .
• Step Four. Perform an Environmental Scan. • Step Five. Perform a SWOT Analysis.
• Step Six. Determine your Strategic Focus. • Step Seven. Seek Performance Breakthroughs.
• Step Eight. Understand and Apply Cause and Effect Relationships. • Step Nine. Develop a Strategy Map.
• Step Ten. Translate goals into KPMs and Perform Gap Analysis.
• Step Eleven. Prepare a Scorecard to track and drive Your Grand Strategy. • Step Twelve. Execute, Adjust, Execute.
Grand Strategy: building your foundation
for performance breakthroughs
by Daniel J. Knight
Imagine you were able to maximize your opportunities, minimize your risks and achieve performance breakthroughs. You're probably thinking – "that would be great, how do I do
it?" Well it's simple but this simplicity demands critical thinking and diligent effort. So if you're interested, let's find out how. Achieving this level of performance requires a deliberate strategy with a performance management and measurement system that enables you to scan the business horizon, focus your time, energy, knowledge,
relationships and resources and execute courses of action that possess the highest pay-off, lowest costs and easiest implementation trajectory. You may wonder whether such a strategy formulation is worth your time and effort, especially if you're in a quickly
changing business environment. This issue came up in a discussion with leading business writer and consultant Seth Godin. We concluded that business strategy drives growth and prosperity for businesses, both large and small. Godin said that for example Howard
Shultz , founder and head of Starbucks Coffee, could have decided to open and run only a few stores, but you better believe that to grow Starbucks like he has he had to have a business strategy.
So with that as introduction let's go through a step-by-step process for developing a business strategy with a performance management and measurement system for your business. Let's call it a "Grand Strategy" because it equates to a necessary precursor for
all subordinate strategies and systems whether they be marketing, innovation or
otherwise. There are 12 steps to this Grand Strategy process. The first 11 steps of this process are best developed as a living document with your top management team and a
facilitator at an off-site meeting to avoid distractions. And step twelve, "Execute, Adjust, Execute" requires strong top management commitment, support and involvement.
Step One. Ask "what's your 'Theory of Business'?" As philosophers tell us, there is nothing as practical as good theory. Briefly answer these four questions to uncover yours. What business are you in and where are you now?
• Where are you going? • How will you get there?
• How will you know you've arrived?
Step Two. Create a clear expression of your intangible business resources. These
intangibles form an intellectual and emotional grounding for your Grand Strategy. They drive your business and business relationships. Without them, you won't be able to
commit the time, energy and tangible resources that move your business forward. These intangibles are:
• Values – high level concepts that you pour your life into regardless of financial
return because they define you and your business. Some examples are family well being, charity and goodwill toward others, honesty and integrity, and making a
difference in the world.
• Beliefs- key principles that state your assumptions about the cause and effect
relationships that drive you and your business. For example, if we provide
excellent products and services that please our customers at a competitive price, we will be a profitable business.
• Attitudes – emotional orientations exhibited by you and your business toward
others that affects how you view them and treat them, and in turn how they react to you and your business. Attitudes result in either positive or negative
expressions such as "most people tend to be fair if treated fairly" or "most people will take advantage of you if you let them."
• Capabilities – inherent knowledge and relationships that support getting work
done for you and your business. For example, such things as patents, suppliers and customer data bases, production processes, sales force knowledge, knowledge about competitors, technological expertise and customer relationships fit here. What are your Values, Beliefs, Attitudes and Capabilities? List them.
Step Three. Write a "Mission Statement." This statement provides you with the
articulation of your business purpose or reason for being. Answering the following four questions in a satisfying amount of detail provides compelling background information from which you can extract a hard hitting mission statement to move your business and Grand Strategy forward.
• Why are you in business?
• What does your business do and how does it do it?
• Who does your business, who supports it, who benefits from it and who, if
anyone, suffers from it?
• How many different kinds of resources are involved in your business, how much
do they costs and how much profit do you expect to make from them?
Answer these questions and notice the power of their focusing affect on your business. From your answers, develop a condensed and hard hitting Mission Statement .
Step Four. Perform an "Environmental Scan" by asking and answering the following questions:
• What industry are you in (retail, wholesale, finance, manufacturing, durable or
non-durable goods and so on) and what are its trends?
• What is the economic situation (interest rates, costs of labor and materials,
unemployment levels, consumer demand, inflation and prices) and how will it affect your business?
• Who are your competitors and potential competitors? What relevant advantages
and disadvantages do they possess?
• Who are your suppliers and potential suppliers? What mutual interests do you
share with them? What natural conflicts exist?
• Who are your customers and potential customers and who are their customers?
What segments do they fall in?
• What are the demographics that impact your business – age groups, ethnics,
economic status? What are their differences in terms of needs and preferences?
• What is the regulatory environment and how does it affect your business? • What are the emerging technologies and how might they affect your business? • Who are your stakeholders (employees, suppliers, customers, investors and
Answer these Environmental Scan questions in order to possess the necessary business intelligence and insight to proceed to the next step.
Step Five. After you complete your scan, then perform a SWOT Analysis. SWOT stands for "Strengths," "Weaknesses," "Opportunities" and "Threats." Your Strengths and
Weaknesses are internal. Your Opportunities and Threats are external. The areas for you to explore under each SWOT Analysis category are:
Strengthsor Weaknesses
Customer Service Products
Systems and Processes R&D Cash Flow Employee Training Employee Loyalty Others? Opportunities or Threats
Emerging Products and Services Technological Change New Markets Competitive Pressures Supplier Relationships Economic Conditions Others?
Now, brainstorm to generate ideas under each category/area. Generate as many as ideas as possible. Using your best judgment, select the top six ideas in terms of relevance and importance for improving the performance and competitiveness of your business. Next, translate the top six selected ideas into goal statements. For this translation process, use the following format: action verb + (restated idea) in order to (object). For example, a goal statement would look like this: "Increase customer satisfaction in order to reduce customer losses and defections."
Step Six. Determine your "Strategic Focus." Business is becoming more and more competitive. Let's call this phenomenon "Hyper-Competition." From it we see the time lapse between finding a competitive edge and having it copied shrinking.
Hyper-Competition demands that you differentiate. This differentiation starts with you selecting a Strategic Focus for your business. Otherwise your products and services become commoditized.
• Customer Intimacy - emphasizes paying close attention to customers desires and
providing them with total, not to be beaten service and solutions. Ritz Carlton Hotels and Nordstroms lead with this discipline.
• Product Leadership – emphasizes R&D and providing the best technology and
quality available in products. Intel and Starbucks lead with this discipline.
• Operational Excellence – emphasizes efficient operations and costs controls to
provide the lowest costs. Wal-Mart and Southwest Airlines lead with this discipline.
Picking one of these as your lead focus represents a smart thing to do. This imperative does not mean that you don't try to do well in the other two. It means that you don't try to do all three equally well. Trying to be all things for all customers puts you on a path to failure because customers will not behave in a way that profits your business. Business is just too hyper-competitive for you to succeed doing all three better than anyone else.
So now look at your: Theory of Business; Values, Beliefs, Attitudes and Capabilities; Mission Statement, Environmental Scan and SWOT Analysis, and then make a judgment call. Pick your Strategic Focus and lead with it.
Step Seven. Seek performance breakthroughs. You begin this process by selecting your Strategic Focus and limiting your goal statements to the top six. These top six goals represent your "Strategic Goals" for achieving performance breakthroughs.
If you look at the time you spend on your business, you find it can be broken down into three categories. These are:
• Administrative and Operations – the time you spend keeping the routine day to
day business running
• Crisis – the time you spend solving unanticipated problems
• Breakthrough – the deliberate time you spend on creative efforts to improve
performance
What happens is that the first two time categories g row to occupy all your time and they push out your breakthrough time. Maintaining a Strategic Focus combined with
developing Strategic Goals to execute amounts to the only workable solution to this challenge. Now, incorporate this thinking into the succeeding steps of your Grand Strategy process.
Step Eight. Understand and apply "Cause and Effect Relationships." Let's discuss the dynamics of Cause and Effect Relationships among your Strategic Goals. There are four
basic "Perspectives" that provide the framework for linking your goals in to your Grand Strategy. These Perspectives are:
• Human Capital – the people talent in your organization and the systems and
process that directly enable them to be productive. A good way to look at the people part is that it's what goes home at night.
• Structural Capital – the systems, structures and strategies that the organization
owns and produces value with. It stays in the organization when you turn off the lights.
• Customer Capital – the relationship, level of satisfaction, reputation, potential for
referrals and loyalty which your organization enjoys with its customers.
• Financial Performance – the level of economic return provided to you and your
owners relative to investment. Performance under this perspective is also compared to alternative investments like T-Bills.
So imagine that you possess superior Human Capital by recruiting, training and retaining top talent and acquiring excellent people support systems. Given this superior Human Capital, might you not be able to improve and create superior Structural Capital ? And with superior Human and Structural Capital , might you not be able to improve and create superior Customer Capital which in turn would improve and create superior Financial Performance? What we have described here equates to a virtuous cycle which enables
you to make more money for you and your owners and at the same time invest more in your Human Capital . This virtuous cycle in turn starts succeeding rounds of
improvement which should cause an upward spiral to higher and higher levels of
performance. You will learn how to develop these Perspectives and link them in the next step.
Step Nine. Develop a "Strategy Map." Let's start by looking at an example. A Harvard Business Reviewarticle, The Employee – Customer Profit Chain at Sears, Jan-Feb 1998,
chronicled a transformation of Sears. Based on this article, an extraction of the Strategy Map for Sears follows:
Mission Statement
"Be a compelling place to Work, Shop and Invest"
o
Financial Performance Goals– Increase Revenues and Profitability
(What would it take to accomplish these strategic goals? Their answer was to increase customer satisfaction to cause increased revenues and profitability)
Customer Capital Goal - Increase Customer Satisfaction
(What would it take to accomplish this Strategic Goal ? Their
answer was to create and maintain well stocked and attractive shelves and provide friendly and helpful service that causes increased customer satisfaction.)
Structural Capital Goals- Create and Maintain Well Stocked and Attractive Shelves
and Provide Friendly and Helpful Service
(What would it take to accomplish these
Strategic Goals? Their answer was to
increase employee training and development in relevant areas. This would increase
employee competence and satisfaction. And this in turn would make employees able and willing to create and maintain well stocked and attractive shelves and provide friendly and helpful service)
Human Capital Goals - Increase Employee Training and Development in the Relevant
Areas in order to cause an Increase in Employee Competence and Satisfaction. (What would it take to accomplish these
Strategic Goals? The answer was top
management belief in the complete series of Cause and Effect Relationships and top management commitment of the time and resources for successful accomplishment.)
Financial (Place Goals here)
Performance Example: Increase Revenue and Profits
Customer (Place Goals here)
Capital Example: Reduce Customer Losses and Defections
by Increasing Customer Satisfaction
Structural (Place Goals here) Capital
Human (Place Goals here)
Capital
As proof of this Cause and Effect Relationship, Sears developed and validated a
predictive model that showed that for each 5 percent increase in employee satisfaction a 1.3 percent increase in customer satisfaction resulted which in turn resulted in a .5 percent increase in revenue. And Sears realized a 4 percent increase in customer
satisfaction in the 12 month period before the article was published and they were expecting revenues to increase by $200 million.
So how do you develop a Strategy Map? The answer - you take a clean sheet of paper and place your Mission Statement at the top. Lay out the four Perspectives underneath to form a Strategy Map framework . Next, use your best judgment and assign your top Strategic Goals to one of the four Strategy Map Perspectives (see example below).
Mission Statement :
(Briefly state your Mission here)Start with the Financial Perspective and work your way down in order to validate your Strategic Goals. You do this by asking for each goal "So what, who cares?" Using this question, you probably won't get much change on the Financial Performance Strategic Goals because these drive the train. But take for example the above Strategy Map Strategic Goal under Customer Capital . It reads in part "Reduce Customer Losses and Defections." You may find out that you don't care about all these customer losses and defections. In fact, some of these customers may not be profitable so you indeed want to loss them. Suddenly, you find yourself restating this part of the goal to the more useful "Reduce Losses and Defections of Our Most Profitable Customers." Do you see how the questions "So what, who cares?" helps you validate and refine your goals? It's an
extremely value tool.
Continuing in the Customer Capital Perspective, ask "Are there other goals (enabling goals) that should be developed and penned in to move the Customer Capital and
Financial Performance Goals in the direction we want them to move?" If there are, then generate these enabling goals and draw in the cause and effect relationship between them and the other goals.
Next move to the Structural Capital Perspective and then the Human Capital Perspective and repeat the process. Often the Human Capital Perspective Goals don't surface in your SWOT Analysis so they have to be generated as enabling goals to make your Strategy Map provide a viable basis to support your Grand Strategy.
Step Ten. Translate your Strategy Map goals into "Key Performance Measures" (KPMs) and perform a "Gap Analysis." First, translate your goals into measurable terms. In some cases, a goal may already be stated in measurable terms. But you often have to break goals down and restate them in measurable terms. For example, theStructural Capital Goal of "Create and Maintain Well Stocked and Attractive Shelves" may be broken down and restated as the KPM "Mystery Shoppers Rating for Store Product Display and
Appeal."
Financial Performance Goals are usually stated in measurable terms so use these terms for your Financial Performance KPMs as appropriate. On Customer, Structural and Human Capital Goals, you usually have to restate them in KPM terms with a number, percentage or ranking. Some examples of KPMs follow:
Financial Perspective KPMs: -Revenue - $xxx
-Profit - $xxx -Cash Flow - $xxx
-Revenue per Employee - $xxx -Return on Investment – x% Customer Capital KPMs: -Customer Retention – x% -Customer Satisfaction – x% -Customer Profitability Segment 1 - $xxx Segment 2 - $xxx Structural Capital KPMs:
-Ratio of Sales Persons to General and Administrative - x/y -Time to Market for New Products – x months
-Inventory Turnover – 100% every x months
• -Mystery Shoppers Rating of Store Product Display and Appeal – Grade • -Mystery Shoppers Rating of Employee Helpfulness – Grade
Human Capital KPMs:
-Employee Turnover - x% per period
-Average Days missed per Employee – x%
-Employee Satisfaction - x% Highly Satisfied, Satisfied and so on -Number of Suggestions Submitted - xx
-Number of Suggestions Adopted – xx
-Number of Employees Fully Qualified for Their Position – xx So translate all of your Strategy Map goals into KPMs.
Now you're ready to perform your Gap Analysis. Start this process by determining where you are on each KPM. For the status on Financial KPMs, use your available financial
numbers, but for the status on Customer, Structural and Human Capital KPMs, you
usually have to create estimated numbers, percentages or rankings. These initial estimates are okay because you want to put a stake in the ground. But you'll also want to put in place a process to collect data and refine these KPMs as you move forward.
Next develop your desired "Targets" for each KPM. Again, this initially amounts to an estimating process based on your best judgment and level of ambition. You then break these Targets down into quarterly aiming points to begin to close the gaps. Again you'll want to put in place a research, analysis and benchmarking process to collect data and refine these Targets as you move forward.
Step Eleven. Prepare a "Scorecard" to keep track and drive your Grand Strategy. Here's a format with examples to illustrate how to prepare one.
Grand Strategy Scorecard
Perspective/ Quarterly Data Source/
Goals KPM Target Actual Status* Owner
Financial Performance Increase
Profitability ROI 12% 13% (+) CFO
Customer Capital
Increase Customer
Satisfaction Sat Rating 95% 94% (-) Customer
Service
Structural Capital
Create and Maintain Grade A- A- (0) Mystery
Well Stocked and Shopper
Attractive Shelves Human Capital
Increase Employee Sat Rating 90% 90% (0) Human
Satisfaction Resources
* (+) = ahead of target / (0) = on target / (-) = behind target
Once you have this Scorecard you have the centerpiece of your Grand Strategy. Now move on to implementation.
Step Twelve. Execute, Adjust, Execute. A Fortune Magazine study in June 1999 found that many CEOs were fired because they failed to execute their strategy. Things really have not changed much since then. As a friend, Mike Kipp, a consultant from Nashville, Tennessee, says "All organizations are perfectly designed to achieve the results they are getting." Don't confuse creating your Grand Strategy with taking action. Now the Grand Strategy process demands real work and organizational change. Otherwise improvement won't occur and things might even get worse. Execution and appropriate adjustments are imperative or you've only done an academic exercise.
Finally, to keep your Grand Strategy and Scorecard up to date and on track, you form a small team of high performers. This team should be prepared to facilitate and help you with implementation across and down through the organization. In this way, you'll get your total organization's brainpower and energy behind your Grand Strategy. People tend to support what they help build. And with your strong leadership combined with openness to involvement and feedback, you'll realize strategic goal linkage and alignment from the top to the bottom of your organization. And with this linkage and alignment, your Grand Strategy will move forward and achieve the breakthroughs you desire in marketing, innovation and performance improvement.
Learning objective
Grand strategy matrix is a last matrix of matching strategy formulation framework. It same as important
as BCG, IE and other matrices. This chapter enables you to understand the preparation of GS matrix.
The Quantitative Strategic Planning Matrix (QSPM)
The last stage of strategy formulation is decision stage. In this stage it is decided that which way is most
appropriate or which alternative strategy should be select. This stage contains QSPM that is only tool
for objective evaluation of alternative strategies. A quan titative method used to collect data and prepare
a matrix for strategic planning. It is based on identified internal and external crucial success factors.
That is only technique designed to determine the relative attractiveness of feasible alternative action.
The QSPM uses input from
Stage 1 analyses and matching results from Stage 2 analyses to decide objectively among alternative
strategies. That is, the EFE Matrix, IFE Matrix, and Competitive Profile Matrix that make up Stage 1,
coupled with the TOWS Matrix, SPACE Analysis, BCG Matrix, IE Matrix, and Grand Strategy Matrix
that make up Stage 2, provide the needed information for setting up the QSPM (Stage 3).
Preparation of matrix
Now the question is that how to prepare QSPM matrix. First it contains key internal and external
factors. An internal factor contains (strength and weakness) and external factor include (opportunities
and threats). It relates to previously IFE and EFE in which weight to all factors. Weight means
importance to internal and external factor. The sum of weight must be equal to one. After assigning the
weights examine stage-2 matrices and identify alternatives strategies that the organization should
consider implementing. The top row of a QSPM consists of alternative strategies derived from the
TOWS Matrix, SPACE Matrix, BCG Matrix, IE Matrix, and Grand Strategy Matrix. These matching
tools usually generate similar feasible alternatives. However, not every strategy suggested by the
matching techniques has to be evaluated in a QSPM. Strategists should use good intuitive judgment in
selecting strategies to include in a QSPM. After assigning the weight to strategy, determine the
attractiveness score of each and afterwards total attractiveness score. The highest total attractiveness
score strategy is most feasible.
Steps in preparation of QSPM
1. List of the firm's key external opportunities/threats and internal strengths/weaknesses in the left
column of the QSPM.
2. Assign weights to each key external and internal factor
3. Examine the Stage 2 (matching) matrices and identify alternative strategies that the organization
should consider implementing
4. Determine the Attractiveness Scores (AS) 5. Compute the Total Attractiveness Scores 6. Compute the Sum Total Attractiveness Score
