Cumulative Causation in a Structural Economic Dynamic Approach to Economic Growth and Uneven Development

Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Cumulative Causation in a Structural

Economic Dynamic Approach to

Economic Growth and Uneven

Development

Araujo, Ricardo

University of Brasilia

29 March 2011

Online at

https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/29960/

! " ! # $ % #

! # # " & #

" " # & "

! ! '

( ! $ ! # #

" ! # "

$ % # ) * + # , *

! & ! "

! ! ! $

- . / 0

1 ! ) * #$

1 2 " 3 / 4 56. 67.66$ 7 8 9 "$" $ : # & & ; " + <

% $ $ / 1',=

0

!" #

! !

7> ! #

( ! $

" & # ! = ! #

! ! ! ! ! #

! # ! ? - @066AB

1 # 1 # @0660B / ! " ! @0666BC$ : & # !

! # ! & ! # !!

!! ! & !

# $

# " >

@ .DD .50B " " " & @ .EEB

# F 1 " @ ..GB @ ..5B " !

# " & # ) * + #$ !

> ! # ! (

! ! # ! #

: F .EH " > * ! # #$ ! % I " # @066E $HAGB #

" ) " =

$ " # ! #

" " ( & $ J ! @ .0EB

! !

H

$ ! # ! # ! "

! # # "

' ! ! # $

# ! " &# #

& ! ( # ! #

! # $ : # ! #

$

: ! # #

" , @ .EH .. B K

K $ ! , !

( ! !

! $ %

" ! = !! !

" &

!

& 0$ !

"

-@066A $ EB L ! & $M

/ ! " ! @0666B ! ! !

! # $

! , ! !! !

' ! !

0

G

# # ( ! ( !

! ! $ ! "

! ! , # & # " $

@ ..EB ! # ! (

! " (

$ ( @06 6B

! ! # & ! # %

! !

"

! ! # " ! !

$ ( @06 B ! !

! , * # & " ! #

" ! ! ! $ :

* ! @06 6B ! ! !

# " , *

# &$

# # " !

! ! # "

, * # & ! # $

" ! ! ! " & " #

! # ! # " ) * + #$ I

" " & , *

! " '

! # " "

A

, ! &

! # $

! ! & # !

! & ! #

" & # ! " ! ! " > ,

H

$ !

! #

# ! !

! # $ ! ! !

! # & # " " 7

> " > #$

1 # 1 # @0660B

! # # # ! # (

D - 1 .5H " (

! ! !

" ! !! ! !

! $ ! L?#C ! !

" # ! ! #

" ! ! #

! # $M ?1 # 1 # @0660 $ 06GBC$

! " #

! # ! ! ! "

H

D

"

! ! $ ! , *

# & # # & #

! ! " $ !

! #

! & $ "

= " " " ! #

" " " $ ?J !

@ .0EB > @ .5EB , @ .. BC$

% " " !

, ! > 7) # # " !

! ! , # #

! "

! ! $ : 7 "

! # !

$ # ! #

" # ! ! ! $

# 8 : ( # # #

" , !

$ : H # ! ! ! , * "

! ) * #$ G

" $ A

5

$" % & '

, * ! " ! #

! " !

! 7 $ : ( ! !

! ! # $ !

! ! "

! $ # !

! ( ! ! $

: "

( ! $ # #

, 7> #

" ! = "

! # $ ? NO C

: " ! # & ! , * !

# ! $ / ( ! ! ! !

! " $

# !

! $ ! "

! # !

$ ! $

E

/ " !

, * ! # " ( !

! ! P # ! ( !

! " "

$

: ( , *

# ! (

@066HB$ " "

( # $ 1

= ! = "

P !

" 8 " _Q

$ ! $ :

Q ! $

!

$ ! " Q "

" ξ$ "

# # 8

. 7 G = 8 B @ B

@ + _Q +

∑

∑

= " ( 8

   + = + = B @ B @ Q Q ξ ξ @HB

" ( 8

   = + = " " B @ π @HB*

I @ R 0 $$$ 7 B " # !

@ B π $+

8

B 6 @ B

@ = @GB

Q Q

Q@ B= @6B @AB

G

" , @ .E $ HHB @ B

= 7 $ % # 7 !

$ ( @ (

# ! # ! B

6

! # $ !

, @ .E B ! " #

" ( " 8

CS $$$

$$$ ? P $$$ $$$

T B @

−

− −

−

= @DB

!

, # ! # "

( ! # *

8

B @

B

@ + _Q +

∑

∑

= −

=

ξ

ξ @5B

: , ! # ! "

+

ρ $ ' ( ! ! , * $ :

! # ! !

! ( ! " ( !

! $ / # ! > #

! ! "

( ! ! $ & ! !

! ! $

# " !

! $ !

! ! !

( % & '

! ! !! " ( !

! ! !7" 7 ! !

! #

! ! $ :

! !

! ! $ !

$ / #

" ! # "

! " ! ! #

! ! ! $

!! ! ( "

# ! ( "

! # $ : ! ! ( ! #

!! " $

#

$ %

0

!

! K $ $ ! " ! #

" ) * + # $

! # # # ! #

# $ ) * + # ! # #

# ! # # # ! # # $

! = # ! $

K K # " ! # !

K ! K # ! # ! K

# K " $ - " # !

K K # " ! # !

K ! K # ! K # K )

K $ $ ! #

! # $ !

" ) * + # " #

$ "

) * + # !! "

# # ! $ : ( #

" ! , *

H

)" * + '

: , * ! ! ( !

$

! ! ! 8

ρ

− = B @

B @

@EB

# ! " ρ $ +

&@ B " 8

B @ B @

& = @.B

# ! > # F 1 " @ ..GB

@ ..5 $ HD5B ! ) #$

# ) # $

& &

ϕ λ

γ + +

= @ 6B

I γ ( ! ! # ! #

7 ! # & 7

$ I !

= ! " "

! $ ! = "

G

= @ B

# =

= ! ! * $ :

= " ! = @ B

! ! 8

= @ 0B

, # # ( @ 6B 8

& &

α γ +

= @ 6B*

I α =λ +ϕ ) $ : ( #

! # ! " = ! # ! $

( @HB ! " !

! $ + # ! + @0665B

! ! " ! 8

Q Q

Q Q

Q

6 !

η

β β−

  

 _{  ≥}

  

=_{  }



<



@ HB

I " ! _! " !

!$η (

# η <6 # β ( $

# @ ..5B$ ! > ( &

A

1 # @0660 $ 06DB$ !

! # # 8 # !

! " "

! ! $ ! # ! !

" 8

(

)

Q Q _Q Q @ B 6 ! !

η σ σ β σ β

 _{− + + − ≥}

 =

<

 @ GB

! # ( ! (

@GB$ " " ! # $ ! # ! 8

σ = Q Q ! σ = ! ! ! σ = Q Q Q

= =σ # # ! #

7 ! 8

[

]

=θ @ θBη @σ σ B βσ @β BQ @ AB

( @ AB ! ! # 7

! $ : # , , # , 5

K ,,, K !

σ

σ =

" ( 8

[

]

=θ @ θBβσ @β BQ @ DB

! ( @ 6B* " 8

5

! ,,, ( ! " # # # #

# $ ,,, " " $

D

[

]

{

}

=γ α θ @ θBβσ @β BQ @ 5B

@0B # & # 8

[

]

{

}

= @ B @ BQ

B @ B @ β σ β θ θ α

γ @ EB

% ! ! ! # # "

8

[

]

{

}

=γ α θ @ θBβσ @β BQ

ρ @ .B

/ ( @ .B " ! ! 7

! # !

$ , " # ! !

! $ # #

" 1 # 1 # @0660 $ 06GB L?#C !

! " # ! ! #

" ! !

# ! # $M

: !

! ! !

" ! $ /

7 " " # ! 8

5

" ! ( @ DB @ .B " (

! " " ! # "

7 ! " # ! ( 8

[

]

{

}

+ − + −

+ −

+ − = −

= ρ γ @ α Bθ @ θBβσ @β BQ @0 B

( @0 B # " " 7

! " ! " ! ! "

" ( " ! #

" ) $ : ! , * #

! " !

( ! " ! ! $

" ! , *

! " ( ! $ % " ! ! ! ! #

" & ! ! $ #

! #

( ! " ( , * $

! " !

" ! ! " ! $ :

( ( ! ! !

! ! $ # @ .EH

$ HG5B L ! # ( #

! # ! & " #

E

: # & !

, * !

! ! !

! ! # ! "

$ :

! ! !

# ! ! ! ! $

> # ( # ! # ! #

! ! ! # !$ :

! " # ! # $

," #

- . "

- ! ! ! ! ! , *

"

" # # #

" ! $ : !

" & ! !

# ' 7 $ + @0665B 7

# * # @ .5.B # "

! " ! ! # $

Q

Q

!

ξβ

σ σ

φ

−

= −

=

=

∑

.

! ( ! ! # # #

! " φ !

( ! " β $ : " #

( # ! "

(

$ !

! # " " ! " " ! !

! ! * + #$

! ( @00B ! #

" ( # ! # ! (

& # $ I ! #

" # ! ! $

# # # ! # !

# # !

# ! ! ! $

: ( > * # ! # # @ .EH $

HGDB L? C(

# & ! $

# (

! # & ! % $M

: ! !! ! + # " +

! ! # ( !

( # ( ! ! $ ' # ( @ .B " "

06

! ! ! "

$ " &

" " " ! ! ! !

" " ( @ .B8

[

]

{

}

+ − + −

+ +

=γ α θ @ θ Bβσ @β BQ

ρ @ .B*

+ = " #

! ! ! ! #

! " ! $ ( @ .B*

# ! ! # ! !

! ! ! !

! ! $ % # $ !

! # ! # ! !

! ! # ! ! #

$

/" ( 0 1

, @ .E ..HB !

! " #

# ! # # " !

! " ! * + #$

! & ! # "

" " !

0

! ! # " ! ) * + #

# # ! ! ! , *

! $ ! # " (

" ! (

# ! ! ! ! $ :

) # &

# ! " ! " ! # ! #

& $ ! ! ! ! # !

# ! ! ! ! #

K ) $

% # ! " # #

! !

!

$ "

! "

D $

0

<$ ; 1$ ..E7..$ # " 7 7

8 $ ' 0 @0B

0A. K 0E0$

D

- ! " "

" # ! !

00

$ + ;$ 0665$

, 1 ; # $( ) H @AB 5AA K 55G$

$ ( <$ 066H$ ( 1 ! F

: $* AG@GB GAE K G5H$

$ ( <$ 06 6$ : ! , !

1 ! $ +

$ ( <$ 06 $ 1 ! F 1 " $

, - @ !B$

$ , ,$ .. $ > * ; # 8 , , ,

/ $ : , * . (

( - / " # ' I $ $ F , $ ' #

J &$

1 # <$ 1 # I$ 0660$ ,

; # $ ( # H 06HK00.$

* ! $ 06 6$ ! , F

1 ! $* D @0B HHH K HDH$

/ ! " ! <$ 0666$ ! , ! 1 ! ,

; # 8 1 $ ( # @GB

H.H K G $

% <$ I " # -$ 1 1 8 1 : + & !

, * ) " * 1 1 $

0H

> '$ .DD$ ( " 0 1 " $

1 " ! , $ 1 " ! $

> '$ .50$ : = " $ E0

0H57 0AA$

F 1 " <$ # $ ..G$ 1 " 2 ' '

( $ $ F , $ ' # J &$

- <$ 066A$ V 8

; # ! 1 $ : 8 2 0 .

# * 3 ) $ " < W $ - $

, $

, +$ .E $ ( 1 " !

# 4 , $ 1 " ! , $ 1 " !

>$

, +$ ..H$ # !

( & 5 6 $ 1 " ! , $ 1 " ! >$

$ ..E$ ! , * F 1 ! 8

, , $ ( # .@0B 0GAK D0$

& ,$ .EE$ > * ; # + # 1 1 $

I & ! , F !

$

F$ ..5$ X% = " X ; #

0G

F$ 06 6$ ! ; # 8 > $ 1 !

$ I & ! , 676 $

# $ .AD$ 1 " ; # $ 7

56 DAK.G$

8 > * ; # + # $ $ !

.EH ) $ ) ' $ H$

# $ .5.$ " (

! # 2 , 8 6 - 7

0 - " 0E$

# $ ..G$ 1 " # - $ / F , + $

+ $

# $ ..5$ 1 7 , 71

; # $ .@HB H55KED$

# $ .EH$ , F * ; > * ; # + #$

HGA K HAE$

J ! $ .0E$ : ! , ! $ HE