[PDF] Top 20 For what it’s worth – the open peer review landscape

... the open public face of the web it does not deter people behaving horribly to ...established peer review system has for years shielded reviewers from a right to reply for their comments; it should ... See full document

... One way to establish one’s methods a priori is to de- velop a SR protocol, that is ‘[ …] a document that pre- sents an explicit scientific ‘road map’ of a planned, uninitiated systematic review’ (p. 3) [4]. If SR ... See full document

... on open source software (OSS). They examined more than 100,000 peer reviews in OSS case studies of the Apache Httpd server, Subversion, Linux, FreeBSD, KDE, and ...to review. Developers manage ... See full document

... an open access [2,3], open peer review journal ...signed peer review reports are published with the article) [4,5], with the aim of making high impact clinical ... See full document

... with open peer review at BMC Pharmacology and Toxicology because of the ethical grounds for doing so [2] and because the potential bene- fits outweigh the negatives ...[22,23]. Open ... See full document

... closed review, open peer review is a system where authors and reviewer are known to each other throughout the ...an open review, authors and reviewers’ names may be published ... See full document

... of what today we call peer reviewers, whose role in certifying what ought to be published we not only have ac- cepted, but have raised on a daïs, judging any work, journal, or book that has not run ... See full document

... ? Open Peer Review Any?reports?and?responses?or?comments?on?the article?can?be?found?at?the?end?of?the?article RESEARCH?ARTICLE ???Geostatistical analysis of Malawi?s changing malaria ?transmission fr[.] ... See full document

... future. Currently, the only other forms of output produced by more than 50 per cent of respondents were chapters in books and authored books in arts and humanities. Individual researchers also expect to start to produce ... See full document

... the review and regardless of outcome) while retaining the author’s ...of review standards – given the historical parallel to page budgets and evolutions in social and technological filtering processes (see ... See full document

... The overt observation method was chosen because it would yield a rich amount of data when exploring the award-making process, how panel members used the guidance notes and how the two rounds of award-making differed from ... See full document

... We chose BMC Microbiology and BMC Infectious Diseases because the journals have a similar pro fi le (table 1) and the same editorial processes, differing mainly in the peer review model. However, the ... See full document

... of peer review infor- mation could be as simple as manually compiling re- view components and publishing a single document as Additional file 1 or as complex as an automated (XML) workflow where each ... See full document

... the peer review ...of peer review: for instance, exercise of quality control, standardization of the conduct of research, influencing the future direction of research, extending the learning ... See full document

... the S-Connect study recruited patients with mild-to-moderate AD (MMSE 14 – 24) taking stable doses of approved symptomatic AD treatments (cholinesterase inhibitors and/or ...double-blind S-Connect study, ... See full document

... example, what is the historical process whereby the notion of a score moved from the field of sports to the domain of business? Credit scores are an interesting case, suggesting that price itself is not always a ... See full document

... characteristics.Nirmala S (2010) studied the Corporatecapital structure in India and reported that Return on Equity is significantly associated with Debt-Equity ... See full document

... this review, including appropriate methods for HCV infection measurement and important confounders should have been adjusted for, were documents a priori and agreed by all ... See full document

... trade, open markets, and floating currencies, businesses, and indeed sovereign states, will be able to compete at a more efficient level than ever ...place. What these institutions have failed to identify ... See full document

... audited. Review committees are therefore not able to make judgments on the compensa- tion offered to research participants based on any consistent guideline 20 ... See full document