[PDF] Top 20 Scoring rules for judgment aggregation

... which judgment aggregation rules can be used, depending on, firstly, the agenda in question, and, secondly, the requirements placed on aggregation, such as anonymity, and of course the ... See full document

... ordinary scoring s, we have so far aimed for collective judgments with a high total ...out, aggregation rules which follow this approach – I call them ‘average-score rules’ as opposed to ... See full document

... ment aggregation has long been an open ...a scoring function as a function that associates each pair (φ, J i ) of an agenda item and a (rational) judgment with a ...responding aggregation rule ... See full document

... preference aggregation, the same rule has been advocated by Caragiannis, Procaccia, and Shah (2014) under the name of modal ranking rule, also on the basis of its truth-tracking ...binomial-k rules subsumes ... See full document

... of judgment aggregation and investigate the circum- stances under which an aggregation rule may be subject to strategic misrepresentation of judgments by a group of ...neutral aggregation ... See full document

... quota rules have been studied in depth by Dietrich and List ...two rules are due to their close similarity to well-known preference aggregation rules with the same ...three rules appear ... See full document

... On the first point, as we argued in Subsection 3.5.2, the mere possibility of JA manipulation is far from manipulation being an issue in actual instances of JA. The reasons for this are twofold: (a) Gathering the data ... See full document

... of judgment aggregation was originally inspired by problems in legal theory (Kornhauser and Sager ...then, judgment aggregation has attracted the interest of scholars in a variety of ... See full document

... in judgment aggregation, as the outcomes do not need to be ...binary aggregation, we are guaranteed that the result will be complete due to the way in which the majority rule and more generally, ... See full document

... details, we refer to other resources, e.g., [Calimeri et al., 2013; Gebser et al., 2017]. We use ; to express disjunctions. We use a variant of the syntax that uses variables—rules with variables represent the set ... See full document

... iterative judgment aggregation? Answers to these questions will depend on a number of pa- rameters, most notably the aggregation rule ...two aggregation rules, the premise-based rule ... See full document

... translating aggregation procedures as DL-PA programs is not ...binomial rules [Costantini et al., 2016]. These rules are particularly interesting because they allow to take into account some hidden ... See full document

... that judgment aggregation rules that satisfy ESME and Continuity are representable as “additive majority ...majority rules can be viewed as non-linear generalizations of the median rule; they ... See full document

... parison indicates that quotas can be set more freely in practice than those theoretical results would suggest, especially in cases where the agents tend to agree with each other, i.e., in cases where the Hamming ... See full document

... preference aggregation does not have into judgment aggregation research model, further researches on these specific structures, especially some specific structures which are under aggregation ... See full document

... concrete aggregation rules for reaching consistent and democratically responsive collective judgments, without a preceding axiomatic ...conclusion-based aggregation rules; (ii) quota ... See full document

... Judgment aggregation is a general framework for collective decision making that can be used to model many different set- ...the aggregation domain is overly ...for judgment aggregation ... See full document

... Within the MATCH-project, research about the concept of differentiated instruction (DI) in mathematics lessons in primary schools show that DI is a concept which occurs before, during and after the lesson and arises in ... See full document

... The theorem is a direct consequence of a result proved by Nehring and Puppe [11] (see Theorem 3 in the survey by List and Puppe [9] for a formulation in the framework of JA). In that work, the authors show that if the ... See full document

... Method: Our model uses Dietrich’s (2007 , 2016) model of judgment aggregation and Beg and Butt (2012) a fuzzy aggregation model. Explaining some basics of our model, let £ be a logical language. A ... See full document