Development of Method of Multifunctional Personnel Assessment Using a Topsis Method

(1)

>?@ABCC?DÿFAÿGH?ÿIBAGÿFIJB@GKCGÿ@?ABL@M?ÿNB@ÿKCOÿB@PKCFQKR STUVWÿYZUVÿS[\ÿ\]\^ST_\ÿ`YV^STUVTVaÿU`ÿb[T^[ÿ^c\decfÿg\Z\Vghÿ ALMM?AANLDÿBJ?@KGFBCÿBNÿGH?ÿB@PKCFQKGFBCiÿjH?@?NB@?kÿGH?ÿ J@BJ?@ÿKClÿBmn?MGFo?ÿA?D?MGFBCÿBNÿJ?@ABCC?DÿKClÿlFoFAFBCÿBNÿ DKmB@ÿFAÿo?@OÿFIJB@GKCGÿKGÿKÿNB@IKGFo?ÿAGKP?ÿBNÿGH?ÿB@PKCFQKR GFBCÿB@ÿFGAÿA?JK@KG?ÿLCFGAiÿpCÿP?C?@KDkÿJ?@ABCC?DÿKAA?AAI?CGÿ FAÿKÿo?@Oÿ@?AJBCAFmD?ÿKClÿMBIJD?qÿGKArkÿ?AJ?MFKDDOÿsH?Cÿs?ÿ sKCGÿGBÿA?GÿLJÿGH?ÿLCFGAÿBNÿGH?ÿB@PKCFQKGFBCÿBCÿGH?ÿmKAFAÿ BNÿILDGFNLCMGFBCKDÿJ?@ABCC?DiÿpCÿGHFAÿMBCG?qGkÿJ?@ABCC?DÿKAR A?AAI?CGÿFIJDF?AÿKÿMBIJD?qÿKJJ@BKMHÿGHKGÿFAÿKJJDF?lÿGBÿGH?ÿ NKMGÿGHKGÿGH?ÿKAA?AAI?CGÿAHBLDlÿm?ÿMK@@F?lÿBLGÿKPKFCAGÿGH?ÿ gT]\e\VSÿ^eTS\eTdÿTVÿUeg\eÿSUÿtdTVSdTVÿS[\ÿ[Ta[ÿhSdVgdegÿU`ÿ Bmn?MGFoFGOkÿKClÿIBAGÿFIJB@GKCGDOkÿGBÿKDDBsÿLAÿNB@ÿA?D?MGFCPÿ uYdcTv\gÿZ\ehUVV\cwÿ

xÿHLIKCÿBJ?@KGB@ÿKJJ?K@AÿGBÿLAÿKAÿKÿILDGFNLCMGFBCKDÿ?DR ?I?CGÿFCÿABMFKDRJ@BlLMGFBCÿAOAG?IAkÿsHBÿHKAÿA?o?@KDÿAJ?R MFKDFAGÿArFDDAÿKClÿFAÿKmD?ÿGBÿKMMBIJDFAHÿA?o?@KDÿNLCMGFBCAÿBNÿ GHFAÿAOAG?IiÿjBÿm?ÿIB@?ÿJ@?MFA?kÿKÿILDGFNLCMGFBCKDÿHLIKCÿ BJ?@KGB@ÿyILDGFNLCMGFBCKDÿBJ?@KGB@ÿRÿz{|}ÿFAÿKÿAJ?MFKDFAGÿsFGHÿ KÿNLCMGFBCKDÿBo?@KmLClKCM?ÿ~kÿsHBÿHKAÿGH?ÿKmFDFGOÿGBÿKMR ^UtZcTh[ÿUV\ÿhZ\^Tv^ÿÿÿNLCMGFBCÿKGÿKCOÿGFI?ÿÿkÿN@BIÿKÿA?GÿBNÿ HFAH?@ÿNLCMGFBCKDÿMKJKMFGF?Aÿ kÿÿyjAF@R KILKkÿÿjAF@KILKÿÿKAH?D?FAHoFDFkÿ}i

CDFr?ÿKÿAFCPD?RNLCMGFBCKDÿHLIKCÿBJ?@KGB@kÿGH?ÿILDGFR NLCMGFBCKDÿBJ?@KGB@AÿKDDBsÿLAÿNB@ÿMBIJD?GFCPÿGH?ÿB@PKCFQKR STUVdcÿhfhS\thÿU`ÿS[\ÿe\^UVvaYedc\ÿhSeY^SYe\Wÿb[T^[ÿdc\ÿSUÿ @?KDFPCÿGH?ÿAG@LMGL@?ÿKClÿMBCGFCL?ÿALMM?AANLDÿNLCMGFBCFCPÿFCÿ GH?ÿMKA?ÿBNÿJK@GFKDÿNKLDGÿBNÿKCOÿAJ?MFKDFAGiÿyjAF@KILKkÿÿ KAH?D?FAHoFDFkÿ}i

AÿJK@GFKDÿNKLDGÿFAÿKÿMKA?ÿsH?CÿGH?ÿDBA?AÿGH?ÿKmFDFGOÿGBÿ

ÿ>HiÿikÿKMLDGOÿBNÿqKMGÿKClÿKGL@KDÿMF?CM?AkÿxrKrFÿjA?@?G?DFÿGKG?ÿCFo?@AFGOkÿLGKFAFkÿ?B@PFKiÿRIKFDÿmKAH?D?FAHoFDFiF@KrDFPIKFDiMBI

ÿ>@BNiÿ@ikÿMHBBDÿBNÿpCNB@IKGFBCKDÿj?MHCBDBPF?AkÿCPFC??@FCPÿKClÿKGH?IKGFMAkÿCFo?@AFGOÿBNÿ?B@PFKkÿjmFDFAFkÿ?B@PFKiÿRIKFDÿAiGAF@KILKLPi?lLiP?

¡

¢£¤¥¦

ÿ

¢¨

ÿ

z¦

©¢ªÿ

¢¨

ÿ

z«¡

¦

¬

¨

«¥¦

¬

¢¥®¡

ÿ

¯°±¢¥¥¡

ÿ

²±±±±¤¥¦

ÿ

³±¬

¥´ÿ

®ÿ

µ¢£±¬

±ÿ

z¦

©¢ª

p@KrDFÿx¶·p¶¸p·p ?@PBÿjp¹xx

²º±¦°®¦

»[\ÿZdZ\eÿU]\ehÿS[\ÿt\S[UgÿU`ÿtYcST`YV^STUVdcÿZ\ehUVV\cÿdhh\hht\VSWÿbTS[ÿS[\ÿZYeZUh\ÿ BNÿl@KsFCPÿKÿIKG@FqÿBNÿNLCMGFBCKDÿMKJKmFDFGF?AÿBNÿILDGFNLCMGFBCKDÿJ?@ABCC?DkÿmKA?lÿBCÿ sHFMHÿs?ÿMKCÿMK@@OÿBLGÿBJGFIKDÿA?D?MGFBCÿBNÿJ?@ABCC?DÿKClÿKDDBMKGFBCÿBNÿNLCMGFBCAiÿjH?ÿ l?o?DBJ?lÿI?GHBlÿBNÿILDGFNLCMGFBCKDÿJ?@ABCC?DÿKAA?AAI?CGÿLA?AÿKÿILDGFRM@FG?@FKÿ?qJ?@Gÿ I?GHBlÿRÿKÿj>pÿI?GHBli

¼½¾¢°ª±ÿLDGFNLCMGFBCKDÿJ?@ABCC?DkÿIKG@FqÿBNÿNLCMGFBCKDÿMKJKMFGF?Akÿl?MFAFBCÿIKG@Fqkÿ j>pkÿl?MFAFBCÿIKrFCPÿI?GHBli

KMMBIJDFAHÿHFAH?@ÿIKClKG?lÿNLCMGFBCkÿmLGÿ@?GKFCAÿGH?ÿKmFDFGOÿ GBÿKMMBIJDFAHÿBGH?@ÿNLCMGFBCAÿKAAFPC?lÿGBÿGH?ÿAOAG?IkÿH? AH?ÿMKCÿm?ÿAsFGMH?lÿGBÿGH?ÿKMMBIJDFAHI?CGÿBNÿBGH?@ÿNLCMR GFBCAiÿjH?ÿJKJ?@AÿyjAF@KILKkÿÿjAF@KILKÿÿKAH?D?FAHR _TcTWÿ¿ÀÁÂÃÿh[UbÿS[dSÿS[\ÿhfhS\tÿhSd]\gÿfÿtYcST`YV^STUVdcÿ Z\ehUVV\cÿtY^[ÿtUe\ÿ\Ä^T\VSÿS[dVÿdÿhfhS\tÿhSd]\gÿfÿS[\ÿ AFCPD?RNLCMGFBCKDÿAJ?MFKDFAGAiÿ

jH?ÿJL@JBA?ÿBNÿGH?ÿsB@rÿFAÿGBÿl?o?DBJÿGH?ÿI?GHBlÿBNÿ KAA?AAI?CGÿILDGFNLCMGFBCKDÿJ?@ABCC?DkÿmOÿsHFMHÿs?ÿsFDDÿm?ÿ KmD?ÿGBÿl?G?@IFC?ÿGH?ÿIKG@FqÿBNÿNLCMGFBCKDÿMKJKMFGF?AÿBNÿILDR GFNLCMGFBCKDÿJ?@ABCC?Di

µ©ÿ

£°¢º¡

¤ÿ

¢¨

ÿ

¤«¡

¦

¬

¨

«¥¦

¬

¢¥®¡

ÿ

£°±¢¥¥¡

ÿ

®±Å

±±±¤¥¦

ÿ

jH?ÿAG@LMGL@?ÿBNÿGH?ÿJ@BmD?IÿBNÿILDGFNLCMGFBCKDÿJ?@ABCC?Dÿ KAA?AAI?CGÿFAÿAFIFDK@ÿGBÿGH?ÿJ@BmD?IÿBNÿILDGFRM@FG?@FBCÿl?R MFAFBCkÿMBCA?ÆL?CGDOkÿGH?ÿABDLGFBCÿGBÿGH?ÿJ@BmD?IÿFAÿmKA?lÿ BCÿGH?ÿI?GHBlÿBNÿILDGFRM@FG?@FBCÿKCKDOAFAÿj>pÿy¶sKCPkÿ ÇBBCkÿÈÉÿÇBBCkÿÈÉ}iÿ

Ê?ÿMKCÿNB@ILDKG?ÿGH?ÿJ@BmD?IÿBNÿILDGFNLCMGFBCKDÿJ?@ABCR C?DÿKAA?AAI?CGÿKAÿNBDDBsA

ÿÊ?ÿHKo?ÿKÿA?GÿBNÿNLCMGFBCAÿGBÿm?ÿKMMBIJDFAH?lÿËÌÍÿÏÐÿ _ÑÐÿ_ÒÓÔÓÿÏ_ÕÿÖÿKClÿKÿA?GÿBNÿJ?@ABCC?DÿGBÿm?ÿKAA?AA?lÿ×ÌÍÿØÐÿ ÙÓÿÚÓÔÓÿ_ÛÿÖkÿsHBA?ÿKAA?AAI?CGÿs?ÿsKCGÿGBÿIKr?ÿ@?PK@lR

(2)

01

234567ÿ9222

346ÿÿ746ÿ7ÿÿ67ÿ2ÿ !"##$ÿ"2ÿ$%&"!'#ÿ6(ÿ')ÿ2ÿ*)ÿ#*!

+,-ÿ/01ÿ23,4/+5,6ÿÿ89:ÿ8;:ÿ8<=>=?_@AÿB1ÿCD65ÿ0CE1ÿCÿ61/ÿ52ÿ/01ÿ C66166F1,/ÿ4G+/1G+CHÿI_JK ÿLÿ 25GÿCÿ6/C,MNCD5,1ÿ23,4/+5,ÿÿ8_J_ÿ:ÿO01G1ÿPKQ=ÿ@A

S01ÿ-+E1,ÿ61/ÿ52ÿ/01ÿC66166F1,/ÿ4G+/1G+Cÿ+,4D3M16ÿ4G+/1G+Cÿ 52ÿ/01ÿ25DD5O+,-ÿ4C/1-5G+16Tÿÿ

U1E+1O+,-ÿVWÿX1G65,CDÿMC/Cÿ52ÿX1G65,,1Dÿ+,E5DE1Mÿ+,ÿ /01ÿC66166F1,/HÿO0+40ÿ+,ÿ/3G,ÿFCYÿZ1ÿM+E+M1Mÿ+,/5ÿFC,Yÿ 4G+/1G+C[ÿ

\,/1GE+1OÿLÿFCYÿCD65ÿZ1ÿM+E+M1Mÿ+,/5ÿFC,Yÿ4G+/1G+C[ S16/+,-ÿLÿFCYÿ+,4D3M1ÿ/01ÿ/16/6ÿ52ÿECG+536ÿ4C/1-5G+16Hÿ 6340ÿC6Tÿ-1,1GCDÿ6]+DD6ÿ/16/6[ÿ45FX3/1Gÿ6]+DD6ÿ/16/6[ÿXG5216N 6+5,CDÿ6]+DD6ÿ/16/6[ÿX6Y405D5-+4CDÿ/16/6[ÿ25G1+-,ÿDC,-3C-1ÿXG5N ^_`ab_cÿeafefÿgbhÿfiÿibjÿ

kG5Fÿ-+E1,ÿ4C/1-5G+16ÿ52ÿ/01ÿC66166F1,/ÿ4G+/1G+Cÿ/01ÿ ^lfeÿgbhÿfa_ibhÿ_geamilcÿ_l`eal`gÿnopÿlaq`arfÿgbhÿ`bealN E+1OsÿCG1ÿ1ECD3C/1MÿZYÿC,ÿ1tX1G/ÿu5Gÿ-G53Xÿ52ÿ1tX1G/6sAÿ

ÿNÿ+6ÿCÿ61/ÿ52ÿ1tX1G/6ÿO05ÿC66166ÿ v3CD+2Y+,-ÿ4C,M+MC/16ÿC445GM+,-ÿ/5ÿ+,M+E+M3CDÿ4G+/1G+CAÿB0+D1ÿ /01ÿ/16/+,-ÿ4C/1-5GYÿ4G+/1G+CÿCG1ÿ1ECD3C/1MÿC6ÿCÿG163D/ÿ52ÿ/01ÿ eafe`bmÿwalfibbaxÿ`bqixqahÿ`bÿeyaÿaqgxzge`ibÿi{ÿfwa_`^_ÿ_l`eaN G+Cÿ52ÿ/01ÿ-+E1,ÿ4C/1-5GYHÿC,MÿX5+,/6ÿ5Z/C+,1Mÿ+,ÿ/01ÿG1D1EC,/ÿ /16/6ÿCG1ÿ45,6+M1G1Mÿ/5ÿZ1ÿC,ÿC66166F1,/Aÿÿ

\,ÿ /0+6ÿ 45,/1t/Hÿ /01ÿ C66166F1,/ÿ 4G+/1G+CÿI_JK ÿ52ÿCÿ6/C,MNCD5,1ÿ23,4/+5,ÿ 8_JHÿO01G1ÿ ÿCG1ÿ1ECD3C/1MÿZYÿC,ÿ1tX1G/ÿ5Gÿ 1tX1G/ÿ-G53XHÿO0+D1ÿ/01ÿ ÿ4G+/1G+CÿCG1ÿF1C63G1Mÿ C445GM+,-ÿ/5ÿ/01ÿ/16/ÿG163D/6Aÿ

S01ÿC66166F1,/ÿ4G+/1G+Cÿ52ÿCÿ6/C,MNCD5,1ÿ23,4/+5,ÿ/5ÿZ1ÿ C445FXD+601Mÿ8_Jÿ0CE1ÿ/01ÿO1+-0/6HÿO0+40ÿCG1ÿM1/1GF+,1MÿZYÿ CÿE14/5Gÿ52ÿ/01ÿO1+-0/6ÿÿ Hÿ

O01G1ÿ|_J_}ÿ~KQ=ÿÿ+6ÿCÿO1+-0/ÿ52ÿ/01ÿC66166F1,/ÿ4G+/1G+N 5,ÿ_J_}ÿÿ52ÿCÿ6/C,MNCD5,1ÿ23,4/+5,ÿ/5ÿZ1ÿC445FXD+601Mÿ8_JAÿS01ÿ O1+-0/6ÿ52ÿ/01ÿC66166F1,/ÿ4G+/1G+Cÿ52ÿ1C40ÿ23,4/+5,ÿ/5ÿZ1ÿ C445FXD+601Mÿ8_Jÿ6053DMÿ6C/+62Yÿ/01ÿ25DD5O+,-ÿ45,M+/+5,Tÿ

ÿ

3Gÿ-5CDÿ+6ÿ/5ÿM1E1D5Xÿ6340ÿCÿF1/05MHÿO0+40ÿCDD5O6ÿ36ÿ25Gÿ M1/1GF+,+,-ÿ/01ÿ23,4/+5,CDÿ4CXC4+/+16ÿFC/G+tÿ52ÿF3D/+23,4N e`ibgxÿwalfibbaxÿgbhÿgfahÿibÿeyaÿwalfibbaxÿh`alabe`gxÿ C66166F1,/Hÿ/5ÿXG5E+M1ÿ5X/+FCDÿCDD54C/+5,ÿ52ÿ23,4/+5,6Aÿk5Gÿ /01ÿX3GX561ÿ52ÿC66166+,-ÿF3D/+23,4/+5,CDÿX1G65,,1DÿHÿO1ÿ 4C,ÿMGCOÿCÿM14+6+5,ÿFC/G+tÿuO01G1ÿ

X1G65,,1DÿG1XG161,/6ÿ/01ÿCD/1G,C/+E16HÿC,Mÿ/01ÿC66166F1,/ÿ 4G+/1G+CÿCG1ÿG1XG161,/1MÿZYÿ/01ÿ4G+/1G+Cÿ25GÿC66166+,-ÿCÿ6/C,MN CD5,1ÿ23,4/+5,ÿÿ8_JHsHÿC,MÿZC61Mÿ5,ÿ/0+6ÿM14+6+5,ÿFC/G+tHÿ36+,-ÿ gÿÿaeyihÿraÿ_gbÿhaeal`baÿ^bgxÿgffaffabeÿi{ÿ

CDDÿX1G65,,1Dÿ/5ÿZ1ÿ61D14/1Mÿ25GÿCÿ6/C,MNCD5,1ÿ23,4/+5,ÿÿ8_JAÿ 1/05Mÿ52ÿF3D/+23,4/+5,CDÿX1G65,,1DÿC66166F1,/ÿ+,N 4D3M16ÿ/01ÿ25DD5O+,-ÿ6/1X6T

ÿ ÿ¡1/1GF+,1ÿ/01ÿM14+6+5,ÿFC/G+tÿ8¢£_Jÿÿ25Gÿ1C40ÿ 23,4/+5,ÿÿ8_J_ÿT

B01G1 ÿPÿKÿQ=ÿ¤¤=ÿ@ ÿ¥ÿKÿQ=ÿ¤¤¤=ÿ¦ §ÿKÿQ=ÿ>¨=ÿ¨©Q=ÿ>

Nÿ+6ÿ/01ÿC661666F1,/ÿu,3F1G+4ÿECD31sÿ52ÿÿ_J_ªÿ4G+/1G+Cÿ 52ÿ/01ÿ8_J_ÿÿ23,4/+5,ÿ52ÿ/01ÿX1G65,,1Dÿ«_¬HÿO0+40ÿ+6ÿ1v3CDÿ/5ÿ/01ÿ gqalgmaÿgl`eyae`_ÿi{ÿeyaÿf_ilafÿha^bahÿcÿeyaÿawalefÿ`bÿ /01ÿ_J_ªÿÿ4G+/1G+Cÿ52ÿ/01ÿ8_Jÿÿ23,4/+5,ÿÿ52ÿ/01ÿ«_¬ÿX1G65,,1Dÿ+2ÿ/01ÿ 4G+/1G+CÿCG1ÿ1ECD3C/1MÿZYÿ/01ÿ1tX1G/6Aÿ/01GO+61Hÿ+/ÿ+6ÿ1v3CDÿ /5ÿ/01ÿ645G1ÿG141+E1MÿZYÿ/01ÿ«_¬ÿX1G65,,1Dÿ+,ÿ/01ÿ_J_ªÿ4G+/1G+Cÿ C66166F1,/ÿ/16/Aÿÿ

ÿ® ÿVCD43DC/1ÿ/01ÿ,5GFCD+¯1MÿM14+6+5,ÿFC/G+tÿT

ÿ° ÿVCD43DC/1ÿ/01ÿO1+-0/1Mÿ,5GFCD+¯1MÿM14+6+5,ÿFCN /G+tT

ÿ± ÿ¡1/1GF+,1ÿ/01ÿX56+/+E1ÿ+M1CDÿC,Mÿ,1-C/+E1ÿ+M1CDÿ 65D3/+5,6T

(3)

=>?@?ÿ

B?CDEFG?ÿFH?DIÿJKILEFKMN

OPQRÿTUÿVDIWLIDE?ÿE>?ÿJ?XD@DEFKMÿY?DJL@?JÿZ@KYÿE>?ÿ XKJFEFG?ÿFH?DIÿJKILEFKMÿDMHÿE>?ÿM?CDEFG?ÿFH?DIÿJKILEFKMN

[>?ÿJ?XD@DEFKMÿZ@KYÿE>?ÿFH?DIÿDIE?@MDEFG?ÿFJN

E>?ÿJ?XD@DEFKMÿZ@KYÿE>?ÿM?CDEFG?ÿFH?DIÿDIE?@MDEFG?ÿFJN

OPQRÿ\UÿVDIWLIDE?ÿE>?ÿ@?IDEFG?ÿWIKJ?M?JJÿEKÿE>?ÿXKJFEFG?ÿ FH?DIÿJKILEFKMN

OPQRÿ]Uÿÿ^DJ?HÿKMÿ@?W?FG?Hÿ@?JLIEJÿH?E?@YFM?ÿDÿYDE@F_ÿKZÿ ZLMWEFKMDIÿWDXD`FIFEF?JN

=>?@?

abcQde

fgh

ÿ

QigcRh

Qÿ

ÿ

VKMJFH?@ÿDMÿYLIEFZLMWEFKMDIÿX?@JKMM?IÿDJJ?JJY?MEÿ?_DYj XI?kÿE>DEÿWI?D@IlÿFIILJE@DE?JÿE>?ÿmK@nÿKZÿE>?ÿX@KXKJ?HÿY?E>j KHKIKClo

pK@ÿ?_DYXI?ÿKZÿE>?ÿDJJ?JJY?MEÿEDJnÿÿm?ÿ>DG?ÿE>?ÿZKIj IKmFMCNÿqrst_uvÿx_yvÿx_zÿ{ÿjÿ|ÿJ?EÿKZÿZLMWEFKMJ}ÿ~rsÿÿÿvÿ ÿ{ÿjÿÿJ?EÿKZÿX?@JKMM?IÿEKÿ`?ÿDJJ?JJ?H}ÿrs_uvÿ_yvÿ_zÿ{ÿÿjÿÿÿ J?EÿKZÿ?_X?@EJoÿ

JJ?JJY?MEÿW@FE?@FDÿDMHÿE>?ÿm?FC>EÿKZÿE>?ÿDJJ?JJY?MEÿ W@FE?@FDÿZK@ÿE>?ÿFMHFGFHLDIÿZLMWEFKMÿD@?ÿCFG?MÿFMÿ[D`I?ÿo

ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ `lÿE>?ÿ_X?@Eÿ@KLXÿDMHÿE>?ÿ@?YDFMFMCÿEmKÿW@FE?@FDÿE>@KLC>ÿ X@FWFMCÿE?JEFMCo

_X?@EJÿDJJ?JJY?MEÿDMHÿE?JEÿ@?JLIEJÿD@?ÿX@?J?ME?HÿFMÿ E>?ÿED`I?Jÿ j¡ÿDWWK@HFMCÿEKÿE>?ÿX?@JKMM?IN

(4)

01

234567ÿ9222

346ÿÿ746ÿ7ÿÿ67ÿ2ÿ !"##$ÿ"2ÿ$%&"!'#ÿ6(ÿ')ÿ2ÿ*)ÿ#*!

+,-./ÿ12ÿ34ÿÿ6789:;;7<ÿ7=>78?ÿ399799@7;?ÿ3;Aÿ?79?ÿ879B<?9

+,-./ÿC2ÿ3Dÿÿ6789:;;7<ÿ7=>78?ÿ399799@7;?ÿ3;Aÿ?79?ÿ879B<?9

+,-./ÿE2ÿ3Fÿÿ6789:;;7<ÿ7=>78?ÿ399799@7;?ÿ3;Aÿ?79?ÿ879B<?9

(5)

>?@?ABCD?ÿ@F?ÿBG@ACHÿIJÿ@F?ÿK?LCMCIDÿJIAÿ?GLFÿCDKCNCKOGPÿ JODL@CIDÿQRSTUÿWXUÿWYZ[ÿ@G\P?Mÿ]^_`

abcdeÿghÿijklmlnoÿqrstluÿÿÿSntÿÿSv

abcdeÿwhÿijklmlnoÿqrstluÿÿÿSntÿÿSx

abcdeÿwhÿijklmlnoÿqrstluÿÿÿSntÿÿSy

ÿ

zIAÿ?GLFÿÿÿK?LCMCIDÿBG@ACH{ÿOMCD|ÿGÿ}~ÿB?@FIK{ÿ?ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ^ P?L@?KÿJIAÿGÿM@GDK^GPID?ÿJODL@CIDÿ

?MOP@MÿJIAÿÿGÿM@GDK^GPID?ÿJODL@CIDÿGA?ÿ|CN?DÿCDÿ@G\P?Mÿ ^

abcdeÿhÿmmjmmqjosÿtjmsmÿSntÿSokslnoÿÿSv

abcdeÿhÿmmjmmqjosÿtjmsmÿSntÿSokslnoÿÿSx

abcdeÿhÿmmjmmqjosÿtjmsmÿSntÿSokslnoÿÿSy

(6)

01

234567ÿ9222

346ÿÿ746ÿ7ÿÿ67ÿ2ÿ !"##$ÿ"2ÿ$%&"!'#ÿ6(ÿ')ÿ2ÿ*)ÿ#*!

+,-./ÿ12ÿ34.ÿ153,62./ÿ7.-893-ÿ/.3.7:62.ÿ34.ÿ;82<3612,9ÿ <,=,<636.-ÿ:,376>ÿ-41?2ÿ62ÿ@,59.ÿA0B

CDEFGÿIJKÿLMNOPQÿSTÿTUVWNPSVMXÿWMYMWPNPZ[

\]^_F

`ab

]^ÿ

ÿ

cdeÿghgeiÿjkeilÿmdeÿnemdjoÿjpÿnqrmspqtumsjthrÿgeiljtterÿ ,--.--:.23vÿ?46<4ÿ6-ÿ5,-./ÿ12ÿ,ÿ:.341/ÿ1;ÿ:8936w<763.76,ÿ ,2,9x-6-ÿwÿ@yz{|{vÿ?46<4ÿ,991?-ÿ8-ÿ;17ÿ/7,?62}ÿ,ÿ:,376>ÿ 1;ÿ;82<3612,9ÿ<,=,569636.-ÿ1;ÿ:8936;82<3612,9ÿ=.7-122.9vÿ5,-./ÿ 12ÿ?46<4ÿ?.ÿ<,2ÿ<,77xÿ183~ÿ

ÿ1=36:,9ÿ-.9.<3612ÿ1;ÿ=.7-122.9ÿ,2/ÿ,991<,3612ÿ1;ÿ;82<w 3612-

ÿ,--.--:.23ÿ1;ÿ34.ÿ=.7-122.9ÿ:8936;82<3612,963xÿ,2/ÿ7.w 96,56963x

ÿjgmsnhrÿieldqstÿjpÿgeiljtterÿstÿmdeÿuhleÿjpÿghimshrÿ ;,893Bÿ

G

GG^_Gaÿ

ÿ

@-67,:8,vÿ{BAÿ.96,56963xÿ1;ÿ-x-3.:-~ÿy7},26,3612,9ÿ /.-6}2ÿ1;ÿ46}49xÿ7.96,59.ÿ48:,2w:,<462.ÿ-x-3.:-ÿ12ÿ34.ÿ 5,-6-ÿ1;ÿ:8936;82<3612,9ÿ1=.7,317-Bÿ,:5.73ÿ<,/.:6<ÿz85w 96-462}vÿ+11vÿ==BÿA1B

+,-4.9.6-4696vÿ|BÿABÿ,2,}.:.23ÿ|2;17:,3612ÿ{x-3.:ÿ 1;ÿ8936;82<3612,9ÿz.7-122.9ÿ--.--:.23Bÿ@4.ÿ|||ÿ|23.72,w msjthrÿlusetmsuÿhtoÿgihumsuhrÿjtpeietueÿtmeitemÿhtoÿjw <6.3xvÿ==BÿwB

+,-4.9.6-4696vÿ|BÿABÿ@4.ÿ9}17634:ÿ1;ÿ{.9.<3612ÿ,2/ÿ 82<3612-ÿ6-376583612ÿ1;ÿ8936;82<3612,9ÿz.7-122.9w,-.ÿ ?4.2ÿ34.ÿ8:5.7ÿ1;ÿ82<3612-ÿ6-ÿ7.,3.7ÿ34,2ÿ34.ÿ8:5.7ÿ 1;ÿz.7-122.9Bÿ 1872,9ÿ1;ÿ@.<426<,9ÿ{<6.2<.ÿ,2/ÿ@.<42191w }6.-vÿ198:.ÿ1vÿ|--8.ÿvÿ==Bÿ0w1B

+,-4.9.6-4696vÿ|Bvÿ¡ÿ@-67,:8,vÿ{BÿABÿ@4.ÿ,9}17634:ÿ;17ÿ 34.ÿ-.9.<3612ÿ,2/ÿ;82<3612-ÿ/6-376583612ÿ1;ÿ:8936;82<3612,9ÿ geiljtter¢ÿcdeÿ£ÿtmeithmsjthrÿlusetmsuÿhtoÿgihumsuhrÿjtw peietueÿtmeitemÿhtoÿjusem¤¥¦ÿgg¢ÿ§¨©ª«¬¢

+,-4.9.6-4696vÿ|Bvÿ¡ÿ@-67,:8,vÿ{BÿABÿ@4.ÿ®9,517,3612ÿ 9}17634:ÿ;17ÿ{.9.<3612ÿ,2/ÿ82<3612-ÿ6-376583612ÿ1;ÿ89w 36;82<3612,9ÿz.7-122.9Bÿ|23.72,3612,9ÿ¯1872,9ÿ1;ÿ37.2/ÿ62ÿ-<6w etmsuÿielehiudÿhtoÿoe°erjgnetm¦ÿ£jrqneª§¦ÿllqeª¦ÿgg¢ÿ ±±w±0B

@-67,:8,vÿ{BÿBÿ1:=83.7ÿ{x-3.:ÿ1;ÿ®,98,3612ÿ,2/ÿ

²hthenetmÿjpÿ²qrmsªpqtumsjthrÿmhkÿjpÿ³isuqrmqihrÿ´tsml¢ÿ {.<12/ÿ®871=.,2ÿ12;.7.2<.ÿ1;ÿ34.ÿ®871=.,2ÿ./.7,3612µ 17ÿ|2;17:,3612ÿ@.<42191}xÿ62ÿ}76<89387.vÿ11/ÿ,2/ÿ34.ÿ®2w 6712:.23vÿ==Bÿ±A¶w±B

@-67,:8,vÿ{Bvÿ¡ÿ+,-4.9.6-4696vÿ|BÿABÿ1/.9ÿ1;ÿ.96,56963xÿ jpÿmiqumqihrÿ·eujtqihmsjt¢ÿcdeÿ£ÿtmeithmsjthrÿlusetmsuÿ htoÿgihumsuhrÿjtpeietueÿtmeitemÿhtoÿjusem¤¥¦ÿgg¢ÿ§¨¸ª A¶Bÿ

¹?,2}vÿBBvÿº112vÿ»BÿA¶±ABÿ8936=9.ÿ3376583.ÿ.<6-612ÿ ,62}~ÿ.341/-ÿ,2/ÿ==96<,3612-Bÿ.?ÿº17~ÿ{=762}.7w.7w 9,}B

Development of Method of Multifunctional Personnel Assessment Using a Topsis Method

 ¡

¢£¤¥¦

ÿ

¢¨

ÿ

z¦

©¢ªÿ

¢¨

ÿ

z«¡

¦

¬

¨

«¥­¦

¬

¢¥®¡

ÿ

¯°±¢¥¥¡

ÿ

²±±±±¤¥¦

ÿ

³±¬

¥´ÿ

®ÿ

µ¢£±¬

±ÿ

z¦

©¢ª

µ©ÿ

£°¢º¡

¤ÿ

¢¨

ÿ

¤«¡

¦

¬

¨

«¥­¦

¬

¢¥®¡

ÿ

£°±¢¥¥¡

ÿ

®±Å

±±±¤¥¦

ÿ

ÿ





ÿ



ÿ

ÿ



ÿ



 ÿ

ÿ

abcQde

fgh

ÿ

QigcRh

Qÿ

ÿ

\]^_F

`ab

]^ÿ

ÿ

G

GG^_Gaÿ

ÿ

¡

¢£¤¥¦

z¦

«¥¦

¯°±¢¥¥¡

²±±±±¤¥¦

z¦

µ©ÿ

¤ÿ

«¥¦

£°±¢¥¥¡

±±±¤¥¦

ÿ

ÿ

G

GG^_Gaÿ